Pike v Rockhampton Optical Pty Ltd

%PDF-1.5

%????

1 0 obj

<</Type/Catalog/Pages 2 0 R/Lang(en-US) /StructTreeRoot 31 0 R/MarkInfo<</Marked true>>>>

endobj

2 0 obj

<</Type/Pages/Count 4/Kids[ 3 0 R 19 0 R 21 0 R 28 0 R] >>

endobj

3 0 obj

<</Type/Page/Parent 2 0 R/Resources<</XObject<</Image5 5 0 R>>/Font<</F1 6 0 R/F2 8 0 R/F3 10 0 R/F4 12 0 R/F5 14 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 595.32 841.92] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<</Type/Group/S/Transparency/CS/DeviceRGB>>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>>

endobj

4 0 obj

<</Filter/FlateDecode/Length 3437>>

stream

x??\[o??~?????????Vl?I$v??-
?>(?l?%?????3??%we?K????E?3????~???????t?#??|r??Mg??-?r2?<?y2??8??8?_????f}zJ?/F????h??iL"?/?B??1I??`d??????az?????|z??|[1]w?PB?????EJ?<?#A?<
S?^??=?y?????$?w?_]N????2??-?Yr?aD??Gl?????D'???{2???g?e#?I???8
???p?.??q%m????c|??0%4???,

R?_???_d

?&?&??qx???iCG?I0?gc?????'?p?????
?I????B??>a??K?L?0?]>?->?!F?D????q??4?kd|
?l??kN?!|#7??????/[1]??x?????/?5??n.g???3W?4S?&X2f?F???v? ?????~h?{????"I??S#*?i????~a?Dh3U???/V??A?Ph4???&/??#?F{??^,?&??-?/?[1]gQH?-???#pr?b?"
#?i???-?R?~??x????I?C?#/??y?KLw^N?3K?8?L??????s0???|?N
?U??????‑w?N??t?????l?7?T???2?Ne??i?

?}?"‑!??\?
????IM%???aE?Y-!???E?:;?????Q??%+x?x????^???i??????@???<?Z?9b?C?#?v

QzJ_t??;z?CLSo?6~k???B?@?
u??B?
*DK?i#??'??Q"sf?RO??.{y|?9M=e?nSEy??a?

????#??????d?4qk0I?(??0????d?DRG;0I??$???8Wb[Qr`????F??-:g??%??>i[?sd???du??b?%[??M?o???^I??~
?R[*C?G?Di?r3??^)?6??~rXW??:?H?????G???:???????0\??????9?{Z?P?3?a/Z:???‑h;?!??^??=?
?+u????h

?z9b>??
}?g,??)?
??)????>Uqpa?????l??M`O???k?aP???b??!???$?S1M???\????TAI\k?????v?f8?`?wG???#??8c9?H3???V???‑?W?V|‑?C-I{9?rA#m[1]@Lq???O???(s??NAMbN??[1]@??j???[r?????u?lB(<?????P??

Q?`???5-?^#wTTs?)

y????U?c?K8?J?^????H??0?D????P?
?m??}

5H#t@h??\???u?l[1]mC????1????l

?#??Y??s??????kU

?U?m

???d?q/gY^h?q

y&=@*2?6}@?6w?GP???S???h?}<?5??~??C?SW??O????:?Y*??N?<[???B?2???i?E?0?#=?0??l??%??????r%?IYL??M?L?b?????????r??????8????K-_5?&??9?|?1
E/
?????d $<Vc???7???//p?

???v?W??Fn???r7??"7?y??#?;?@??TA????UY?i?s^? ????
?=I??????r???kM??f)????J????=M???z?HA?????.??1?c?C??&q!?=c?T?w13????A?<???S?R?#e8v?t
r?
??#??1?Kj??Y????
4?H9??V'??8?????X?u?j22??:??????\?????v?h?xP?3S]???!r?T????=????{?&????|&?0????
QM????98?m?u???p??rs?g????b?r+dU-??T?-?z
b?!j
?q.?s??????d??>?'p?;>??I???a@??????`y>,?2u?d???|?+?d?P;?4"?F
????<?>?9

