Paull v Queensland Racing Integrity Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Paull v Queensland Racing Integrity Commission [2018] QCAT 214

PARTIES:

GREGORY BRIAN PAULL
(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND RACING INTEGRITY COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR155-15

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

10 July 2018

HEARING DATE:

19 February 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Ann Fitzpatrick

ORDERS:

The Tribunal directs:

1.   The Decision of the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board of 24 June, 2015 affirming the original decision of the Board of Queensland All Codes Racing Industry Board is set aside;

2.   The Decision of the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board of 24 June, 2015 in respect of conviction and penalty are set aside;

3.   A new decision is substituted that an alleged breach of GAR, Rule 86(af); GAR, Rule 86(aa) and GAR, Rule 86(q) is not established.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – LICENSING OR REGULATION OF OTHER PROFESSIONS, TRADES OR CALLINGS – OTHER PROFESSIONS, TRADES AND CALLINGS – Greyhound Trainer – where greyhound trainer sought review of decision to warn him off for ten years – where reviewable decision found greyhound trainer engaged in live baiting – breach of Greyhound Australasia Rules

EVIDENCE – PROOF – STANDARD OF PROOF – STANDARD OF SATISFACTION – SUFFICIENCY – GENERALLY – video footage – where quality of footage imperfect – no authentication of video footage

Animal Care and Protection Act 2001 (Qld), s 30, s 31,
s 32, s 33
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 19, s 20, s 24, s 33
Racing Act 2002 (Qld), s 152A

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented

Respondent:

J Ford, instructed by Clayton Utz Solicitors

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Application to review

  1. This is an application to review a decision made on 24 June 2015 by the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board. The Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board heard an appeal from a decision of the Board of Queensland All Codes Racing Industry Board trading as Racing Queensland. Racing Queensland considered 4 allegations against Mr Paull. It found him guilty of each charge and imposed a penalty that Mr Paull be warned off from the greyhound industry for life.

  2. The decision of the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board, the subject of this review is:

    …that Mr Paull was present at the time live baiting was being conducted on the premises in question and as a result thereof he is guilty of the charges and this Board so finds the appeal in respect to conviction is dismissed.

    It is the decision of this Board that a period of 10 years is an adequate deterrent in all of the circumstances and that penalty is substituted for the life ban imposed by Racing Queensland.

  3. This application to review is made under section 152A of the Racing Act 2002 (Qld) and section 33 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (‘QCAT Act’).

  4. By section 19 of the QCAT Act, this Tribunal has all the functions of the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board. By section 20 of the QCAT Act:

    (a)the purpose of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paull v Queensland Racing Integrity Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCAT 214
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Paull v Queensland Racing Integrity Commission involved a challenge by a greyhound trainer against a decision by the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board, affirmed by the Queensland Racing Integrity Commission, to warn him off for ten years. The disciplinary action followed findings that he had engaged in live baiting, which is a breach of Greyhound Australasia Rules. The Court of Appeal was asked to determine whether the decision to warn him off was legally sound, considering the admissibility and sufficiency of the evidence presented against him.

The key legal issues centred on the admissibility and sufficiency of the video evidence presented by the Queensland Racing Integrity Commission. The appellant argued that the video footage was not properly authenticated and was of insufficient quality to establish the alleged breaches. The court needed to assess whether the video evidence met the legal standards for admissibility and whether it was sufficient to prove the breaches beyond reasonable doubt.

The court examined the nature of the video evidence and noted that while the quality was imperfect, it was still admissible as long as it was reasonably authenticated. The court emphasised that the quality of the footage went to its weight rather than its admissibility. The court found that the evidence, while not perfect, was sufficient to establish the alleged breaches. However, the court also noted that the evidence did not sufficiently establish the appellant's involvement in the breaches, leading to the conclusion that the decision to warn him off was not legally sound.

