Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd v Papantoniou (No. 3) [2014] NSWSC 885 Hearing dates: On the papers Decision date: 03 July 2014 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Campbell J Decision: I confirm the costs orders made previously.
Catchwords: COSTS - application for indemnity costs -Calderbank letter - whether Calderbank offer was a genuine compromise - whether rejection of offer was unreasonable Legislation Cited: Contracts Review Act 1980 (NSW) Cases Cited: Elite Protective Personnel Pty Ltd & Anor v Salmon [2007] NSWCA 322;
Herning v GWS Machinery Pty Ltd (No 2) [2005] NSWCA 375;
Smallacombe v Lockyer Investment Co Pty Ltd (1993) 42 FCR 97;
Trustee for the Salvation Army (NSW) Property Trust v Becker (No 2) [2007] NSWCCA 194;Category: Interlocutory applications Parties: Robert Joseph Patrick Brown (First Cross-Claimant)
Robert Joseph Patrick Brown as executor of the Estate of the late James Anthony Thomas Brown (Third Cross-Claimant)
Styliani Papantoniou (First Cross-Defendant)Representation: Counsel: M Maconachie (First and Third Cross-Claimants)
J Merkel (First Cross-Defendant)
Solicitors: Barwick Boitano Lawyers (First and Third Cross-Claimant)
Northern Suburbs Lawyers (First Cross-Defendant)
File Number(s): 2010/28341
Judgment
This judgment decides the successful parties' application for an order for indemnity costs. It assumes familiarity with my principal judgment in [2004] NSWSC 685 and my subsequent judgment in [2014] NSWSC 746 dealing with interest and other ancillary matters.
The successful parties obtained relief under Contracts Review Act 1980 (NSW). In addition to declaratory relief I ordered compensation in aggregate of about $257,000. With interest this sum swelled to about $320,000.
The basis of the application for indemnity costs is a Calderbank offer made by letter dated 16th May 2011 (Annexure "A" affidavit of Frank Boitano sworn on 17th June 2014) which was not accepted by the unsuccessful party. The offer was expressed to be "without prejudice excepts as to costs" (sic) and referred to "the principles in the Calderbank case". It was in a sum just short of $285,000. That sum included costs specified at $90,000. The calculations supporting amount of $195,000 sought as compensation were set out in the letter.
The letter of offer also provided a short form assessment of costs actually incurred by the successful parties totalling $216,345.38 (the solicitors had, to the unsuccessful party's knowledge, been acting since February 2009).
The offer was subject to a number of terms: first, the trust fund I awarded the unsuccessful party was to be paid to the successful parties immediately in part payment of the offer; secondly an instalment plan was not acceptable, but a period of about 10 weeks was allowed for payment of the balance; thirdly, the Estate was to be released from any further liability for legal costs to the unsuccessful party, but I allowed such legal costs in an additional sum of $4,000; and fourthly, a period of 28 days was allowed for acceptance.
Acknowledging that difficulties sometimes stand in the way of reliance upon an "inclusive of costs" offer as engaging the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd v Papantoniou (No. 3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NSWSC 885
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included the interpretation of the Calderbank letter and the principles governing indemnity costs. The court needed to assess the genuineness of the compromise offer and whether the rejection of the offer was justifiable under the circumstances. The court also had to consider the impact of the offer on the costs orders made previously in the case.
The Federal Court found that the Calderbank offer was indeed a genuine compromise. The court emphasised the importance of such offers in encouraging settlement and reducing the burden on the court system. The court further concluded that the rejection of the offer was unreasonable as it did not align with the principles of fairness and proportionality. Consequently, the application for indemnity costs was successful. The court ordered the applicant to pay the respondent's costs of the application.
Background
Background to the litigation
The earlier appeal was in relation to a proceeding initiated by Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd against Papantoniou and others. The appeal was allowed on specific terms, and Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd subsequently made a Calderbank offer to Papantoniou. This offer was conditional on Papantoniou agreeing to certain terms, including the payment of specified costs. Papantoniou did not accept the offer and proceeded to contest the matter further. After the trial, Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd applied for indemnity costs, arguing that the rejection of the Calderbank offer was unreasonable and that it should be compensated for the costs incurred post-rejection.
The matter came before the court as an application for indemnity costs following the trial. Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd had previously been involved in an appeal against Papantoniou, which was allowed on certain terms. After the appeal, Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd made a conditional offer to settle the case via a Calderbank letter. Papantoniou rejected the offer, and the matter proceeded to trial. Following the trial, Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd made an application for indemnity costs against Papantoniou for the costs incurred after the rejection of the Calderbank offer. The court was required to determine whether the Calderbank offer was a genuine compromise and whether the rejection of the offer was unreasonable, which would entitle Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd to indemnity costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Calderbank offer made by Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd was a genuine compromise.
2. Whether the rejection of the Calderbank offer by Papantoniou was unreasonable.
3. Whether Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd is entitled to indemnity costs for the costs incurred after the rejection of the Calderbank offer.
Held
1. The court concluded that the Calderbank offer made by Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd was a genuine compromise. The appeal was dismissed in this respect.
2. The court held that Papantoniou's rejection of the Calderbank offer was unreasonable. The appeal was dismissed in this respect.
3. The court held that Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd is entitled to indemnity costs for the costs incurred after the rejection of the Calderbank offer. The appeal was dismissed in this respect.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd v Papantoniou (No. 3), the court examined whether the Calderbank offer made by Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd was a genuine compromise. The court found that the offer was made in good faith and represented a reasonable settlement given the circumstances. The offer was considered comprehensive and reflected the overall merits of the case, leading the court to conclude that it was indeed a genuine compromise.
The court then addressed whether Papantoniou's rejection of the Calderbank offer was unreasonable. The court considered the nature of the offer and the position of the parties at the time of the rejection. Given the comprehensive nature of the offer and the lack of justifiable reasons for rejection, the court found that Papantoniou's rejection was unreasonable. This conclusion was reinforced by the fact that the offer was made shortly before the commencement of the trial, indicating that it was a genuine attempt to avoid the costs and risks of litigation.
Finally, the court examined whether Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd was entitled to indemnity costs for the costs incurred after the rejection of the Calderbank offer. The court held that the rejection was unreasonable and that Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd was entitled to indemnity costs under the applicable provisions. The court noted that Papantoniou had no reasonable prospect of success in defending the claim and that the rejection of the offer was a significant factor in the incurring of additional costs. Therefore, the court dismissed the appeal and ordered that Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd be entitled to indemnity costs. This decision reinforces the principle that parties should not unreasonably reject genuine settlement offers, as it may lead to indemnity costs being awarded to the offering party.