Playford and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

Playford and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy [2018] AATA 19 (15 January 2018)

Division:TAXATION & COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/3909

Re:Matthew Playford

APPLICANT

AndInspector-General in Bankruptcy

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Ms G Lazanas, Senior Member

Date:15 January 2018

Place:Sydney

The decision of the delegate of the Inspector-General dated 6 June 2017 is affirmed.

...................................[sgd]..................................

Ms G Lazanas, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

Bankruptcy – discharge — trustee's objection – bankrupt failed to disclose bank account monies – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), s 43

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), ss 149D, 149K, 149N, 149Q

CASES

Frost v Sheahan (2005) 220 ALR 733

Mango Boulevard Pty Ltd v Whitton and Ors (2015) 333 ALR 471

Neffati and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy [2016] AATA 941

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms G Lazanas, Senior Member

15 January 2018

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Matthew William Playford was made bankrupt pursuant to a sequestration order made on 29 May 2013. Mr Gregg Robertson Johnson was appointed as the trustee of his estate (“the trustee”).

  2. Mr Playford was due to be discharged from his bankruptcy on 18 February 2017 unless his trustee objected. Such an objection was filed on or about 8 February 2017 in reliance on five grounds. Subsequently, the trustee ceased to object on four grounds but pressed the 5th ground set out in s 149D(1)(n) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (“the Bankruptcy Act”). This was on the basis that Mr Playford failed, whether intentionally or not, to disclose to the trustee his beneficial interest in any property.

  3. The relevant non-disclosure was a bank account with BankSA which had a credit balance of $84,216.38 as at the date of his bankruptcy. The funds in that account were withdrawn by Mr Playford progressively between 21 and 27 June 2013 and the account was subsequently closed.

  4. On 24 March 2016, the trustee wrote to Mr Playford seeking an explanation of his failure to disclose the bank account and requiring him to repay the funds to the bankrupt estate. This correspondence was followed up by the trustee sending further letters on 16 August 2016 and on 22 May 2017. Mr Playford stated at the hearing that he had not failed to disclose the bank account monies and, separately, that he and his former solicitor had explained the situation to the trustee in conversations. I will come to Mr Playford’s version of events and submissions shortly.

  5. There was a further non-disclosure by Mr Playford of a Westpac cheque issued in October 2012 by South Australian Police in the sum of $67,975 to Mr Frank Johnson which was later deposited into a bank account with Beyond Bank in the name of Frank Johnson in March 2013. “Frank Johnson” was one of many aliases of Mr Playford. The non-disclosure of the cheque was uncovered during further investigations by the trustee in July 2015 and was information that was provided by the trustee in support of his notice of objection.

  6. On 6 June 2017, a delegate of the Inspector-General…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Playford and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Playford against a decision of the delegate of the Inspector-General in Bankruptcy, which affirmed the trustee's objection to Mr Playford's discharge from bankruptcy. The core of the dispute revolved around Mr Playford's failure to disclose funds held in a BankSA bank account and his subsequent lack of full cooperation with the trustee's investigations into this non-disclosure. The appeal was heard by Ms G Lazanas, Senior Member.

The legal issues before the Senior Member were whether the trustee's objection to Mr Playford's discharge was validly made on grounds specified in the *Bankruptcy Act*, and whether there was sufficient evidence to support the existence of those grounds. Specifically, the court had to determine if Mr Playford had failed to disclose a beneficial interest in bank account monies and if he had not fully cooperated with the trustee.

The Senior Member found that the delegate correctly identified that Mr Playford had a beneficial interest in the BankSA funds, which should have been disclosed as an asset in his Statement of Affairs but was not. The Senior Member also agreed with the delegate that there was sufficient evidence to support the trustee's objection, noting the trustee's diligent efforts to obtain information and Mr Playford's failure to provide satisfactory explanations or the required funds. The Senior Member was not persuaded by Mr Playford's arguments, particularly in light of his professional background as a solicitor and his engagement of legal representation, which undermined any claim that health issues prevented his cooperation.