The Court of Appeal set aside the decision of the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board and substituted a new decision that the alleged breaches were not established. The court ordered that the decision of the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board of 24 June 2015 affirming the original decision of the Board of Queensland All Codes Racing Industry Board be set aside, as well as the decision of the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board of 24 June 2015 in respect of conviction and penalty. A new decision was substituted that an alleged breach of GAR, Rule 86(af); GAR, Rule 86(aa) and GAR, Rule 86(q) was not established.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal directs:

1. The Decision of the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board of 24 June, 2015 affirming the original decision of the Board of Queensland All Codes Racing Industry Board is set aside;

2. The Decision of the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board of 24 June, 2015 in respect of conviction and penalty are set aside;

3. A new decision is substituted that an alleged breach of GAR, Rule 86(af); GAR, Rule 86(aa) and GAR, Rule 86(q) is not established.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Respondents also tendered the following:(a)Queensland All Codes Racing Industry Board Paper (‘Exhibit 10’);(b)Racing Queensland Statement of Reasons (‘Exhibit 11’);(c)Racing Disciplinary Board Transcript of Proceedings, dated 24 June 2015 (‘Exhibit 12’);(d)Racing Disciplinary Board Appeal Decision, dated 24 June 2015 (‘Exhibit 13’);(e)Transcript of Steward’s Inquiry dated 19 March 2015 (‘Exhibit 14’);(f)Show Cause Notice, dated 15 April 2015 (‘Exhibit 15’); and(g)Show Cause Response, dated 22 April 2015 (‘Exhibit 16’).Status of DVD Evidence The Respondent filed 11 DVDs as Attachments to an Affidavit of Jaime Lee Knight, Thoroughbred Integrity Officer, affirmed 18 September 2015. Mr Paull earlier brought an Application to have those DVDs excluded from evidence in these proceedings. On 12 May 2016, his Application was dismissed. That decision was appealed. On 9 August 2017, Justice Carmody, sitting as the QCAT Appeal Tribunal, decided that the DVDs were admissible in evidence, with the exception of audio at 9:56:24am to 9:58:28am.[3][3]Paull v Queensland All Codes Racing Industry Board [2017] QCATA 92. In the course of his decision, Justice Carmody said:The Regulator claims, in effect, that the tapes are virtual “eyewitnesses” to the Mr Paull’s disciplinary breaches. In evidentiary language, they are copy documents capable of proving any stated fact under the common law rules of evidence if the author or witness with direct knowledge personally identifies and vouches for them or the affected party voluntarily (that is, willingly and not inadvertently or forcibly) admits or adopts them as true. Otherwise, they are inadmissible for the purposes of proving what it records unless exempted by Part 6 of the Evidence Act 1977 (Qld) from the absolute ban on second-hand documentary hearsay.[4]…Video tapes may, of course, also be proved simply by production in Tribunal proceedings, but it would seldom be fair or just to allow and act on anonymous hearsay in disciplinary proceedings where, as here, a Regulator has the onus of proving contested liability facts to the standard of reasonable satisfaction.[5]…There is no reason to question the reliability of the audio-visual material. The Applicant can expect to be given the opportunity to explain, refute, criticise, contradict or discredit the material. As long as the Tribunal is reasonably satisfied as to the authenticity of the video tapes (which it should be circumspect about) unavailability of any verifying witness to cross-examine is a matter going more to the weight than admissibility.[6][4]Ibid [116]-[117].[5]Ibid [122].[6]Ibid [150]. In the end, the Respondent did not seek to tender any of the DVDs other than Exhibits 8 and 9, as a consequence of putting parts of the DVDs to Mr Paull. As the remaining nine DVDs were not tendered as evidence, I have had no regard to them. In relation to footage outside that put to Mr Paull, it was submitted that, pursuant to s 28 of the QCAT Act, this Tribunal may inform itself in any way it considers appropriate and must ensure, so far as practicable, that all relevant material is disclosed to the tribunal to enable it to decide the proceeding with all the relevant facts.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As a result of these findings, it is not necessary to make any decision in relation penalty. However, if I were wrong in relation to all the matters set out in this Decision, it would be appropriate to affirm the decision in relation to penalty on the basis of the submissions made to me by the Respondent in that regard.Correct and preferable decision The Tribunal makes the following decision:(a)The Decision of the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board of 24 June 2015 affirming the original decision of the Board of Queensland All Codes Racing Industry Board is set aside;(b)The Decision of the Queensland Racing Disciplinary Board of 24 June 2015 in respect of conviction and penalty is set aside; and(c)A new Decision is substituted that an alleged breach of GAR, Rule 86(af); GAR, Rule 86(aa) and GAR, Rule 86(q) is not established.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.