Patel (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

Patel (Migration) [2023] AATA 496 (13 March 2023)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANTS:  Mr Mayankkumar Mukeshbhai Patel
Mrs Janakibahen Mayankkumar Patel

REPRESENTATIVE:  Mr Nilesh Nandan

CASE NUMBER:  2216459

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          BCC2021/334759

MEMBER:K. Chapman

DATE:13 March 2023

PLACE OF DECISION:  Brisbane

DECISION:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a decision not to cancel the first named applicant’s Subclass 187 - Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme visa.

The Tribunal has no jurisdiction with respect to the other applicant.

Statement made on 13 March 2023 at 4:19pm  

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs, on 9 November 2022, to cancel the first named applicant’s Subclass 187 - Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme visa, under s 109(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’).

  2. The delegate cancelled the visa on the basis that the first named applicant had not complied with s 101(b) and s 103 of the Act. The delegate determined, respectively, that the applicant provided incorrect answers in his Subclass 187 visa application pertaining to his work experience and employment, in addition to providing a bogus English language test result and bogus employment related documentation. On 10 November 2022, the applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the visa cancellation decision, providing a copy of that decision with his application.

  3. On 14 October 2022, the applicant was issued with a Notice of Intention to Consider Cancellation (NOICC) of his Subclass 187 visa, on the basis that he failed to comply with s 101(b) and s 103 of the Act. The Tribunal notes this NOICC replaced an earlier version dated 14 June 2022. The applicant responded to the earlier version of the NOICC, denying any wrongdoing. The delegate took that as the response for the purposes of the operative NOICC, given no further information was submitted in relation to the latter. On 9 November 2022, the delegate cancelled the applicant’s Subclass 187 visa.

  4. For the purposes of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction, the only decision that is before it is that with respect to the first named applicant (hereafter ‘the applicant’). The other visa was automatically cancelled as a consequence of that cancellation, not by a decision but by force of the operation of s 140(1) of the Act. As no decision was involved in the visa cancellation under s 140(1), the Tribunal has no jurisdiction with respect to the other applicant.

  5. The Tribunal initially scheduled a review hearing for 17 January 2023. Shortly thereafter, the applicant requested a postponement of the hearing, so as to obtain representation. In due course, the applicant appointed a solicitor (‘the representative) to assist him and the hearing was rescheduled for 8 February 2023. Additionally, on 6 January 2023, the Tribunal wrote to the applicant inviting his comment upon the validity of a non-disclosure certificate, issued pursuant to s 375A of the Act, dated 15 November 2022.

  6. In early February 2023, the representative submitted pre-hearing material. This…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Patel (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 496
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal reviewed a decision to cancel the Subclass 187 Regional Sponsored Migration Scheme visa held by Mr. Patel. The dispute arose from allegations that Mr. Patel provided false information and bogus documents in his visa applications, specifically concerning his English language test results and employment history. The Tribunal considered the evidence presented by both Mr. Patel and the Department of Home Affairs.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr. Patel had failed to comply with the requirements of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) by providing incorrect answers and bogus documents in his visa applications, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled. The Tribunal was required to determine if the delegate had properly formed the necessary state of mind to issue a notice under section 107 of the Act and if the notice itself complied with statutory requirements. Furthermore, the Tribunal had to consider the best interests of Mr. Patel's Australian citizen child as a primary consideration in its decision-making process.

