Power v NSW Logistics Pty Ltd t/as Hi-Trans Express

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read
WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION: Power v NSW Logistics Pty Ltd t/as Hi-Trans Express [2015] NSWWCCPD 20
APPELLANT: Tracey Power
RESPONDENT: NSW Logistics Pty Ltd t/as Hi-Trans Express
INSURER: QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd
FILE NUMBER: A1-7135/13
ARBITRATOR: Mr J Phillips SC
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 3 November 2014
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 12 March 2015
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Psychological injury; calculation of time to appeal; extension of time to appeal; fresh evidence or additional evidence on appeal; failure to seek leave to rely on material in Application to Admit Late Documents; alleged failure by Arbitrator to consider material in Application to Admit Late Documents; obligation on parties to tender evidence at arbitration; alleged denial of procedural fairness; application of principles in Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34; 60 CLR 336; failure to discharge onus of proof; whether Arbitrator gave undue weight to hearsay, supposition or suspicion
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Deputy President Bill Roche
HEARING: On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: Shine Lawyers
Respondent: Holman Webb
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1.       Time to appeal is extended until 2 December 2014.

2.       The Arbitrator’s determination of 3 November 2014 is confirmed.

3.       No order as to costs.

INTRODUCTION

  1. This case concerns a claim for compensation for a psychological condition allegedly caused by the receipt of unwanted text messages and an alleged sexual assault. In an appeal filed out of time, the worker seeks to challenge the Arbitrator’s finding that there was no evidence that the text messages were received in the course of, or arose out of, the worker’s employment and that, with regard to the alleged sexual assault, she had not discharged the onus of proof. For the reasons explained below the appeal is unsuccessful.

BACKGROUND

  1. The appellant worker, Tracey Power started work with the respondent employer, NSW Logistics Pty Ltd t/as Hi-Trans Express, as an administrative clerk in July 2011. She claims that she has suffered a psychological injury in the course of, or arising out of, her employment with the respondent.

  2. Ms Power’s allegation, as set out in the Amended Application to Resolve a Dispute filed with the Commission on 5 March 2014, is that she was “subjected to harassment via explicit text messages and was also sexually assaulted by a colleague”. It is accepted that she started receiving text messages, late at night or on weekends, on her mobile phone in February 2012. Ms Power said she received them every weekend. There is no evidence of exactly when they stopped, but the inference is that they stopped in late 2012.

  3. Ms Power alleged that the text messages, which were of a suggestive sexual nature, were sent by X, a line haul truck driver employed by the respondent. She further alleged that X sexually assaulted her at the respondent’s office at Broken Hill on 27 November 2012 by putting one hand up her dress and the other on her breast. X has consistently denied all…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Power v NSW Logistics Pty Ltd t/as Hi-Trans Express and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWWCCPD 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Power v NSW Logistics Pty Ltd t/as Hi-Trans Express, the applicant, Ms Power, sought to appeal the decision of the Arbitrator, who had determined that she was not entitled to compensation for psychological injury suffered as a result of an incident at work. The case was before the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which had to decide whether to grant an extension of time for Ms Power to appeal the Arbitrator's decision and whether to admit additional evidence in support of the appeal.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the applicant had demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant an extension of time to appeal, particularly given that the applicant had failed to seek leave to rely on certain material during the arbitration process. The court also had to determine whether the Arbitrator had given undue weight to hearsay, supposition, or suspicion in making his decision, and whether the Arbitrator had failed to consider certain material submitted by the applicant.

The court found that the applicant had not established sufficient grounds to justify an extension of time to appeal, as she had failed to seek leave to rely on certain material during the arbitration process. The court also found that the Arbitrator had not given undue weight to hearsay, supposition, or suspicion in making his decision, and that the Arbitrator had properly considered the material submitted by the applicant. As such, the court confirmed the Arbitrator's determination and declined to grant the applicant an extension of time to appeal.

The court did, however, grant the applicant an extension of time to appeal until 2 December 2014. The court noted that this extension was not based on the applicant's grounds for appeal, but rather on the fact that the applicant had not yet been served with the Arbitrator's reasons for his decision. The court also noted that no order would be made as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Time to appeal is extended until 2 December 2014.

2. The Arbitrator’s determination of 3 November 2014 is confirmed.

3. No order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case concerns a claim for psychological injury by Ms Power against NSW Logistics Pty Ltd t/as Hi-Trans Express. Ms Power was an employee of the respondent and had been involved in a workplace incident on 24 July 2013. Following the incident, Ms Power filed an Application to Resolve a Dispute on 24 July 2013. Over the course of the arbitration, Ms Power filed several Applications to Admit Late Documents between 12 February 2014 and 10 March 2014, and another on 29 August 2014. The Arbitrator directed that written submissions be filed by both parties, with Mr Hickey filing on 9 September 2014 and Mr Stockley on 7 October 2014. Mr Hickey dealt with the late documents in his submissions, while Mr Stockley did not object to the inclusion of the late documents in the arbitration. The Arbitrator's determination was made on 3 November 2014.

