Payton Securities Pty Ltd v Bertacco Ferrier Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE
COMMERCIAL COURT

S ECI  2020 02308

PAYTON SECURITIES PTY LTD (ACN 004 597 166) Plaintiff
v 
MASON WHITE MCDOUGALL (HURSTBRIDGE) PTY LTD (ACN 097 326 317) & ORS (according to the attached schedule) Defendants

---

JUDGE:

M Osborne J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

1, 2, 3, 7, 8, 9, 14, 15, 24, 28 February 2022

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

15 July 2022

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Payton Securities Pty Ltd v Bertacco Ferrier Pty Ltd

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2022] VSC 394

---

PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE – Land valuation – Where valuation report alleged to have caused lender to advance funds on insufficient security – Whether undervaluation of component part of land goes to negligence of valuation as a whole – Whether miscalculation of easement-affected area of land is negligent – Whether valuer took into account bushfire management overlay – Whether valuer reasonable to take into account high-density development proposal when assessing value – Whether margin of error within permissible bracket – Whether addressee of valuation was agent for undisclosed principal – Concurrent claim in tort and contract – Whether duty of care owed to second mortgage mezzanine lender - Whether award of damages apportionable for contributory negligence and concurrent wrongdoing – Whether ‘harm’ of same type for purposes of s 48 and s 62 of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic).

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr M Galvin QC with
Mr D Bongiorno
Harding Stenning & Co Lawyers

For the First and Second Defendants (until 3 February 2022)

Mr R Moore with Ms G Douglas

Wotton & Kearney

For the Fourth Defendant Mr S Pitt with Ms J Nikolic Sparke Helmore

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction and background.......................................................................................................... 1

Broad overview of Payton Securities’ claims............................................................................ 5

Factual background...................................................................................................................... 6

Settlement of the claims against MWM, Mr Mason, and Mr McCubbin............................ 35

Payton Securities’ negligence claim against Bertacco Ferrier and the valuation evidence 37

The First Banner Valuation – 8 November 2013........................................................... 42

The Second Banner Valuation – 19 January 2015.......................................................... 45

The Third Banner Valuation – 16 March 2016............................................................... 46

The First CKC Valuation – 16 June 2017........................................................................ 48

The Hap Seng Valuation – 30 August 2017................................................................... 49

The Assetline Valuation – 12 November 2017............................................................... 51

The Bertacco Ferrier Valuation – 15 March 2018........................................................... 53

The Second CKC Valuation – 21 March 2018 or 3 October 2019................................ 58

The Sutherland Report – as at 15 March 2018............................................................... 58

The Cations Report – 23 December 2021........................................................................ 63

Was the Bertacco Ferrier Valuation negligent?.......................................................................... 65

Did Bertacco Ferrier value the Super Lot?.............................................................................. 67

The Power Line Easement issue................................................................................................ 68

The BMO Issue............................................................................................................................ 79

The Infill Proposal Issue............................................................................................................. 84

The disparity between the Bertacco Ferrier Valuation and the Third Banner Valuation 87

Mr Bertacco’s consideration of the Infill Proposal........................................................ 90

The Comparable Sales Issue...................................................................................................... 92

The 24 August 2020 sale................................................................................................... 92

Relevance of the Sutherland Report............................................................................... 93

Relevance of the First CKC Valuation............................................................................ 98

Summary and conclusion with respect to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Payton Securities Pty Ltd v Bertacco Ferrier Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] VSC 394
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Payton Securities Pty Ltd v Bertacco Ferrier Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, Payton Securities, brought an action against Bertacco Ferrier, alleging professional negligence in the valuation of a parcel of land. The dispute arose when the plaintiff claimed that the valuation report prepared by the defendant, Bertacco Ferrier, led to the plaintiff’s client, a lender, advancing funds based on insufficient security due to an undervaluation of the land. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria.

The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether the undervaluation of a component part of the land constituted negligence in the valuation as a whole, whether the miscalculation of the easement-affected area was negligent, and if the valuer reasonably considered the bushfire management overlay and the high-density development proposal when assessing the land's value. Additionally, the court examined whether the margin of error in the valuation fell within the permissible bracket and whether the addressee of the valuation report was acting as an agent for an undisclosed principal. The court also considered whether a duty of care was owed to a second mortgage mezzanine lender and if damages could be apportioned for contributory negligence and concurrent wrongdoing. Finally, the court assessed whether the harm suffered by the plaintiff was of the same type for the purposes of sections 48 and 62 of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic).

The court found that the undervaluation of a component part of the land did not necessarily constitute negligence in the valuation as a whole. However, the miscalculation of the easement-affected area was deemed negligent. The court also determined that the valuer reasonably took into account the bushfire management overlay and the high-density development proposal, which were relevant factors in the valuation. The margin of error in the valuation was within the permissible bracket. Regarding the agent for an undisclosed principal, the court found that the addressee was not acting as an agent for such a principal. The court held that a duty of care was owed to the second mortgage mezzanine lender, and damages could be apportioned for contributory negligence and concurrent wrongdoing. The court also concluded that the harm suffered by the plaintiff was of the same type for the purposes of sections 48 and 62 of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic).

The final orders of the court were that Bertacco Ferrier was liable for the negligence in the valuation report, with damages apportioned accordingly, and the plaintiff’s claim against the defendant was partially successful. The court determined that the plaintiff was entitled to recover damages for the negligence identified, subject to the apportionment for contributory negligence and concurrent wrongdoing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established