Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd and Australian Trade Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

[2013] AATA  231

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2012/3205

Re

Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

And

Australian Trade Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms N Bell, Senior Member

Date 17 April 2013 
Place Sydney

The decision under review is set aside and remitted to the Australian Trade Commission with the direction that section 94(1)(b)(ii) of the Export Market Development Grants Act 1997 does not apply.

....[Sgd]....................................................................

Ms N Bell, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

TRADE AND COMMERCER – Industry assistance – Export market development grant – Whether new business a continuation of previous business – whether old and new business are similar – decision under review set aside and remitted

LEGISLATION

Export Market development Grants Act 1997 (Cth), ss 94, 94(1), 94(1)(b)(ii)

CASES

Amlink Technologies Pty Ltd and Australian Trade Commission (2005) 86 ALD 370

Magee and Australian Trade Commission (1994) 36 ALD 304

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Export Market Development Grants (Change in Ownership of Business) Guidelines 2006

EMDG Administrative Guidelines, July 2011

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms N Bell, Senior Member

  1. The Fairlight CMI was an icon of 1980s music.

  2. A large and costly computer musical instrument, it enabled an operator to sample sounds and play them back on a music keyboard at the chosen pitch. It was the world’s first commercial sampler, preceding the introduction of personal computers, and, over the next decade, achieving such popularity among those who had the funds to acquire it that one prominent popular musician included in the jacket notes to his album the words: “There is no Fairlight on this Record”. (Phil Collins, No Jacket Required, 1985).

  3. Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd was incorporated in 1975 by Peter Vogel and Kim Ryrie. The company’s most notable product was the CMI. In 1989, two years after Peter Vogel left the company to pursue other activities, Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd went into administration, following the production of less expensive samplers by Japanese competitors. The company’s assets were purchased by Fairlight ESP Pty Ltd. After moving away from musical instruments and into the production of recording and mixing consoles, Fairlight ESP Pty Ltd went into administration in 2003. Its assets were purchased by Fairlight AU Pty Ltd which pursued production of recording and mixing devices and continues in that business today.

  4. After more than 20 years away from the music industry and with no continuing involvement with Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd, Fairlight ESP Pty Ltd or Fairlight AU Pty Ltd, Peter Vogel began a new company, Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd (the new Fairlight Instruments). The “old” Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd had been de-registered in 1992. The new Fairlight Instruments commenced to design, sell and distribute the CMI-30A, a computer musical instrument that looks very much like the old CMI.

  5. The old Fairlight Instruments had been granted ten development grants under the Export Market Development Grants Act 1974, the predecessor to the 1997 Act of the same name. This number of grants exceeds the current limit of seven grants per applicant. The new Fairlight Instruments’ application for a grant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd and Australian Trade Commissio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 231
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd challenged a decision of the Australian Trade Commission, which had found that the company was ineligible for an export market development grant under the Export Market Development Grants Act 1997. The issue before the court was whether the new company, Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd, should be treated as a continuation of the old company for the purposes of determining eligibility for the grant.

The court considered the legal principles that should be applied in determining whether two companies are sufficiently similar to be considered a continuation of one another. The court held that the test for determining whether two companies are a continuation of one another is not a mathematical exercise, but rather a question of degree. The court must weigh the similarities and differences between the two companies and arrive at an overall conclusion.

In this case, the court found that the new company was not sufficiently similar to the old company to warrant treating it as a continuation of the old company. The court found that the new company had a different structure, management, and operations to the old company, and that the old company had ceased to exist prior to the new company being established. The court held that the Australian Trade Commission had erred in finding that the new company was a continuation of the old company, and set aside the decision under review.

The court remitted the matter to the Australian Trade Commission with directions that section 94(1)(b)(ii) of the Export Market Development Grants Act 1997 does not apply to the new company.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd and the Australian Trade Commission. Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd, originally established as Fairlight Instruments Limited, was a company involved in the development and manufacture of electronic musical instruments. The company had previously been granted an export market development grant by the Australian Trade Commission under the Export Market Development Grants Act 1997. Subsequently, the company was restructured and renamed Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd. The Australian Trade Commission subsequently denied the restructured company a new export market development grant, asserting that the new company was not sufficiently distinct from the old company to warrant a new grant. Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd sought judicial review of the Trade Commission's decision, arguing that the new company should be treated as a continuation of the old company for the purposes of the grant.

The matter came before the court as a judicial review application. Fairlight Instruments Pty Ltd applied for judicial review of the Australian Trade Commission's decision to deny the new company an export market development grant. The application was heard by the court, which was tasked with determining whether the Trade Commission's decision was legally sound. The court considered the arguments presented by both parties and reviewed the relevant statutory provisions and precedents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

These comparisons and their cumulative effect do not constitute a mathematical exercise. I must weigh the similarities and differences and arrive at an overall conclusion. The conclusion I have reached is that the old Fairlight Instruments and the new Fairlight Instruments are not sufficiently similar to warrant treating the new company as a continuation of the old company.DECISION The decision under review is set aside and remitted to the Australian Trade Commission with the direction that section 94(1)(b)(ii) of the Export Market Development Grants Act 1997 does not apply.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the similarities and differences between the old and new Fairlight Instruments companies to determine whether the new company should be treated as a continuation of the old one under the Act. The court concluded that while there were some similarities, such as the name and location, there were also significant differences in ownership and management structure. The court emphasised that the comparison was not a mathematical exercise but rather an overall assessment of the entities' characteristics.

In making this determination, the court applied the principle that a company's continuity is assessed based on the retention of the same business, ownership, and control. The court found that the new company did not retain the same ownership and control as the old company, leading to the conclusion that it should not be treated as a continuation.

Regarding the Australian Trade Commission's decision, the court held that the Commission's conclusion that the new company was a continuation of the old one was not supported by the evidence. The court noted that the Commission had failed to properly weigh the relevant factors and had placed undue emphasis on the superficial similarities between the two companies. The court also found that the Commission had not adequately considered the differences between the two entities, particularly in terms of ownership and control.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that when assessing whether a new company should be treated as a continuation of an old company for the purposes of the Act, the court will consider all relevant factors, including ownership, control, and business operations. The court will not accept a conclusion that is based on a superficial comparison of names and locations without considering the overall characteristics of the entities. Additionally, the court must ensure that the decision-maker properly weighs all relevant factors and does not place undue emphasis on superficial similarities.