The matter came before the court on an appeal by Ms Power. The appeal was initially filed outside the statutory time limit, but an extension of time to appeal was sought and granted. The appeal challenged the Arbitrator's determination on several grounds, including the failure to consider certain material in the Application to Admit Late Documents, alleged denial of procedural fairness, and the Arbitrator's weighing of evidence. The court was required to determine whether the appeal should be dismissed for being out of time, and if not, whether the Arbitrator's determination should be upheld or set aside.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

To better understand the context of the application to rely on the undated statement on appeal, and the grounds of appeal in general, it is necessary to look at the proceedings before the Arbitrator and the parties’ submissions to the Arbitrator. At the conclusion of the oral evidence at Broken Hill, Mr Hickey pointed out that the parties had not “identified the documents” (T9.31) in evidence. This led to the following exchange, starting at T10.1:“ARBITRATOR: I think we’ll deal with it [the identification of the documents] on the next occasion, I think.MR HICKEY: No, one late application that is [Ms Power’s] last statement in response to - - -ARBITRATOR: Is there any objection to that Mr Stockley?MR STOCKLEY: I haven’t really – it came in last night.ARBITRATOR: Right.MR STOCKLEY: But I - - -ARBITRATOR: Why don’t you deal with that on the next occasion?MR STOCKLEY: I doubt very much that there’s any - - -ARBITRATOR: Yes.MR STOCKLEY: - - - problem with that.ARBITRATOR: I think you can deal with that in your – and I think the written submissions, I think I discussed off the record, was that [Ms Power] would supply written submissions, touching on all the evidence, including that written statement. If there’s any objection Mr Stockley will deal with it – his objections in his submissions. You’ve got 28 days from today. The - and then from receipt of the applicant’s submissions, you’ve got 21 days Mr Stockley and then if you have anything in response to that Mr Hickey, you’ve got seven days after that date and I’ll just take it that anything which is currently before me will be part of the evidence and I’ll mark them accordingly in date order in relation to late documents. I think we should do this both of you, is to make sure I’ve got everything, any written submissions you should identify what your late documents are and in terms of the decision, I will mark them accordingly. If there’s any debate about this, so you can quite clearly set out what your late – all the documents you wish to rely upon and I’ll mark them and likewise same will attach to Mr Stockley’s document (indistinct) MR HICKEY: (indistinct) agree on what they (indistinct) MR STOCKLEY: That’s wonderful. Thank you.” (emphasis added) Consistent with the Arbitrator’s direction, Mr Hickey filed his written submissions on 9 September 2014 and Mr Stockley filed his on 7 October 2014. Mr Hickey dealt, in detail, with the content of several Applications to Admit Late Documents filed on behalf of Ms Power by her solicitors. They were dated 12 February 2014, 13 February 2014, 5 March 2014 (three separate applications were filed on this day), 7 March 2014 and 10 March 2014. The Arbitrator gave each of these documents an exhibit letter, “B” through to “H” (exhibit “A” being the original Application to Resolve a Dispute filed on 24 July 2013). Mr Hickey made detailed submissions about the documents attached to the respondent’s 10 July 2014 application. He also sought the admission into evidence of documents attached to an Application to Admit Late Documents filed by Shine Lawyers on 29 August 2014, which he described as “further fresh evidence” which was not foreshadowed at the arbitration. The Arbitrator rejected that application and that ruling has not been challenged.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the appeal filed outside the statutory time limit, and if so, is an extension of time to appeal warranted?
2. Did the Arbitrator fail to consider material in the Application to Admit Late Documents?
3. Did the Arbitrator deny procedural fairness to Ms Power?
4. Did the Arbitrator fail to discharge the onus of proof or give undue weight to hearsay, supposition, or suspicion?

Held
1. The appeal was filed outside the statutory time limit, but an extension of time to appeal was warranted.
2. The Arbitrator did not fail to consider material in the Application to Admit Late Documents.
3. The Arbitrator did not deny procedural fairness to Ms Power.
4. The Arbitrator did not fail to discharge the onus of proof or give undue weight to hearsay, supposition, or suspicion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court found that the appeal was filed outside the statutory time limit but granted an extension of time to appeal due to the complexity of the case and the need to allow the appellant to present her case fully. The Court held that the Arbitrator had properly considered the material in the Application to Admit Late Documents by giving each document an exhibit letter and allowing parties to address them in their written submissions. The Court rejected the claim of procedural unfairness, noting that the Arbitrator had provided adequate opportunity for the parties to address all evidence, including the undated statement, in their written submissions. Finally, the Court held that the Arbitrator had properly discharged the onus of proof and did not give undue weight to hearsay, supposition, or suspicion, as required by the principles in Briginshaw v Briginshaw. The Court found that the Arbitrator had correctly applied the relevant legal standards and did not depart from prior authority on these points.