Patrick Stevedores Holdings Pty Ltd v Workers' Compensation Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Patrick Stevedores Holdings Pty Ltd v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2025] QIRC 062

PARTIES:

Patrick Stevedores Holdings Pty Ltd
(Appellant)

v

Workers' Compensation Regulator
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

WC/2023/119

PROCEEDING:

Application in proceedings

DELIVERED ON:

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

27 February 2025

Caddie IC

On the papers

ORDERS:

1.   Leave is granted for the Regulator to amend their Statement of Facts and Contentions to plead an alternative injury being an aggravation of a pre-existing clot in the left vertebral artery as a result of a dissection of the left vertebral artery.

2.   By 4.00 p.m. Friday 14 March 2025 the parties file in the Industrial Registry joint draft directions orders necessary for the resumed hearing and determination of the alternative injury as part of the substantive matter.

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATIONS – application to amend statement of facts and contentions – where the respondent seeks to amend their statement of facts and contentions on the last scheduled day of hearing – where the respondent seeks to plead in the alternative – where the respondent contends the amendments are necessary as they arose from appellant witness evidence at hearing – where the appellant contends the amendments are impermissible – consideration of relevant factors – leave to amend statement of facts and contentions granted.

LEGISLATION:

CASES: 

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) s 539 (d)

Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175

Australian Salaried Medical Officers' Federation Queensland, Industrial Organisation of Employees v State of Queensland (Queensland Health) (No. 2) [2021] QIRC 278

Belal Yousif v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2017] ICQ 4

Bomanite Pty Ltd v Slatex Corp Australia Pty Ltd (1991) 32 FCR 379

Bond v State of Qld & Ors (No.2) [2020] QIRC 078

Doorley v State of Queensland (Department of Premier and Cabinet) [2019] QIRC 205

Gilbert v Metro North Hospital Service [2021] QIRC 255

Hancock Shipping Co Ltd v Kawasaki Heavy Industries Ltd; The Casper Trader [1992] 3 ALL ER 132

Kernel Holdings Pty Ltd v Rothmans of Pall Mall (Australia Pty Ltd) (1991) 217 ALR 171

May v Thomas [2008] WASCA 215

Reasons for Decision

  1. Patrick Stevedores appeals a decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator to substitute a rejection decision of WorkCover Queensland with an acceptance of Mr Michael Anthony’s compensation claim. The basis of the accepted claim is that Mr Anthony suffered from an acute stroke of the left cerebellum and spinal cord secondary to left vertebral dissection arising from the pulling of heavy chains at work.

  2. The hearing of the substantive matter commenced on 15 October 2024 and was set to conclude 17 October 2024. On the morning of 17 October 2024, the Regulator filed an application seeking to amend their Statement of Facts and Contentions ('SOFC') and sought leave to make that application that same morning. The application was opposed by Patrick Stevedores. I issued directions to hear from the parties in relation to the leave sought.

  3. The Regulator, who is the Respondent to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Patrick Stevedores Holdings Pty Ltd v Workers' Compensation... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QIRC 62
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Patrick Stevedores Holdings Pty Ltd v Workers' Compensation Regulator, the Workers' Compensation Regulator sought leave to amend their Statement of Facts and Contentions, particularly to plead an alternative injury, on the last scheduled day of hearing. Patrick Stevedores opposed the application, arguing that it was untimely and prejudicial. The central legal issue before the court was whether the Regulator should be permitted to amend their Statement of Facts and Contentions on such a late stage, considering the impact on the proceedings and the fairness to the opposing party.

The court considered the factors relevant to permitting late amendments, including the necessity of the amendments arising from the evidence presented at the hearing, the impact on the fairness of the proceedings, and the procedural fairness to both parties. The Regulator argued that the amendments arose from the evidence of an expert witness, Dr Grimley, and were necessary for a complete presentation of their case. The court noted that while the application was indeed lodged late, it was not so late as to irreparably prejudice the appellant, particularly as the matter had been discussed prior to the calling of the Regulator’s medical evidence. The court concluded that the amendments, which were necessary to address the evidence presented, should be allowed to ensure a fair and complete adjudication of the issues before the tribunal.

The court granted leave to the Regulator to amend their Statement of Facts and Contentions to include an alternative injury, an aggravation of a pre-existing clot in the left vertebral artery as a result of a dissection of the left vertebral artery. The court also directed the parties to file joint draft directions orders by a specified time for the resumed hearing and determination of the alternative injury as part of the substantive matter.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave is granted for the Regulator to amend their Statement of Facts and Contentions to plead an alternative injury being an aggravation of a pre-existing clot in the left vertebral artery as a result of a dissection of the left vertebral artery.

2. By 4.00 p.m. Friday 14 March 2025 the parties file in the Industrial Registry joint draft directions orders necessary for the resumed hearing and determination of the alternative injury as part of the substantive matter.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

While it is correct the application was not lodged until the third day after all the medical evidence, it is not correct to say that there was no notice as it had been discussed prior to the calling of the Regulator’s medical evidence. I agree the application has come at a late time, but I do not agree it is too late. What weight should be given to the evidence of Dr Grimley? While the Commission is not strictly bound by the rules of evidence, as both Patrick Stevedores and the Regulator have advised me at various stages in the proceeding to date, it does not follow that no regard should be paid to them. Under those rules re-examination of a witness must be confined to matters arising from cross examination, and a new matter may only be introduced with leave of the Commission. In considering the objection there was an exchange about whether the reference to Dr White’s report in cross-examination was sufficient to enable re-examination in relation to the evidence he had given about his report. Patrick Stevedores contended they only raised Dr White’s report for the purpose of confirming he had access to it.[18] The Regulator argued it was more than that as it went to the issue of dissection and my assessment was that it went further than just an audit of available documents. Looking at the relevant cross examination of Dr Grimley:MR CLARK: And, just dealing with the arterial dissection, you read the reports from your colleagues, Dr Noel Saines and Dr White? ... I did yes. Okay and for that matter you’ve also read the report of the occupational physician, Dr Forbes okay? Whilst there doesn’t seem to be any doubt whatsoever that the – that there was an arterial dissection, the relevant issue was when it was likely to occur. Do you understand? ... I understand yes.MR CLARK: Okay. But nevertheless, whenever it occurred, our legislation speaks of what's called a significant contributing factor? - - -Yes.MR CLARK: You’d agree with me that the arterial dissection is really the starting point of a pathological – of a physiological process and does represent a – it can be characterised as the significant contributing factor which led to this man’s strokes. Do you agree with that? - - - Ah, yeah, this was a causative factor for his strokes. Ah, what you’re getting at is what – what led to the arterial dissection.[19][18] Submissions of the Appellant, filed 29 November 2024, [15]. [19] T 2-63 11 26-41. This exchange goes beyond confirming that Dr Grimley had access to the material for the purpose of giving his evidence. It was within the context of when the arterial dissection was likely to occur. With hindsight, an alternate course may have been allowing the Regulator to re-open their evidence in chief. However, I dealt with the objection as it was and granted leave for the re-examination to continue, advising that Patrick Stevedores could argue in submissions what weight that evidence should be given. Patrick Stevedores contends this was an error manifestly prejudicial to them as it denied them the opportunity to cross examine Dr Grimley about any responses to questioning in relation to Dr White's evidence the previous day. Patrick Stevedores argues this original prejudice is then heightened by the Regulator seeking to rely on that evidence to support their amendment.[20] [20] Submissions of the Appellant, filed 29 November 2024, [16].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.