Hunter Property Holdings (Aust) Pty Ltd v Vista RV Crossover Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Application for extension of time to serve evidence in opposition by Hunter Property Holdings (Aust) Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application 1439409(12) - VISTA RV - filed in the name of Vista RV Crossover Pty Ltd.

Delegate: Claudia Murray
Representation: Opponent: Mr Peter Willis of Counsel, instructed by Mr Mark Worsnop of Kahns Lawyers, Melbourne
Applicant: Mr Malcolm Bell, assisted by Ms Fiona Galbraith, patent and trade marks attorneys, both of Phillips Ormonde & Fitzpatrick, Melbourne.
Decision: 2012 ATMO 50
Section 52 opposition: Application under regulation 5.15 for extension of time to serve evidence in support – application allowed – costs awarded against trade mark applicant (objector to the extension).

Background

  1. This is a decision with reasons in the matter of an application for extension of time to serve evidence in support of an opposition to registration. Vista RV Crossover Pty Ltd, of Bayswater, Victoria (‘the applicant’) filed trade mark application number 1439409 on 26 July 2011 to register, as a trade mark, the word and letters:

VISTA RV

  1. The application was filed in class 12 of the Nice Classification of Goods and Services, in respect of ‘Off-road camper trailers’.

  2. A ground for rejection under section 44 was raised against the application during examination, based upon prior trade mark registration number 1154833, owned by Hunter Property Holdings (Aust) Pty Ltd, for the trade mark ‘Vista’ in classes 12 and 39, in respect of the following goods and services:

    Class 12: Motorhomes, campervans, caravans, camper trailers and campmobiles; vehicle bodies and chassis; parts and accessories for the aforesaid goods

    Class 39: Rental of motorhomes, campervans, caravans, camper trailers and campmobiles; rental of accessories for the aforesaid goods

  3. The applicant filed evidence of its own use in response to the ground of rejection, which was then withdrawn. The application was advertised as accepted for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 17 November 2011.

  4. Hunter Property Holdings (Aust) Pty Ltd, of Mooroolbark Victoria (‘the opponent’) could have waited out the three month opposition period (also extendible in some circumstances for a further three months) available to it for the purpose, but instead chose to file its notice of opposition on very day that the acceptance of the application was advertised.

  5. The statutory period for evidence in support of the opposition to be served and filed therefore commenced on that day, and the final date for this to be done, 17 February 2012, passed without further communication from opponent. However, on 5 March 2012, the Trade Marks Office (‘the Office’) received a late application from the opponent for an extension of time of three months, until 17 May 2012, to serve its evidence. The reasons for needing the extra time given in the opponent’s application were as follows:

    Both parties are trying to negotiate a settlement. In Federal Court proceedings No. VID1371/2011 issued on 5 December 2011 the Opponent is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hunter Property Holdings (Aust) Pty Ltd v Vista RV Crossover... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] ATMO 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Hearing Officer Claudia Murray concerning an application by Hunter Property Holdings (Aust) Pty Ltd (the opponent) for an extension of time to serve its evidence in support of its opposition to a trade mark application by Vista RV Crossover Pty Ltd (the applicant). The dispute centred on whether the opponent had adequately demonstrated that settlement negotiations were actively being pursued, a prerequisite for obtaining such an extension under the relevant regulations.

The legal issues before the Hearing Officer were whether the opponent had satisfied the requirements of regulation 5.15 of the relevant regulations, specifically whether the Registrar was reasonably satisfied that an extension of time for serving evidence was appropriate. This involved determining whether the opponent had demonstrated that settlement negotiations were genuinely on foot, and whether the parties had been given a reasonable opportunity to make representations concerning the application. The applicant argued that the parties were not engaged in settlement negotiations, and that the opponent's reference to court-ordered mediation in separate Federal Court proceedings did not constitute such negotiations.

The Hearing Officer reasoned that while there is a public interest in the timely resolution of opposition proceedings, this was outweighed by the public interest in ensuring that serious oppositions are decided on their merits rather than being determined by administrative issues. The opponent's submissions, including statutory declarations and correspondence, satisfied the Hearing Officer that an extension was appropriate. The Hearing Officer found that the opponent had not failed to justify its request on the basis of negotiations being on foot, and that the applicant's consent to court-ordered mediation in separate proceedings did not negate the possibility of settlement discussions.

