Administrative
Appeals
Tribunal
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2005] AATA 868
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) S2005/175
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION ) Re ALLAN PULL Applicant
And
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AND INDIGENOUS AFFAIRS
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal Deputy President D G Jarvis Date6 September 2005
PlaceAdelaide
Decision The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.
D G Jarvis
(Signed)
Deputy President
(c)On 1 October 1992, he was convicted of four offences, namely enforcement of a breached bond, unlawful possession, building breaking and felony, and building breaking with the intent to commit a felony. The offences were committed on four different dates. He was sentenced to varying terms of imprisonment ranging from six to a head sentence of fifteen months, with some of the terms suspended and with a non-parole period of nine months in relation to the head sentence.
(d)On 11 August 1995, he was sentenced to two years’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of nine months, for burglary.
(e)On 4 September 1995, he was imprisoned for two months for driving under disqualification.
(f)On 28 January 1998, he was convicted of eight offences committed on six different occasions. There were five convictions for larceny, one for receiving, one for false pretences, and one for enforcement of a breached bond. He was sentenced to terms of imprisonment ranging from one month to a head sentence of twelve months and fifteen days, with a non-parole period in relation to the head sentence of twelve months and fifteen days.
(g)On 24 March 1998, he was convicted of two counts of damaging property and two counts of being unlawfully on premises, and was sentenced to one month’s imprisonment.
(h)On 17 September 2001, he was convicted of being unlawfully on premises and non-aggravated serious criminal trespass (place of residence), driving under disqualification and larceny. The latter two offences were committed on separate dates, and the former two offences were committed on the same date. He was sentenced to eighteen months’ imprisonment, which was suspended.
(i)On 13 January 2003, he was convicted of two counts of driving under disqualification on two different dates, and was sentenced to two months’ imprisonment, which was however suspended.
(j)On 14 May 2004, he was convicted of fourteen different offences, which included non-aggravated serious criminal trespass (place of residence) and dishonestly taking property without the owner’s consent; larceny and unlawful possession; a separate offence of larceny; enforcement of a breached bond; driving under disqualification; being unlawfully on premises; and five counts of failing to comply with bail agreement. Most of these offences occurred on different dates. He was sentenced to two years’ imprisonment, with a non-parole period of four months.
29. The applicant’s complete criminal history appears at pages 7 to 12 of exhibit R1, and this incorporates the dates of his offences. He admitted in evidence that he has had 121 convictions since 1983. The convictions are for a wide-range of offences in addition to those referred to in the preceding paragraph. Many of his convictions are for driving…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Pull and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indi... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] AATA 868
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the relevant legislative provisions and case law, including Seyfarth v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs and Johnson v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (No. 3). The court held that the Tribunal had jurisdiction to review the decision even if the reviewable decision was invalid. The court also held that the delegate's failure to consider the absorbed person visa did not necessarily render the decision invalid, as the applicant had not demonstrated how the outcome would have been different if the absorbed person visa had been considered. The court further held that the other considerations, such as the applicant's alcoholism and drug addiction, his offending due to alcoholism and drug addiction, and the best interests of his child, could not outweigh the primary considerations, which included the applicant's substantial criminal record.
The court affirmed the decision under review, holding that the Tribunal had correctly considered all relevant matters and exercised its discretion appropriately. The court held that the Tribunal had correctly taken into account the applicant's relationship with his daughters aged 16 and 18, and the meaning of "home invasion." The court also held that the Tribunal had correctly considered the relevance of the deemed decision to cancel the absorbed person visa in consequence of the cancellation of the transitional (permanent) visa Class BF. The court concluded that the decision was not unlawful or irrational, and that the Tribunal had exercised its discretion appropriately in affirming the decision under review.
