[2009] QDC 259
DISTRICT COURT
CIVIL JURISDICTION
JUDGE ROBIN QC
No 3557 of 2008
| PEPPER FINANCE CORPORATION LIMITED (ACN 094 317 647) | Plaintiff |
| and | |
| SIOSIFA MAFI FATAFEHI | Defendant |
BRISBANE
..DATE 29/06/2009
ORDER
CATCHWORDS: District Court of Queensland Act 1967 s 68(3)(b) - Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 292, r 295(1) - mortgagor's application for summary judgment for recovery of possession - mortgage debt exceeded court's monetary jurisdiction, but was not claimed - Valuer General's valuation of mortgaged property fell within relevant monetary limit although market value did not - adjournment granted with direction calculated to assist the parties to agree on the state of accounts between them (which might assist the defendant to formulate a proposal to liquidate arrears) - leave to adduce oral evidence by the defendant not granted
HIS HONOUR: There is a summary judgment application before the Court. The plaintiff/applicant seeks to recover possession of the defendant's residential property, without any claim for a money judgment.
The circumstances are similar in that way to an application which came before me last Friday in BD3558 of 2008, Pepper Finance Corporation Limited v VG Products Pty Ltd.
The reasons given on that occasion explain the way in which the plaintiff is proceeding. It is probably necessary again today to dispose of the contention in the defence which may be setting up that the Court lacks jurisdiction on the basis that the value of the property at the time of purchase by the defendant was $365,000.
If the Court has no jurisdiction in respect of the claim, given the value of the property sought to be brought into the plaintiff's possession, the Court cannot make any orders today.
However, the material before the Court indicates that the Valuer General's valuation for the property, which is the pertinent one, is within the $250,000 limit. See s 68(3)(b) of the District Court of Queensland Act 1967.
It is immaterial that according to the statement of the defendant's account, Exhibit C to the affidavit of Ms Nguyen, the balance of that account may be $258,102.67, as at 12th of May 2009, which exceeds the monetary jurisdiction. There is simply no money claim before the Court. The plaintiff intends to resort to its contractual remedies, presumably centering on exercise of power of sale, to obtain satisfaction.
The defendant is in Court, represented by his solicitor,
Mr Johnson, seeking an adjournment of the application for three months. That is an unusually long period. It is not unusual that it is being sought. Mr Johnson tells the Court that his client has to look after six children and that the relevant property is their home.
It is hoped that in the three months the defendant will get matters in order. That is unlikely on the face of it, as the plaintiff has, following the defendant's asserted non compliance with a notice of default given last year, when the three monthly payments were in arrears, elected to require payment of the whole of the secured indebtedness.
The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Pepper Finance Corporation Ltd v. Fatafehi and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] QDC 259
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether it had jurisdiction to hear the case and, if so, whether to grant the defendant's request for an adjournment of the application for summary judgment for three months. The court also had to consider whether to grant the defendant leave to adduce oral evidence. The court found that there was no entitlement to an adjournment of the duration sought by the defendant's solicitor. The court did not grant the defendant leave to adduce oral evidence as it would have taken the plaintiff by surprise and required an adjournment to obtain instructions, so that he could cross-examine.
The court reasoned that the defendant's approach of attempting to repair the situation by making the aggregate of monthly payments which he ought to have may not resolve the situation. The court also noted that there were many instances of charges being made, such as dishonour fees, following dishonoured payments, and there were default interest charges in escalating amounts, arrears management fees, "Agent costs", legal costs, and some fairly large charges for "Completion Fee" and "Title Insurance". The court directed that the plaintiff provide the defendant with an up-to-date statement of account and that the defendant provide the plaintiff with the complete material he wished to rely on in defence of the application. The court also reserved consideration of the plaintiff's application for costs wasted by the adjournment.
The court ordered that the application for summary judgment be adjourned to the 13th of July 2009. Within four business days of the plaintiff providing to the defendant's solicitors a statement bringing up-to-date the statement Exhibit C to the affidavit of Florence Nguyen regarding the defendant's account, or by the 6th of July 2009, whichever was the later, the defendant must provide the plaintiff's solicitors with the complete material he wished to rely on in defence of the application. The plaintiff was to provide any further material it wished to rely on by 9 July 2009. The court also reserved consideration of the plaintiff's application for costs wasted by the adjournment and granted liberty to apply.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi