PATRICIA KIRTON and AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

[2012] AATA 732 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Numbers

2010/2399

2010/2400

Re

PATRICIA KIRTON

APPLICANT

And

AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Dr P McDermott, RFD, Senior Member

Date 24 October 2012
Place Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decisions under review.

.........................[Sgd]...............................................

Dr P McDermott, RFD, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – Commonwealth corporation employee – Injury to ankle – Aggravation of injury – Ongoing pain and discomfort – Claim for treatment of injury – Medical opinion as to cause of pain and discomfort – Pain and discomfort not caused by injury or aggravation of injury – Decisions under review affirmed

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Medical report not filed – Summonsed material – No objection to admission of report at hearing – Tribunal sought to allow Applicant to call report author as witness – Applicant did not seek to call witness for cross-examination – Submission that cannot call own witness for cross-examination – General Practice Direction – No ownership of a witness – Submission to exclude report rejected  

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 14, 16, 19, 64, 66

CASES

Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298

Muin v Refugee Review Tribunal (2002) 190 ALR 601

Packer v Cameron (1989) 54 SASR 246

Re Almond and Secretary, Department of Social Security (1990) 20 ALD 746

Re Moline and Comcare [2003] AATA 827

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Heydon, J. D., Cross on Evidence (8th Australian Edition, 2010)

General Practice Direction

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr P McDermott, RFD, Senior Member

24 October 2012

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mrs Patricia Kirton (“the applicant”) is an employee of the Australia Postal Corporation (“the respondent”). She has suffered injuries to her left ankle at work in both 2003 and 2006. She claims to continue to experience pain, swelling, instability and other symptoms in the lateral aspect of her left ankle as a consequence of those injuries. She claims compensation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“the Act”).

    CLAIMS

  2. The applicant has made two claims for rehabilitation and compensation.

  3. On 1 April 2003, the applicant lodged a claim for rehabilitation and compensation for “left foot & ankle & Achilles & inflammation, tendonitis, bursitis tinosinositis, painful right rib area”.[1] This claim was made in respect of an incident which occurred on 24 February 2003 after she had walked through the mail exchange where she worked to laminate some documents in the administration area. There was some water on the floor which had leaked from an air conditioner. She slipped and hurt her “foot (L) & R rib area”. On 14 April 2003, a determination was made which accepted liability for the injury, which was then described as a “bruised left foot, right lower rib, lower sacral spine”; the date of injury was accepted as being 24 February 2003.[2]

    [1] Exhibit A, T-document 16, pp. 33-35, especially at p. 33.

    [2] Exhibit A, T-document 24, p. 45.

  4. On 27 March 2006, the applicant made another claim for rehabilitation and compensation for “

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PATRICIA KIRTON and AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 732
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Patricia Kirton sought review of two decisions by the Australian Postal Corporation (APC) declining to pay her compensation for injuries sustained in 2003 and 2006. The APC accepted that the injuries had occurred but disputed that they had caused her ongoing pain in her left ankle. Kirton argued that the injuries had caused her to suffer the pain and discomfort, which was an injury under the Commonwealth's Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was required to determine whether the injuries had caused her ongoing pain and whether the pain was an injury or disease within the meaning of the Act.

The AAT considered the evidence, including Kirton's statement, medical reports, and submissions from both parties. The Tribunal found that while Kirton had sustained injuries in 2003 and 2006, there was insufficient evidence to establish that the injuries had caused her ongoing pain. The Tribunal noted that several medical specialists had been unable to provide a definitive explanation for the source of Kirton's pain, and that the evidence did not support a finding that her pain was due to the workplace injuries. The Tribunal also rejected the applicant's attempt to call a medical expert as a witness for cross-examination, finding that the applicant had not sought to call the witness and could not rely on the General Practice Direction to do so.

