PLENTY & PLENTY v PATTINSON and ROSS D HODBY and ASSOCIATES
[2001] SASC 83Civil
DUGGAN J. In this matter I have found that the defendants are liable to the plaintiffs for loss occasioned by the negligence of each defendant. The first defendant, a valuer, provided a valuation of the property which was mortgaged to the plaintiffs as security for a loan advanced by them. The second defendant was a finance broker who recommended the loan to the plaintiffs. I have dealt with liability as a separate issue and the action will proceed to the assessment of damages in due course.
I reserved the issue of contribution between the defendants until the parties had the opportunity to read my reasons on liability. Submissions on contribution have now been made and it is necessary to address that issue in these reasons.
As I have pointed out in the reasons for decision on liability, the first and second defendants have issued contribution notices against each other claiming contribution pursuant to s 25(1)(c) of the Wrongs Act, 1936.
It is necessary to deal first with an argument raised by Mr Pickhaver, for the second defendant, in support of a submission that the second defendant was entitled to a full indemnity from the first defendant. Mr Pickhaver acknowledged that I had found the second defendant negligent in recommending the transaction to the plaintiffs when it knew, or should have known, that the first defendant’s report was inadequate and when it had failed to make any enquiries as to the financial position of the borrowers.
However, he argued that any recommendation to the plaintiffs by the second defendant based on the valuation should not be taken into account in determining whether the second defendant was liable to the first defendant by way of contribution. In support of this proposition Mr Pickhaver said that the first defendant was an expert, the valuation was critical and the first defendant owed a duty to the second defendant as well as the plaintiff.
I cannot agree with the proposition put forward by Mr Pickhaver. Section 25(1)(c) enables a tortfeasor to recover contribution from another tortfeasor in respect of damage to the plaintiff for which both are liable. Section 26 states that the amount of contribution should be such as may be found to be just and equitable “having regard to the extent of that person’s responsibility for the damage”. I have found that one aspect of the second defendant’s negligence was that it recommended the loan despite the obviously inadequate valuation. The valuation was an important consideration in the plaintiffs’ decision to enter into the transaction. In my view the second defendant’s negligence in relation to the valuation is one aspect to be taken into account in determining the level of contribution as between the defendants.
The other aspect of the second defendant’s negligence arose from its recommendation that the plaintiffs should enter into the loan transaction when no enquiries had been made by the second defendant as…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Plenty & Plenty v Pattinson & Anor No. Scgrg-82-1230 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] SASC 83
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues revolved around the defendants' negligence and the extent to which each was liable for the plaintiffs' loss. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the second defendant was entitled to a full indemnity from the first defendant or if there was a basis for contribution between them. The second defendant argued that since the first defendant was an expert and the valuation was critical, it owed a duty to the second defendant as well as the plaintiff. However, the court rejected this argument, holding that the second defendant's negligence in recommending the loan based on the inadequate valuation and without proper enquiry into the borrowers' financial status were significant factors in determining contribution.
The court found that both defendants were liable for the plaintiffs' financial loss resulting from the loan agreement. The first defendant's grossly inflated valuation and the second defendant's negligent recommendation based on that valuation and lack of enquiry into the borrowers' financial position both contributed to the plaintiffs' decision to enter into the transaction. The court held that the second defendant's negligence regarding the valuation was an important aspect to consider in determining the level of contribution. The court concluded that it would be just and equitable to order that each defendant contribute 50% to the plaintiffs' loss.
The final orders included that the defendants were liable for the plaintiffs' loss and that each defendant would contribute 50% to the plaintiffs' damages. The matter would proceed to the assessment of damages.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: DUGGAN J