Prentice v Boyle

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

PRENTICE v BOYLE [2010] FMCA 681
BANKRUPTCY – Undervalued transactions – aircraft purchased in name of bankrupt – transfer of title to wife for no consideration – claimed purchase as agent for wife and loan of purchase money – no independent evidence of agreements – claims disbelieved – property vested in trustee – orders for delivery to trustee.
Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), ss.77A, 81, 120, 120(1), 120(5), 121, 121(3), 121(4), 188, 222(10)
Federal Magistrates Court (Bankruptcy) Rules 2006 (Cth)
Sale of Goods Act 1896 (QLD), s.20
For The Good Times Pty Ltd v Boyle & Anor [2009] FMCA 512
For the Good Times Pty Ltd v Coltern Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 807
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118
McMurtrie v Commonwealth of Australia [2006] NSWCA 14
Watson v Foxman (1995) 49 NSWLR 315
Applicant:

MAXWELL WILLIAM PRENTICE

AS TRUSTEE OF THE PROPERTY OF NORMAN BOYLE

Respondent:

VICKI LYNNE BOYLE

AKA VICKI SALON

File Number: SYG 252 of 2010
Judgment of: Smith FM
Hearing dates: 3 & 4 August 2010
Date for Last Submission: 16 August 2010
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 14 September 2010

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr J T Johnson
Solicitors for the Applicant: Sally Nash & Co.
Counsel for the Respondent: Respondent in person

ORDERS

  1. Declare that the Evektor Sportstar Plane registration number 24.4113 Airframe No: 2004 0303 (“Evektor Sportstar Plane”) was acquired by Norman Clifford Boyle beneficially under an agreement to purchase dated 3 May 2004 completed on or about 24 August 2004. 

  2. Declare that the Evektor Sportstar Plane was the property of Norman Clifford Boyle at the time it was transferred to the respondent on or about 28 June 2006. 

  3. Declare that the transfer of the Evektor Sportstar Plane by Norman Clifford Boyle to the respondent on or about 28 June 2006 is void against the applicant. 

  4. Declare that the Evektor Sportstar Plane is property vested in the applicant in his capacity as trustee of the bankrupt estate of Norman Clifford Boyle. 

  5. The respondent, by herself, her servants, employees or agents are restrained from using or seeking to use the Evektor Sportstar Plane in any way other than for the purposes of complying with these orders. 

  6. The undertaking as to damages given by the applicant to the Court on 16 February 2010 and 25 April 2010 is discharged. 

  7. The respondent by herself, her servants, employees and agents shall forthwith deliver up or cause to be delivered up to the applicant the Evektor Sportstar Plane, together with its logbook and all other documents and articles necessary for its use and registration.  Delivery shall be given to any servant or agent of the applicant authorised by him in writing to take possession of the Evektor Sportstar Plane. 

  8. In the event of there being a default in compliance with order 7 above within 3 days, and following upon the applicant filing with the Court an affidavit to that effect, a writ of specific delivery may be issued to the sheriff for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prentice v Boyle and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FMCA 681
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Prentice v Boyle involved a dispute between the applicant, who acted as trustee for the bankrupt estate of Norman Clifford Boyle, and the respondent, Mrs Norma Jean Boyle, over the ownership of an Evektor Sportstar Plane. The applicant sought a declaration that the aircraft was owned by Mr Boyle at the time it was transferred to the respondent, and that the transfer was void against the applicant. The court was required to determine whether Mr Boyle had acquired the aircraft personally or whether it was held on trust for Mrs Boyle, as well as whether the transfer of the aircraft to the respondent was valid.

The court found that there was no evidence to suggest that Mr Boyle had acquired the aircraft as an agent for Mrs Boyle or that the aircraft was held on trust for her. The court also found that the registration of the aircraft in Mr Boyle's name and the fact that he used the aircraft for both business and personal purposes supported the conclusion that he had acquired it personally. The court further found that the transfer of the aircraft to the respondent was void against the applicant, as it occurred after Mr Boyle's bankruptcy and therefore formed part of his bankrupt estate.

The court made several orders in favour of the applicant, including a declaration that the aircraft was owned by Mr Boyle at the time of the transfer to the respondent, that the transfer was void, and that the aircraft was now vested in the applicant as trustee for the bankrupt estate of Mr Boyle. The court also ordered the respondent to deliver the aircraft to the applicant, together with its logbook and all other necessary documents, and restrained her from using the aircraft except for the purposes of complying with the orders. The applicant was granted liberty to apply for further orders if the respondent failed to comply with the delivery order.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

Declare that the Evektor Sportstar Plane registration number 24.4113 Airframe No: 2004 0303 (“Evektor Sportstar Plane”) was acquired by Norman Clifford Boyle beneficially under an agreement to purchase dated 3 May 2004 completed on or about 24 August 2004.