The AAT affirmed the APC's decisions, finding that there was no evidence to support a finding that Kirton's ongoing pain was caused by the workplace injuries. The Tribunal noted that while Kirton had suffered injuries in 2003 and 2006, there was no evidence to establish that these injuries had caused her ongoing pain. The Tribunal also found that the APC had acted lawfully in declining to pay compensation to Kirton. The AAT did not make any orders as the reviewable decisions were affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The first issue for determination is whether the injuries sustained by the applicant in 2003 and 2006 led to her suffering the pain in her left ankle. The respondent does not accept the claims of the applicant. The second issue before the tribunal is whether the left ankle condition of the applicant is an “injury” or a “disease” within the meaning of the Act.EVIDENCE OF APPLICANT The applicant verified the correctness of her statement that was admitted in the proceedings. She is a supervisor of the counter staff at the mail centre where she works. Her duties include administrative work, stock control, customer interface and generating new business. She stated that she is second in charge of the office and that the respondent has accommodated her with restricted duties for nearly nine years. She stated that she does most of her work while seated but that she does all the duties expected of her and that she does “a full seven hours 21”.[8] [8] Transcript, 9 November 2011, P-5, L1. The applicant stated that a rehabilitation person had requested that she do more work at the counter. She stated that Dr Bartlett, her general practitioner, had agreed to her spending 20 minutes at the counter and 10 minutes off the counter, as in sitting. She has requested supporting shoes to be able to perform her duties. She wears supporting braces for her ankle. She stated that she uses a lightweight brace when not doing a lot of standing. The sitting and standing in her work has rotated. Her managers mainly use her for administrative work but there have been instances where she has been required to be on the counter because of staff shortages. She states that she has suffered severely from doing this and that most of the time she takes painkillers to get her through the night and to get her up the next morning. The applicant stated that the pain is around the ankle bone of the left outer side of her ankle and runs down the foot towards her little toe. She confirmed that the pain has always been at that site since her injury in February 2003. She stated that she does not experience any pain in the talonavicular joint but also said that she was aware of the location of that joint. The applicant confirmed that she had read and considered the reports of Dr Kuhnemann and Dr Saxby in relation to her application. She stated that she was aware that she last saw Dr Saxby, who considers that her current symptoms are related to changes in the talonavicular joint, on 19 October 2009. She was asked by her counsel whether Dr Saxby had ever asked her whether she experienced pain in that area: she answered “no”.[9] She stated that when she saw Dr Saxby previously in 2003, she was not examined by him personally but by his colleague. The applicant also stated that she estimated Dr Saxby had seen her for “possibly five minutes” when she saw him in 2009.[10] She stated that Dr Saxby had her walk across the room, twisted her foot and ankle, and remarked: “it is what it is”.[11] She did not know what time she actually went in to see Dr Saxby.[9] Transcript, 9 November 2011, P-8, L27.[10] Transcript, 9 November 2011, P-11, L14.[11] Transcript, 9 November 2011, P-11, L34.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 12 January 2010, a determination was made that the respondent had no present liability to pay compensation under ss 16 and 19 of the Act for the applicant's “bruised left foot, right lower rib, lower sacral spine” (claimed to be attributable to an incident on 24 February 2003) and “temporary exacerbation of ligamentous strain left ankle” (claimed to be attributable to an incident on 15 March 2006).[5] [5] Exhibit A, T-document 146, pp. 235-236.REVIEWABLE DECISIONS On 19 April 2010, a reviewable decision affirmed the determination dated 12 January 2010 relating to the “bruised left foot, right lower rib, lower sacral spine”.[6] On that date another reviewable decision affirmed the determination relating to the “temporary exacerbation of ligamentous strain left ankle” condition.[7] The applicant has sought review of both of these reviewable decisions in respect of her left ankle. No claim was made in respect of the “right lower rib, lower sacral spine” of the applicant.[6] Exhibit A, T-document 149, pp. 240-246.[7] Exhibit A, T-document 150, pp. 247-250. This Tribunal can review those reviewable decisions under s 64 of the Act.ISSUES The first issue for determination is whether the injuries sustained by the applicant in 2003 and 2006 led to her suffering the pain in her left ankle. The respondent does not accept the claims of the applicant. The second issue before the tribunal is whether the left ankle condition of the applicant is an “injury” or a “disease” within the meaning of the Act.EVIDENCE OF APPLICANT The applicant verified the correctness of her statement that was admitted in the proceedings. She is a supervisor of the counter staff at the mail centre where she works. Her duties include administrative work, stock control, customer interface and generating new business. She stated that she is second in charge of the office and that the respondent has accommodated her with restricted duties for nearly nine years. She stated that she does most of her work while seated but that she does all the duties expected of her and that she does “a full seven hours 21”.