Perosh and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Perosh and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 980 (23 April 2018)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/3838

Re:Peter Perosh

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Professor R McCallum AO, Member

Date:23 April 2018

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is varied as follows:

1) The taxi fares from Mr Peter Perosh’s home to the TAFE at St Leonards and return for the 31 weeks of the academic year is a reasonable and necessary support which is to be fully funded under the National Disability Insurance Scheme. 

2) The taxi fares from Mr Peter Perosh’s home to the gym in Castle Hill and return each week is a reasonable and necessary support which is to be fully funded under the National Disability Insurance Scheme. 

........................[sgd]............................................

Professor R McCallum AO, Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – applicant with cerebral palsy – reasonable and necessary supports – whether costs of transport to TAFE, the gym and outings is a reasonable and necessary support – whether supports should be fully funded – McGarrigle considered – decision under review varied

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) ss 3,4, 34(1), 100(6), 103, 209

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth) r 5.1, 2.10

CASES

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308

National Disability Insurance Agency v McGarrigle [2017] FCAFC 132

REASONS FOR DECISION

Professor R McCallum AO, Member

23 April 2018

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, Mr Peter Perosh is a young adult who lives with his parents and sister in a rural area of the Hills District in Sydney.

  2. Mr Peter Perosh has spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy.

  3. Dr Heather Burnett and Dr Mary-Clare Waugh from Westmead Children's Hospital wrote a report dated 11 April 2016. The doctors explain Mr Peter Perosh’s spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy. This report reads in part as follows:

    Peter … has spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy (GMFCS IV, MACS 2, CFCS II, FMS 2/1/I).       

    …

    He uses his walking frame at Conductive Education but has challenges in the home environment getting into it. He needs standby assistance to mobilize safely in his walker. He mostly uses his wheelchair for mobility.

    …

    He does require full assistance for activities of daily living, including toileting and dressing as well as bathing. He can perform some simple tasks around the home, such as getting out food so that someone can make a snack for him. Maria and Donna suspect that he could probably make himself a snack as well; however, he prefers to have this done for him. The family had home modifications completed in 2013 and the home is fully accessible for Peter in his wheelchair. This includes a fully accessible, 5m x 5m bathroom as well as an electronic change-table.

    …

    PHYSICAL EXAMINATION

    Height: 164.5 cm.

    Weight: 61.7 kg

    Peter was a pleasant and cooperative young man throughout today's consultation. His seated posture was slumped forward in the upper spine; however, he was easily able to lift his head…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perosh and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 980
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal concerning Mr Peter Perosh, a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS), and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The dispute centred on whether the costs associated with Mr Perosh's transport to TAFE, gym, and social outings constituted reasonable and necessary supports under the NDIS. Mr Perosh, who has cerebral palsy, sought funding for these transport expenses, which were primarily incurred through taxi fares, even after utilising a NSW taxi discount scheme.

The Tribunal was required to determine if the transport costs for Mr Perosh's attendance at TAFE, his physical therapy sessions at the gym, and his participation in weekly outings with his carer were reasonable and necessary supports. In making this determination, the Tribunal had to consider the criteria set out in section 34(1) of the NDIS Act, specifically paragraphs (c), (e), and (f), which relate to value for money, the reasonable expectations of families and the community, and whether the support is most appropriately funded by the NDIS. The Tribunal also had to consider the NDIA's position that such costs might relate to day-to-day living expenses not attributable to disability support needs.

The Tribunal's reasoning was significantly guided by the Federal Court's decision in *McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency* [2017] FCA 308. Following *McGarrigle*, the Tribunal adopted the principle that once a support is determined to be reasonable and necessary, it should be fully funded by the NDIS. The Tribunal found that Mr Perosh's transport needs met the criteria outlined in paragraphs (a), (b), and (d) of section 34(1) of the NDIS Act, as confirmed by the NDIA. Applying the *McGarrigle* precedent, the Tribunal concluded that the transport costs to TAFE and the gym were reasonable and necessary supports. The Tribunal also found that the proposed outings, while not yet undertaken, were reasonable aspirations for Mr Perosh.

