Details
- Case
- [2022] FedCFamC2G 637
- Decision Date
-
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The case of Pena v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs concerns a Colombian citizen, Ms Pena, who arrived in Australia on a tourist visa and subsequently applied for a student visa with her husband and daughter. The applicants' student visa application was refused by the Delegate, and the Tribunal was tasked with reviewing this decision. The central legal issue was whether Ms Pena met the genuine temporary entrant criterion for a student visa, specifically whether she intended to return to Colombia at the end of her stay in Australia. The Tribunal examined various factors, including Ms Pena's family ties in Australia and Colombia, her employment history, and her reasons for studying in Australia.
The Tribunal found several factors weighed against Ms Pena's claim. Firstly, it noted that Ms Pena's immediate family members were already residing in Australia, which could incentivise her to remain in the country. Secondly, the Tribunal was concerned about the timing of the student visa application, which was lodged just before the tourist visa was set to expire, suggesting a lack of genuine intention to return to Colombia. Additionally, the Tribunal found that Ms Pena had a stable job and income in Colombia, which raised doubts about her genuine intention to study in Australia. The Tribunal also questioned the practical value of the proposed vocational course, given Ms Pena's extensive prior work experience.
Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that Ms Pena did not meet the genuine temporary entrant criterion and affirmed the Delegate's decision to refuse the student visa application. The Tribunal was not satisfied that Ms Pena intended to return to Colombia at the end of her stay and found that she did not meet the requirements under cl 500.212(a) of the Migration Regulations. The decision highlights the importance of demonstrating genuine intent to return to one's home country as part of the student visa application process.
Background
Background to the litigation
At hearing:(a)the Court Book (“CB”) was marked as Exhibit 1;(b)a copy of the ANZSCO Classification of Occupations for Unit Group 1341 (“ANZSCO Classification of Occupations”) was marked as Exhibit 2; and(c)two affidavits of the applicants’ lawyer Ms Frankel were read.BACKGROUND PRIOR TO THE TRIBUNAL DECISION The background to this matter prior to the Tribunal Decision is as follows:(a)Ms Pena is a citizen of Colombia who first arrived in Australia on a visitor (Class FA) (subclass 600) visa on 3 December 2018 (“Tourist Visa”). Ms Pena was joined by her teenage daughter, Ms Pedraza;(b)Ms Pena’s husband, Mr Pascuas, had been granted a Student Visa on 22 June 2018 and subsequently arrived in Australia to commence studying;(c)on 28 February 2019 Ms Pena, Ms Pedraza and Mr Pascuas lodged a combined application for the Student Visa;(d)on 12 April 2019 the Delegate contacted the applicants’ lawyer requesting further information (“Request”) in relation to the genuine temporary entrant criterion for the Student Visa, requesting a response within 28 days;(e)on 9 May 2019 Ms Pena responded to the Request, supplying supporting documents and a statement addressing the genuine temporary entrant criterion;(f)on 28 May 2019 the Delegate’s Decision was to refuse the applicants’ Student Visa application. Mr Pascuas and Ms Pedraza were refused on the basis that they failed to meet the secondary criteria for grant of a Student Visa as their Student Visa status was reliant upon the Student Visa status of Ms Pena;(g)on 12 June 2019 the applicants applied to the Tribunal for review of the Delegate’s Decision (“Tribunal Application”): CB 121-123;(h)on 5 December 2019 the applicants provided information and documents to the Tribunal, including a confirmation of enrolment, in support of the Tribunal Application: CB 136-148;(i)on 1 July 2020 the applicants provided further documents and submissions to the Tribunal in support of the Tribunal Application; and(j)on 9 July 2020 Ms Pena and Mr Pascuas attended a hearing before the Tribunal (“Tribunal Hearing”), at which they were assisted by a Spanish interpreter: CB 233 at [6].TRIBUNAL DECISION On 7 October 2020 the Tribunal Decision affirmed the Delegate’s Decision: CB 232-237. In the Tribunal Decision the Tribunal:(a)summarised the applicants’ migration history: CB 235-236 at [27]-[28] and [33];(b)identified the material before it, including the Delegate’s Decision and other documents, such as current certificates of enrolment, passports