Poniatowska v Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

PONIATOWSKA v CHANNEL SEVEN SYDNEY PTY LTD & ANOR (No 5)

[2017] SASC 32

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Parker

16 March 2017

DEFAMATION - ACTIONS FOR DEFAMATION - COSTS - GENERAL RULE - COSTS FOLLOW THE EVENT - COSTS OF ACTION

DEFAMATION - ACTIONS FOR DEFAMATION - COSTS - INDEMNITY COSTS

Application for the award of costs following the successful defence of defamation proceedings. The plaintiff submitted costs should not be awarded to the defendants and if costs are to be awarded the court should make a lump sum order not exceeding $50,000. The defendants submit they are prima facie entitled to the ordinary principle that costs follow the event and that by virtue of s 38 of the Defamation Act 2005 they are entitled to costs on an indemnity basis. The defendants also submit that they should be awarded interest on the costs calculated from the end of the trial or in the alternative from the date of judgment.

Held, per Parker J:

1.  The plaintiff unreasonably failed to accept a settlement offer.

2.  The interests of justice do not require that indemnity costs not be awarded.

3.  The defendants are awarded costs on an indemnity basis.

4.  The defendants are not awarded interest on costs calculated from the end of the trial or the date of judgment.

Defamation Act 2005 s 38; Supreme Court Act 1935 s 40, s 114; District Court Act 1991 s 40; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 r 263, r 264, referred to.
Machado v Underwood (No 2) [2016] SASCFC 123, applied.
Cornes v The Ten Group Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] SASC 141; Cornes v The Ten Group (2012) 114 SASR 46; De Poi v Advertiser - News Weekend Publishing Company Pty Ltd (No 2) [2016] SASCFC 45, discussed.
Australian Guarantee Corporation v De Jager [1984] VR 483; Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336; Colgate-Palmolive v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225; Davis v Nationwide News Pty Ltd [2008] NSWSC 946; De Poi v Advertiser - News Weekend Publishing Company Pty Ltd (No 2) [2015] SADC 25; Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298; NMFM Property Pty Ltd & Ors v Citibank Ltd (No 2) (2001) 109 FCR 77; Osborne v Kelly (1999) 75 SASR 392; Public Trustee as Litigation Guardian for Pinter v Newman [2012] SASCFC 18; Ragata Developments Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation (1993) 217 ALR 175; Yates Property Corp Pty Ltd v Boland (No 2) (1997) 147 ALR 685, considered.

WORDS AND PHRASES CONSIDERED/DEFINED

"Settlement offers", "financial positions of applicant", "interests of justice"

PONIATOWSKA v CHANNEL SEVEN SYDNEY PTY LTD & ANOR (No 5)
[2017] SASC 32

Civil:

  1. Parker J: This is an application for the award of costs following the successful defence of defamation proceedings. The defendants submit that by virtue of s 38 of the Defamation Act 2005 they are entitled to costs on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Poniatowska v Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] SASC 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ms Poniatowska initiated defamation proceedings against Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd and Channel Seven Perth Pty Ltd, following the broadcast of a story on the Today Tonight television program. The broadcast was found to be defamatory, leading to a dispute over the costs associated with the proceedings. The defendants argued that Ms Poniatowska unreasonably failed to accept their settlement offers, while she contended that the offers were inadequate. The court was tasked with determining whether the defendants' settlement offers were reasonable, whether Ms Poniatowska unreasonably rejected them, and whether the interests of justice required the denial of indemnity costs.

The court examined the settlement offers made by the defendants, which included payments of $20,000 and $50,000 plus costs. The court found that these offers were reasonable, considering the context and the outcome of the defamation case. Ms Poniatowska's rejection of these offers without counter-proposals or engagement in negotiations was deemed unreasonable. Furthermore, the court concluded that the interests of justice did not necessitate the denial of indemnity costs, as Ms Poniatowska had wholly failed in her defamation claim. Therefore, the court ruled that Ms Poniatowska must pay the defendants' costs on an indemnity basis.

The reasoning of the court was grounded in section 38(2)(b) of the Defamation Act, which mandates an indemnity costs order unless the interests of justice require otherwise. The court found that Ms Poniatowska's failure to accept reasonable settlement offers was unreasonable, and that the interests of justice did not preclude the award of indemnity costs. This decision aligns with the legislative intent to encourage the resolution of defamation disputes through settlement, while also providing a remedy for defendants who are forced to defend such claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