Consequently, the Tribunal ordered that the decision under review be varied. The NDIA was required to fund the full costs of Mr Perosh's transport to TAFE and the gym, and to include funding for transport to enable him to participate in weekly outings with his carer. This outcome reflects the Tribunal's adherence to the principle of full funding for supports deemed reasonable and necessary under the NDIS.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Peter Perosh receives taxi discount vouchers under the NSW Taxi Transport Subsidy Scheme. My understanding is that the costs sought are the costs of the discounted taxi fares. I take the estimate of $100 per trip from Mr Peter Perosh’s home to the TAFE at St Leonards and return to be approximate costs. Obviously, taxi fares will vary having regard to traffic flows etc.THE EVIDENCE OF MRS MARIA PEROSH Mrs Maria Perosh who is Mr Peter Perosh’s Mother gave sworn evidence. Mrs Perosh explained that her son was born with cerebral palsy. Mrs Maria Perosh said that she currently works in information technology. Mrs Maria Perosh explained Mr Peter Perosh’s weekly timetable as follows:On Mondays – he leaves at 8:00am by taxi to attend TAFE at 9:00am. He finishes at 12:00pm. A taxi brings him home. He goes with his carer to TAFE, who helps, as Mrs Maria Perosh works full-time.On Tuesdays – a Physiotherapist comes to the house for a 1 hour treatment session. On Wednesdays – Mr Peter Perosh attends gym for a Physical therapy session for strengthening for thirty minutes. He travels to and from by taxi. On Thursdays – he leaves at 8:00am by taxi to attend TAFE at 9:00am. He finishes at 12:00pm. A taxi brings him home. On Fridays – there is a physiotherapist treatment session for another hour. He is with his carer for the rest of the day. Mrs Maria Perosh was asked how she paid for the taxi fares. She said that she has opened a cab charge account. Even with the NSW Taxi Transport Subsidy Scheme, she said she is out of pocket for $250 per week, this being the cost of the taxis to and from TAFE, and to and from the gym. Mrs Maria Perosh was asked about the public transport options. She said that they live in a rural part of the Hills District. There are no footpaths. This means that her son would have to go by wheelchair 500 metres on a gravel road to a bus stop. It was put to Mrs Maria Perosh that Mr Peter Perosh could catch a taxi to Pennant Hills Railway Station, then take a train to St Leonards and then an accessible bus to the TAFE. Mrs Maria Perosh said that this might take up to 1 hour and 30 minutes each way and that Mr Peter Perosh fatigues easily. Mrs Perosh said that she now works full-time from 9:00am to 5:00pm. However, she comes home by 3:00pm to relieve the carer and does the remainder of her work from home. Mrs Maria Perosh was asked whether the family could afford another vehicle in which to transport Mr Peter Perosh and his wheelchair. She explained that they could not afford this. Mrs Maria Perosh said that her husband was unemployed for six months last year. Mrs Maria Perosh was asked about the request for the transport costs to enable Mr Peter Perosh to go on weekly outings with his carer to Castle Hill. She said that he has not gone there yet. However, she said he would like to go to have lunch, to watch a movie or to do some shopping. Mrs Maria Perosh was asked how the family travelled to the Tribunal for the hearing. She said that they travelled in her four wheel drive (FWD) vehicle which can accommodate Mr Peter Perosh’s manual wheelchair. It cannot accommodate his electronic wheelchair.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr John Perosh said that he takes his son to swimming every Saturday afternoon. He added that he takes him to the shops after work on two or three evenings each week.THE MCGARRIGLE DECISIONS AND THE COST OF REASONABLE AND NECESSARY SUPPORTS To the best of my knowledge, this is the first occasion where this Tribunal has had to consider the decisions of the Federal Court of Australia concerning the costs of the transport components of participant plans which are reasonable and necessary supports under the NDIS. In McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308, Mortimer J sitting in the Federal Court of Australia held that in the matter before her the NDIA was required to pay for the full costs of transportation as set out in the participant plan. As I comprehend the judgment of Mortimer J, her Honour came to the view that once an item like transport was found to be a reasonable and necessary support in a participant plan, the NDIS was liable to pay for the full cost of the item. At paragraphs [93]-[95] of her judgment, Mortimer J stated as follows:93 In my opinion, the text and context of s 33(5)(c), read with s 34(1) indicates that the CEO (or the delegate or Tribunal) must either be satisfied that a support has the character of being a reasonable and necessary support, or that it does not. Once a support is identified and described (to take an example away from this case, speech therapy lessons three times a week), then the question for the CEO (or the delegate or Tribunal) is whether she or he is satisfied that