Prasad v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Prasad v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FCA 791

Review of: Prasad v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] AATA 3438
File number: NSD 1335 of 2023
Judgment of: SHARIFF J
Date of judgment: 19 July 2024
Catchwords: MIGRATION – application for judicial review of decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to affirm decision of delegate of the Minister not to revoke cancellation of the applicant’s visa under 501CA(4) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – whether Tribunal acted on a misunderstanding of law by failing to take into account applicant’s personal circumstances when attributing weight to primary consideration of expectations of the Australian community – whether Tribunal denied applicant procedural fairness by failing to consider argument relying on CKL21 v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] FCAFC 70; (2022) 293 FCR 634 – whether Tribunal denied applicant procedural fairness by failing to advise or inform applicant and witnesses of proposed adverse credibility findings – whether Tribunal failed to give proper, genuine and realistic consideration to representations made by applicant regarding rehabilitation and risk of reoffending – whether Tribunal ignored, overlooked or misunderstood evidence adduced by witness – no errors established – application dismissed with costs
Legislation:

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 499(2A), 500(1)(ba), 500(6H), 500(6J), 500(6L)(c), 501(3A), 501(6), 501CA, 501CA(4), 501CA(4)(b)(ii)

Direction No 79 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA

Direction No 90 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA

Direction No 99 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA

Cases cited:

Ali v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCA 559

BJI20 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCA 1632

BQL15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 104

CKL21 v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] FCAFC 70; (2022) 293 FCR 634

Comcare v Lilley [2013] FCAFC 121; (2013) 216 FCR 214

Commissioner for Australian Capital Territory Revenue v Alphaone Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 576

Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] HCA 26; (2003) 77 ALJR 1088

Dunasemantv Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCAFC 13; (2022) 292 FCR 155

FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 185; (2019) 272 FCR 454

GXXS v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCA 468

Hala v Minister for Justice [2015] FCAFC 13; (2015) 145 ALD 552

Ismail v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 2; (2024) 98 ALJR 196

LidonoPty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) [2002] FCA 174; (2002) 191 ALR 328

Manebona v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCAFC 116; (2023) 298…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prasad v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicult... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 791
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Prasad v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs, the applicant, a non-citizen, sought judicial review of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s (AAT) decision to affirm the Minister’s decision not to revoke the cancellation of his visa. The applicant argued that the AAT made errors in its assessment of the primary consideration of expectations of the Australian community, denied him procedural fairness in various respects, and failed to properly consider his representations regarding rehabilitation and risk of reoffending. The court was required to determine whether the AAT erred in law, denied procedural fairness, or failed to give proper consideration to the applicant’s evidence.

The court found that the AAT did not misunderstand the law by failing to consider the applicant’s personal circumstances when attributing weight to the expectations of the Australian community primary consideration. The court held that the AAT was bound by Direction 99, which stated that decision-makers should proceed based on the Government’s views as articulated, without independently assessing the community’s expectations in the particular case. The court also found that the AAT did not deny procedural fairness by failing to consider the applicant’s argument relying on CKL21 v Minister for Home Affairs, as the argument was not clearly articulated. Furthermore, the court held that the AAT did not deny procedural fairness by failing to advise the applicant and his witnesses of proposed adverse credibility findings, as the applicant had ample opportunity to address the inconsistencies in their evidence. Finally, the court found that the AAT gave proper, genuine and realistic consideration to the applicant’s representations regarding rehabilitation and risk of reoffending, and did not ignore, overlook or misunderstand evidence adduced by the applicant’s sister.