and enrolment status documents: CB 233 at [5];(c)set out the background to the matter and the applicants’ submissions as set out in their written evidence and as stated in their sworn evidence to the Tribunal: CB 235 at [18] and [22];(d)provided a detailed summary of the applicants’ evidence given during the Tribunal Hearing: CB 235-236 at [23]-[38];(e)provided a summary of the country information which it had considered: CB 236 at [39]-[40];(f)found that:(i)the fact that Ms Pena’s immediate family, Mr Pascuas, Ms Pedraza and Ms Pena’s brother are all residing in Australia serves as a significant incentive for her to wish to remain living in Australia;(ii)the fact that Ms Pena’s parents remain in Colombia might serve as an incentive for her to go back to Colombia; and (iii)found that the family members who are presently in Australia are the closest to her, and therefore placed significant weight on that fact as evidence of a concern that the applicants may not wish to depart Australia at the end of their stay: CB 234-235 at [17];(g)noted that Ms Pena had purchased an apartment in Colombia around seven years ago, and considered the fact that she does have some financial ties to Colombia and weighed those facts in favour of the applicants’ case: CB 235 at [20]; (h)found that Ms Pena had studied at university level and had obtained a Bachelor’s degree in Spanish and in English but was now seeking to study at a vocational level: CB 235 at [21];(i)found that Ms Pena had experience in the workforce as explained in her written evidence, largely in an assistant role and that this work experience was in a field inconsistent with her current studies: CB 235 at [22];(j)found that Ms Pena had considerable work experience and was earning a reasonable income in Colombia when she gave up her long-standing employment in Colombia and decided to study in Australia whilst on a Tourist visa, and therefore further found that she may not have had the right intention when applying for a Tourist visa and that this caused the Tribunal some concern: CB 235 at [22];(k)noted that the fact Mr Pascuas was already in Australia on a Student Visa caused it some concern about the sincerity of Ms Pena’s application to study in Australia: CB 235 at [23]; (l)noted that Ms Pena was travelling with Mr Pascuas on a Visitor visa when Ms Pedraza was at an age where she would be impacted by the loss of her friendship groups by being uprooted from her school, and observed that it seemed odd to the Tribunal that a decision was made to stay in Australia and to not allow Ms Pedraza to finish her schooling in Colombia: CB 235 at [24];(m)observed that it seemed that there must have been a pre-conceived plan for the family to move to Australia, and that it seemed odd that the applicants would give up their jobs, lifestyle and friends to travel to a foreign country just to allow Ms Pena to study on a temporary visa: CB 235 at [24];(n)noted that when Ms Pena was asked whether Ms Pedraza was pleased with the change requiring Ms Pedraza to leave all her friends behind, Ms Pena said that “she was ok with that” and that Ms Pedraza was looking forward to the opportunity to meet new friends: CB 235 at [25];(o)said that it expected there must have been a plan before travelling to Australia as the applicants did not return to Colombia to sort out their financial affairs after they arrived in Australia: CB 235 at [26];(p)found that all the parties were inconvenienced by the change of plan and the cost involved in settling down in Australia: CB 235 at [27];(q)found that the application for a Student Visa was made in February 2019 just prior to the time that the Visitor Visa would have expired on 4 May 2019: CB 235 at [28];(r)did not accept the evidence of the applicants that they travelled to Australia and that Ms Pena decided she would study to improve her work prospects as Ms Pena was in a long-standing occupation with a steady job of seven years: CB 236 at [29];(s)that Ms Pena was “now proposing to study a Diploma in Child Care”: CB 236 at [30];(t)having regard to Ms Pena’s circumstances and where she is at in her career, was not satisfied that the study proposed would assist her in the future to improve her employment prospects in her home country or a third country. The Tribunal considered the vocational course proposed to be of marginal value to someone with Ms Pena’s many years of experience: CB 236 at [31];(u)found there was a lack of evidence provided to the Tribunal and no adequate explanation about the reality of opening a child care centre in Colombia, and that if Ms Pena was seriously contemplating opening