Pelton and Banbury and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

PELTON & BANBURY AND ANOR [2019] FamCA 712
FAMILY LAW – INTERIM PROPERTY – Sale of Business – where the parties are ordered to appoint a business broker to place the business on the market for sale – where the most significant area of dispute between the parties is in relation to the business owned and operated throughout the marriage – where there have been ongoing and complicated disputes with respect to the management of the business post-separation – where the business has been valued by a Single Expert – where the wife seeks orders that the business and other assets of the relationship be sold – where the husband submitted that the business should not be sold prior to the final hearing in order to allow there to be an audit – where the husband’s application for an audit of the business was misconceived – where there is a real possibility that the value of the business will be further diminished if the sale is delayed – where the sale of the business is intended to preserve the asset pool –orders are made restraining the parties from using the intellectual property of the business and client data base following its sale – given level of disputation orders made pursuant to s 106A of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) – the husband’s application for spousal maintenance is dismissed – the matter is set down for final hearing.
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)
Strahan & Strahan (Interim Property Orders) (2011) FLC 93-446; [2009] FamCAFC 166
AG v Adelaide Steamship Co (1913) 18 CLR 30; 19 ALR 405
Ledarn & Ledarn [2013] FamCA 858
Jackson and Sterling Industries Limited (1987) 162 CLR 612; [1987] HCA 23
APPLICANT: Ms Pelton
RESPONDENT: Mr Banbury
SECOND RESPONDENT: Mr Hellis
FILE NUMBER: MLC 10051 of 2018
DATE DELIVERED: 7th October 2019
PLACE DELIVERED: Melbourne
PLACE HEARD: Melbourne
JUDGMENT OF: Macmillan J
HEARING DATE: 2nd and 3rd September 2019

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Mr Dickson QC
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Hargreaves Family Lawyers
COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: Mr Ribbands of counsel and Mr Mort of counsel
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Morgan Legal
COUNSEL FOR THE SECOND RESPONDENT: Mr Mellas of counsel
SOLICITOR FOR THE SECOND RESPONDENT: Gadens Lawyers

Orders

Interim Financial Arrangements

  1. That within 7 days the parties do all things and sign all such documents as are required to cause:

    (a)$100,000 to be transferred from the Commonwealth Bank Account #...37 into the jointly held Commonwealth Bank Account #...87 ("the Joint Account'); and

    (b)Q Group to cause the Husband's monthly rental payments to be direct debited from an account in the Husband's sole name and, in the event any rental from the date of these Orders is direct debited from the Joint Account, the Husband shall reimburse the Joint Account within 24 hours of the payment being debited.

Sale of Business

  1. That within 7 days the parties forthwith do all such acts and things…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pelton and Banbury and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FamCA 712
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned interim financial arrangements and directions for the sale of a business between the parties, Pelton and Banbury, and a second respondent, Mr. Hellis. The dispute involved the management and sale of a business operated by C Pty Ltd, the distribution of sale proceeds, and the handling of various financial accounts and tax obligations.

The court was required to determine the terms of interim financial arrangements, including the transfer of funds and the direct debiting of rental payments. It also needed to establish a process for the sale of the business, including the appointment of a business broker, the method of sale, and the distribution of proceeds. Further issues included the restraint on the use of a business database, the application of funds to discharge loans, and the finalisation of tax returns for the Banbury/Pelton Group. The court also addressed procedural matters, including the authorisation of a Registrar to sign documents on behalf of a defaulting party and the filing of evidence and submissions for an upcoming trial.

Justice Macmillan ordered the immediate transfer of $100,000 into a joint account and stipulated that future rental payments be debited from an account in the husband's sole name, with reimbursement to the joint account if necessary. The court directed the parties to appoint a business broker within seven days to market C Pty Ltd for sale by expressions of interest, unless otherwise advised. The wife was given conduct of the sale, with provisions for the husband to be kept informed and to have the liberty to contact the broker. The contract of sale was to include intellectual property and databases, with no non-compete clauses required for either party. Proceeds from the sale were to be applied first to sale costs and then deposited into a joint trust account. A restraint was imposed on the parties and Mr. Hellis from retaining or utilising the business database. The court also made orders regarding the application of funds to discharge Division 7A loans and the finalisation of tax matters for the Banbury/Pelton Group.

