TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Application for an Extension of Time to serve Evidence in Answer to Opposition by Professional Golfers Association Ltd to registration of trade mark application 808471(25) - LPGA and device - filed in the name of Ladies Professional Golf Association.
Background
On 28 September 1999 Ladies Professional Golf Association ('the applicant') applied to register trade mark application no 808471 (depicted below) in respect of 'Clothing, footwear and headgear' in class 25.
The application was examined, and subsequently advertised accepted in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 17 August 2000.
On 16 November 2000 Professional Golfers' Association of Australia Limited ('the opponent') filed Notice of Opposition to registration of the trade mark. Following allowance of four 3-month extensions of time in which to do so, evidence in support was served on 11 December 2001.
The due date for service of evidence in answer was 11 March 2002. On 19 April 2002, the applicant applied for an extension of time to 11 June, on the ground that negotiations were taking place between the parties. The statutory declaration of Victoria Sharmandine Hiley, Solicitor of Colin Biggers & Paisley, dated 17 April 2002 ('the first Hiley declaration') accompanied the extension application.
The opponent objected to the granting of the extension, arguing that no good reason had been provided for the lateness of the extension application, and that no negotiations had commenced between the parties. The applicant was invited to comment, and responded by providing an outline of circumstances surrounding the extension application. A Senior Examiner of Trade Marks considered the extension application. She was not satisfied that the applicant had made out a proper case and advised the parties that she intended to refuse the extension of time. The applicant requested to be heard.
The matter came before me in Sydney on 23 July 2002. Appearing for the applicant were Mr David Studdy of Counsel, with Ms Victoria Hiley, Solicitor of Colin Biggers & Paisley. The opponent did not attend the hearing.
Prior to the hearing, the applicant filed with the Trade Marks Office ('TMO') and forwarded to the opponent the following:
Statutory declaration of Victoria Sharmandine Hiley, Solicitor, dated 18 July 2002, with Exhibits "A" to "G" and "VSH1" ('the second Hiley declaration')
Statutory declaration of Victoria Sharmandine Hiley, Solicitor, dated 22 July 2002, with Annexures "A" and "B" ('the third Hiley declaration')
Statutory declaration of Elizabeth A Galloway, Senior Vice President and Chief Legal Officer of Ladies Professional Golf Association, dated 28 June 2002, with Exhibits "A" to "H"
The applicant advised that Ms Hiley's declarations relate to this extension of time matter, whereas Ms Galloway's declaration forms part of the applicant's evidence in answer.
Submissions
Mr Studdy explained that the current position in this matter is different to that which was before the Senior Examiner in June. He said that the information now provided by way of the statutory declarations of Ms Hiley establishes…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Professional Golfers Association Ltd v Ladies Professional G... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] ATMO 79
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the delegate were whether the applicant had made out a proper case for the extension of time, considering the relative inconvenience to the parties, and whether the public interest favoured granting the extension. Specifically, the delegate had to determine if the applicant's explanation for the delay was satisfactory, whether negotiations between the parties constituted a sufficient reason for the delay, and if the opponent had complied with its procedural obligations. The delegate also considered whether the Registrar had an obligation to notify the applicant of the commencement date for serving evidence in answer, as argued by the applicant.
The delegate reasoned that the opponent had complied with regulation 5.7 of the Trade Marks Regulations by serving its evidence in support within the extended time allowed, and therefore regulation 5.10 was not triggered, meaning the Registrar had no obligation to notify the applicant of the commencement date for evidence in answer. However, the delegate accepted the applicant's explanation that the late filing of the extension application was due to error and misunderstanding on the part of its agent, who was under the impression that the Trade Marks Office would provide notification of the due date. The delegate found that the applicant had subsequently provided adequate evidence, including correspondence between the parties, to demonstrate that negotiations were on foot and constituted a proper case for an extension. The delegate also found that refusing the extension would cause significant inconvenience to the applicant, potentially jeopardising its trade mark application, while the opponent would not be unduly disadvantaged. Considering the public interest in allowing substantive issues to be determined on merit and the fact that this was a first extension request, the delegate concluded that granting the extension was appropriate.
The delegate granted the extension of time to 11 June 2002.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi