Pinnacle Runway Pty Ltd v Triangl Limited (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Pinnacle Runway Pty Ltd v Triangl Limited (No 3) [2020] FCA 1379

File number: VID 794 of 2016
Judgment of: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 25 September 2020
Catchwords: COSTS – indemnity costs – where respondent successful in defence of claim of trade mark infringement and applicant successful in cross-claim – discretion as to costs – whether rejection of settlement offers unreasonable or imprudent – applicable principles in relation to indemnity costs – where settlement offers placed the offeree in a substantially better position than it achieved at trial – indemnity costs ordered
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37M, 37N, 43

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) s 58

Federal Court Rules 2011 rr 25.03, 25.14, 40.02 , 40.08

Cases cited:

Anchorage Capital Partners Pty Limited v ACPA Pty Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCAFC 112

Bing! Software Pty Ltd v Bing Technologies Pty Ltd (No 1) (2008) 79 IPR 454

Black v Tomislav Lipovac BHNF Maria Lipovac [1990] FCA 699; (1998) ALR 386

Bohemia Crystal Pty Ltd v Host Corporation Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 892

Damorgold Pty Ltd v. Blindware Pty Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCA 364

Eskine v 72-74 Gordon Crescent Lane Cove Pty Ltd [2019] FCAFC 73

Firebird Global Master Fund II Ltd v Republic of Nauru (No 2) (2015) 327 ALR 192; [2015] HCA 53

GM Global Technology Operations LLC v. S.S.S. Auto Parts Pty Ltd (No.2) (Costs) [2019] FCA 1813

Hazeldene’s Chicken Farm Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority (No 2) [2005] VSCA 298; (2005) 13 VR 435

Kismet International Pty Ltd v Guano Fertiliser Sales Pty Ltd (No 2) [2013] FCA 705

Les Laboratoires Servier v Apotex Pty Ltd (2016) 247 FCR 61

Magenta Nominees Pty Ltd v Richard Ellis (Western Australia) Pty Ltd [1994] FCA 302

Mowie Fisheries Pty Ltd v Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd [1996] FCA 931

Ofria v Cameron (No 2) [2008] NSWCA 242

Pinnacle Runway Pty Ltd v Triangl Limited & Anor [2019] FCA 1662

SMEC Testing Services Pty Ltd v Campbelltown City Council [2000] NSWCA 323

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Trade Marks
Number of paragraphs: 133
Date of last submissions: 7 November 2019
Date of hearing: Heard on the papers
Counsel for the Applicant/Cross-Respondent: Mr T Cordiner QC and Mr A Sykes
Solicitor for the Applicant/Cross-Respondent: Actuate IP
Counsel for the Respondents/Cross-Claimant: Mr N Murray SC and Ms F St John
Solicitor for the Respondents/Cross-Claimant: Corrs Chambers Westgarth

ORDERS

VID 794 of 2016
BETWEEN:

PINNACLE RUNWAY PTY LTD

Applicant

AND:

TRIANGL LIMITED

First Respondent

TRIANGL GROUP LIMITED

Second Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

TRIANGL GROUP LIMITED

Cross-Claimant

AND:

PINNACLE RUNWAY PTY LTD

Cross-Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MURPHY J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 SEPTEMBER 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Applicant pay the Second Respondent’s costs of and associated with the application alleging trade mark infringement (the infringement claim):

(a)for the period from the commencement of the infringement claim against the Second Respondent until 12…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pinnacle Runway Pty Ltd v Triangl Limited (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1379
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Pinnacle Runway Pty Ltd v Triangl Limited (No 3), the Federal Court considered the issue of indemnity costs in relation to a trade mark infringement claim and a cross-claim. Pinnacle Runway Pty Ltd, the applicant, alleged that Triangl Group Limited, the respondent, infringed its registered trade mark DELPHINE. Conversely, Triangl brought a cross-claim asserting that Pinnacle's registration of the DELPHINE trade mark should be cancelled because Pinnacle was not the first to use it. Both claims were unsuccessful. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate allocation of costs between the parties, given the unsuccessful nature of both the main claim and the cross-claim.

The central legal issues involved determining the principles applicable to indemnity costs in the context of unsuccessful claims and cross-claims, and whether the rejection of settlement offers was unreasonable or imprudent. The court examined whether the settlement offers placed the offeree in a substantially better position than they achieved at trial, and the appropriate discretion to be exercised in ordering costs. The court considered the extensive submissions and affidavits provided by both parties, which highlighted the substantial legal costs incurred relative to the potential damages.

