Paule v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Paule v Commissioner of Taxation [2019] FCA 394

File numbers: VID 678 of 2018
VID 681 of 2018
VID 682 of 2018
VID 683 of 2018
VID 994 of 2018
Judge: THAWLEY J
Date of judgment: 22 March 2019
Catchwords: TAXATION – appeal from decision of the Commissioner of Taxation to disallow objections to amended assessments – where trustees of various trusts sold shares and made capital gains – where various roll-overs had occurred prior to the sale of shares – whether provisions of Subdiv 115-A of the Income Tax Assessment act 1997 (Cth) operated such that the trustee was taken to have held the shares for a period of at least 12 months – whether s 115-30 or s 115-34 or both deemed the shares to have been acquired at least 12 months earlier – whether the applicants’ construction of ss 115-25, 115-30 and 115-34 was open on the wording of the provisions – whether the Court should read into s 115‑34 a reference to s 115-30
Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15AA

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) Subdivs 115-A, 122-A, 122-B, 124-N, 124-M, ss 112-115, 112-150, 115-5, 115-10, 115-15, 115-20, 115-25, 115-30, 115-32, 115-34, 115-40, 115-45, 122-45(1), 122-50, 122-70(2), 124‑780(3)(d), 124-870, 950-100(1), 995-1(1)

Tax Laws Amendment (2010 Measures No 1) Act 2010 (Cth) items 141, 142

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) Part IVC

Cases cited:

Barry R Liggins Pty Ltd v Comptroller-General of Customs (1991) 32 FCR 112

Certain Lloyd’s Underwriters v Cross (2012) 248 CLR 378

Cooper Brookes (Wollongong) Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1981) 147 CLR 297

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Media Holdings Ltd (2012) 250 CLR 503

HFM043 v Republic of Nauru (2018) 359 ALR 176

R v Kelly (2004) 218 CLR 216

SZTAL v  Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2017] HCA 34; 347 ALR 405

Taylor v Owners, Strata Plan 11564 (2014) 253 CLR 531

Wentworth Securities Ltd v Jones [1980] AC 74

Date of hearing: 8 February 2019
Date of last submissions: 22 February 2019
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Taxation
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 79
Counsel for the Applicants: M Flynn QC and A Lee
Solicitor for the Applicants:

Thomson Geer

Counsel for the Respondent:

E Wheelahan QC and L Molesworth

Solicitor for the Respondent: MinterEllison

ORDERS

VID 678 of 2018

BETWEEN:

ANNA PAULE

Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

JUDGE:

THAWLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 MARCH 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.Unless either party applies within 14 days for a different order with respect to costs, the applicant pay the respondent’s costs.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ORDERS

VID 681 of 2018

BETWEEN:

CORNELIA PAULE

Applicant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

JUDGE:

THAWLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 MARCH 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Paule v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 394
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Paule v Commissioner of Taxation, the applicants, who were beneficiaries of various trusts, sought to challenge the disallowance of objections to amended assessments made by the Commissioner of Taxation. The core dispute centred on whether the applicants were entitled to a discount capital gain on the sale of shares by the trustees of the trusts, given the series of roll-overs that occurred prior to the sale. The legal issues the court needed to address included the interpretation of Subdivision 115-A of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) and specifically sections 115-25, 115-30, and 115-34. The applicants argued that the provisions should be construed in a way that would allow them to claim a discount capital gain, but the Commissioner argued otherwise.

