David and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

David and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 2709 (8 August 2018)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/4858

Re:LUKE DAVID

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:SENIOR MEMBER R CAMERON

Date:8 August 2018

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides:

(a)That taxi fares for the trips described in the table in paragraph 16 of these reasons are reasonable and necessary supports to be funded under the NDIS; and

(b)That the participation fee and airplane tickets for a carer to attend interstate sports events with the Applicant twice a year are reasonable and necessary supports that are to be funded under the NDIS.

................[sgd]........................................................

SENIOR MEMBER R CAMERON

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – applicant with Nemaline Myopathy – whether cost of transport reasonable and necessary support – object of NDIS – cost of airplane tickets for carer to attend sporting events – cost of taxis to visit friends and family

Legislation

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)

Cases

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308

National Disability Insurance Agency v McGarrigle [2017] FACFC 132

RePerosh and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 980

Secondary Materials

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

REASONS FOR DECISION

SENIOR MEMBER R CAMERON

8 August 2018

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application by Luke David for a review of a decision made on 18 July 2017, following an internal review by a delegate of the Chief Executive Officer of the Respondent not to include further funding in his then applicable National Disability Insurance Scheme (“NDIS”) plan for gymnasium membership[1], support worker accommodation and flight costs, Victorian Electric Wheelchair Sports Association membership fees and interstate participation fees. (“the reviewable decision”)

    [1] The issue of gymnasium membership was not ultimately canvassed during the hearing and the Applicant in his Synopsis of Final Contentions did not pursue this part of the matter. He only pursued two categories of claim: The taxi fares and participation fee and airplane tickets for a carer to attend interstate sports events. See Part B of the Applicant’s Synopsis of Final Contentions at paragraph 3. The Respondent’s Synopsis proceeded on the same footing.

    THE EVIDENCE AND MATERIALS BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL

  2. There was both documentary and viva voce evidence before the Tribunal at the hearing of this matter.

  3. The evidence adduced was as follows:

    (a)The Applicant by witness statement and in the witness box;

    (b)The Applicant’s mother by witness statement and in the witness box;

    (c)Reece Miller by witness statement and in the witness box;

    (d)Wendy Chandler, occupational therapist, with a report dated 16 April 2018 and in the witness box;

    (e)Melanie Holmes, occupational therapist, with a report and in the witness box;

    (f)The T documents;

    (g)The Supplementary T documents; and

    (h)A further bundle of documents consisting of the Applicant’s estimated taxi costs, Applicant’s estimated travel costs by taxi versus LINK, Qantas Disability Access Facilitation Plan, Yooralla’s Ventilator Accommodation Support Service,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read David and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 2709
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a dispute between Mr David, an applicant with Nemaline Myopathy, and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). Mr David requires 24-hour ventilation due to his severe and progressive muscle disorder, is wheelchair-bound, and dependent on others for all care. The core of the dispute concerned whether certain costs associated with his care and participation in life were reasonable and necessary supports to be funded under the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS).

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the cost of airplane tickets for a carer to accompany Mr David to interstate sporting events twice a year, and the cost of taxis for him to visit friends and family, constituted reasonable and necessary supports under the NDIS Act 2013. This involved assessing the object of the NDIS against the specific circumstances of Mr David's complex medical needs, including his respiratory failure, thermoregulatory difficulties, and physical dependence.

The Tribunal reasoned that the object of the NDIS is to provide reasonable and necessary supports to participants to enable them to live a life that includes community participation and social and economic participation. Applying this principle, the Tribunal accepted that taxi fares for specific trips to visit friends and family were reasonable and necessary supports, acknowledging the applicant's need for assistance with transport. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that the participation fees and airplane tickets for a carer to attend interstate sporting events with Mr David twice a year were also reasonable and necessary supports. The Tribunal's decision was to set aside the NDIA's previous decision and substitute it with orders that these specified transport costs and carer attendance at sporting events be funded under the NDIS.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Each party also submitted to the Tribunal Statements of Facts, Issues and Contentions and a Synopsis of Final Contentions.SOME RELEVANT FACTS CONCERNING THE APPLICANT The Applicant’s NDIS plan was made under the provisions of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (“the Act”). Mr David was born on 23 February 1992. He suffers from a condition known as Nemaline Myopathy. This condition is a disorder of the muscle which leads to severe muscle weakness and respiratory failure. Consequently, he requires the use of a ventilator 24 hours a day. The condition is described as a severe and progressive disorder which is lifelong in nature.[2] He is wheelchair-bound and dependent on others to provide him with all necessary care for his needs. Currently, he lives in the family home with his mother.[2] Medical opinions concerning his condition were provided to the Tribunal and in evidence from Associate Professor Andrew Kornberg, a Consultant Neurologist at St Vincent's Hospital Melbourne, (document T 11 of the T documents), Dr Gayathiri Wang of the Respiratory and Sleep Medicine section of the Austin Hospital, (document T 9 of the T documents) and Dr Claire Kembry (an attachment to the Applicant’s witness statement). The effects of this condition are such that the Applicant requires assistance with dressing, showering and toileting. When showering he is required to shower with his ventilator functioning and is only able to remove the ventilator facemask for very short periods during the shower or when shaving or otherwise cleaning such equipment. He cannot cook or prepare food for himself. Another issue that arises from his condition is what has been described in some of the material as “thermoregulatory difficulties.” This is sometimes described as “temperature control” in the material and is particularly difficult for him during the colder months. Even in the warmer months, he is prone to feeling cold and it requires him to wear reasonably warm clothing at all times but in particular when he travels outdoors.[3] The effects of coldness become more pronounced if he has to wait for extended periods for whatever reason. Similarly, extreme heat is also a problem for the Applicant and he is more susceptible to heatstroke than a normal person on days of high temperature. [3] The Applicant even gave evidence that temperatures below 24° can still cause him to become quite cold. Some of the measures that he has to take to keep warm include wearing thermal pants, two pairs of socks, carrying heavy bags and on really cold days putting more clothes on. When it is really cold he has no option but to remain indoors. It is fair to say from the evidence that maintaining a consistent body temperature in a variety of settings for the Applicant is a constant challenge. His torso is considerably deformed[4] and weak by reason of the illness, such that it requires mechanical support for him to sit upright, usually with assistance of weight bearing through his right arm. This has the unfortunate side-effect of impairing the use of his right hand somewhat.[4] His wheelchair has a customised seat mould to provide optimal support, comfort, respiratory function and pressure care, for his torso and compromised respiratory function.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Applying a similar rationale, the Tribunal accepts that a support worker’s participation fees is a reasonable and necessary support. However, the Respondent’s contention that carer’s meals should not be funded is fairly made and the Tribunal therefore considers that they should not be allowed.CONCLUSION By reason of the foregoing matters, the decision under review will be set aside. The Tribunal considers that the correct and preferable decision is that the following orders be made:(c)That taxi fares for the trips described in the table in paragraph 16 of these reasons are reasonable and necessary supports to be funded under the NDIS; and(d)That the participation fee and airplane tickets for a carer to attend interstate sports events with the Applicant twice a year are reasonable and necessary supports that are to be funded under the NDIS. The Tribunal grants liberty to the parties to apply should there be any questions or further directions required concerning the terms of these orders or any further orders that may be made.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established