Consequently, the Senior Member affirmed the decision of the delegate of the Inspector-General dated 6 June 2017.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The delegate of the Inspector-General decided that on its face the ground taken by the trustee was a ground specified in s 149D(1) and I find she was correct in doing so under s 149N(1)(a) of the Bankruptcy Act. Mr Playford did not dispute that he had a beneficial interest in the funds in the bank account with BankSA. While Mr Playford claimed at the hearing to have disclosed the monies held with BankSA to the trustee at all relevant times and referred to item 38 in Part D of his Statement of Affairs, that item clearly did not reference any bank account monies with BankSA. Item 38 in Part D of the form relates to liabilities, namely, secured creditors and reveals that Mr Playford had a home loan with BankSA. The bank account monies held on deposit with BankSA were obviously an entirely different matter and were not listed at item 23 in Part C of the Statement of Affairs which is where they should have been disclosed as one of Mr Playford’s assets. Item 23 in Part C requires details of all accounts held with banks and other financial institutions within the last 12 months, which Mr Playford failed to accurately complete. Mr Playford was disingenuous in asserting that he had disclosed in his Statement of Affairs all his bank accounts and dealings with BankSA.Is there sufficient evidence to support the existence of the ground? The delegate referred to the evidence relied on by the trustee and in her assessment found that there was sufficient evidence to support the existence of the ground: s 149N(1)(b) of the Bankruptcy Act. I agree that there was sufficient evidence and was also impressed by the delegate’s diligent efforts to seek additional information from the trustee in order to satisfy herself that the objection was properly maintained, including her letters to the trustee dated 3 October 2017 and 19 October 2017 requesting specific details and supporting documents which were in evidence as Supplementary T-Documents. The evidence comprised the fact that the trustee made clear to Mr Playford that he required the sum of $84,216.38 to be returned to the estate and that repayment of the monies has not occurred. The trustee had repeatedly requested explanations for the non-disclosure of the funds in the account with BankSA as well as information about how the funds had been disbursed. Further, the trustee’s investigations revealed that Mr Playford failed to disclose expenditure of various other funds which are the subject of ongoing investigations. These requests for information went unanswered. The only response on behalf of Mr Playford is recorded in a file note on 7 April 2017 of a conversation the trustee had with Mr Playford’s former solicitor. The trustee provided a copy of that file note to the delegate and explained in correspondence with the delegate that Mr Playford’s then solicitor did not offer any explanation for Mr Playford’s failure to provide information required by the trustee, contrary to the assertions made by Mr Playford that the situation had been explained to the trustee “as best he knew how”. The trustee stated in a letter to the delegate dated 18 October 2017, as follows: The majority of the conversation [with Mr Playford’s solicitor] was in relation to the Bankrupt’s medical issues and history. In relation to the actual objection, we had a general discussion about the objection grounds and I confirmed that my requests for information had not been satisfactorily responded to.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On the other hand, there was cogent evidence that Mr Playford had not disclosed the bank account monies with BankSA to the trustee and had not fully co-operated with the trustee in his investigations. I agree with the submission of counsel for the Inspector-General that the trustee correctly observed the objection to Mr Playford’s discharge serves the purpose of requiring him to co-operate more fully with the trustee in his administration and to fully and frankly disclose matters to the trustee and, further, that that obligation would be significantly reduced if Mr Playford were discharged from bankruptcy. Additionally, if health issues were a factor, it is difficult to understand how those matters were an issue in dealing with matters required to be answered by the trustee, especially as Mr Playford was a practicing solicitor at the time of his bankruptcy and he also subsequently engaged a solicitor to deal with issues arising from his bankruptcy including, as noted above, liaising on his behalf with the trustee. In all the circumstances, I was not persuaded by Mr Playford that the decision of the delegate of the Inspector-General was incorrect. CONCLUSION For the reasons given, the decision of the delegate of the Inspector-General dated 6 June 2017 is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.