y??????=?P?L?-

?'(j

~Aa????B&??n

??e?\!?6??f????jz?????[1]W?'F?%\??J???l???4??_?/r????_????????d??=?~???ql?u?W8??#?+??}?
???5??)?f?{*??4?????p?????)v???1d[1]<??=??+|??m
?H??pk?R?vZ???C??????????fa??rs?&?%/H????`v`????<???ku`??`?!?^HD?p????r?l?)?8o?i?p?7??^?;T????tW??t?????#‑
m??H??‑??[1]Q?;?U??>?‑A8J=MS??6?c?dB??O?E???????V?????Ww?N@t?jJ??????zG?D??e???????M??????v??QtNO??R??`8???
G??q.??+]s??w?Un?U??5?????*D*????T??f??*b0y/=|?t|u}?C~?si?bA??ocd??
.???Xu???K?0OV&?zo0O#9?f??
?S??n???Iw?7?+<3?????+?]???????v???????EXhL??b4??K?[1]g6?v?I??5K?w??E5S???%???????[?$P??M"ry??-?r??}i????????Q??hP??y??O?Y???-x????????[h)4??C
????M?5?t^????x{_?v?t<Z?;9?T??;?V???F????M??s"5J?‑??1??$l??[:?-??????}???QR%??S$????b???j???
u??4?[???+vf??????%?5?????A??Ip?V(E?]>??u?Oq~?c???‑R?????D??D6??NN????:?+?_????1Z??'??2_??o%f3?S?????N]?l`???????%?W??V???\M????e?7?'?[??[1]?D‑???:!?az?s??]1?U3?‑????‑GdG-?2L?0t?b??????t,??i}??|???=?Zl??XG?)"8?T????/?c???‑c??&tH??R???*Sx?????
c?qE?Oz:??;;r?L??i[1]?B?[??y|J???8?????t(???W??yr?W|TD?c?byq?zq);?{uzk??? ??S?R:???!?r4???vVQ-9?kPe????wS2?zP???[1]????I????.oEk*O-?‑?R???$??>?S‑?<?X?+Ez\,????'???????l?????[???o5???4)J
??"????_?y???{???r??4F?????bj?6t?\nE4??8??C-?{?4?S`???5??????????I?'?.(?a???1nN??b???p'???7?????j??'4,?]??Z?Bg?[1]??EbT??????Z??r??4??@??G??????G? ??}
?=3F???&????Hjbt*L~A5???????0??^?u??8<??F)?W??k??m?g?2?~?-m‑?u??-q??J?{3??'??d?y????l&?I?????e??Z
????:??[????jYE??q??

endstream

endobj

5 0 obj

<</Type/XObject/Subtype/Image/Width 468/Height 139/ColorSpace/DeviceRGB/BitsPerComponent 8/Filter/DCTDecode/Interpolate true/Length 9771>>

stream

????JFIF``??C

‑ $.' ",#(7),01444'9=82<.342??C

2!!22222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222????

"[1]??[1]

???[1][1]}[1]!1AQa"q2???#B??R??$3br?
%&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????[1]

???[1][1][1]w[1]!1AQaq"2?B????#3R?br?
$4?%?&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
[1]???(??
??5?+@??N?}

?G????@9??r?~!A????R}Vu?Q‑???????|????????????7????t

?T?V)F????g+aaw{??q??'????h>?X?????]x?.???e???;???p?o???L?e"P???+?4_i‑"??F?

?????????????????}??s%??g+$g??=????qG??W??7???-???HuxW,????????[1]?;??`???~"?D??m???>?:?(?H????
???%s???E??v??:??V??????????W???‑??]?J?&?

???#??*?MWW?????????????@:?*?f??(???????N4}<
?g???????u-
?????#???,??X??w
qQ??c?G?~????U????.q???d??=
?M_(|>?????Q?O$V?-??pcQ?}I?????0??\[frV?(?????^???F
?[?????"? ?r{??5?
?D??F??????x?[?????z??/7???b|?\g??j?rw4QG?????x?Y:e?????Y?L?p??Z???k'??-?5=?Hf‑g???o????@ ????%c'?? ????>?x?<?
??[?`??????^???=C??_?????L?/?????_0???c?MC???????????????7?>z?????_<QS???????{xo?|??????^???=C??_???(???*>??????????????????#????,-o_-?-*??????k?~?????E??(}?????Rm??${?QZQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEKX?-?]"?R?8??3#{???x????????????}1g?G????T??Wg?k????5??R??Op?????Q?g???D??I????>????
*???5???????????c????L??a???????)(?>?t'?????6?+??yx??,cJ?El?????><?K??3^?v?g??,#?b9?????|?????
??G ?????]-t??z?F?b?????????]J??sV?u???????;?w
???~5?????<C?????Gs|g;OB?[1]?+???????\h?????‑???????U?h???????kV??o5[??v????n=[1]?$?_#?????\?W?y???a??W??{??;=3E?????a??/?[??
?o[V?
2\N??????QTd?=??<

??K??"??`??Ta???tp???s?W?|?ST????