The Hearing Officer granted the opponent's application for an extension of time until 17 May 2012. The Hearing Officer also awarded costs against the unsuccessful trade mark applicant, Vista RV Crossover Pty Ltd, according to the official scale.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The relevant provisions of regulation 5.15 state:(1) A party to the opposition proceedings may apply to the Registrar:(a) for an extension of the period for serving a copy of the evidence under regulation 5.7, 5.10 or 5.12…(2) The Registrar may grant an application on reasonable terms specified by the Registrar.(3) The Registrar must not grant an application unless the Registrar:(a) is reasonably satisfied that the applicant has served a copy of the application, and of any documents accompanying the application, on the other party; and(b) has given the parties a reasonable opportunity to make representations concerning the application; and(c) is reasonably satisfied that:(i) in the case of an application to which paragraph (1) (a) applies — the extension of the period for serving a copy of the evidence…is appropriate.(4) For the purposes of paragraph (3) (b), the representations may be made in writing or at a hearing or by such other means as the Registrar reasonably allows.Evidence and submissions In the course of providing its written outline of hearing submissions objecting to the extension of time, the trade mark applicant also provided to me and to the opponent the following:ØStatutory declaration of Malcolm Neil Bell, with Exhibits MNB-1 to MNB-4, dated 30 April 2012. Mr Bell’s declaration exhibits documents relating to the Federal Court proceedings between the parties, together with recent exchanges of letters and emails between the parties’ representatives, including in relation to attendance of compulsory mediation ordered by the Federal Court. The correspondence reflects a certain degree of mutual antagonism. The opponent responded with:ØStatutory declaration of Mark Laurence Worsnop, with Exhibits A to G, dated 30 April 2012. Mr Worsnop’s declaration also exhibits correspondence exchanged between the parties, which is of an earlier date (2011) than that in Mr Bell’s declaration, but which also reflects two parties ‘at loggerheads’ over the ‘VISTA’ trade mark, as Mr Bell put it at the commencement of the hearing. It is a rare point of common ground between the parties that the history of their grievances dates back to 2008. Mr Bell’s arguments against the extension went essentially to the inadequacies of the opponent’s original case in support of its extension request, and to the fact that the applicant simply disputed that the parties have ever been involved in settlement negotiations, as claimed by the opponent. He quoted various cases in support of the applicant’s position that this first extension of time request should not be granted, most notably Parkhurst Pines Pty Ltd and Ors v Truefeat Pty Ltd (1995) 31 IPR 157 (Parkhurst Pines). Mr Bell submitted:In the extension application, the Opponent states that the parties "are trying to negotiate a settlement". It also refers to mediation of the Federal Court proceedings.The parties are not, and have not ever been, trying to negotiate a settlement, either generally, or more relevantly in relation to this opposition. The parties have through their solicitors discussed whether they might meet to discuss the Federal Court proceedings. This is dealt with in the Bell declaration. It is apparent from the Bell declaration, and the correspondence exhibited thereto that there have never been any settlement discussions.Federal Court proceedings are now, and have for some time, been referred to mediation by the court. The Federal Court requires parties to attend mediation at some point in the litigation process before trial. That there would be a court-ordered mediation of the proceedings was essentially inevitable, so the fact that the Applicant consented to orders that the Federal Court proceedings be referred to mediation does not demonstrate that the parties were engaged in negotiations to settle these proceedings.Since the 2002 PGA decision[1] was handed down, the Registrar has adopted a change in practice which allows parties to suspend an opposition by mutual consent in order to have time to carry out settlement negotiations. The Official Notice dated 21 February 2008 states that extensions of time requested for the purpose of negotiations "requested after 1 March 2008 will only be allowed if the other party provides its written consent. Furthermore, the extension applicant must provide sufficient information to show negotiations are being actively pursued by both parties."In recent years, suspension of oppositions has commonly occurred by consent when negotiations are on foot. However, in this case, the Applicant would not have consented to a suspension of the opposition proceedings had the Opponent requested this before its evidence in support was due. It was not in its interests to do so, and settlement discussions were not on foot at that time (nor are they now). The fact the Applicant would not have consented to a suspension of time in this opposition is irrefutable evidence that negotiations were not on foot in this opposition when the Opponent's extension of time application was filed.The Opponent should not be permitted to obtain a de facto suspension of this opposition merely by pointing to the fact that the parties have consented to the Federal Court proceedings being referred to mediation.The Opponent has clearly failed to justify its extension request on the basis that negotiations are on foot…In Parkhurst Pines, the Hearing Officer refused the first extension of time request. The Hearing Officer was influenced by the fact that the applicants may be adversely affected by being caught up in a lengthy process, having regard to the strong possibility that the opponent will seek further extensions. Such a concern is a live issue in this case too, given the Opponent has not indicated that it has a clear intention of preparing evidence in support before the Federal Court proceedings are resolved.[1] Professional Golfers Association Ltd v Ladies Professional Golf Association [2002] ATMO 79, 17 September 2002

Decision

Reasons for decision

In regards to the public interest, while I agree with the applicant that there exists a reasonable public interest in any opposition proceeding in a timely manner, I do not agree that this should override the far stronger public concerns I have alluded to above. That is, the strong public interest in a serious opposition being decided on the merits of the case, not upon what amounts to an administrative hitch very early in proceedings.Decision The opponent’s hearing submissions in support of its application for extension of time to serve its evidence in support have satisfied me that it is appropriate to grant the extension at issue, until 17 May 2012, without further delay. This I now do. Costs The trade mark applicant sought its costs in this matter. However, it is usual for costs to follow the event, and I believe that is an appropriate outcome here. I award costs, according to the official scale, against the unsuccessful trade mark applicant, Vista RV Crossover Pty Ltd.Claudia MurrayHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings15 May 2012

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established