Platinum Property Group Pty Ltd v Dilworth Constructions Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Platinum Property Group Pty Ltd v Dilworth Constructions Pty Ltd [2018] QCAT 267

PARTIES:

PLATINUM PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD
(applicant)

v

DILWORTH CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

BDL169-16

MATTER TYPE:

Building matters

DELIVERED ON:

13 August, 2018

HEARING DATE:

15 September 2017

HEARD AT:

Maroochydore

DECISION OF:

Member Ann Fitzpatrick

ORDERS:

1. The Respondent Dilworth Constructions Pty Ltd file and serve submissions in relation to the calculation of penalty interest pursuant to s67P of the Queensland Building and ConstructionCommission Act 1991 (Qld) on the sum of $4,404.38, setting out the date on which the calculation commences and providing the calculation until 13 August 2018: by 4pm 27 August 2018.

2.   The Applicant Platinum Property Group Pty Ltd file and serve any submissions in reply: by 4 pm 10 September 2018.

CATCHWORDS:

Building dispute – principal and subcontractor – defective work – offset cost of rectification and moneys owed under the contract – interest and penalty interest

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), ss 67P and 77(2)

Barry Pitt Construction Pty Ltd v Smith & Anor [2014] QCATA 339
Clark v Macourt (2013) 253 CLR 1
Lida Build Pty Ltd v Miller & Anor [2013] QCATA 139
Robinson v Harman (1848) 1 Ex 850
Sterling Estates Development Corporation Pty Ltd v Malouf [2003] NSWCA 278

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Mr A Stopka, Director

Respondent:

Mr G Dilworth, Director

REASONS FOR DECISION

The nature of the claim and cross-claim

  1. This matter involves:

    (a)a claim by the Applicant for recovery of the cost of rectifying and completing work undertaken by the Respondent as its subcontractor, and an earlier subcontractor, in the construction of a house at 11 Nevis Court, Parrearra, Queensland, in an amount of $14,083.00 plus interest; and

    (b)a counter-application for recovery of unpaid invoices made by the Respondent against the Applicant, in an amount of $4,404.38, a further sum of $862.85 for the cost of materials, plus interest.

    The proceeding

  2. This matter commenced as a minor civil dispute in the Magistrates Court at Maroochydore. It was then transferred to the Building Matters List in this Tribunal, following compliance with Section 77(2) of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act, 1991 (Qld).

  3. Mr Anthony Stopka, Director of the Applicant, conducted the Applicant’s case.  Mr Stopka gave evidence. The Applicant also called Mr John Escher, Carpenter, and Mr Mike Watts, Building Consultant. 

  4. The parties have filed many copies of material since the matter commenced. At the hearing the following documents were isolated and relied upon by the parties.

  5. The Applicant relied upon the following material tendered as Exhibits at the hearing:

    (a)Statement Mr Anthony Stopka, filed 10 July 2017 (Exhibit 1);

    (b)Affidavit of John Escher, filed 30 March 2016 (Exhibit 2);

    (c)Photograph of floor installation and rectification (Exhibit 3);

    (d)Expert Report of Mr Mike Watts, filed 4 February 2017 (Exhibit 4);

    (e)Bundle of Invoices in relation to rectification work (Exhibit 7);

    (f)Reply document, plus attachments, filed 15 August 2017 (Exhibit 10).

  6. Mr Grant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Platinum Property Group Pty Ltd v Dilworth Constructions Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCAT 267
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Platinum Property Group Pty Ltd v Dilworth Constructions Pty Ltd involved a dispute over defective work in a residential building project in Queensland. Platinum Property Group Pty Ltd (the Applicant) was the principal contractor, and Dilworth Constructions Pty Ltd (the Respondent) was engaged as a subcontractor to complete carpentry works. The Applicant originally contracted with another party, Mr Jack Rangely, who was unable to complete the works due to an injury. The Respondent agreed to finish the works but the terms of this agreement were disputed. The Applicant sought rectification of the defective work and to offset these costs against moneys owed to the Respondent. Additionally, the Applicant claimed interest and penalty interest on the sum of $4,404.38.

