Peabody West Burton Pty Ltd v Mason

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Peabody West Burton Pty Ltd & Ors v Mason & Ors [2012] QLC 0023
PARTIES:

Peabody West Burton Pty Ltd, CITIC West/North Burton Pty Ltd and Talbot Group Exploration Pty Ltd
(applicants)

v.

Edward Peter Mason, Mora Ellen Mason and Valda Ann Mason
(respondents)
FILE NO: MRA788-11
DIVISION: Land Court of Queensland - General Division
PROCEEDING: Determination of compensation payable to the respondents under Schedule 1 of the Mineral Resources Act 1989 and related matters
DELIVERED ON: 31 May 2012
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARD AT: Mackay
MEMBER: Mr PA Smith
ORDER:

1. Pursuant to section 22(3) of Schedule 1 MRA, the Court determines the applicants’ future compensation liability to the respondents for an authorised activity to be carried out by the applicants, in relation to Lot 8, in the total sum of Three Thousand, Two Hundred and Twenty Dollars ($3,220).

2.     Pursuant to section 363 MRA, the respondents permit the applicants access to Lot 8 in accordance with the terms of the Conduct and Compensation Agreement to be entered into between the applicants and the respondents, in the form of Exhibit 6, with the inclusion at Schedule 2 of the Court’s determination of compensation.

CATCHWORDS:

MINING — determination of compensation liability for exploration activities — heads of compensation —diminution of value — whether compensation payable for future risk of mining — claim for experts’ fees

Mineral Resources Act 1989, Schedule 1, ss 13, 22

APPEARANCES: H Bowskill of Counsel for the applicants
G Houen, agent, for the respondents

SOLICITORS:

McCullough Robertson, Lawyers for the applicants

Background

  1. On 10 November 2011 Peabody West Burton Pty Ltd,[1] CITIC West/North Burton Pty Ltd and Talbot Group Exploration Pty Ltd (“the applicants”) commenced proceedings in the Land Court by way of originating application against Edward Peter Mason, Mora Ellen Mason and Valda Ann Mason (“the respondents”). Subsequently, and without objection from the respondents, the applicants filed an amending originating application. The purpose of the amending application was to more appropriately set out the orders sought by the proceeding. By the amended application, the orders that the applicants seek are as follows:

    “1Pursuant to section 22(3) of Schedule 1 MRA, an order that the Court decide the Applicants’ future compensation liability to the Respondents for an authorised activity to be carried out by the Applicants, in relation to Lot 8, in terms consistent with the valuation report prepared by Taylor Byrne which is annexure ‘C’ to this application.

    2Pursuant to section 363 MRA, an order that the Respondents permit the Applicants access to Lot 8 in accordance with the terms of the Conduct and Compensation Agreement to be entered into between the Applicants and the Respondents, in the form of Exhibit 6, with the inclusion at Schedule 2 of the Court’s determination of compensation.”

    [1]     It is noted that the first applicant was originally named as West Burton Coal Pty Ltd. However, by letter dated 7 March 2012 from the applicants’ solicitors, the Court was advised that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Peabody West Burton Pty Ltd v Mason and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QLC 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Peabody West Burton Pty Ltd sought determination of its compensation liability to Mason under the Mining Act 1992 (MRA). The applicants carried out exploration activities on Lot 8, owned by Mason, and sought to establish the extent of their compensation liability. The applicants claimed that they were not liable for any compensation, while Mason argued for compensation for diminution of value and future risk of mining. The dispute also included a claim for experts’ fees.

The central legal issue was whether compensation was payable for the future risk of mining and the appropriate heads of compensation under s.13 of Schedule 1 of the MRA. The court had to decide if compensation was payable for the future risk of mining, and if so, how it should be assessed. It also needed to consider the evidence of two expert valuers, who had drawn opposing conclusions on the issue of diminution of value. The court found that the wording of s.13 of Schedule 1 of the MRA required compensation to be paid for the actual damage caused by the exploration activities, not for the future risk of mining.

