PGC Holdings Pty Ltd v Jalfire Pty Ltd (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

PGC Holdings Pty Ltd v Jalfire Pty Ltd & Anor (No. 2) [2018] QCAT 363

PARTIES:

PGC HOLDINGS PTY LTD
(applicant)

v

JALFIRE PTY LTD

(first respondent)

HIGHER LEVEL THINKING PTY LTD (ACN 165 487 463) TRUSTEE UNDER INSTRUMENT 7177 16645

(second respondent)

APPLICATION NO:

NDR193-15

MATTER TYPE:

Other civil dispute matters

DELIVERED ON:

19 October 2018

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Senior Member Brown

ORDERS:

1.   Jalfire Pty Ltd and Higher Level Thinking Pty Ltd must each pay to PGC Holdings Pty Ltd costs in the amount of $5,148.59 within fourteen (14) days;

2.   The proceeding against Jalfire Pty Ltd is otherwise dismissed;

3.   PGC Holdings Pty Ltd must file and serve any further expert evidence limited to:

(a)    A geotechnical engineer report;

(b)   A supplementary report by Benjamin Jones, by: 4:00pm on 16 November 2018.

4.   Higher Level Thinking Pty Ltd must provide such access to its property as may be required for the purpose of an inspection by a geotechnical engineer engaged by PGC Holdings Pty Ltd;

5.   Higher level Thinking Pty Ltd must file and serve any further expert evidence limited to a report by an appropriately qualified engineer, by: 4:00pm on 14 December 2018.

6.   No party, nor any expert engaged by a party, may rely upon or refer to any report by Jeffrey Hills & Associates filed in the proceeding;

7.   The evidence given at the hearing on 2 March 2017 may not be relied upon by the parties and will not be considered by the Tribunal in any final decision;

8.   The matter is listed for a Directions Hearing on a date to be advised;

9.   The matter is listed for a two day Tribunal Hearing on a date to be advised.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – PARTIES AND NON PARTIES – WHO IS A PARTY – whether interests of justice require an order for costs – where party not joined at the time of conduct leading to costs order – whether conduct of party before being joined relevant in consideration of costs – whether party can be liable for costs in respect of conduct before party joined

Neighbourhood Disputes (Dividing Fences and Trees) Act 2011 (Qld), s 62(1), s 66, s 83, s 84
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 6(7), s 7, s 39(b), s 40, s 42, s 46(1), s 47, s 47(1), s 47(2)(a), s 47(3), s 48, s 100, s 102, s 102(1), s 102(3)(a), s 102(3)(b), s 102(3)(c), s 102(3)(e), s 102(3)(f), s 103, s 106, s 107(1)

Burdekin Shire Council v Pioneer Sugar Mills Pty Ltd [2005] QPELR 13
Cachia v Hanes (1994) 179 CLR 403
Donovan Hill Pty Ltd v McNab Constructions Australia Pty Ltd [2015] QCA 114
Knight v FP Special Assets (1992) 174 CLR 178
Lyons v Queensland Building and Construction Commission & Dreamstarter Pty Ltd (in liquidation) [2016] QCAT 218

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PGC Holdings Pty Ltd v Jalfire Pty Ltd (No. 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCAT 363
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties involved in this case are PGC Holdings Pty Ltd and Jalfire Pty Ltd, who are engaged in a legal dispute over a tree issue. The matter was initially filed by PGC on 22 December 2015, and Jalfire responded on 17 February 2016. The case revolves around an expert engineer, Mr Jeffrey Hills, who was engaged by Jalfire and provided two reports on the issue. The case was set for an experts' conclave and a hearing, which took place on 16 December 2016 and 2 March 2017, respectively. However, it was later revealed that Jalfire had transferred ownership of the land in question to Higher Level Thinking Pty Ltd, a company of which Mr Hills is a director, secretary, and shareholder, prior to the conclave. This transfer was not disclosed to PGC or the tribunal, and Mr Hills' role in the company was not disclosed during the hearing.

The legal issues that the court was required to decide in this case were whether there should be an order in respect of the costs thrown of the experts' conclave and the hearing and what further directions should be made in the proceedings. The court had to consider whether the interests of justice required an order for costs and whether the conduct of Jalfire and Mr Hills before being joined was relevant in the consideration of costs. Additionally, the court had to determine whether Jalfire and Higher Level Thinking Pty Ltd could be held liable for costs in respect of the conduct before Jalfire was joined.