a child care centre in Bogota she would have had a more defined plan, and did not accept that the course were going to add value to Ms Pena’s prospects of getting employment in the future in Colombia as Ms Pena had not provided any convincing evidence to the Tribunal as to how she planned to implement the plan: CB 236 at [32];(v)Ms Pena had travelled elsewhere internationally and stated she had not been refused a visa from any other country, a fact to which the Tribunal attached some weight in her favour on the basis that she had complied with the migration laws of other countries: CB 236 at [33];(w)noted that Ms Pena had said that in spite of the fact that she studied English in Colombia she did not feel confident with her English skills in Australia as the previous studies were taught by Colombians and it was quite difficult for her to improve her skills, her accent and to practice English, and the Tribunal found that it could not make a finding about whether Ms Pena’s career will improve in Colombia by reason of the fact that she has studied in English in Australia: CB 236 at [35];(x)took into consideration that Ms Pena did study English at a university in Colombia and that she had a prior interest in the subject, so that it was plausible that she would wish to update her skills in Australia and immerse herself in speaking English on a daily basis, and placed some weight in favour of her case based on these facts: CB 236 at [36];(y)did not accept as fact Ms Pena’s statement that she planned to return to Colombia as she had everything in her own country and that she did not plan to stay in Australia as she has her friends, her culture and a job to go back to, because the applicants have not returned to Colombia since their arrival in Australia: CB 236 at [38]; and(z)found it was not satisfied that Ms Pena intended to genuinely stay in Australia temporarily and that she did not meet cl 500.212(a) of Sch 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (“Migration Regulations”): CB 237 at [42], and that the criteria for the grant of the Student Visa was therefore not met: CB 237 at [43], and therefore affirmed the Delegate’s Decision: CB 237 at [44].CONSIDERATION The requirement for jurisdictional error
Decision
Reasons for decision
The background to this matter prior to the Tribunal Decision is as follows:(a)Ms Pena is a citizen of Colombia who first arrived in Australia on a visitor (Class FA) (subclass 600) visa on 3 December 2018 (“Tourist Visa”). Ms Pena was joined by her teenage daughter, Ms Pedraza;(b)Ms Pena’s husband, Mr Pascuas, had been granted a Student Visa on 22 June 2018 and subsequently arrived in Australia to commence studying;(c)on 28 February 2019 Ms Pena, Ms Pedraza and Mr Pascuas lodged a combined application for the Student Visa;(d)on 12 April 2019 the Delegate contacted the applicants’ lawyer requesting further information (“Request”) in relation to the genuine temporary entrant criterion for the Student Visa, requesting a response within 28 days;(e)on 9 May 2019 Ms Pena responded to the Request, supplying supporting documents and a statement addressing the genuine temporary entrant criterion;(f)on 28 May 2019 the Delegate’s Decision was to refuse the applicants’ Student Visa application. Mr Pascuas and Ms Pedraza were refused on the basis that they failed to meet the secondary criteria for grant of a Student Visa as their Student Visa status was reliant upon the Student Visa status of Ms Pena;(g)on 12 June 2019 the applicants applied to the Tribunal for review of the Delegate’s Decision (“Tribunal Application”): CB 121-123;(h)on 5 December 2019 the applicants provided information and documents to the Tribunal, including a confirmation of enrolment, in support of the Tribunal Application: CB 136-148;(i)on 1 July 2020 the applicants provided further documents and submissions to the Tribunal in support of the Tribunal Application; and(j)on 9 July 2020 Ms Pena and Mr Pascuas attended a hearing before the Tribunal (“Tribunal Hearing”), at which they were assisted by a Spanish interpreter: CB 233 at [6].TRIBUNAL DECISION On 7 October 2020 the Tribunal Decision affirmed the Delegate’s Decision: CB 232-237. In the Tribunal Decision the Tribunal:(a)summarised the applicants’ migration history: CB 235-236 at [27]-[28] and [33];(b)identified the material before it, including the Delegate’s Decision and other documents, such as current certificates of enrolment, passports and enrolment status documents: CB 233 at [5];(c)set out the background to the matter and the applicants’ submissions as set out in their written evidence and as stated