Preston SuperAccess Pty Limited and Australian Trade Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

[2013] AATA 537

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/3765

Re

Preston SuperAccess Pty Limited

APPLICANT

And

Australian Trade Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

The Hon. Brian Tamberlin, QC, Deputy President

Date 2 August 2013
Place Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

......................[sgd]...............................................

The Hon. Brian Tamberlin, QC, Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

TRADE AND COMMERCE – industry assistance – export market development grants – change of ownership of business – whether the new business is similar to the old business – whether the new business should be treated as a continuation of the old business – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Export Market Development Grants Act 1997 ss 7, 93, 94, 101

CASES

Re Amlink Technologies Pty Ltd and Australian Trade Commission (2005) 86 ALD 370; [2005] AATA 359

Re Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd and Australian Trade Commission [2013] AATA 231

Re Magee and Australian Trade Commission (1994) 36 ALD 304

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Export Market Development Grants (Change in Ownership of Business) Guidelines 2006

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. Brian Tamberlin, QC, Deputy President

2 August 2013

  1. The Applicant (Preston SuperAccess Pty Limited) seeks review of a decision by the Respondent Commission of 13 August 2012, which affirmed an earlier decision to refuse an application for an export market development grant for the 2010-2011 year on the ground that the Applicant’s business was a continuation of business activities previously carried out by Mr John Preston, Preston International Pty Ltd, Preston Erection Pty Ltd and Preston Australia Pty Ltd.

  2. The basis for the decision was that Preston SuperAccess was continuing a business previously carried on in respect of which there had been eight prior grants, and the application by Preston SuperAccess was a ninth application and as such was not eligible to receive a grant as the maximum number of grants payable is seven under s 7 of the Export Market Development Grants Act 1997 (the Act).

    LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK

  3. The Act provides for an assistance incentive scheme under which small and medium Australian exporters, having a total annual turnover of less than $50 million which are committed to and capable of seeking out and developing export businesses, are repaid part of the expenses incurred in promoting their products.

  4. The scheme is capped which means there is a finite amount of money allocated by the Australian government to fund the administration of the scheme and the payment of grants.

  5. The object of the grants is that Australian businesses that are developing export markets for eligible products, and have a prospect of success in their export enterprise, should be eligible for a grant.

  6. Under the general rules of eligibility in s 7 of the Act a person is only eligible for a grant if the person is not a grantee in respect of seven or more previous grant years.

  7. Under s 93 an underlying principle of the provisions is that the rules relating to grants that are payable “in respect of a business” (including the limitation on the number of grants that are payable)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Preston SuperAccess Pty Limited and Australian Trade Commiss... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 537
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the parties involved are Preston SuperAccess Pty Limited and the Australian Trade Commission, with the dispute centering on the eligibility for export market development grants. The matter was heard and determined by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal of Australia. The core issue before the court was whether the new business of the applicant, Preston SuperAccess Pty Limited, is sufficiently similar to its former businesses, Super Scaffold and SuperDeck, such that it should be treated as a continuation of those businesses for the purposes of the Export Market Development Grants Act. The applicant had applied for 10 export market development grants, but these were denied on the basis that the new business was not similar enough to the old businesses to qualify for the grants.

The Tribunal examined the evidence provided, including documents and expert testimony, to assess the degree of similarity between the businesses. The court noted that the applicant's new business, SuperAccess, was in its early stages and heavily reliant on the intellectual property and assistance from the existing Preston entities. The intellectual property at the heart of the businesses, particularly the inventions related to multi-storey construction, scaffolding, and decking, was found to be similar across the different entities. Given this similarity and the fact that the new business is a continuation of the old businesses in terms of the intellectual property and the core business focus, the Tribunal concluded that the new business should indeed be treated as a continuation of the old businesses.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the statutory provisions and guidelines, which require a factual evaluation of the degree of similarity between the businesses. The Tribunal found that the new business, despite some variations in product or service, was substantially similar to the old businesses. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Australian Trade Commission to deny the grants on the basis that the new business was not sufficiently similar to the old businesses. This decision underscores the importance of a thorough factual evaluation in determining the eligibility for export market development grants.

Background

Background to the litigation

Preston SuperAccess Pty Limited and associated entities (Preston entities) have applied for export market development grants under the Export Market Development Grants Act. The applications were made by Mr Preston, who has been involved in the scaffolding and formwork industry since 1982. He is the inventor of the Preston Folding Scaffold, a successful product in the scaffolding industry. The Preston entities have made claims for a total of ten export market development grants. The evidence presented in the case includes documents and expert testimony from Mr Crawford, a qualified civil engineer with extensive experience in the scaffolding industry.