The court's reasoning and outcome were that Jalfire Pty Ltd and Higher Level Thinking Pty Ltd must each pay to PGC Holdings Pty Ltd costs in the amount of $5,148.59 within fourteen days. The proceeding against Jalfire Pty Ltd was dismissed, and PGC Holdings Pty Ltd was required to file and serve any further expert evidence limited to a geotechnical engineer report and a supplementary report by Benjamin Jones by a specified date. Higher Level Thinking Pty Ltd was required to provide access to its property for an inspection by a geotechnical engineer engaged by PGC Holdings Pty Ltd and to file and serve any further expert evidence limited to a report by an appropriately qualified engineer by a specified date. Additionally, no party, nor any expert engaged by a party, may rely upon or refer to any report by Jeffrey Hills & Associates filed in the proceeding, and the evidence given at the hearing on 2 March 2017 may not be relied upon by the parties and will not be considered by the Tribunal in any final decision.

In summary, the court held Jalfire Pty Ltd and Higher Level Thinking Pty Ltd liable for costs in respect of the conduct before Jalfire was joined, and the proceedings against Jalfire Pty Ltd were dismissed. The court also set out further directions for the parties to follow in the proceedings, including the submission of expert evidence and access to property for inspection.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Jalfire Pty Ltd and Higher Level Thinking Pty Ltd must each pay to PGC Holdings Pty Ltd costs in the amount of $5,148.59 within fourteen (14) days;

2. The proceeding against Jalfire Pty Ltd is otherwise dismissed;

3. PGC Holdings Pty Ltd must file and serve any further expert evidence limited to:

(a) A geotechnical engineer report;

(b) A supplementary report by Benjamin Jones, by: 4:00pm on 16 November 2018.

4. Higher Level Thinking Pty Ltd must provide such access to its property as may be required for the purpose of an inspection by a geotechnical engineer engaged by PGC Holdings Pty Ltd;

5. Higher level Thinking Pty Ltd must file and serve any further expert evidence limited to a report by an appropriately qualified engineer, by: 4:00pm on 14 December 2018.

6. No party, nor any expert engaged by a party, may rely upon or refer to any report by Jeffrey Hills & Associates filed in the proceeding;

7. The evidence given at the hearing on 2 March 2017 may not be relied upon by the parties and will not be considered by the Tribunal in any final decision;

8. The matter is listed for a Directions Hearing on a date to be advised;

9. The matter is listed for a two day Tribunal Hearing on a date to be advised.

Background

Background to the litigation

The following issues now fall for determination:(a)should there be an order in respect of the costs thrown of the experts’ conclave and the hearing?(b)what further directions should be made in the proceedings? Background The application for a tree dispute was filed by PGC on 22 December 2015. Jalfire’s response was filed on 17 February 2016. Jalfire engaged an expert engineer, Mr Jeffrey Hills. Mr Hills’ first report is dated 19 April 2016[2] and was filed in the tribunal attached as appendix ‘A’ to a more comprehensive report by Mr Hills dated 9 August 2016.[3] On 26 September 2016 the tribunal made directions listing the matter for an experts’ conclave on 16 December 2016 and for hearing on 2 March 2017. At the time the directions were made, the parties had filed their expert evidence. PGC had filed expert reports by Mr Benjamin Stone, an engineer and Mr Craig Reid, an arborist. Jalfire had filed the aforesaid expert reports by Mr Hills and a report by Mr John Prince, an arborist. The experts’ conclave, conducted on 16 December 2016, was attended by all of the experts. A joint report was subsequently prepared and filed in the tribunal.[4][2]Report prepared by Jeffrey Hills of Jeffrey Hills & Associates (Report No.1) dated 19 April 2016.[3]Report prepared by Jeffrey Hills of Jeffrey Hills & Associates (Report No.2) dated 9 August 2016.[4]Joint report filed 30 January 2017. Unbeknownst to PGC or the tribunal, and prior to the conclave, Jalfire transferred ownership of the land on which the trees had been situated to Higher Level Thinking Pty Ltd a company of which Mr Hills is a director, secretary and shareholder. [5] Higher Level Thinking holds the land in trust for Energy Assessor Pty Ltd as trustee for Jeffrey and Jennifer Hills Superannuation Fund.[6] There is no evidence before the Tribunal as to the identity of office bearers or shareholders of Energy Assessor Pty Ltd. The relevant trust deed is not before the Tribunal. The transfer was registered on 14 December 2016.[7] As I have noted, the experts’ conclave was held two days later on 16 December 2016. The hearing took place on 2 March 2017. Mr Hills gave evidence at the hearing as an expert witness. Neither Jalfire nor Mr Hills disclosed during the hearing that the property had been transferred to Higher Level Thinking or that Mr Hills thereby had an interest in the outcome of the proceeding as director of the registered owner of the land as trustee. Both Jalfire and Mr Hills had the opportunity to disclose the sale of the property and the role of Mr Hills in respect of the sale, through his involvement in Higher Level Thinking, and did not do so. These observations cannot be controversial having been the subject of findings by the tribunal. [5]Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) Current Organisation Extract dated 26 August 2017.[6]Enterprise Avenue Trust - Trust Deed dated 5 October 2016.[7]Historical title search dated 22 August 2017.The findings by the tribunal