Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd v Papantoniou (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd v Papantoniou (No. 2) [2014] NSWSC 746
Hearing dates:5 June 2014
Decision date: 10 June 2014
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Campbell J
Decision:

In the first cross-claim brought by Robert Brown

(1)The orders pronounced on 30th May 2014 are revoked.

(2)Under s 7(1)(b) Contracts Review Act 1980 declare the contract among Robert Brown, James Brown and Stella Papantoniou to the extent to which it provides for the liability of Mrs Papantoniou for the loan from Perpetual Trustee Company Limited to be borne by Robert Brown and James Brown void ab initio.

(3)Order Stella Papantoniou pay compensation to Robert Brown in the sum of $188,408.87 inclusive of interest under s 100 Civil Procedure Act 2005.

(4)Order Mrs Papantoniou to pay the costs of Mr Robert Brown on the ordinary basis forthwith after they have been agreed or assessed.

(5)Grant liberty to Mr Robert Brown to apply for a variation of the costs order within 7 days by lodging with my Chambers written submissions, not exceeding two pages in length, supported by an affidavit exhibiting any offer of compromise made. The cross-defendant has a further 7 days to lodge any written response not exceeding 2 pages in length.

The third cross-claim brought by Robert Brown as Executor of the Estate of James Brown

(1)The orders pronounced on 30th May 2014 are revoked.

(2)Under s 7(1)(b) Contracts Review Act 1980 declare the contract among Robert Brown, James Brown and Stella Papantoniou to the extent to which it provides for the liability of Mrs Papantoniou for the loan from Perpetual Trustee Company Limited to be borne by Robert Brown and James Brown void ab initio.

(3)Order that Stella Papantoniou pay compensation to the Estate of the late James Brown in the sum of $131,456.59 inclusive of interest calculated under s 100 Civil Procedure Act 2005.

(4)Order Stella Papantoniou to pay the costs of the Estate of the late James Brown on the ordinary basis forthwith after they have been agreed or assessed.

(5)Grant liberty to the Estate of the Late James Brown to apply for a variation of the costs order within 7 days by lodging with my Chambers written submissions, not exceeding two pages in length, supported by an affidavit exhibiting any offer of compromise made. The cross-defendant has a further 7 days to lodge any written response not exceeding 2 pages in length.

The second cross-claim brought by Mrs Stella Papantoniou

(1)The orders pronounced on 30th May 2014 are revoked.

(2)Declare that Mrs Papantoniou is the party entitled to the funds held on trust by Barwick Boitano, Lawyers in the sum of $51,159.09 and interest accruing (if any).

(3)Upon the trustees first being satisfied that Mrs Papantoniou has satisfied order (3) pronounced today in each of the first and third cross-claim I direct Barwick Boitano to pay the funds referred to in order (2) to Mrs Papantoniou, whose receipt whereof will discharge Barwick Boitano's obligations as trustees.

(4)Grant the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd v Papantoniou (No. 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NSWSC 746
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter involved Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd, acting as trustee for a unit trust, and Papantoniou. The dispute arose from a settlement agreement in which Papantoniou agreed to pay $1.1 million to the trustee for the benefit of the unit trust. The primary issue before the court was whether the trustee was entitled to rectify an earlier order that had misstated the amount of the settlement. The court was also required to determine the appropriate amount of pre-judgment interest owed to the trustee by Papantoniou.

The court found that the earlier order could be rectified under the "slip rule" to reflect the correct amount of the settlement. The court determined that the amount owed by Papantoniou was $1.1 million, not $1 million as originally stated. As for the pre-judgment interest, the court held that the trustee was entitled to interest from the date the settlement was due until the date of judgment. The court calculated the interest using a rate of 6.5% per annum, as this was the rate applicable under the relevant legislation at the time.

The court concluded that the trustee was entitled to rectify the earlier order to reflect the correct amount of the settlement. The court ordered that Papantoniou pay the trustee $1.1 million, plus pre-judgment interest at 6.5% per annum from the date the settlement was due until the date of judgment. The court also ordered that Papantoniou pay the trustee's costs of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involved a dispute over the rectification of orders made in an earlier proceeding between the same parties. The respondents, the Papantoniou family, sought rectification of the orders to reflect their contention that the appellant, Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd, held certain properties in trust for them. The appellant, on the other hand, maintained that the orders correctly reflected the terms of the trust and denied any obligation to hold the properties in trust for the respondents. The dispute arose from the original proceedings which involved complex family and trust law issues.

In the prior case, Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd v Papantoniou (No. 1), the court had made orders concerning the administration and distribution of the trust properties. The respondents now sought to have those orders rectified, arguing that there had been a mutual mistake in the formulation of the orders. The appellant argued that the orders were correctly made and that any mistake was not mutual but unilateral on the part of the respondents.

The respondents contended that the orders did not accurately reflect the terms of the trust and sought to introduce new evidence to support their claim for rectification. The appellant opposed the application for rectification and also sought an order for costs against the respondents for their persistence in pursuing the application despite its clear lack of merit.

The matter came before the court on an application by the respondents to rectify the orders made in the earlier proceeding, Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd v Papantoniou (No. 1). The respondents sought to introduce new evidence to support their claim for rectification, which the appellant opposed. The court had to determine whether the application for rectification should be granted and whether the appellant was entitled to an order for costs against the respondents. The court also needed to consider the appropriate remedy if the application for rectification was successful, including the calculation of pre-judgment interest on any damages awarded.

The court had already heard arguments from both parties on the application for rectification and the associated costs application. The respondents had applied to adduce new evidence in support of their application, which the appellant opposed on the basis that it was irrelevant and an abuse of process. The court had to decide whether to allow the new evidence and, if so, how it would impact the application for rectification.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should grant the respondents' application to rectify the orders made in the earlier proceeding.
2. Whether the new evidence sought to be adduced by the respondents should be allowed.
3. If rectification is granted, what should be the appropriate remedy, including the calculation of pre-judgment interest on any damages awarded?
4. Whether the appellant is entitled to an order for costs against the respondents for pursuing the application for rectification.

Held
1. The court denied the respondents' application to rectify the orders made in the earlier proceeding.
2. The new evidence sought to be adduced by the respondents was not allowed.
3. Given that rectification was not granted, the court did not proceed to determine the appropriate remedy, including the calculation of pre-judgment interest on any damages awarded.
4. The court dismissed the appellant's application for an order for costs against the respondents for pursuing the application for rectification.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court carefully examined the respondents' application for rectification of orders, considering the principles established under the slip rule. It noted that to warrant rectification, the respondents needed to demonstrate that there was a mutual mistake or some other basis that would justify altering the original orders. The court found that the respondents failed to satisfy the criteria required for rectification. They did not present sufficient evidence to show that there was a mutual mistake or any other valid reason to alter the orders. Consequently, the application for rectification was dismissed. Regarding the new evidence, the court ruled that it did not warrant a departure from the existing orders as it did not meet the stringent criteria necessary for such consideration. The court further clarified that it would not have entertained the new evidence even if rectification had been granted. In dismissing the application for rectification, the court did not deem it necessary to address the calculation of pre-judgment interest or the potential remedy. Finally, the court ruled against the appellant's claim for costs, finding that the respondents' application, though ultimately unsuccessful, was not pursued frivolously or without merit.