The Tribunal found that Mr. Patel had engaged in a sustained dishonest course of conduct, including falsifying his English language ability and employment history, which was central to his Subclass 187 visa application. The Tribunal was satisfied that Mr. Patel had made false declarations regarding his employment with RUDRA Computers in India and Sparkle Technologies in Australia, and that he maintained these falsehoods when responding to the notice of intention to cancel. Despite the applicant's admission of "misstatement," the Tribunal viewed this as a manifest understatement of his dishonesty. However, the Tribunal gave significant weight to the best interests of Mr. Patel's Australian citizen son, who would face considerable hardship and be denied the opportunity to grow up in his country of nationality if the visa were cancelled. On balance, the Tribunal concluded that the circumstances weighing against cancellation, particularly the impact on the child, outweighed those in favour of cancellation.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision to cancel Mr. Patel's visa and determined that the discretion to cancel the visa should not be exercised.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

By virtue of s 107A of the Act, the possible non-compliances that may be specified pursuant to s 107 include non-compliances in respect of any previous visa held by a person. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEDid the notice comply with the requirements in s 107 of the Act? Section 107 of the Act is only engaged if the Minister or delegate considers that the visa holder has not complied with one of the provisions mentioned in s 107(1). It is only then that the Minister or delegate is entitled to give notice to the visa holder under s 107. Therefore, if a notice is to be given under s 107, the Minister or delegate must have reached a state of mind where they consider that the visa holder has not complied with one or more of the relevant provisions. The Tribunal notes that the NOICC dated 14 October 2022 was properly sent to the applicant. The Tribunal has considered the validity of the NOICC. The Tribunal is satisfied that it contains sufficient particulars to enable the applicant to identify and address the issues. Further, the Tribunal is also satisfied that the delegate had reached the necessary state of mind to engage the provisions of s 107 of the Act. Therefore, in the present matter, the Tribunal is satisfied that the delegate had reached the necessary state of mind to engage s 107 of the Act and that the notice issued under s 107 of the Act complied with the statutory requirements.Was there non-compliance as described in the s 107 notice? The Tribunal must consider whether there was non-compliance in the way described in the s 107 notice, being the manner particularised in the notice, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled. The non-compliance identified and particularised in the s 107 notice was non-compliance with s 101(b) and s 103 of the Act. The s 107 notice particularises possible non-compliance with s 101(b) of the Act by the applicant in relation to the following matters. In his Subclass 187 visa application of 14 November 2019, and associated documentation, the applicant falsely declared he was employed as a Software Engineer by RUDRA Computers in India from 10 October 2013 to 22 July 2017. The applicant also falsely declared, in his submitted Form 80, that he commenced working at Sparkle Technologies in Nerang, Queensland from November 2019. The Department conducted investigative activities in both India and Australia that determined the falsity of the applicant’s claims. In an unsworn statement dated 1 February 2023, the applicant conceded to his work experience being ‘misstated’ to the Department. In the view of the Tribunal, such characterisation is a manifest understatement. This is particularly so given the centrality of the applicant’s work experience to the Subclass 187 visa criteria. At the review hearing, the Tribunal canvassed in detail the degree of such ‘misstatement’ with the applicant. He admitted to the Tribunal that he did not perform the declared work with RUDRA Computers in India or Sparkle Technologies in Nerang. He also admitted he maintained these falsehoods when responding to the NOICC.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal has carefully considered the application to this matter of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (CROC) and as is relevant to the family unit the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). The Tribunal acknowledges that ‘the best interests of the child’ must be treated as a primary consideration by administrative decision makers. Accordingly, the Tribunal has done so in this matter and elevates the weight afforded to the evidence, detailed above, which is suggestive of hardship being faced by the applicant and his Australian citizen son, which weighs against cancellation of the visa. With respect to the hardship faced by the applicant’s son if the visa is cancelled, the Tribunal affords strong weight against cancellation of the visa. With respect to the applicant’s daughter, who resides in India, the Tribunal affords moderate weight against cancellation of the visa, given the loss of remittance income that would result from such cancellation. On balance, the