The court further ordered that if a party failed to sign necessary documents within 14 days of a request, a Registrar was authorised to sign on their behalf pursuant to section 106A of the Family Law Act. All questions of costs were reserved. The wife's amended application, save for any applications for costs, was dismissed. The court adjourned all extant applications for final orders for a four-day hearing commencing on 28 January 2020, and set strict timelines for the filing of evidence, financial statements, and submissions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Interim Financial Arrangements

1.

That within 7 days the parties do all things and sign all such documents as are required to cause:

(a) $100,000 to be transferred from the Commonwealth Bank Account #...37 into the jointly held Commonwealth Bank Account #...87 ("the Joint Account'); and

(b) Q Group to cause the Husband's monthly rental payments to be direct debited from an account in the Husband's sole name and, in the event any rental from the date of these Orders is direct debited from the Joint Account, the Husband shall reimburse the Joint Account within 24 hours of the payment being debited.

Sale of Business

2.

That within 7 days the parties forthwith do all such acts and things and sign all such documents as are required to appoint Mr L of M Business ("the Business Broker"), or such other business broker as agreed between the parties to market for sale the business operated by C Pty Ltd, and known as C Pty Ltd (“C Pty Ltd") for sale.

3.

That in relation to the sale of C Pty Ltd:

(a) The parties shall sign the Engagement Letter appointing the Business Broker within 7 days;

(b) The Wife obtain the written recommendations of the business broker as to the way in which to market C Pty Ltd for sale;

(c) The sale be by Expressions of Interest, unless otherwise recommended by the business broker;

(d) An independent solicitor be appointed to prepare the contract of sale and effect the sale of the business;

(e) The Wife have conduct of the sale;

(f) The Wife keep the Husband apprised in relation to all recommendations and/or advice received from the business broker and/or the independent solicitor;

(g) The Husband be at liberty to contact the business broker and obtain any information in relation to the sale of C Pty Ltd, and the Wife provide any authorisation required to enable the Husband to do so;

(h) The contract of sale for C Pty Ltd will include the sale of intellectual property and database of the business; and

(i) Neither the Wife nor the Husband will be required to enter into a non-compete clause.

4.

That at settlement of the sale of C Pty Ltd the proceeds be distributed:

(a) To pay all costs, commissions and expenses of the sale; and

(b) To deposit the balance into the Joint Trust Account.

Restraint

5.

Until further order neither the husband, the wife nor Mr. Hellis (“the second named respondent”) shall be permitted to retain a copy of the database of C Pty Ltd or utilize such database in any subsequent business operation.

(a) Any asset of D Pty Ltd as trustee for the E Trust including, but not limited to, any funds held in any bank account.

Division 7A Loan Accounts

6.

That within 14 days of the sale of the K property and/or the J property, the parties obtain the written advice of Mr G of F Company as to how the funds held in the Commonwealth Bank account numbers #...89 (Everyday Offset), #...7 (K property Offset), #...70 (J property Offset), #...08 (… Offset), and #...07 (Motor Vehicle 1 Offset) ought be applied to discharge the Division 7A Loans owing within the Banbury/Pelton Group and the professional fees of F Company incurred in preparing that advice be paid from the Joint Account within 7 days of F Company's invoice being issued.

Banbury/Pelton Group Income Tax Returns

7.

That the Husband and the Wife do all such acts and things and sign all such documents as are required to instruct Mr G of F Company within 14 days to:

(a) Finalise any outstanding taxation matters, including any return in respect of Fringe Benefits Tax, for the 2018 financial year; and

(b) Prepare the 2019 income taxation returns and financial statements of the "Banbury/Pelton Group" including the H Fund and any return in respect of Fringe Benefits Tax.

8.

That the fees of F Company to prepare the income tax returns and financial statements referred to in paragraph 14 be paid from the Joint Account within 7 days of F Company's invoice being issued.