Ga??y?W???W?tAu?A??EUA?U[1]?????&???N?LG

?)??????:+B
o?~

??^??V?f?G/4??i:?c?q???IEW;??o???z???V-?z?c?c?9?+???????L?#o?Z?a??????*M?

+????)

+1C??

???G??:ez^???#?V????l7
q?G;?S??)?y?}_??Z???&?t??d????2???5??{_?Mk?h?7P?0??u??Z?=I???

cF????4?N???????e?#? ?[1]???T??????????h?,??q_??<

?@1??S?u?N?o???[@?"??H?rN1s?_e??‑"???U?????3Q4\Y?_Kh?
<w?i?3?????9??0?

???i???;?"???^p??[1]?!????*O?
?T??]o?>??1m-??f-b???????r??????????)?(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??+???f_Y[g?-??1?_BW??????????L?*;?o^???>??\??v?????????????|???A??????c?h????+????}???K1?3
???????_?y??
??b??????[1]n?^3???Y?G????W?|
~!??k)?N+8?[?g???q??x??(????????????[?n?I????I\ep[‑???@?

z???B?????????w?

??iq??3?_???{i???QEB
(??
???.?????N?[0??D^?S??H'????k???=??OR

?H???m???H??'&?o?p]G??O1.?$`?rN}Y?xu???????

h???Q^??G????????m??I?d??E}QJ
@?>&?????????.??lF_&_M?6?? ?K??A??[???v????????"?zTl^??4V????H<?jE?I, H?_??Pkz?1
???_?3j???7??k?z???_?3j???7??j&\
?????,?_????+??????,?_????)@&iQE?EPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEP_>|y?1x???,??A?V9?b???.????????8?s??|?vG???Z?lTw>w?`?pZ?-??????[1]???????#??I??d%`?]?[?=?_?x??q????Q[|????I?;XA?+5???k?z?G?F?????K??4+ ?2:a_????Tw9J?o??f__?c???n}?????)?????e?K?M?

7?OtL???????c??2??????H???)???Z?k?~=??F??????m1?N???~??T??Gc??g???z??q"????^?_2| ???<s
s?K{?6??????

????HlD?
(?????(??=k?]????????a?8_???^]o??s?{?z??6?"????8?NO?\?c'vj????K?7?

??????ygAi???9?

?]o?/O????~??k?|??????????????E?Y?'?%?????/b?;?EF?T?q?=z??V5H`?[1]LN?T?t?{??]k??5-F??u? OUn? ~u?U????k???{?????iy???‑?_SV?z?j?????f???o?
????????f???o?
???f?????gJ??8?_W????gJ??8?J3J?(?
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
???[??u???o??3??"??@x???^??t??wD?G?!???+&9‑)H???
???W??????t??Xu6??????????5?S????j??[??7?????VR??S???
????vP???????+J?????>????I?+?????c;????u?????Q??????Z??i???M??P???!?=???x-??]]En???4?F}I?
??4?_???w?Mr?K?Re??["?c?}u????F?m????-?????;?????4I??r??r??;*{:?kH?'s'????|=y????????9V??N??]?????}???????#??2????-<gd&????
?)????_?????.???? ?A?s?'?kV??N?<????{?????r?z??kA??=|?z?????M??a???J???h??>???>??I
??2‑??(??bk?|+????1?N?

?~?????Us?rBx???$?$?M????\?m>??c????‑??x?Z‑‑????n??????*??W?F??jz?0i0M5??PB
T?????X????v???-Q?:?????NW??2s??'a8?x?%?$??I5????,?4???y????????k??

??i???????#B???????vS?‑??EV?E{?8?>??q????????????
?)?%?F???8??k???7?_?g?E??k:???????5E??r<R,??WBXut5??5d?|9??????U?;7F?5??}?+Z?g?.??o??m??'?B

????rZ‑?_x??FmW??&???}?_x??FmW??&???9?m}????t?????@??}????t?????@?4???????(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(?Z????6??R?????l}=*????/?9x??{C.@????+??6F?
?p???%e?q??J)r??3??|>??K=????t?????=G?????wE?
:?V*FA??4?3???e??c??<???>??q?P???.???G?6??A/?ls?Z?IQ??????W?i??3s7??Y??W???#???+Z??????
??OnA??????Y@p$???*??U?o?&???Q?4??wH??#?g????u????6???Q????????