The court concluded that Triangl should be awarded its costs in relation to the infringement claim on an indemnity basis from 13 February 2018 onwards. This decision was based on the unreasonableness of Pinnacle's refusal to accept Triangl's settlement offer, which would have placed Pinnacle in a substantially better position than it achieved at trial. For the period up to 12 February 2018, Triangl's costs were to be paid on a party-party basis. Regarding the cross-claim, Pinnacle was awarded its costs up to 12 February 2018 on a party-party basis, with each party bearing their own costs thereafter. The court found that the conduct of the parties did not justify awarding costs for the failure to sue the correct entity.

The final orders were that Pinnacle pay Triangl's costs of the infringement claim on an indemnity basis from 13 February 2018 and on a party-party basis up to that date. Triangl was ordered to pay Pinnacle's costs of the cross-claim on a party-party basis up to 12 February 2018, with each party bearing their own costs thereafter.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Applicant pay the Second Respondent’s costs of and associated with the application alleging trade mark infringement (the infringement claim):

(a) for the period from the commencement of the infringement claim against the Second Respondent until 12 February 2018, on a party-party basis; and

(b) for the period from 13 February 2018, on an indemnity basis;

as agreed or assessed.

2. The Second Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of and associated with the cross-claim for the period up to 12 February 2018 on a party and party basis, as agreed or assessed. Thereafter each party bear their own costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I have concluded that it is appropriate to order that:(a)Pinnacle pay Triangl’s costs of and associated with the infringement claim from the commencement of the claim up to and including 12 February 2018 on a party-party basis on the Federal Court scale, and thereafter on an indemnity basis;(b)Triangl pay Pinnacle’s costs of the cross-claim up to and including 12 February 2018 on a party-party basis on the Federal Court scale, and thereafter each party bear their own costs.THE EVIDENCE Pinnacle relies upon the following evidence;(a)an affidavit of Colin Cheung, a Principal of Pinnacle’s solicitors, Actuate IP, affirmed 31 October 2019; and(b)an affidavit of Louella Willis, a lawyer employed by Actuate IP, affirmed 7 November 2019 which set out the results of internet searches she conducted on 6 November 2019. The searches disclose that, at that time, third parties appeared to be offering for sale products of the second respondent which continue to bear the style name DELPHINE;(c)an affidavit of Andrew Petale, a lawyer formerly employed by Actuate IP, affirmed 26 March 2018 which was filed in the substantive proceeding; and (d)an affidavit of Louis Lao, a lawyer employed by Actuate IP, affirmed 18 September 2018 which was filed in the substantive proceeding.PINNACLE’S PROPOSED ORDERS Pinnacle submits that in circumstances where the Court dismissed the infringement claim and the cross-claim and found that there was “no clear winner”, and also found that both parties likely spent more on legal costs than their respective positions and claims were worth, that except for the matters Pinnacle raises it would be appropriate for the Court to refuse to award costs to either party. But Pinnacle’s primary position is that the Court should make the following orders:(a)for the respondents to pay Pinnacle’s costs thrown away by reason of it issuing proceedings against the first respondent, Triangl Ltd, the joining of Triangl as the second respondent, and the subsequent discontinuance of the proceeding against Triangl Ltd, in an amount to be agreed or assessed on a lump sum basis;(b)Triangl pay Pinnacle’s costs thrown away by reason of its abandonment of the relevant grounds of the cross-claim in an amount to be agreed or assessed on a lump sum basis; and(c)pursuant to ss 43, 37N(3)(b) and (4) and/or 37P of the Act: (i)within seven days Triangl be ordered to file and serve a notice setting out their total legal costs, separately identifying total disbursements, including the hourly rates at which the legal practitioners worked;(ii)within seven days Pinnacle be ordered to provide the same; and(iii)if Triangl’s costs are greater than Pinnacle’s costs, Triangl pay Pinnacle 25% of the difference between their costs, or such other (or nil) amount as the Court deems fit;(the proposed orders). Pinnacle points to the following matters in support of the contention that the Court should make the proposed orders. Pinnacle contends that it suffered substantial costs thrown away because Triangl and its director, Craig Ellis, had misdirected or misled it as to the identity of the entity that used the DELPHINE name, which resulted in Pinnacle commencing the proceeding against the first respondent, Triangl Ltd, and then being forced to amend the proceeding to name the second respondent, Triangl, and to discontinue against the first respondent. It submits that Triangl should pay Pinnacle’s costs thrown away by reason of those matters.