Accordingly, the court dismissed the applicant’s application for judicial review, with costs. The court held that the AAT’s decision was not tainted by error and that the applicant had not established any grounds for review. The court ordered that the application be dismissed and that the applicant pay the first respondent’s costs as agreed or assessed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs as agreed or assessed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This ground raises the question of whether the Tribunal denied the applicant procedural fairness in respect of a finding it made about the credibility of the evidence given by the applicant’s mother and sister. The part of the Tribunal’s reasons which is relevant to this ground is AAT [169]-[170], where the Tribunal stated:The Applicant’s mother and sister said they were unaware of the Applicant [sic] drug use and offending until very recently when a copy of his criminal history was provided for the purpose of this application. His mother described herself as “amazed” and “just stunned”. His sister was asked if she knew the details of the more recent assaults, and she said “I know the details that Dr Donnelly sent me, what he sent me, yes”.This evidence does not sit comfortably with the evidence in the District Court sentencing remarks that the Applicant’s mother and sister were in court when the Applicant was sentenced for his attack on Ms K and the threatening messages he sent to Ms N. The irresistible inference is that they were in court, not by coincidence, but because the Applicant was being sentenced. The learned Judge described the offending. They each have a good command of English. I find it extremely unlikely that they were unaware of what he was being sentenced for in August 2022. Therefore I find that they were not completely honest in their evidence, which undermines the credibility of their evidence in general.(Emphasis added). Also relevant are the passages from AAT [292]-[297] and [301]-[303], under the heading “Procedural fairness”, where the Tribunal stated:292. I formed the opinion that the Applicant’s mother and sister were not completely honest about their knowledge of the Applicant’s offending, and that their behaviour indicated that they were not seriously concerned that he could commit suicide here or in Fiji.293. On 6 October 2023, the Tribunal sent an email to the Applicant (copied to the Respondent) attaching extracts of the transcript of the evidence given by the Applicant’s mother and sister, and invited the Applicant to submit further evidence from those witnesses addressing these issues. The email included:“The current state of the evidence may lead the Tribunal to make adverse findings about the credibility of the Applicant’s mother and/or sister due to the above apparent anomalies in their evidence. Further, the Tribunal may infer that the Applicant’s mother, sister or both were told by the Applicant to tell the Tribunal that he was suicidal at the prospect of being returned to Fiji to enhance his prospects of getting his visa back.”294. That afternoon, the Applicant’s counsel stated that the Applicant was prohibited from putting forward further evidence by s500(6J) of the Act. He further submitted that“even if it be accepted that the Applicant’s mother and sister were present in Court on the relevant occasion, it does not necessarily follow that they were present in Court for the entirety of the sentencing proceedings. Nor does it necessarily follow that the Applicant’s sister and mother followed all that was said in the sentencing proceedings…The fact that the Applicant’s sister and mother were present at the Applicant’s sentencing hearing does not mean that their presence at those proceedings meant that they received full knowledge of the Applicant’s criminal history, including the full nature and sentences the Applicant had received.”295. The Applicant’s mother and sister were never asked if they had full knowledge of his criminal history including the sentences he received. High level knowledge was never in issue. The issue was their denial of any knowledge prior to these proceedings.296. The Applicant’s counsel construed the quoted passage from the Tribunal’s email as an “Allegation of Perverting the Course of Justice / Breach of Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)” and that the “the Applicant, the Applicant’s mother and sister have conspired to give false and misleading evidence before the Tribunal”.297. On the morning of 9 October 2023, the Respondent emailed the Tribunal advising that the Minister did not contend that the Applicant, his mother and his sister had conspired to each mention the Applicant’s alleged risk of suicide. The Tribunal therefore proceeded to determine the application on the basis that there was no such arrangement. The Respondent reiterated the submission made in the hearing that the evidence did not demonstrate any risk of suicide, and specifically pointed to the lack of medical evidence.…301. The Applicant’s submissions that were provided on 6 October 2023 included:“As a matter of procedural fairness, before the Tribunal could make adverse findings in relation to the impugned issues raised, the allegations would need to be put to the Applicant, the Applicant’s mother and the Applicant’s sister…The Applicant is also concerned that these issues have been raised, in effect, at the 11th hour by the Tribunal. They were not, of course, raised during the trial by either the Tribunal or the Minister. These raise serious procedural fairness concerns for the Applicant.”302. During the hearing, in the interests of procedural fairness, the Tribunal recounted evidence that a witness had given that was inconsistent with evidence the Applicant had given, and gave the Applicant an opportunity to address the inconsistency. His counsel expressed doubts about the Tribunal’s recollection of the evidence, which underlined the importance of having an accurate record of the oral evidence. The hearing concluded on Friday 29 September 2023. The 206 page transcript of proceedings was received by the Tribunal on the afternoon of Wednesday 4 October 2023. The Tribunal raised these matters with the parties on the morning of Friday 6 October 2023. The Tribunal was required to decide the application before midnight on Monday 9 October 2023.303. With respect to the Applicant’s complaint that matters were not put to the witnesses during the hearing, it is not reasonable to expect the Respondent, or the Tribunal for that matter, to alert the Applicant to every weakness in his case. That is especially so in circumstances where there was a great deal of evidence from the Applicant and his witnesses, no real-time record of it, and the Applicant was well positioned to address the relevant weakness in issue had he wanted to. The District Court sentencing remarks were provided to the Applicant last year with an invitation to comment on them. He did comment in a document dated 22 December 2022. The sentencing remarks were also contained in the “G-Documents” that were served on him several weeks before the hearing. The Applicant secured legal representation in April 2023. He and his counsel were obviously present in the Tribunal hearing when his mother and sister each said they did not know about any of his offending until a copy of his criminal record was provided in the context of these proceedings. There was ample opportunity for the Applicant to address the apparent inconsistency between their evidence and the evidence of a District Court judge in re-examination. The invitation from the Tribunal following the hearing was made over and above the requirements of procedural fairness.(Emphasis added; footnotes omitted).