The court determined that compensation was payable for the actual damage caused by the exploration activities, but not for the future risk of mining. It held that the provisions under s.13 of Schedule 1 of the MRA were distinct from those relating to the grant of a mining lease under s.281 of the MRA. The court held that the heads of compensation in s.13(4) of Schedule 1 must be read in light of this distinction. The court found that the applicants were liable to pay Mason compensation in the sum of $3,220. The court also held that the applicants were not liable for Mason's experts’ fees.

The court made two orders. Firstly, it determined the applicants’ future compensation liability to Mason in the total sum of $3,220. Secondly, it permitted the applicants access to Lot 8 in accordance with the terms of the Conduct and Compensation Agreement, with the inclusion of the court’s determination of compensation.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to section 22(3) of Schedule 1 MRA, the Court determines the applicants’ future compensation liability to the respondents for an authorised activity to be carried out by the applicants, in relation to Lot 8, in the total sum of Three Thousand, Two Hundred and Twenty Dollars ($3,220).

2. Pursuant to section 363 MRA, the respondents permit the applicants access to Lot 8 in accordance with the terms of the Conduct and Compensation Agreement to be entered into between the applicants and the respondents, in the form of Exhibit 6, with the inclusion at Schedule 2 of the Court’s determination of compensation.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Two key points arise from the valuation evidence above of Mr Lyons and Mr Jinks. Mr Lyons does not make any allowance for diminution of value because in his view there is “no evidence in the market place for rural properties in Central Queensland that would give any indication that there is a discount for such short term activities”. For his part, Mr Jinks acknowledges that his view is “unsupported by evidence”. It is in my experience an unusual circumstance for two experienced valuers to both draw important, opposite, conclusions based on either a lack of evidence or no evidence. Of course, Mr Lyons is making a positive assertion that sales show no evidence to support the respondents’ claim. There was not, however, an analysis of sales of properties without EPCs present vs those with EPCs. Assistance in resolving the dilemma caused by this evidence is to be found in a close examination of the actual words of s.13, Schedule 1. A number of aspects of the construction of s.13 of Schedule 1 are clear. To begin with, it is immediately apparent that the provisions are quite different to those which apply relating to the payment of compensation for the grant of a mining lease under s.281 of the MRA.[19] While compensation pursuant to s.281 of the MRA relates to the grant of a mining lease, under s.13(1), Schedule 1, a landholder is compensated “for any compensatable effect the eligible claimant suffers caused by relevant authorised activities”. In simple terms, under Schedule 1 the landholder is compensated for the actual damage that the explorer does to the landholder’s property in actually carrying out the exploration activities.[19] See, by way of example, Barrett v Weir & Gregcarbil Pty Ltd [2009] QLC 182; Markert v Struber & Anor [2010] QLC 60 and Slater & Anor v Appleton & Anor [2012] QLC 0007. In my view, the heads of compensation in Schedule 1, s.13(4) must be read in light of this distinction. In this regard, the observations of Thomas J, with whom Andrews CJ and de Jersey J agreed, in R v The Land Court; ex parte Kennecott Explorations (Australia) Ltd[20] are quite pertinent. His Honour said:[21]“… 'diminution of the value of the lands of the owner or occupier or any improvements thereon' may be very different according to whether the diminution is that caused by the taking of the coal mining tenement, or the taking of the surface area only, or the taking up and working of the mining tenement. In short, when one looks at the words 'diminution of the value' in s 129(4)(A)(b) one immediately has to ask 'diminution of the value by reason of what acts or events?'.In some other compulsory acquisition and compensation provisions, there is an express statement of the acts or events in respect of which the assessment is to compensate the owner. For example in compulsory acquisitions under the Acquisition of Land Act 1967 it is the taking of the land which is the causative factor, and in general terms the measure of compensation is the loss which the owner sustains by reason of his land being taken (subject of course to the express statutory directions in relation to assessment of compensation). The answer in the present case is suggested by the terms of s 128. The reference to 'compensation', although negatively expressed, is to compensation 'for the right to take up and occupy or work a mining tenement'…”[20] [1989] 1 Qd R 335.[21] At 338-9.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.