The court did not make any further orders. The decision of the Tribunal was affirmed, and the applicant's appeal was dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter initially came before the Federal Court of Australia, which transferred the case to the AAT for review of the decision to cancel the transitional (permanent) visa Class BF. The applicant argued that the delegate's failure to consider the effect on the absorbed person visa rendered the decision invalid. The AAT was required to assess the validity of the delegate's decision and determine whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to review the decision despite any procedural flaws. The case proceeded with submissions from both parties and relevant legal authorities were cited.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the delegate of the respondent did not consider whether the applicant also held an absorbed person visa, and if so, does that invalidate the decision to cancel the Class BF visa?
2. Whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the decision despite the delegate's failure to consider the absorbed person visa?
3. Whether the decision not to cancel the visa was appropriate given the applicant's substantial criminal record and other considerations, including Ministerial Direction No. 21?
4. What is the meaning of "home invasion" in the context of the applicant's offending due to alcoholism and drug addiction?
5. How do the best interests of the applicant's child and his relationship with his daughters aged 16 and 18 factor into the decision?
6. Whether other considerations can outweigh the primary considerations in the decision-making process?
7. What is the relevance of the deemed decision to cancel the absorbed person visa in consequence of the cancellation of the transitional (permanent) visa Class BF?
Held
1. The delegate of the respondent did not consider whether the applicant held an absorbed person visa, but this did not invalidate the decision to cancel the Class BF visa.
2. The Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the decision despite the delegate's failure to consider the absorbed person visa.
3. The decision not to cancel the visa was appropriate given the applicant's substantial criminal record and other considerations, including Ministerial Direction No. 21.
4. The meaning of "home invasion" in the context of the applicant's offending was considered, but it was determined that it did not alter the outcome of the case.
5. The best interests of the applicant's child and his relationship with his daughters aged 16 and 18 were considered but did not outweigh the primary considerations.
6. Other considerations can outweigh the primary considerations in the decision-making process, but they did not in this instance.
7. The deemed decision to cancel the absorbed person visa in consequence of the cancellation of the transitional (permanent) visa Class BF is relevant but did not affect the outcome of the case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing whether the delegate's failure to consider the absorbed person visa invalidated the decision to cancel the Class BF visa. The court noted that the failure did not necessarily invalidate the decision, as the Tribunal had jurisdiction to review the decision regardless. The court referenced previous cases, such as Seyfarth v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs, to establish that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to review such decisions. The court further explained that the Tribunal could consider the absorbed person visa even though the delegate did not, aligning with the principle from Johnson v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (No. 3) that the Tribunal can look beyond the decision-maker's considerations.
The court then examined whether the decision not to cancel the visa was appropriate. It weighed the applicant's substantial criminal record against other considerations, including Ministerial Direction No. 21. The court found that the applicant's criminal record, compounded by alcoholism and drug addiction, was a significant factor. However, the court also considered the applicant's potential to rehabilitate, his relationship with his daughters, and the best interests of his child. The court concluded that the decision not to cancel the visa was appropriate, taking into account the totality of the circumstances, including Ministerial Direction No. 21.
Regarding the meaning of "home invasion" in the context of the applicant's offending, the court examined the evidence and concluded that it did not affect the outcome of the case. The court relied on past jurisprudence to clarify that the term "home invasion" does not necessarily require physical presence at a home but can encompass other forms of criminal conduct.
The court also addressed the best interests of the applicant's child and his relationship with his daughters aged 16 and 18. Although these factors were considered, the court found that they did not outweigh the primary considerations. This conclusion was influenced by the applicant's criminal history and the need for rehabilitation.
In considering whether other considerations could outweigh the primary considerations, the court found that in this case, they did not. The court emphasised that while the best interests of the child and the relationship with his daughters were important, they did not override the significant concerns raised by the applicant's criminal record and character test failure.
Finally, the court discussed the relevance of the deemed decision to cancel the absorbed person visa in consequence of the cancellation of the transitional (permanent) visa Class BF. The court determined that while this was a relevant factor, it did not alter the outcome of the case. The primary focus remained on the applicant's suitability to remain in Australia under the Migration Act 1958. The court's decision reaffirmed the importance of balancing primary and other considerations in immigration law, particularly in cases involving substantial criminal records and character tests.