Section 106A Order

9.

If either party refuses or neglects to sign any document required to give effect to these Orders within 14 days of being requested to do so, then pursuant to Section 106A of the Family Law Act a Registrar of this Honourable Court is authorised to sign on behalf of the defaulting party upon the request of the non-defaulting party in writing and an Affidavit for the solicitor for the non-defaulting party shall constitute sufficient evidence of the default.

Costs

10.

All questions of costs be reserved for determination.

11.

By 4.00 pm on 16 October 2019 the first and second respondents file and serve any written submissions in support of any application for costs arising out of or incidental to the Amended Application in Case filed 29 August 2019.

12.

By 4.00 pm on 30 October 2019 the applicant file and serve any written submissions in reply to any applications for costs.

13.

That any submissions as to costs should be limited to 10 pages.

14.

The wife’s Amended Application in a Case filed 29 August 2019 and the first and second respondents responses thereto, save and except for any applications for costs, be otherwise dismissed.

Trial Directions

15.

All extant applications for final orders be adjourned for hearing before Justice Macmillan at 10.00 am on 28 January 2020 as a 4 day matter.

16.

By 4.00 pm on 5 December 2019 the applicant file and serve upon all other parties:

(a) any further affidavits of evidence in chief of all witnesses relied upon (noting that affidavits relied upon for previous hearings cannot be relied upon as evidence in chief without leave); and

(b) a financial statement that complies with Chapter 13 of the Family Law Rules.

17.

By 4.00 pm on 21 November 2019 the first respondent file and serve upon all other parties:

(a) any further affidavits of evidence in chief of all witnesses relied upon (noting that affidavits relied upon for previous hearings cannot be relied upon as evidence in chief without leave); and

(b) a financial statement that complies with Chapter 13 of the Family Law Rules.

18.

By 4.00 pm on 5 December 2019 the second named respondent file and serve upon all other parties any further affidavits of evidence in chief of all witnesses relied upon (noting that affidavits relied upon for previous hearings cannot be relied upon as evidence in chief without leave).

19.

By 4.00 pm on 19 December 2019 the applicant file and serve any affidavit in reply to the affidavits of the respondent.

20.

No party file any further material other than as provided by these orders without leave of the Court.

21.

If either party takes objection to any evidence of the other party:

(a) any objection be taken no later than 14 days prior to the trial by service of written notice on the solicitor for the other party;

(b) The party so served shall notify the objecting party in writing no later than 7 days prior to the trial of which objections so taken are the subject of agreement and which require determination.

22.

All parties have leave to issue subpoenas for the production of documents by arrangement with the registrar docketed with the management of the file.

23.

All parties have liberty to approach the registrar responsible for the management of the court file to vary the obligations under these orders to ensure readiness for trial.

24.

Should any party fail to comply with these orders or the ensuing amending directions of the docketed registrar, the party who has complied may immediately thereafter file an application in a case supported by an affidavit seeking for the matter to proceed on an undefended basis.

25.

The applicant pay all setting down and trial fees by 4.00 pm on 20 January 2020 or obtain the requisite waiver thereof.

26.

The practitioners and/or the parties in the event that they are not legally represented file electronically to … and serve upon all other parties by 4.00 pm on 22 January 2020 the following:

(a) a concise set of orders to be sought if different from those already filed;

(b) a list of the applications and affidavits filed pursuant to these orders to be read and, if not the whole affidavit, the relevant paragraphs relied upon;

(c) a list of the parties’ respective legal and equitable interests in property and liabilities;

(d) a list of objections to evidence upon which rulings are required, if any; and

(e) a bullet-point summary of argument in relation to the legal and factual issues in dispute.

(f) Each party provide to the court at the commencement of the hearing, a statement setting out the costs incurred to that date and from what source those costs have been paid and what costs are expected to be incurred until the completion of the hearing.

27.

The practitioners and/or the parties in the event that they are not legally represented be at liberty to approach Justice Macmillan’s Associate via email for an urgent listing of the matter if required.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.