The court found that the applicants' interpretation of the relevant sections was not supported by the wording of the provisions. The court held that the provisions did not operate in a sequential or combined manner as the applicants suggested. Rather, the court held that the provisions must be read in isolation and that the applicants' construction was not permissible under the statutory scheme. The court also rejected the applicants' argument that the court should read into section 115-34 a reference to section 115-30. The court concluded that the applicants were not entitled to a discount capital gain because the provisions did not deem the shares to have been acquired at least 12 months earlier. The application was dismissed, and the applicants were ordered to pay the Commissioner's costs unless a different order was sought within 14 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. Unless either party applies within 14 days for a different order with respect to costs, the applicant pay the respondent’s costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It was only the fact that one of the roll-overs in each series of roll-overs was of a particular type (one covered by s 115-34(1)(c)) that the provisions did not operate to allow a discount capital gain. If the series of roll-overs had not included a roll-over covered by s 115-34(1)(c) the gain would have been a discount capital gain. For example, if the S&TP Trust did not have units in a unit trust operating the business, but had shares in a company which operated the business, it could have carried out three Subdiv 124-M scrip-for-scrip roll-overs and the gain on disposal of the Findex shares would have been a discount capital gain consistent with the broad policy revealed by the statutory scheme. It is difficult to see the policy reason for excluding the present taxpayers, or taxpayers in an equivalent position, from the benefit of a discount capital gain simply because one of the roll-overs in the series was one to which s 115-34(1)(c) applied; none was clearly articulated. However, it is not for this Court to second guess the legislature or the Commissioner’s administration of the tax laws.FACTUAL BACKGROUND The facts in respect of each applicant are set out in Annexure A to these reasons. The facts so far as they concern Mrs Paule were as follows. Mrs Paule was a beneficiary of the S&TP Trust, presently entitled to 25% of its income in the year ended 30 June 2008. As at 14 January 2008, the S&TP Trust held all of the issued units in The Lifeplan Insurance Agencies Unit Trust (Lifeplan Unit Trust) and had held those units for more than 12 months. The following then occurred: (1)Subdivision 124-N roll-over: On 14 January 2008:(a)the Lifeplan Unit Trust disposed of all of its assets to STP Holdings Pty Ltd (this involved a “same-asset roll-over”); and(b)the S&TP Trust’s ownership of the units in the Lifeplan Unit Trust ended and were replaced by shares in STP Holdings (this involved a “replacement-asset roll-over”). The S&TP Trust chose to obtain a roll-over under Subdiv 124-N of the 1997 Act in respect of the disposal of each of its units in the Lifeplan Unit Trust.(2)Subdivision 124-M roll-over: On or around 15 January 2008, the S&TP Trust exchanged all of its shares in STP Holdings for newly issued shares in E-Quest Holdings Pty Ltd. The trust chose to obtain a roll-over for the disposal of those shares under Subdiv 124-M.(3)Subdivision 124-M roll-over: On or shortly after 15 January 2008, the trust exchanged all of its shares in E-Quest for shares in Findex. It chose to obtain a roll-over for the disposal of the E-Quest shares under Subdiv 124-M. (4)CGT event: On 18 January 2008, the trust sold its Findex shares to Macquarie Financial Services Holdings Pty Ltd for $5,256,432 realising a capital gain. As can be seen, the sequence of the roll-overs in respect of the S&TP Trust was: Subdivision 124-N, Subdivision 124-M and Subdivision 124-M. As more fully set out in Annexure A, the sequence relevant to the other applicants was:(a)the SP Family Trust, of which Spiro Paule was a beneficiary – Subdivision 124-N and Subdivision 124-M;(b)the STP Family Trust, of which Terry Paule was a beneficiary – Subdivision 124-N and Subdivision 124-M; and(c)the Grosvenor Trust, of which Philip Hart was a beneficiary – Subdivision 122-A, Subdivision 124-M and Subdivision 124-M.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The shares in Findex were “acquired as a replacement-asset for a replacement-asset roll-over (other than a roll-over covered by paragraph 115-34(1)(c))”. That is, the shares in Findex met the description in item 2, column 1 of the table in s 115-30(1). Accordingly, s 115-25 applied “as if the acquirer had acquired” the shares in Findex at the time identified in item 2, column 2 in the table to s 115-30(1). Item 2, column 2 contains two possibilities, (a) or (b), as to the time at which the asset was treated as having been acquired:(1)As to (a): the “original asset” in the roll-over was the shares in E-Quest which had been acquired on 15 January 2008. (2)As to (b): the Findex shares were acquired in “an unbroken series of replacement-asset roll-overs”, but this “unbroken series” cannot include roll-overs covered by paragraph 115-34(1)(c). The first roll-over was one “covered by” s 115-34(1)(c). Accordingly, at best, the “unbroken series” comprised the two Subdiv 124-M roll-overs which both occurred on 15 January 2008. Conclusion It follows that s 115-25(1) was not satisfied:(1)s 115-30(1) did not operate to deem the Findex shares to be acquired any earlier than 15 January 2018;(2)s 115-34(2) did not operate to deem the Findex shares to have been acquired at least 12 months earlier than the date of disposal.Second matter: The applicants’ construction Mrs Paule advanced two arguments in support of a different construction:(1)First, that the provisions had a “sequential” or “combined” operation.