Presley v Geraghty

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read
29 CLR 154

GERAGHTY

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Northern Territory-Supreme Court-Deputy Judge-Appointment-Validity-

Supreme Coart Ordinance 1911-1919 (Northern Territory) (No. 9 of 1911- No. 13 of 1919), secs. 3-9, 10B, 10c. MELBOURNE, Mar. 11, 17.

Sec. 10B of the Supreme Court Ordinance 1911-1919 (Northern Territory) provides that "(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in this ordinance the Governor-General may, by commission, appoint a person to be a Deputy Judge of the Supreme Court during such period and for such purposes as are specified in the commission. (2) In relation to the purposes for which he is appointed the Deputy Judge shall have all the powers and may exercise all the authorities which are vested in or may be exercised by the Judge of the Supreme Court."

Held, by Knox C.J., Gavan Duffy and Rich JJ. (Higgins and Starke JJ. dissenting), that that section gives no power to appoint a Deputy Judge at a time when there is no Judge of the Supreme Court.

APPLICATION for leave to appeal from the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory.

On 9th and 10th August 1920 at Darwin, in the Northern Territory, before Gerald Hogan, a Special Magistrate of the Northern Territory, an information was heard whereby Edward Patrick Geraghty charged that Villiers Clarence Murray Presley unlawfully had in his possession certain beer upon which duty had not been paid. The

29 CLR 155

information was dismissed, and the informant appealed to the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory. The appeal came on for hearing on 2nd November 1920 before the same Gerald Hogan, purporting to sit as a Deputy Judge of the Supreme Court, and he, on 8th November 1920, at the conclusion of the hearing, allowed the appeal and imposed a penalty upon the defendant.

The defendant now, on notice to the Minister for Home and Territories, moved for leave to appeal to the High Court from that decision, one of the grounds of the proposed appeal being that Mr. Hogan had not been duly appointed to the position of Deputy Judge. It appeared that in the Commonwealth Gazette of 30th September 1920 there was published a notice that David John Davies Bevan, Esq., who was then the Judge of the Supreme Court, was removed from office as from 22nd September 1920 that thereafter no Judge of the Supreme Court had been appointed and that Mr. Hogan was, by commission dated 21st October 1920, appointed Deputy Judge for a term of three months from 15th October 1920 " for the purpose of dealing with any cases which may in accordance with law come before the Supreme Court."

Sanderson, for the applicant. The word "deputy" ordinarily implies that there is an existing principal, and there is nothing in the Supreme Court Ordinance 1911-1919 which shows that it has not that implication in secs. 10B and 10c of that ordinance. See Stroud's Dictionary, sub "Deputy," citing from Termes de la Ley County Courts Act 1888 (51 &52 Vict. c. 43), sec. 21; Ex parte…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Presley v Geraghty and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1921] HCA 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an application for leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory. The applicant, Villiers Clarence Murray Presley, sought to appeal an order made by Gerald Hogan, who purported to act as a Deputy Judge of the Supreme Court. Presley's grounds for appeal included the assertion that Mr. Hogan had not been duly appointed to the position of Deputy Judge. The dispute arose from an information laid by Edward Patrick Geraghty, alleging Presley unlawfully possessed unpaid duty beer, which was initially dismissed by a Special Magistrate but later allowed on appeal by Mr. Hogan, who imposed a penalty.

The central legal issue before the High Court was the validity of Mr. Hogan's appointment as Deputy Judge. Specifically, the court had to determine whether section 10B of the *Supreme Court Ordinance 1911-1919* (Northern Territory) authorised the Governor-General to appoint a Deputy Judge at a time when there was no substantive Judge of the Supreme Court in office. The Judge of the Supreme Court had been removed from office prior to Mr. Hogan's appointment, and no new Judge had been appointed subsequently.

A majority of the High Court, comprising Knox C.J., Gavan Duffy and Rich JJ., held that section 10B did not grant power to appoint a Deputy Judge when no Judge of the Supreme Court was in existence. Their reasoning focused on the ordinary meaning of the word "deputy," which implies acting in place of an existing principal. They noted that section 10C of the Ordinance, which required a Deputy Judge to take an oath before the Judge of the Supreme Court, further suggested the necessity of an existing Judge. While acknowledging that amendments had altered the oath-taking procedure, the majority found no clear indication in the Ordinance that the Legislature intended to permit the appointment of a Deputy Judge in the absence of a substantive Judge. Higgins and Starke JJ. dissented, arguing that the term "Deputy Judge" could refer to an independent office and that the Ordinance's provisions, particularly the specified period and purposes of appointment, did not necessitate the existence of a substantive Judge.

The majority of the Court, having concluded that Mr. Hogan's appointment was invalid, suggested that litigation should cease with the Minister for Home and Territories consenting to pay the costs of the motion and undertaking not to enforce the conviction. This outcome effectively meant that the appeal would not proceed on its merits due to the jurisdictional issue.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established