in their sworn evidence to the Tribunal: CB 235 at [18] and [22];(d)provided a detailed summary of the applicants’ evidence given during the Tribunal Hearing: CB 235-236 at [23]-[38];(e)provided a summary of the country information which it had considered: CB 236 at [39]-[40];(f)found that:(i)the fact that Ms Pena’s immediate family, Mr Pascuas, Ms Pedraza and Ms Pena’s brother are all residing in Australia serves as a significant incentive for her to wish to remain living in Australia;(ii)the fact that Ms Pena’s parents remain in Colombia might serve as an incentive for her to go back to Colombia; and (iii)found that the family members who are presently in Australia are the closest to her, and therefore placed significant weight on that fact as evidence of a concern that the applicants may not wish to depart Australia at the end of their stay: CB 234-235 at [17];(g)noted that Ms Pena had purchased an apartment in Colombia around seven years ago, and considered the fact that she does have some financial ties to Colombia and weighed those facts in favour of the applicants’ case: CB 235 at [20]; (h)found that Ms Pena had studied at university level and had obtained a Bachelor’s degree in Spanish and in English but was now seeking to study at a vocational level: CB 235 at [21];(i)found that Ms Pena had experience in the workforce as explained in her written evidence, largely in an assistant role and that this work experience was in a field inconsistent with her current studies: CB 235 at [22];(j)found that Ms Pena had considerable work experience and was earning a reasonable income in Colombia when she gave up her long-standing employment in Colombia and decided to study in Australia whilst on a Tourist visa, and therefore further found that she may not have had the right intention when applying for a Tourist visa and that this caused the Tribunal some concern: CB 235 at [22];(k)noted that the fact Mr Pascuas was already in Australia on a Student Visa caused it some concern about the sincerity of Ms Pena’s application to study in Australia: CB 235 at [23]; (l)noted that Ms Pena was travelling with Mr Pascuas on a Visitor visa when Ms Pedraza was at an age where she would be impacted by the loss of her friendship groups by being uprooted from her school, and observed that it seemed odd to the Tribunal that a decision was made to stay in Australia and to not allow Ms Pedraza to finish her schooling in Colombia: CB 235 at [24];(m)observed that it seemed that there must have been a pre-conceived plan for the family to move to Australia, and that it seemed odd that the applicants would give up their jobs, lifestyle and friends to travel to a foreign country just to allow Ms Pena to study on a temporary visa: CB 235 at [24];(n)noted that when Ms Pena was asked whether Ms Pedraza was pleased with the change requiring Ms Pedraza to leave all her friends behind, Ms Pena said that “she was ok with that” and that Ms Pedraza was looking forward to the opportunity to meet new friends: CB 235 at [25];(o)said that it expected there must have been a plan before travelling to Australia as the applicants did not return to Colombia to sort out their financial affairs after they arrived in Australia: CB 235 at [26];(p)found that all the parties were inconvenienced by the change of plan and the cost involved in settling down in Australia: CB 235 at [27];(q)found that the application for a Student Visa was made in February 2019 just prior to the time that the Visitor Visa would have expired on 4 May 2019: CB 235 at [28];(r)did not accept the evidence of the applicants that they travelled to Australia and that Ms Pena decided she would study to improve her work prospects as Ms Pena was in a long-standing occupation with a steady job of seven years: CB 236 at [29];(s)that Ms Pena was “now proposing to study a Diploma in Child Care”: CB 236 at [30];(t)having regard to Ms Pena’s circumstances and where she is at in her career, was not satisfied that the study proposed would assist her in the future to improve her employment prospects in her home country or a third country. The Tribunal considered the vocational course proposed to be of marginal value to someone with Ms Pena’s many years of experience: CB 236 at [31];(u)found there was a lack of evidence provided to the Tribunal and no adequate explanation about the reality of opening a child care centre in Colombia, and that if Ms Pena was seriously contemplating opening a child care centre in Bogota she would have had a more defined plan, and did not accept that the course were going to add value to Ms Pena’s prospects of getting