2.

Declare that the Evektor Sportstar Plane was the property of Norman Clifford Boyle at the time it was transferred to the respondent on or about 28 June 2006.

3.

Declare that the transfer of the Evektor Sportstar Plane by Norman Clifford Boyle to the respondent on or about 28 June 2006 is void against the applicant.

4.

Declare that the Evektor Sportstar Plane is property vested in the applicant in his capacity as trustee of the bankrupt estate of Norman Clifford Boyle.

5.

The respondent, by herself, her servants, employees or agents are restrained from using or seeking to use the Evektor Sportstar Plane in any way other than for the purposes of complying with these orders.

6.

The undertaking as to damages given by the applicant to the Court on 16 February 2010 and 25 April 2010 is discharged.

7.

The respondent by herself, her servants, employees and agents shall forthwith deliver up or cause to be delivered up to the applicant the Evektor Sportstar Plane, together with its logbook and all other documents and articles necessary for its use and registration. Delivery shall be given to any servant or agent of the applicant authorised by him in writing to take possession of the Evektor Sportstar Plane.

8.

In the event of there being a default in compliance with order 7 above within 3 days, and following upon the applicant filing with the Court an affidavit to that effect, a writ of specific delivery may be issued to the sheriff for possession of the Evektor Sportstar Plane. The writ shall direct the sheriff to take possession of the Evektor Sportstar Plane, together with its logbook and all other documents and articles necessary for its use and registration, and to deliver the Evektor Sportstar Plane to the applicant or any servant or agent of the applicant authorised in writing by him for that purpose.

9.

The applicant has liberty to apply for further orders should the respondent not deliver the Evektor Sportstar Plane, together with its logbook and all other documents and articles necessary for its use and registration, to either the sheriff or the applicant.

10.

The respondent pay the applicant’s costs including reserved costs as agreed or taxed pursuant to the

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Delivery of the aircraft under the purchase agreement was due to occur at Merimbula Airfield. An acknowledgement of delivery to Mr Boyle personally is signed by him on 29 August 2004. Immediately prior to delivery, evidence was provided to SilverWing that Mr Boyle had become registered as the sole owner of the aircraft with Recreational Aviation Australia Inc. A certificate showing this was issued on 26 August 2004, and states: RAA AIRCRAFT REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE Date issued: 26 Aug 2004 This is not a certificate of title This aircraft has been entered into the register of Recreational Aviation Australian Inc. in accordance with Civil Aviation Orders and this certificate is not transferable. It is the responsibility of the aircraft registrant to ensure that this aircraft complies with and is operated in accordance with all applicable Orders and Regulations. The period of validity is subject to the satisfactory completion of all relevant aircraft inspections. Any changes to the items on this certificate including change of registrant or change of ownership of the aircraft must be notified to RAA within 14 days of the change and must make this certificate available to the new registrant. This certificate becomes void on sale or transfer of the aircraft and the disposing registrant must notify RAA within 14 days of the sale or transfer. In the event of destruction of the aircraft, or when the aircraft is withdrawn from use, the registrant must notify RAA within 14 days and must forward this certificate to RAA. [details of registration omitted] Also on the SilverWing file is a copy of a letter on ‘Norm Boyle’ letterhead, faxed to it from Mrs Boyle on 25 August 2004. It is signed by Mrs Boyle, and states: Please note Norms address for registration is [address] Merimbula NSW 2548. I apologise for the delay in getting this info to you Norm is in North Queensland and has been uncontactable for the last few days. Manifestly, none of the above documentation and events provide any evidence to suggest anything other than that property in the aircraft was acquired only by Mr Boyle, that it was acquired personally by him and not as an agent for Mrs Boyle, and that this probably occurred with the knowledge of Mrs Boyle. Additional documents were obtained by the Trustee from Recreational Aviation Australia Inc, showing the registration of the aircraft in the subsequent years. They show that renewals were made by Mr Boyle, and that certificates were issued to him as the sole owner on 20 May 2005, and 23 May 2006. It is common ground that Mr Boyle acquired a pilot’s licence and used the aircraft, after commencing training soon after the purchase of the aircraft. It is reasonable to infer that he then used it, inter alia, in the course of his business affairs, which must have required him frequently to travel between the South Coast and the Southern Highlands of NSW, and possibly elsewhere in Australia. I also accept that the aircraft was probably also used for family purposes.