The court was required to determine whether the Respondent was liable for the defective work and whether the Applicant was entitled to offset the rectification costs against the money owed to the Respondent. The court also needed to establish if the Applicant was entitled to interest and penalty interest on the sum claimed. The primary legal issues revolved around the interpretation of the contract between the parties, the extent of the Respondent's liability for the defective work, and the calculation of interest and penalty interest.

The court examined the various documents and communications between the parties, including the Master Builders Period Subcontract, work orders, and emails. The court noted that while the Master Builders Period Subcontract was signed by the Applicant, it was unsigned by the Respondent. The court also considered the work orders, which specified the work to be done and conditions for payment. The court found that the communications between the parties indicated an agreement for the Respondent to take over the carpentry works without any payment to Mr Rangely. The court determined that the Respondent was liable for the defective work and that the Applicant was entitled to offset the rectification costs against the money owed to the Respondent. Regarding the interest and penalty interest, the court ordered the Respondent to file submissions on the calculation of penalty interest by a specified date.

In summary, the court held that the Respondent was liable for the defective work and that the Applicant could offset the rectification costs against the money owed. The court ordered the Respondent to provide submissions on the calculation of penalty interest on the sum of $4,404.38, with the Applicant to file any reply submissions by a specified date.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Respondent Dilworth Constructions Pty Ltd file and serve submissions in relation to the calculation of penalty interest pursuant to s67P of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) on the sum of $4,404.38, setting out the date on which the calculation commences and providing the calculation until 13 August 2018: by 4pm 27 August 2018.

2. The Applicant Platinum Property Group Pty Ltd file and serve any submissions in reply: by 4 pm 10 September 2018.

Background

Background to the litigation

Finally, the Applicant relied upon an initial Inspection Report prepared by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC), dated 26 November 2015, filed together with the original Application to which I have referred.Background The Applicant was the builder of a house at 11 Nevis Court, Parrearra, Queensland. The Applicant originally contracted with a Mr Jack Rangely to undertake carpentry works as subcontractor. Mr Rangely was unable to complete the contract due to an injury and the Respondent agreed to complete the work. The terms on which the Respondent agreed to continue the work is in dispute. The documents which potentially form part of the contract between the Applicant and the Respondent are:(a)A standard form Master Builders Period Subcontract, dated 1 July 2014, signed by the Applicant on 12 March 2015, but unsigned by the Respondent. A registered post record purports to show the document being sent to the Respondent on 12 March 2015;(b)Work Order 0079/445, addressed to “Carpenter”, noting delivery date 1 October 2014;(c)Work Order 0079/450, addressed to the Respondent, noting delivery date 16 January 2015, emailed to the Respondent on 16 January 2015;(d)Email Matt Nilon, the Applicant’s site supervisor, to Jack Rangely and Grant Dilworth of the Respondent dated 20 November 2014;(e)Email Grant Dilworth to Matt Nilon dated 21 November 2014.(f)Text messages between Matt Nilon and Grant Dilworth in relation to the performance of extra work;(g)Construction plans. The statement of Grant Dilworth refers to some discussions between himself and Matt Nilon at the time of reaching agreement to undertake subcontracting work. Mr Dilworth also refers to conversations between himself and Mr Nilon in relation to the performance of extra work and performance of rectification of work undertaken by Mr Rangely at the commencement of the agreement between the parties. Work Order 0079/445 required carpentry works to erect frames, trusses, steel posts, bulkheads, cyclone rods and upper flooring and sarking. That work was to be undertaken by Mr Rangely. Work Order 0079/450 required lockup and an extra allowance for top hung windows, external ceiling battens, steps to a theatre and installation of an extra bath. Each Work Order bears a number of “Notes” at the base of the Work Order, including:‘6. Progress claim invoices for part payment of this order will not be accepted.8. All work must be completed prior to submitting invoice.’ The email dated 20 November 2014, from Matt Nilon to Jack Rangely and Grant Dilworth, said:Hi Jack and Grant, I believe it has been worked out between you that Grant will be taking over the carpentry contract and there will be no moneys owed to Jack Rangely, by Platinum Residential Designer Homes, for works done on the project by himself or any of his workers. Grant will take full responsibility for any hourly rate works owed to Jack Rangely and accept full responsibility for the carpentry contract in a financial and works liable manner. Please can both of you respond formerly (sic) so we are all completely transparent and there is no disagreement.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.