After I had heard submissions on the costs question the Full Court published its reasons for judgment in Machado v Underwood (No 2).[1] The defendants sought permission to make further submissions referring to that authority. I granted permission and invited Ms Poniatowska to respond. I have taken into account the submissions made by both parties relating to Machado. [1] [2016] SASCFC 123.Background Ms Poniatowska sued Channel Seven Sydney Pty Ltd and Channel Seven Perth Pty Ltd for defamation in relation to a story included in the Today Tonight television program broadcast by those two entities in New South Wales, Western Australia and elsewhere. The story was also republished on the internet, albeit the evidence was that few persons accessed it. Ms Poniatowska pleaded that the Today Tonight story gave rise to a series of defamatory imputations. In essence, those imputations were that she was guilty of fraud, was a cheat and dishonest and had taken money from taxpayers without paying it back. The Today Tonight story was published on the same day as the High Court delivered judgment dismissing an appeal by the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions against the decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court to set aside the conviction of Ms Poniatowska for Centrelink fraud. Counsel for Ms Poniatowska had indicated in his opening submissions that she was seeking loss and damages in the sum of $750,000 plus costs. In his closing submissions counsel sought an award of $1.1M plus interest. I found that the material referring to Ms Poniatowska in the Today Tonight story was defamatory. I also found that the defendants had made out each of the several defences upon which they relied. In particular, I concluded that the defence of justification had been made out as Ms Poniatowska had acted fraudulently in her dealings with Centrelink. The basis for the latter finding was that Ms Poniatowska had received notices from Centrelink advising her of the obligation to declare her income or changes of her income to that agency. I rejected the explanations she provided as to why she had not fully and accurately declared her income to Centrelink. I also did not accept her evidence that she had initially pleaded guilty to the Centrelink fraud charges because her legal advisers had bullied her and acted contrary to her instructions. I noted that the trial took longer than was necessary because of the fact that, at times, Ms Poniatowska’s answers to questions were non-responsive or argumentative or amounted to a speech. Settlement offers The defendants made a number of settlement offers to Ms Poniatowska. They were as follows:a)On 25 September 2013 a written Calderbank offer was made offering to settle her claim for a payment of $20,000 plus costs to be taxed or agreed. At that time the defendants already had costs orders in their favour. The effect of the offer by the defendants was that they would bear their own costs and release her from liability under the subsisting orders. On 30 October 2013 Ms Poniatowska rejected that offer. She did not make any counter-offer but invited the defendants to increase their offer by reference to the fact that another unrelated defamation matter had recently settled for $4.3 million. She also proposed that any further offer should include the sum of $20,000 to cover her costs during the period when she was self-represented. I note that during this period any entitlement to costs would have been limited to the recovery of disbursements.b)On 18 December 2013 the defendants reiterated their earlier offer to pay $20,000 plus costs in settlement of Ms Poniatowska’s claim. They also noted that they were willing to discuss an all inclusive settlement if that was her preference. The letter from the defendants’ solicitors referred to both Calderbank and s 38 of the Defamation Act 2005. Ms Poniatowska did not respond to that offer.c)On 8 April 2014 (14 days prior to the commencement of the trial) the defendants made a further written offer to pay Ms Poniatowska $50,000 plus costs to be taxed or agreed by way of settlement. Once again, the effect of the offer was that the defendants would waive their right to enforce multiple costs orders made against Ms Poniatowska. The letter also referred to Calderbank and s 38 of the Defamation Act. Ms Poniatwoska did not respond to that offer.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no information before the Court concerning the arrangement between the defendants and their solicitors as to the timing of fee payments. However, for present purposes I will proceed on the assumption that the defendants would have paid periodically as the matter proceeded and they would not make a windfall gain if interest were to be awarded from the date of the judgment. Nevertheless, as the plaintiff has not contributed to the delay in delivery of judgment, I do not consider it appropriate to award interest from the date that the trial concluded. For the same reason, I also do not consider it appropriate to award interest from the date of judgement.Conclusion I have found that Ms Poniatowska unreasonably failed to accept a settlement offer. I have also found that the interests of justice do not require that indemnity costs not be awarded. Accordingly, I will order that Ms Poniatowska must pay the costs of the defendants on an indemnity basis in accordance with s 38(2)(b) of the Defamation Act. Due to that finding it is unnecessary to consider the alternative contention advanced by the defendants that an indemnity costs order should be made in the exercise of the general discretion of the Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 38 of the Defamation Act establishes a specific regime for the award of costs in defamation proceedings. It provides as follows:38—Costs in defamation proceedings(1) In awarding costs in defamation proceedings, the court may have regard to—(a) the way in which the parties to the proceedings conducted their cases (including any misuse of a party’s superior financial position to hinder the early resolution of the proceedings); and(b) any other matters that the court considers relevant.(2) Without limiting subsection (1), a court must (unless the interests of justice require otherwise)—(a) if defamation proceedings are successfully brought by a plaintiff and costs in the proceedings are to be awarded to the plaintiff—order costs of and incidental to the proceedings to be assessed on an indemnity basis if the court is satisfied that the defendant unreasonably failed to make a settlement offer or agree to a settlement offer proposed by the plaintiff; or(b) if defamation proceedings are unsuccessfully brought by a plaintiff and costs in the proceedings are to be awarded to the defendant—order costs of and incidental to the proceedings to be assessed on an indemnity basis if the court is satisfied that the plaintiff unreasonably failed to accept a settlement offer made by the defendant.(3) In this section—settlement offer means any offer to settle the proceedings made before the proceedings are determined, and includes an offer to make amends (whether made before or after the proceedings are commenced), that was a reasonable offer at the time it was made.Consideration In Cornes v The Ten Group Pty Ltd (No 2) Peek J held that s 38(2) of the Defamation Act requires that indemnity costs must be awarded in the circumstances referred to in that provision unless the interests of justice require otherwise.[10] The approach adopted by Peek J was approved by the Full Court on appeal in Cornes v The Ten Group.[11] The Full Court observed in De Poi v Advertiser - News Weekend Publishing Company Pty Ltd (No 2) that insistence upon a confidentiality obligation will usually be considered unreasonable in defamation proceedings.[12][10] [2011] SASC 141 at [6].[11] (2012) 114 SASR 46 at [123]–[126], Gray J with Kourakis and Blue JJ agreeing.[12] [2016] SASCFC 45 at [20]. There are two requirement that must be satisfied under s 38(2)(b). First, the plaintiff must have been wholly unsuccessful in the defamation proceedings. Second, the Court must be satisfied that the plaintiff unreasonably failed to accept a settlement offer made by the defendant. If those two requirements are satisfied then the Court must order costs on an indemnity basis unless it is satisfied that the interests of justice require otherwise. The effect of the provision is to reverse the ordinary approach that the award of indemnity costs is exceptional. Because Ms Poniatowska was wholly unsuccessful at trial it is necessary to consider two issues before deciding the application for indemnity costs made by the defendants. First, did she unreasonably fail to accept a settlement offer. Secondly, do the interests of justice require that indemnity costs not be awarded.Whether unreasonable failure to accept settlement offers