F?
??^?Z-?3{??*?W?6???7P?????pz??/
^?=?????
?Q?05?P?av?!?t???^???????p?3_^?d?*???????G*
fg?:??[?]??????????{?>‑?.?/?[G?p?????z???a\??Px/??????k????t?
??k???H?c???8?SZ?R??QE????h?+kv??
?nFC? 63??A[?P
?
???
????Z?‑?>??{?nt?W?YSc?+0#9?MttR??Ws???wS\??;K3??|?$?????v???????????[kx?-a??v?
,h3?0*Z)X.QE0
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??$Q??%?]Ua?j?z>??dzu?????U?(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(?_x??????G5????v????I????{V?p7????????ZT?=??‑??&4iYx?:????h??<?d?g??G)??O

?]epw?o?F??-???Cn??_???|Y?????O!?y?[~7c?q????????u??_????Y???m$?rU?p??Gl??+??\?????#?<@?&|???????a]??z.=???x?K?D?n?5

???x,U??b>T???

??xSQ?k?i??j??Q[??/?E?2T?P?8<?J.=‑??u????h?['????a?d?V???
?????]?????A?Q}J/I=?????HC??-+????z?h^??V1???????‑?oO??m??]?xR]???8?k???H????[F??uo"Nng2<Gs??
?>?wT???xyou??6'??y6??G?_?p
q??N?c????????k:Tw???m?E???cbH8??Z??4?SP?qw????Y?M??ke???]??{????????c???]koi? ?2?[?7?????1?9?KR??M^???,7?ZO?D??]A???q?`??<?I
????_E?]B????2
???NF@c?8?E??????gk-???)wv8
Rk?[?
?<??~?o??[k??}x????S??{? I$I!?.?????????@V?{`ubIo?4??`?r+?j0x?F?b???Z??$?w???????5???x???|g????N???K???p??Z???S?x6???‑?}q5?6RM!g;???O?#~??v=3??+?<.?{Xh?jf?R????‑??s???W^6???e??E???????Gl?????\?????FmF?]^????U?UO=?‑???S?????????T??=j???8?E?sz,B???G???s?_7????E?????[???o?M0e???99>?=ESvW>?????????
J??o,?????2X8?;?o????g?????B?N?y?\9bYpA??pqK?P???/?d???o???Y??)??l??_?????|A??

Y?????0?????Y???|:?|]?k???0Af?L??W8

?‑???
?????????;??d???4??V?

????4??i0Rx?<?Z?????|?g??)H?T????

???^I?V??O?Zf???,:V??C??v0;??K????>
??u???k?8u ?????Q??[C??k?9<)?k?b+t?xY??T???Z?u??R1yF??`9???f?}???}o?????/_L?p??!12??y???j?|_{?Y|;???~?sf??F0?T7??$??K?,{?P?????[??-^?X"gH#??Ga^2|=?Z|H‑????????1??8?9??????‑??H|??)5+???7-??!??|
r>?4??????]??????t???F`al???pkz??S?W??z???\??+??0g?????<E?x{?~???W??k$?Y\??c+??o??`??V?+?.> ??u?Y???=?|s???9?^??W?Y_???}z?nex??S
!1?yQ‑p9??y???G>?t?/??G???o????z?_??
(??X??K??^??

??7??yH?????z
??+??i????4???L:?Q0?)??m6?
~I5{????<;???\?- ??`?&bG?R?g??G0X?z???

>?{???

d???(5?>0???????^??W??(
?[@^i??;???zqY‑???<
?}6?T????Kg??????‑??`??V?.??<#s?

"?{??I
q????=??

???I???+?9?&we??<?xa?

y???/??
?=v??s%??,~v#?i?2?????{?n?????????Ap
?D?d?ws???
?????W??x?|K????s?????4????7?@??0??\?-???^j???<C??K|?p?8????|??}9yq?K+??-??ci6'V????1??e??

??c?O?????k????>??=3Q?]??
??????:???%?????ho?z?|F?&???m2?O!?Gr0??9??5C?~+?4o??U??5???.8??q??:???3?L????=?X??){??d )fe,8?*

~???‑1?F??{5?|??JzL??
????Qp??Z??K??????[A????,J?c?????W????'??gO????Sn??[6? C???*?@??m??h??W??FM???w???g t#??9???Q^?m[R?????!???i?"Yf
?/?9??k?B}V?????Xk7?w
?b??2X8?;??=?????{????:??u=??E?[?2P?>~x??W?????????u?CW?a??d??=
s??G0r???????h?DvK0???ei1?n??z?a^1?{?/<W???b
?$r9

$?5???
(?????xj?T????&?+]gN-?<?Lr+
28????j(??Os?7?t???$

[1]?a4????4?????(>??j:?????/??ZJ???
??nB?
02
}Ew4R??q^???k?k??????k0?&[p?+(e?3?!H?j???x???
?i?z<?tD????????
??????h??s????;?gO??sk‑?iB?r??6?
??????l>#???????G?l??