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant sought revocation of the Cancellation Decision pursuant to the statutory process outlined in s 501CA(4) of the Act. On 17 July 2023, a delegate of the Minister decided not to revoke the cancellation decision (the Non-Revocation Decision). The applicant then sought review of the Non-Revocation Decision in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) under s 500(1)(ba) of the Act. The hearing of that application took place over two days on 28 and 29 September 2023. The applicant was legally represented at the hearing and filed a statement of facts, issues and contentions (ASFIC). The Minister was also legally represented at the hearing and also filed a statement of facts, issues and contentions (MSFIC). Written and oral evidence was given by the applicant and others, including his mother and sister, in support of his claims. By orders made on 9 October 2023, and for the reasons published on 25 October 2023, the Tribunal affirmed the Non-Revocation Decision: see Prasad v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] AATA 3438 (AAT). The Tribunal determined that the applicant did not pass the “character test” defined in s 501(6) of the Act given his substantial criminal record, and that the sole issue before it was whether there was “another reason” to revoke the Cancellation Decision under s 501CA(4)(b)(ii) of the Act: at AAT [7]. The Tribunal noted that it was bound by Direction No 99 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA (Direction 99): at AAT [9]. Ultimately, the Tribunal determined that the “primary considerations” as to the protection of the Australian community, family violence and expectations of the Australian community outweighed the countervailing primary and “other” considerations which weighed in the applicant’s favour: at AAT [305]. The Tribunal concluded that the application of Direction 99 favoured non-revocation of the Cancellation Decision and affirmed the Non-Revocation Decision: at AAT [305]-[306]. By an application to this Court, the applicant sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision. The applicant relied on five grounds of review, which can be briefly stated as follows:(a)Ground 1: that the Tribunal acted on a clear misunderstanding of the law by failing to take into account the applicant’s personal circumstances when deciding what weight to attribute to the expectations of the Australian community primary consideration (Primary Consideration 5);(b)Ground 2: that the Tribunal denied the applicant procedural fairness by failing to respond to a substantial, clearly articulated argument based on the Full Court decision in CKL21 v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] FCAFC 70; (2022) 293 FCR 634, when assessing the applicant’s future risk of harm under the protection of the Australian community primary consideration (Primary Consideration 1) and coming to the conclusion that the applicant’s commitment and ability to refrain from reoffending had “not been tested in the wider community”: at AAT [121];(c)Ground 3: that the Tribunal denied the applicant procedural fairness by failing to identify an issue that was critical to its decision and advise him of an adverse conclusion which was not obviously known to be open to the applicant on the material before the Tribunal —namely, an adverse credibility finding in relation to the applicant’s mother and sister (who had given evidence at the Tribunal hearing);(d)Ground 4: that the Tribunal failed to give proper, genuine and realistic consideration to a number of the applicant’s representations in finding that the applicant had done “several courses aimed at addressing family violence” (at AAT [186]), that the applicant had “made very limited efforts to rehabilitate” (at AAT [234]) and that there was “no evidence that [the applicant] is suffering any particular difficulty” in immigration detention (at AAT [240]); and(e)Ground 5: that the Tribunal constructively failed to exercise jurisdiction in that it ignored, overlooked or misunderstood evidence adduced by the applicant’s sister regarding her awareness of the applicant’s drug use.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In reply submissions and in argument before me, the applicant cavilled with the Minister’s contention that the same argument that is made in this case was made in Ismail. The applicant submitted that, in Ismail, the complaint was that the delegate had failed to have regard to a mandatory consideration, being the applicant’s personal circumstances, when weighing the expectations of the Australian community: citing Ismail at [47]. Here, however, the applicant submitted that his complaint is that the Tribunal acted on a misunderstanding of the law, which is a different species of error. The applicant contended that nothing in Ismail held that a decision-maker is prohibited from having regard to a non-citizen’s individual circumstances when assessing the attribution of weight to Primary Consideration 5: citing Ismail at [49]-[52]. It was contended that in Ismail, the applicant had not expressly advanced a claim that the adverse attribution of weight to the primary consideration of the expectations of the Australian community should be offset by reason of individual circumstances, whereas that was an express contention in the present case which the applicant claimed was supported by the Full Court’s decision in Dunasemant. The applicant contended that Dunasemant remains good law and was not overruled by, or even addressed in, Ismail.B.2 Consideration I do not accept the applicant’s contentions. To explain why, it is necessary to start with the text of Primary Consideration 5. It is set out at paragraph 8.5 of Direction 99 and provides, relevantly, as follows:8.5Expectations of the Australian Community(1)The Australian community expects non-citizens to obey Australian laws while in Australia. Where a non-citizen has engaged in serious conduct in breach of this expectation, or where there is an unacceptable risk that they may do so, the Australian community, as a norm, expects the Government to not allow such a non-citizen to enter or remain in Australia.(2)In addition, visa cancellation or refusal, or non-revocation of the mandatory cancellation of a visa, may be appropriate simply because the nature of the character concerns or offences is such that the Australian community would expect that the person should not be granted or continue to hold a visa. In particular, the Australian community expects that the Australian Government can and should refuse entry to non-citizens, or cancel their visas, if they raise serious character concerns through conduct, in Australia or elsewhere, of the following kind:a)acts of family violence; or…c)commission of serious crimes against women, children or other vulnerable members of the community such as the elderly or disabled; in this context, ‘serious crimes’ include crimes of a violent or sexual nature…(3)The above expectations of the Australian community apply regardless of whether the non-citizen poses a measurable risk of causing physical harm to the Australian community.(4)This consideration is about the expectations of the Australian community as a whole, and in this respect, decision-makers should proceed on the basis of the Government’s views as articulated above, without independently assessing the community’s expectations in the particular case.(Emphasis added).