(2)Secondly, that – to the extent there were two or more possible constructions of the provisions – her construction was to be preferred having regard to the legislative history and intended effect of the 2010 Amendments. For the reasons which follow, these two arguments must be rejected. Sequential or Combined Operation The applicants contended that the provisions had a sequential or combined operation. As to the sequential operation, Mrs Paule contended that s 115-34(2) operated first to deem the shares in STP Holdings to have been acquired “at least 12 months before” those shares were exchanged for newly issued shares in E-Quest, because:(1)a CGT event happened to the S&TP Trust’s shares in STP Holdings when those shares were exchanged for shares in E-Quest: s 115‑34(1)(a);(2)at the time of the CGT event, the S&TP Trust had owned the shares in STP Holdings for less than 12 months: s 115-34(1)(b); and(3)S&TP Trust acquired the shares as a replacement asset for a replacement-asset roll-over within Subdivision 124-N: s 115‑34(1)(c)(iii). Each of those matters is to be accepted. However, that is relevant for the purposes of working out whether the capital gain on the disposal of the STP Holdings shares was a discount capital gain. Whether or not it was a discount capital gain did not in fact need to be determined because the S&TP Trust claimed roll-over relief such that any capital gain was disregarded. That particular disposal, however, is not of direct concern. The relevant disposal for present purposes is the final disposal, namely the disposal of the Findex shares.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is relevant to note that each sequence commenced with a roll-over which involved both a same-assert roll-over and a replacement-asset roll-over.CONSIDERATION Whether the disposal of shares by the S&TP Trust resulted in a discount capital gain revolves around the proper construction of ss 115-25, 115-30 and 115-34 found in Subdiv 115-A of the ITAA 1997. I set out below:(1)first, what I have concluded is the correct construction of those provisions;(2)secondly, why the applicants’ construction cannot be accepted; (3)thirdly, why the applicants’ alternative argument – that the Court should read into s 115‑34(2) a reference to s 115-30 – must be rejected.First matter: The correct construction In 2010, s 115-30 was amended and s 115-32 and s 115-34 were added to the ITAA 1997: Tax Laws Amendment (2010 Measures No 1) Act 2010 (Cth) (2010 Amendments) Sch 6 items 141, 142. The amendments to s 115-30 and the addition of s 115-32 and s 115-34 applied to assessments for income years including 21 September 1999 and later: 2010 Amendments Sch 6 item 146. That is, the amendments operated retrospectively and applied to the assessments in this case. Division 115 of the 1997 Act is entitled “Discount capital gains and trusts’ net capital gains”. Subdivision 115-A is entitled “Discount capital gains”. The uncontentious matters: ss 115-5 to 115-20 It was agreed between the parties that the requirements of ss 115-10 to 115-20 were satisfied and that s 115-5 was satisfied to that extent. These sections provided: 115‑5 What is a discount capital gain?A discount capital gain is a *capital gain that meets the requirements of sections 115‑10, 115‑15, 115‑20 and 115‑25.Note:Sections 115‑40, 115‑45 and 775‑70 identify capital gains that are not discount capital gains, despite this section.115‑10 Who can make a discount capital gain?To be a *discount capital gain, the *capital gain must be made by:(a) an individual; or(b) a *complying superannuation entity; or(c) a trust; or(d)a *life insurance company in relation to a *a discount capital gain from a *CGT event in respect of a *CGT asset that is a *complying superannuation asset. 115‑15 Discount capital gain must be made after 21 September 1999To be a *discount capital gain, the *capital gain must result from a *CGT event happening after 11.45 am (by legal time in the Australian Capital Territory) on 21 September 1999.115‑20 Discount capital gain must not have indexed cost base(1)To be a *discount capital gain, the *capital gain must have been worked out:(a)using a *cost base that has been calculated without reference to indexation at any time; or(b)for a capital gain that arose under *CGT event K7—using the *cost of the *depreciating asset concerned.Note:A listed investment company must also calculate capital gains without reference to indexation in order to allow its shareholders to access the concessions in Subdivision 115‑D.(2)For the purposes of working out whether the *capital gain is a *discount capital gain and the amount of that gain, the *cost base taken into account in working out the capital gain may be recalculated without reference to indexation if the cost base had an element including indexation because of another provision of this Act. This subsection has effect despite that other provision.Note:This lets a capital gain of an entity (the gain entity) on a CGT asset be a discount capital gain even if:(a)another provision of this Act (such as a provision for a same‑asset roll‑over or Division 128) set the gain entity’s cost base for the asset by reference to the cost base for the asset when it was owned by another entity (the earlier owner), and the earlier owner’s cost base for the asset included indexation; or(b)another provision of this Act (such as a provision for a replacement‑asset roll‑over) set the cost base of the asset by reference to the cost base of the original asset involved in the roll‑over, and the original asset’s cost base included indexation.Example: In 1995 Elizabeth acquired land from her ex‑husband under an order made by a court under the Family Law Act 1975. Former section 160ZZM of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 treated her as having paid $56,000 for the land, equal to her ex‑husband’s indexed cost base for it. His cost base for the land then was $40,000.In 2000, she sold the land for capital proceeds of $150,000.Her discount capital gain on the land is $110,000 (equal to the capital proceeds less the cost base for the land without indexation).(3)This section does not apply to a *capital gain worked out under subsection 104‑255(3) (about carried interests).The contentious matter: s 115-25