employment in the future in Colombia as Ms Pena had not provided any convincing evidence to the Tribunal as to how she planned to implement the plan: CB 236 at [32];(v)Ms Pena had travelled elsewhere internationally and stated she had not been refused a visa from any other country, a fact to which the Tribunal attached some weight in her favour on the basis that she had complied with the migration laws of other countries: CB 236 at [33];(w)noted that Ms Pena had said that in spite of the fact that she studied English in Colombia she did not feel confident with her English skills in Australia as the previous studies were taught by Colombians and it was quite difficult for her to improve her skills, her accent and to practice English, and the Tribunal found that it could not make a finding about whether Ms Pena’s career will improve in Colombia by reason of the fact that she has studied in English in Australia: CB 236 at [35];(x)took into consideration that Ms Pena did study English at a university in Colombia and that she had a prior interest in the subject, so that it was plausible that she would wish to update her skills in Australia and immerse herself in speaking English on a daily basis, and placed some weight in favour of her case based on these facts: CB 236 at [36];(y)did not accept as fact Ms Pena’s statement that she planned to return to Colombia as she had everything in her own country and that she did not plan to stay in Australia as she has her friends, her culture and a job to go back to, because the applicants have not returned to Colombia since their arrival in Australia: CB 236 at [38]; and(z)found it was not satisfied that Ms Pena intended to genuinely stay in Australia temporarily and that she did not meet cl 500.212(a) of Sch 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (“Migration Regulations”): CB 237 at [42], and that the criteria for the grant of the Student Visa was therefore not met: CB 237 at [43], and therefore affirmed the Delegate’s Decision: CB 237 at [44].CONSIDERATION The requirement for jurisdictional error
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the Tribunal Decision the Tribunal:(a)summarised the applicants’ migration history: CB 235-236 at [27]-[28] and [33];(b)identified the material before it, including the Delegate’s Decision and other documents, such as current certificates of enrolment, passports and enrolment status documents: CB 233 at [5];(c)set out the background to the matter and the applicants’ submissions as set out in their written evidence and as stated in their sworn evidence to the Tribunal: CB 235 at [18] and [22];(d)provided a detailed summary of the applicants’ evidence given during the Tribunal Hearing: CB 235-236 at [23]-[38];(e)provided a summary of the country information which it had considered: CB 236 at [39]-[40];(f)found that:(i)the fact that Ms Pena’s immediate family, Mr Pascuas, Ms Pedraza and Ms Pena’s brother are all residing in Australia serves as a significant incentive for her to wish to remain living in Australia;(ii)the fact that Ms Pena’s parents remain in Colombia might serve as an incentive for her to go back to Colombia; and (iii)found that the family members who are presently in Australia are the closest to her, and therefore placed significant weight on that fact as evidence of a concern that the applicants may not wish to depart Australia at the end of their stay: CB 234-235 at [17];(g)noted that Ms Pena had purchased an apartment in Colombia around seven years ago, and considered the fact that she does have some financial ties to Colombia and weighed those facts in favour of the applicants’ case: CB 235 at [20]; (h)found that Ms Pena had studied at university level and had obtained a Bachelor’s degree in Spanish and in English but was now seeking to study at a vocational level: CB 235 at [21];(i)found that Ms Pena had experience in the workforce as explained in her written evidence, largely in an assistant role and that this work experience was in a field inconsistent with her current studies: CB 235 at [22];(j)found that Ms Pena had considerable work experience and was earning a reasonable income in Colombia when she gave up her long-standing employment in Colombia and decided to study in Australia whilst on a Tourist visa, and therefore further found that she may not have had the right intention when applying for a Tourist visa and that this caused the Tribunal some concern: CB 235 at [22];(k)noted that the fact Mr Pascuas was already in Australia on a Student Visa caused it some concern about the sincerity of Ms Pena’s application to study in Australia: CB 