[8] [8] Transcript, 9 November 2011, P-5, L1. The applicant stated that a rehabilitation person had requested that she do more work at the counter. She stated that Dr Bartlett, her general practitioner, had agreed to her spending 20 minutes at the counter and 10 minutes off the counter, as in sitting. She has requested supporting shoes to be able to perform her duties. She wears supporting braces for her ankle. She stated that she uses a lightweight brace when not doing a lot of standing. The sitting and standing in her work has rotated. Her managers mainly use her for administrative work but there have been instances where she has been required to be on the counter because of staff shortages. She states that she has suffered severely from doing this and that most of the time she takes painkillers to get her through the night and to get her up the next morning. The applicant stated that the pain is around the ankle bone of the left outer side of her ankle and runs down the foot towards her little toe. She confirmed that the pain has always been at that site since her injury in February 2003. She stated that she does not experience any pain in the talonavicular joint but also said that she was aware of the location of that joint.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 19 provides that Comcare (or the respondent in this case) is liable to make incapacity payments where an employee is incapacitated for work as a result of an injury. It also provides for how such incapacity payments are calculated.CONSIDERATION The applicant contends that since 12 January 2010, when the determinations were made, she has continued to require medical treatment and to take time off work because of the injuries that she sustained in 2003 and 2006. The applicant asserts that she continues to experience pain and discomfort in her left ankle. The question that I have to determine is whether this pain is related to the injuries that she sustained in 2003 and 2006. There is no issue that the applicant sustained those injuries. I give my reasons why I do not consider that since 2010 her condition of the left ankle is an ailment or an aggravation of an ailment that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the employment of the applicant. After the 2003 injury the applicant underwent an arthroscopy and a debridement by Dr Kuhnemann. After that procedure she resumed her full duties at the workplace. The applicant has had no surgical treatment after her 2006 injury. After that injury she had rehabilitation which ceased in February 2007; since then she has worked normal hours. She has not had a further rehabilitation program. There have been a number of reasons put forward to explain the source of the pain of the applicant. But on the state of the evidence before me I am unable to make a finding that her pain and symptoms are a result of the workplace injuries. I give my reasons. There are a number of medical reports that are in evidence in which some specialists have been unable to give an explanation as to why the applicant experiences such pain. One report is by Dr Hatcher. In his report which was dated 16 February 2010, Dr Hatcher advised:[93] Unfortunately, I cannot find any objective reason why Patricia would be complaining of such severe pain. The ATFL tear in itself would not at this stage be expected to be painful. She has had extensive investigations including recent MRI scan, plain x-rays, stress views and ultrasound scan which did not show a convincing reason for her lateral ankle pain. I have advised her that physiotherapy is the way to go her [sic] to strengthen her ankle and provide her with more coordination and proprioception. [93] Exhibit J. The applicant states that she was unaware of the existence of the reports of Dr Hatcher. Dr Bartlett states that he does not recall giving a referral to Dr Hatcher although the reports appear to have been written to Dr Bartlett on the basis that he has given a referral. That may well have been the case because the applicant stated that she saw Dr Hatcher at the suggestion of a physiotherapist. The admission of the reports is now a matter of contention. In final submissions, the applicant contends that “strident objections” were taken to the tendering of the reports of Dr Hatcher. However, the reports of Dr Hatcher were admitted into evidence without objection at the hearing on 9 November 2011.[94] I informed the applicant that having known of the reports I would nevertheless have called for the reports having regard to the inquisitorial nature of the Tribunal.[95] The reports of Dr Hatcher were commissioned by the applicant soon after the reviewable decisions were made and were the considered reports of a specialist who had investigated her condition. There was no statutory obstacle to the admission of the reports; it is well‑known that a provision such as s 66(1) of the Act does not bind the respondent.[96] The reports of Dr Hatcher were in the summonsed papers of Dr Bartlett which were available for inspection prior to the hearing. Indeed, counsel for the applicant had stated that he had inspected the summonsed papers[97] and would have seen the reports of Dr Hatcher. [94] Transcript, 9 November 2011, P-42 – P-43.[95] Transcript, 9 November 2011, P-48.[96] Re Moline and Comcare [2003] AATA 827 at [5].[97] Transcript, 9 November 2011, P-48, L22.