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As I said in Pinnacle Runway Pty Ltd v Triangl Limited & Anor [2019] FCA 1662 (the liability judgment or LJ) these were ill-advised proceedings and there is no clear winner. The applicant and cross-respondent, Pinnacle Runway Pty Ltd (Pinnacle) alleged but failed to establish that the second respondent and cross-claimant, Triangl Group Limited (Triangl), infringed its registered trade mark, DELPHINE (the infringement claim). Triangl alleged but failed to establish that Pinnacle’s registration of the DELPHINE trade mark should be cancelled on the basis that Pinnacle was not the first to use it (the cross-claim). Further, even if Pinnacle had been successful in the infringement claim, its damages entitlements would not have been worth the powder and shot. As I said (at LJ [2]):Pinnacle spent many times more in legal costs in bringing the claim than it could ever have reasonably hoped to recover by way of damages. Triangl spent many times more defending the claim and bringing the cross-claim than it could have possibly been required to pay in damages. This unfortunate litigation involved substantial expenditure of the parties’ and Court resources and, for reasons which are unclear, the parties were unable to reach a commercial settlement. These reasons concern the legal costs incurred by the parties. I have delayed in making a decision regarding costs as it seemed a better use of my time to await the decision of the Full Court in the appeal which has been commenced, given that costs are likely to follow the event. The hearing of the appeal has however been delayed, and it is plain from the submissions that because the costs incurred by the parties are so substantial in comparison to the damages that could have been recovered, the issue of costs looms large in the appeal. In response to a communication from my chambers both parties said that they would prefer the decision on costs to be made before the appeal is heard, and I have accordingly turned to the question. Unfortunately, I neglected to place a limit on the length of the costs submissions to be filed, and the parties filed costs submissions together with affidavits and annexures running to a total of 83 pages. As a result, to deal with the parties’ various arguments these reasons are lengthier than I would have wished. In summary, having been successful in the infringement claim Triangl seeks an order for its costs in that proceeding on an indemnity basis, and if not on a party-party basis. It seeks that the costs of the cross-claim lie where they fall. However, if the Court considers that Pinnacle should have its costs of successfully defending the cross-claim, Triangl argues they should be reduced to the Federal Circuit Court (FCC) Scale. Pinnacle’s primary contention is that the Court should award it 25% of the difference between the, as asserted, higher costs incurred by Triangl for the whole proceeding (both the infringement claim and the cross-claim) as compared to Pinnacle’s costs for the whole proceeding. If not, it having been successful in the cross-claim, Pinnacle seeks an order for its costs in relation to that part of the proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Pinnacle also notes that, despite seeking the proposed orders, it made a Calderbank offer on 25 October 2019 in which it offered not to appeal the liability judgment and to settle the issue of costs on the basis that each party bear their own costs. The offer was not accepted and Pinnacle subsequently filed an appeal.Consideration Some of Pinnacle’s contentions relate to the infringement claim alone, and others involve rolling up consideration of the costs of the infringement claim with consideration of the costs of the cross-claim. In the circumstances of the present case I am not persuaded that it is appropriate to roll up consideration of the costs in that way. The facts and circumstances relevant to which party should have the benefit of a costs order are different as between the infringement claim and the cross-claim and it is appropriate to consider them separately, at least largely. Having said that, and as I explain, my view that it was unreasonable for Pinnacle not to have accepted Triangl’s second Calderbank offer made in relation to the whole proceeding (both infringement claim and cross-claim) has an effect on my view as to the appropriate order in relation to costs in the cross-claim. Once the issues in relation to the costs of the infringement claim are considered largely separately from those in relation to the costs of the cross-claim I can see little merit in Pinnacle’s proposed orders. First, I do not accept Pinnacle’s contention that it should have its costs thrown away because it was misdirected or misled by Triangl and its director, Mr Ellis, which resulted in it commencing the proceeding against the wrong Triangl entity. The evidence does not establish that Mr Ellis, Triangl Ltd or Triangl deliberately misdirected or misled Pinnacle’s lawyers in relation to the correct Triangl entity such that it might be appropriate that Triangl bear the costs thrown away. It was put to Mr Ellis in cross examination that he did not alert Pinnacle to the fact that it had commenced the proceeding against the wrong Triangl entity because he wanted to make the case as difficult and expensive as possible for Pinnacle. Essentially Mr Ellis said that he did not inform Pinnacle of its mistake because he had a lot to do and he had to prioritise his work. He said, and I accepted (at LJ [86]), that the “last thing” he was thinking about in response to Pinnacle’s demands was whether it had sued the right entity. It was the task of Pinnacle’s lawyers, Actuate IP, to commence the proceeding against the correct Triangl entity. I have no difficulty in accepting that it was reasonable for Mr Petale to commence the case against Triangl Ltd given the information that he had, but there were further available methods open for him to satisfy himself as to the correct Triangle entity, including by making a “trap” purchase so as to obtain an invoice, by making an application for preliminary discovery, or undertaking a search of entities within the Triangle group of companies. In the absence of evidence that Mr Ellis, Triangl Ltd or Triangl deliberately sought to misdirect or mislead Pinnacle or its solicitors, Pinnacle draws a long bow in arguing that the successful respondent to the proceeding should pay the costs of its failure to sue the correct party. I am not persuaded that the conduct of Mr Ellis, Triangl Ltd or Triangl rises to the level of justifying such an order.