Piepkorn v Police No. Scciv-04-242

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

PIEPKORN v POLICE
[2004] SASC 137

Magistrates Appeal:  Criminal

  1. ANDERSON J:     In this matter the appellant has appealed following a conviction recorded against her in the Mount Barker Magistrates Court on 22 January 2004.

  2. The appellant had been charged with failing to give way to an oncoming vehicle and turning right contrary to Rule 72(5)(b) of the Australian Road Rules. The charge arose from an accident which occurred on 1 September 2003 at the intersection of Burnside Road and Mine Flat Road, Strathalbyn. Prior to the trial the appellant had indicated that she intended pleading not guilty but on the morning of the trial she pleaded guilty before the Magistrate at Mount Barker. The appellant was convicted and fined $45.

  3. The appeal to this Court is against both the conviction and the sentence imposed by the Magistrate.

  4. The appellant says that she was coerced and intimidated by the police officers into entering her plea of guilty.  The police officers involved include the officer who went to the scene of the accident Constable Bowden and Sergeant Illingworth the prosecutor on the actual day the matter was listed for hearing.

  5. The appellant gave evidence before me as to her version of what happened at the relevant time and then the two police officers gave evidence.  Sergeant Illingworth had filed two affidavits in relation to this matter and because the appellant represented herself I put to her the main details set out in those affidavits.  Essentially, the appellant agreed with the affidavits of Sergeant Illingworth.  The appellant claimed that two photographs were not taken soon after the accident, as Constable Bowden said, but were taken at a later time and that the tracks shown on the dirt road were tracks left by another vehicle at another time and were not related to the accident.

  6. Sergeant Illingworth had said in his affidavit words to the effect:

    “The court has to make a determination of fact, what do you think they will believe when they see these photos?  Isn’t it possible that you might have been on the wrong side of the road, just a little bit, given that there are no lines marked?”

  7. The appellant agreed that Sergeant Illingworth did say that, or something like it, and she agreed finally that she did say that she might have been a little bit over the middle of the road.

  8. There was then a discussion between Sergeant Illingworth and the appellant and she alleges that he said “you go into court and plead guilty and I’ll make it so you don’t get a conviction”.  The appellant said that at that time she was nearly crying with pain from a headache and she could not argue the point anymore and agreed to plead guilty.

  9. Sergeant Illingworth denied that version of events and gave what seems to me to be a perfectly logical explanation of what he said at the time.  He said that a conversation relating to the recording of a conviction did take place.  He indicated…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Piepkorn v Police No. Scciv-04-242 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 137
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Piepkorn v Police, the appellant, Piepkorn, appealed against her conviction and sentence imposed by the Mount Barker Magistrates Court following her guilty plea to charges of failing to give way to an oncoming vehicle and turning right contrary to Rule 72(5)(b) of the Australian Road Rules. The charges arose from a road accident at the intersection of Burnside Road and Mine Flat Road, Strathalbyn, on 1 September 2003. Piepkorn initially indicated she would plead not guilty, but changed her plea to guilty on the morning of the trial. The appellant was fined $45.

The central issue before the court was whether the appellant's guilty plea was entered voluntarily and whether the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive. The appellant argued that she was coerced and intimidated by police officers into pleading guilty, particularly by Sergeant Illingworth, who allegedly promised her that there would be no conviction if she pleaded guilty. The appellant also alleged that Constable Bowden accused her of being drunk, which he denied. The court had to determine the credibility of the evidence given by the appellant and the police officers.

The court considered the evidence provided by the appellant and the police officers. The appellant's claims of coercion were rejected as she was deemed an experienced litigator who would have been capable of understanding the implications of her plea and requesting an adjournment if necessary. The court found Sergeant Illingworth's evidence more credible, accepting that while a conversation about sentencing options did occur, there was no assurance given about the outcome. The court also accepted Constable Bowden's evidence that he did not accuse the appellant of being drunk. Regarding the accident, the court found the appellant's vehicle was on the wrong side of the road, supported by the skid marks and the evidence provided by Sergeant Illingworth.

The court concluded that there was no miscarriage of justice and dismissed both the appeal against the conviction and the sentence. The appeal was dismissed as the court found that the appellant had clearly understood the charges and intended to plead guilty. The sentence of a $45 fine was deemed particularly lenient.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established