POETHKE v NICOLAS No. SCGRG-95-216 Judgment No. S6645

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

POETHKE v NICOLAS

Civil

LANDER J

This is a most unfortunate case and it is most regrettable that the matter ever came to trial.

The plaintiff is the brother of the defendant and they are the only children of Karl Heinz Poethke and Ursula Poethke.

The plaintiff’s claim is for a declaration that the defendant holds one half of the land situated at 32 Brookside Avenue, Tranmere as trustee for the benefit of the plaintiff and for an order that the defendant transfer to the plaintiff a 50 per cent legal share in the land to enable the plaintiff to be registered on the Certificate of Title as tenant in common with the defendant. 

For an understanding of the plaintiff’s case and the defendant’s defence it is necessary to trace the history of the family.

History to 1971

Karl and Ursula Poethke were both born in Germany.  Karl served in the German Army in the Second World War, was captured by the Russians and did not return to Germany until 1950.  Karl and Ursula married in 1952.  Karl was employed in Germany working in central heating.  The defendant was born in 1953 and the plaintiff was born in 1957. The family came to Australia in July 1959. 

Initially they lived in a hostel at Gepps Cross for about a year.  They then moved into a house at 32  Heythsebury Street, Elizabeth where they remained until April 1977 when Karl, Ursula and the plaintiff moved to property the subject of the dispute at 32 Brookside Avenue, Tranmere.

Karl Poethke obtained employment at Horsell, Jarmyn & Sons Pty Ltd.  Ursula remained at home.  She has never been employed but later, and I will refer to this in more detail, she worked in a business which was conducted by the plaintiff and defendant. 

Karl Poethke left Horsell, Jarmyn & Sons to become self employed working as a contractor erecting verandahs and similar structures.

Whilst self employed he suffered an injury to his arm which disabled him and he was unable to continue his work.  He had trouble paying his bills and became bankrupt sometime in the 1960’s.          Thereafter, Mr Poethke worked outside South Australia.  He regularly travelled to Western Australia from where he sent money to his wife and family.

Although the evidence is not clear,  it is probable that he was discharged from bankruptcy in 1971.

When Karl and Ursula Poethke left Germany they left behind their parents.  In December 1971 Karl Poethke travelled to Germany to see his parents.  I am not sure on the evidence whether Mrs Poethke went at the same time.  The evidence in relation to their travels to Europe is confused and confusing. 

It appears that Mrs Poethke returned to Germany on one occasion with Mr Poethke and Mr Poethke went on three occasions by himself.    I think the best evidence in relation to this topic is contained in the passports.  From a reading of the passports I find that Karl Poethke went in 1971, 1972, 1976…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read POETHKE v NICOLAS No. SCGRG-95-216 Judgment No. S6645 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6645
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of POETHKE v NICOLAS involved a dispute between siblings, the plaintiff and defendant, over the ownership of a property located at 32 Brookside Avenue, Tranmere. The plaintiff sought a declaration that the defendant held the property as a trustee for him and an order for the defendant to transfer her half share of the property back to him. The defendant, on the other hand, argued that the property was purchased by their parents and that she and the plaintiff were merely trustees of the property for their parents' benefit.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the defendant held the property as a trustee for the plaintiff or whether she held it for their parents. The court examined the circumstances surrounding the acquisition of the property, the intentions of the parties at the time of the transfer, and the subsequent conduct of the parties.

The court found that the property was purchased by the parents using their own funds, and that the siblings were trustees of the property for their parents' benefit. The court rejected the plaintiff's claim that the property was a gift from their former employer, Mr Ward Smith, and held that the parents had sufficient funds to purchase the property themselves. The court also found that there was no agreement between the siblings for the defendant to hold the property as a trustee for the plaintiff. As a result, the plaintiff's claim was dismissed, and the court held that the defendant held the property as a trustee for their parents.

In conclusion, the court found that the defendant held the property as a trustee for the parents and dismissed the plaintiff's claim for a declaration and an order for the transfer of the property.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established