235 at [23]; (l)noted that Ms Pena was travelling with Mr Pascuas on a Visitor visa when Ms Pedraza was at an age where she would be impacted by the loss of her friendship groups by being uprooted from her school, and observed that it seemed odd to the Tribunal that a decision was made to stay in Australia and to not allow Ms Pedraza to finish her schooling in Colombia: CB 235 at [24];(m)observed that it seemed that there must have been a pre-conceived plan for the family to move to Australia, and that it seemed odd that the applicants would give up their jobs, lifestyle and friends to travel to a foreign country just to allow Ms Pena to study on a temporary visa: CB 235 at [24];(n)noted that when Ms Pena was asked whether Ms Pedraza was pleased with the change requiring Ms Pedraza to leave all her friends behind, Ms Pena said that “she was ok with that” and that Ms Pedraza was looking forward to the opportunity to meet new friends: CB 235 at [25];(o)said that it expected there must have been a plan before travelling to Australia as the applicants did not return to Colombia to sort out their financial affairs after they arrived in Australia: CB 235 at [26];(p)found that all the parties were inconvenienced by the change of plan and the cost involved in settling down in Australia: CB 235 at [27];(q)found that the application for a Student Visa was made in February 2019 just prior to the time that the Visitor Visa would have expired on 4 May 2019: CB 235 at [28];(r)did not accept the evidence of the applicants that they travelled to Australia and that Ms Pena decided she would study to improve her work prospects as Ms Pena was in a long-standing occupation with a steady job of seven years: CB 236 at [29];(s)that Ms Pena was “now proposing to study a Diploma in Child Care”: CB 236 at [30];(t)having regard to Ms Pena’s circumstances and where she is at in her career, was not satisfied that the study proposed would assist her in the future to improve her employment prospects in her home country or a third country. The Tribunal considered the vocational course proposed to be of marginal value to someone with Ms Pena’s many years of experience: CB 236 at [31];(u)found there was a lack of evidence provided to the Tribunal and no adequate explanation about the reality of opening a child care centre in Colombia, and that if Ms Pena was seriously contemplating opening a child care centre in Bogota she would have had a more defined plan, and did not accept that the course were going to add value to Ms Pena’s prospects of getting employment in the future in Colombia as Ms Pena had not provided any convincing evidence to the Tribunal as to how she planned to implement the plan: CB 236 at [32];(v)Ms Pena had travelled elsewhere internationally and stated she had not been refused a visa from any other country, a fact to which the Tribunal attached some weight in her favour on the basis that she had complied with the migration laws of other countries: CB 236 at [33];(w)noted that Ms Pena had said that in spite of the fact that she studied English in Colombia she did not feel confident with her English skills in Australia as the previous studies were taught by Colombians and it was quite difficult for her to improve her skills, her accent and to practice English, and the Tribunal found that it could not make a finding about whether Ms Pena’s career will improve in Colombia by reason of the fact that she has studied in English in Australia: CB 236 at [35];(x)took into consideration that Ms Pena did study English at a university in Colombia and that she had a prior interest in the subject, so that it was plausible that she would wish to update her skills in Australia and immerse herself in speaking English on a daily basis, and placed some weight in favour of her case based on these facts: CB 236 at [36];(y)did not accept as fact Ms Pena’s statement that she planned to return to Colombia as she had everything in her own country and that she did not plan to stay in Australia as she has her friends, her culture and a job to go back to, because the applicants have not returned to Colombia since their arrival in Australia: CB 236 at [38]; and(z)found it was not satisfied that Ms Pena intended to genuinely stay in Australia temporarily and that she did not meet cl 500.212(a) of Sch 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (“Migration Regulations”): CB 237 at [42], and that the criteria for the grant of the Student Visa was therefore not met: CB 237 at [43], and therefore affirmed the Delegate’s Decision: CB 237 at [44].CONSIDERATION The requirement for jurisdictional error