????v??E
?G?!???????E??<?+??yy???==?Z??Z}?tt??-??Xn???
??????E??i?k???Ew5?z????n???#'?'?^?o
???MmOF????I??Yve[nA??O??}E
?n??x???w???6??{j?<v??tT??d|?I????xR??????????n[1]???‑c3
??????(?\?o??6???t??h??

6??[1]a?*????/
?????‑!?nt???K?????
,99???QE??

kH???{?.?K[?&??Q????5???????h?!???
-?

?D'

i?$?=}+?h???gw??^???‑?????i??NZV?d???j??>???Yc?C<A?K?|??T?
\q???J?? ?8??‑

??e?????
+?5???

?U?x3[????x?E???n?)b?,>\2?`?X?8?A????h???xn?I?|?uA'?OQ?dW?\|.??????????????[t??????'?{?5pN???+U??u??=??]>%[??+;
???????<so????[?a????????z?h??.x??Y?+M*???:????r?a?Co8 ?????‑??z??????v?t?<??yl?T?zd[TP????u????O?u?c?i????n?
~j?$??????CQ'???????Y????o=?`?(d??[1]?????*?9P]?*~x?=??P?Zq?‑O5C??H ???r??E?|=?5
?gK???'??L???[???n??H??T?????????R'??q?
D?0?0?Lc?Z???‑?Zv??
in???cR?L????:f?‑?,<?????7??O
??????????Y??|???;V???MCP?<#y????,??e???x?d??w?Qdg

?58~%j?'???!????qtq($c?????_?????h????Of???o?

?????r?,<???
?a?xR?????H?`T???
?????????kS???|Cuuc??%[?B?{?I?1??????,??????‑ ????,???-qa???r0:`??^?w?im?Xu;?G?Y?xA'?;?y?.~?+????.y??<??'???/.?????T?h??????????t[1]Ke??
?SA,????J???O ‑
?]?Y?
?????????jRAsq~?eh?T?y?o??4?[1]x????N????2y
???2??m#?????(?
?t?.m??h/'[???
$??C??q????&?]??????[%????I
ol9n01??uE?#??
??|}???\[?????G-????????x??????4

j??? ??RB?????????????????V?>?<S?j????????*P??Hw=??.?O???e~????=?[1]U
I?

?I=+?h????w
|m?xr?A??t??????????rI????Wg??/R?<?x?\??l#Q2???s?`?s??sE?.?[1]??????77p?Mf???FO??????oZ????

???w?.???p[|??v?>?=??(?????x

?????l?,F??F??]????'????W?A?????g??y?3?v9?{f???Ap??)???

endstream

endobj

6 0 obj

<</Type/Font/Subtype/TrueType/Name/F1/BaseFont/Times#20New#20Roman/Encoding/WinAnsiEncoding/FontDescriptor 7 0 R/FirstChar 32/LastChar 32/Widths 201 0 R>>

endobj

7 0 obj

<</Type/FontDescriptor/FontName/Times#20New#20Roman/Flags 32/ItalicAngle 0/Ascent 891/Descent -216/CapHeight 693/AvgWidth 401/MaxWidth 2568/FontWeight 400/XHeight 250/Leading 42/StemV 40/FontBBox[ -568 -216 2000 693]…

The matter before the court was an application for leave to appeal a decision made by a Magistrate in a minor civil dispute. The applicant, Ms Pike, had purchased prescription sunglasses from Rockhampton Optical Pty Ltd but claimed they were defective and unwearable. She sought a refund of the contribution she had made to her health fund. The Magistrate dismissed her claim on the basis that the respondent was not a 'trader' within the meaning of the relevant legislation, as it was acting in the discipline of optometry. Ms Pike now seeks leave to appeal that decision, arguing that the Magistrate's conclusion was an error of law.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether leave to appeal should be granted. A secondary issue was whether the Magistrate's decision contained an error of law. The court considered whether the Magistrate had erred in concluding that the respondent was not a 'trader' within the meaning of the relevant statute. The court had to determine whether the Magistrate had applied the correct legal principles in reaching this conclusion.

The court granted leave to appeal and allowed the appeal. The court found that the Magistrate had erred in law by incorrectly applying the definition of 'trader'. The court held that the respondent was indeed a 'trader' within the meaning of the relevant statute and that the Magistrate's decision should be set aside. The matter was returned to the Tribunal for re-hearing and determination. The court did not speculate on the likely outcome of the re-hearing but focused on the legal errors made by the Magistrate.

Continue reading Pike v Rockhampton Optical Pty Ltd

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Orders of the court

Background to the litigation

Evidence Before The Court

Reasons for decision

Legal Principle Established