This case involves a review of the decision made by the Australian Trade Commission (ATC) on 13 August 2012. The decision concerned the eligibility of Preston SuperAccess Pty Limited for an export market development grant under the Export Market Development Grants Act. The matter was heard and determined by a tribunal or a similar body, which examined the evidence and arguments presented by both parties. The tribunal reviewed the Guidelines for assessing the similarity between the businesses and determined whether the new business should be treated as a continuation of the old businesses.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Preston agrees that the Preston entities have made claims for 10 export market development grants in all.EVIDENCE The evidence took the form of documents submitted by both sides, including the T-documents; material submitted by Mr Preston together with oral evidence in chief and by way of cross-examination of Mr John Preston and Mr Crawford, who was an expert witness called by Mr Preston whose field of expertise and experience is in scaffolding and formwork. Mr Crawford has been involved in the scaffolding industry since 1982 and he is a qualified civil engineer from both the University of New South Wales and the Sydney Technical College.APPROACH It is clear from ss 93 and 94 of the Act that the limitation on the number of grants requires consideration of the similarities and differences between the businesses carried on, notwithstanding a change in ownership. Under the Guidelines, consideration must be given to the directors, shareholders and management personnel of the new and old businesses. Businesses can be substantially similar notwithstanding that there has been a development or variation in the range or type of product or service provided in the course of the business. A variation in the nature or type of product or in the manner in which the business is carried on is, of course, a relevant factor to be taken into account under the Guidelines. Limited guidance can be obtained from decided cases because in each case the question is essentially one of fact and degree. The considerations that products sold are more technically advanced, or the business is conducted on a larger scale, do not of themselves necessarily mean that the new business is not to be treated as a continuation of the old business: see Re Amlink Technologies Pty Ltd and Australian Trade Commission (2005) 86 ALD 370; [2005] AATA 359 at [66]. Nor does the fact that the new business evolves or develops as a result of a competitive market pressures mean that the business cannot be treated as a continuation of the old business: see Re Magee and Australian Trade Commission (1994) 36 ALD 304 at 311. The comparison of the degree of similarity between the businesses requires a balancing and weighing of the considerations required to be taken into account by the Guidelines, in the light of the evidence, and forming a degree of satisfaction based on an evaluation of the relative weight to be assigned to the relevant considerations. It is not a mathematical exercise, but one of factual evaluation and weight: see Re Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd and Australian Trade Commission [2013] AATA 231 at [55]. I now turn to the question whether the new business of the Applicant is similar to the old business, or part of it, to such an extent that I am satisfied that the new business should be treated as a continuation of the old business.GUIDELINE (a) – PRODUCT – COMPARISON This requires consideration of the similarities between the products of the old and new businesses. The original product of the business carried on under the management of Mr Preston at the earliest stages involved the fitting of scaffolding and some system scaffolding. In and after 1985 Mr Preston’s business involved the exploitation and development of the intellectual property and rights arising from his invention of the Preston Folding Scaffold. This was a very successful business because it was fast to erect and saved money.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The intellectual property which is at the heart of the three businesses is similar in nature, namely in each case, an invention by Mr Preston in the area of multi-storey construction, scaffolding and decking. Apart from the intellectual property the evidence does not indicate what other assets the Applicant has. As the new business is in a very early stage of development it is dependent on assistance from existing Preston entities. Although Mr Preston has produced a number of other inventions, the central business of the three relevant inventions in this case is that they relate to exploitation of his intellectual property in multi-storey supporting structures for the building construction.CONCLUSION Having regard to the above considerations in the light of the evidence, I am satisfied that the business in respect of which the grant is sought is sufficiently similar to the Preston Folding Scaffold and SuperDeck businesses to such an extent that the new business of SuperAccess should be treated as a continuation of the old businesses which concern Super Scaffold and SuperDeck. I therefore affirm the decision of the Respondent of 13 August 2012.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the similarities between the products and intellectual property of the old and new businesses, guided by the Export Market Development Grants Act and its guidelines. It noted that while the new business involved some variations, such as the development of the SuperDeck, these did not negate the substantial similarity required to treat it as a continuation. The court found that the core intellectual property, which involved Mr. Preston's inventions in multi-storey construction, scaffolding, and decking, was consistent across the businesses. This intellectual property was the central asset driving the businesses, despite other possible assets not being clearly identified in the evidence. The court balanced these factors and concluded that the new business should be treated as a continuation of the old ones. This decision was based on the principle that a business can still be considered a continuation even if there are variations in the products or services provided, provided the core intellectual property remains consistent. The court did not find it necessary to depart from or distinguish any prior authority, as the decision was largely fact-specific and based on the particular circumstances presented in the case.