support, as identified, is reasonable and necessary for that particular participant. It may be open to the CEO to be satisfied that a differently identified support is reasonable and necessary: in this example, speech therapy lessons once a week. That determination can only be made on the basis of probative evidence. The scheme contemplates full funding of reasonable and necessary supports94 Once a decision is made that the support, as identified and described, is reasonable and necessary, then subject to the other requirements in s 33(5) and s 34, the scheme requires and contemplates that support “will” be funded. In my opinion, that can only mean wholly or fully funded.95 The subject matter of the CEO’s approval in s 33(2)(b) is the reasonable and necessary supports that “will” be funded. The language is imperative, and in my opinion this is consistent with the applicant’s contention that the relevant gateway established by the legislative scheme is whether the support is “reasonable and necessary”, and once through that gateway, the scheme intends the support will be fully funded. There are no references in these provisions to “contributions” from the participant, the participants’ family or carers. I have explained, in my opinion, how s 34(1)(e) is intended to operate: that is, it is intended to operate at the stage of the CEO (or the delegate or Tribunal) forming a state of satisfaction about what are “reasonable and necessary supports”. It is not intended to ask the decision-maker to assess whether any of the persons in para (e) are capable, or willing, to make a financial contribution towards the proposed support. That is made especially clear by the inclusion in the list in para (e) of the “the community”. Parliament did not intend the decision-maker to ask, in forming a state of satisfaction, whether the community could or should make a financial contribution to the funding of a support found by the decision-maker to be reasonable and necessary in order for the participant to work towards the goals, objectives and aspirations set out in the participant’s plan.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Until otherwise guided by the courts, it is my view that the proper course for this Tribunal to take is to adhere to the holding by Mortimer J that once a support is held to be a reasonable and necessary support, it should be fully funded. As her Honour said in paragraph 95, “…[T]he relevant gateway established by the legislative scheme is whether the support is “reasonable and necessary”, and once through that gateway, the scheme intends the support will be fully funded.”CONSIDERATION I am required to determine whether the transport costs of Mr Peter Perosh attending the TAFE, going to the gym and going on outings are reasonable and necessary supports. If I find that any or all of these transport costs are reasonable and necessary supports, in accordance with Mortimer J’s holding I shall order that the NDIS is required to cover their full costs.The Section 34(1) Criteria Section 34(1) of the NDIS Act which has been quoted above, sets forth the criteria for determining whether or not a support is a reasonable and necessary support. Counsel for the Respondent confirmed what the Respondent had written in paragraph 4.3 of its Statement of Position. The Respondent is satisfied that the claim for increased transport costs meets the criteria set out in paragraphs (a), (b) and (d) of section 34(1) of the NDIS Act. Having regard to the evidence before the Tribunal, I find that Mr Peter Perosh’s claim does meet the criteria in these paragraphs. Therefore, I am required to decide whether the claim meets paragraphs (c), (e) and (f) of section 34(1) of the NDIS Act. For ease of comprehension I repeat these paragraphs as follows:(1) For the purposes of specifying, in a statement of participant supports, the general supports that will be provided, and the reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded, the CEO must be satisfied of all of the following in relation to the funding or provision of each such support:…(c) the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support;…(e) the funding or provision of the support takes account of what it is reasonable to expect families, carers, informal networks and the community to provide;(f) the support is most appropriately funded or provided through the National Disability Insurance Scheme, and is not more appropriately funded or provided through other general systems of service delivery or support services offered by a person, agency or body, or systems of service delivery or support services offered:(i) as part of a universal service obligation; or(ii) in accordance with reasonable adjustments required under a law dealing with discrimination on the basis of disability.The position of the Respondent The primary submission of the Respondent was founded on Rule 5.1(d) of the Support Rules. Rule 5.1(d) is as follows:General criteria for supports5.1 A support will not be provided or funded under the NDIS if:…(d) it relates to day-to-day living costs (for example, rent, groceries and utility fees) that are not attributable to a participant’s disability support needs.