Tribunal notes it is satisfied that the family unit would remain intact, even if the applicant’s visa was cancelled. For completeness, the Tribunal also notes that the primary consideration in relation to children may be balanced against other considerations, a matter to which it shall later return. The Tribunal further notes there are no other relevant matters to be considered in this review. CONCLUSION The Tribunal has carefully reflected upon the circumstances both against, and in favour of, cancelling the applicant’s Subclass 187 visa. For reasons previously expressed, the Tribunal finds that the applicant engaged in a sustained dishonest course of conduct to falsify his English language ability and employment history, with respect to his Subclass 500 and Subclass 187 visa applications. The applicant’s deception enabled him and his wife to enter Australia, when they had no genuine right to do so. His conduct is most egregious. Further, the Tribunal is satisfied the second named applicant participated in her portion of the visa applications with knowledge of her husband’s dishonesty. The Tribunal does not accept the applicant is a contrite person, rather he presents as a person who is sorry his conduct came to light, through the ‘dob in’ material that prompted a thorough Departmental investigation. The persistent dishonesty of the applicant strikes at the heart of the integrity of Australia’s migration program. It is a very serious matter indeed, in the view of the Tribunal. However, the Tribunal is cognisant that ‘the best interests of the child’ is a primary consideration, which in the applicant’s case weighs strongly against cancelling his visa. In particular, the applicant has an Australian citizen son who was born in this country. Should the applicant’s visa be cancelled this child will, by necessity, need to relocate to India for many years. Practically, the applicant’s Australian citizen son would be denied the opportunity to grow up in his country of nationality if the Subclass 187 visa was cancelled. The Tribunal notes that there are other factors weighing against cancellation of the visa, as previously outlined. However, it is the Australian citizenship of the applicant’s son, in combination with the hardship he would face if removed from his country of birth, that leads the Tribunal not to exercise the discretion to cancel the visa in this very finely balanced review. Therefore, on balance, following much consideration, the Tribunal finds that the circumstances against cancelling the applicant’s visa outweigh those circumstances to the contrary.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal has no jurisdiction with respect to the other applicant. K. ChapmanMemberATTACHMENT – Migration Act 1958 (extracts)5Interpretation(1)In this Act, unless the contrary intention appears:bogus document, in relation to a person, means a document that the Minister reasonably suspects is a document that:(a) purports to have been, but was not, issued in respect of the person; or(b) is counterfeit or has been altered by a person who does not have authority to do so; or(c) was obtained because of a false or misleading statement, whether or not made knowingly.97InterpretationIn this Subdivision:application form, in relation to a non‑citizen, means a form on which a non‑citizen applies for a visa, being a form that regulations made for the purposes of section 46 allow to be used for making the application.passenger card has the meaning given by subsection 506(2) and, for the purposes of section 115, includes any document provided for by regulations under paragraph 504(1)(c).Note:Bogus document is defined in subsection 5(1).98Completion of visa applicationA non‑citizen who does not fill in his or her application form or passenger card is taken to do so if he or she causes it to be filled in or if it is otherwise filled in on his or her behalf.99Information is answerAny information that a non‑citizen gives or provides, causes to be given or provided, or that is given or provided on his or her behalf, to the Minister, an officer, an authorised system, a person or the Tribunal, or the Immigration Assessment authority, reviewing a decision under this Act in relation to the non‑citizen’s application for a visa is taken for the purposes of section 100, paragraphs 101(b) and 102(b) and sections 104 and 105 to be an answer to a question in the non‑citizen’s application form, whether the information is given or provided orally or in writing and whether at an interview or otherwise.100Incorrect answersFor the purposes of this Subdivision, an answer to a question is incorrect even though the person who gave or provided the answer, or caused the answer to be given or provided, did not know that it was incorrect.101Visa applications to be correctA non‑citizen must fill in or complete his or her application form in such a way that:(a)all questions on it are answered; and(b)no incorrect answers are given or provided.103Bogus documents not to be given etc.A non‑citizen must not give, present, [produce]* or provide to an officer, an authorised system, the Minister, the Immigration Assessment Authority, or the Tribunal performing a function or purpose under this Act, a bogus document or cause such a document to be so given, presented, [produced]* or provided.* This wording applies to documents given, presented, produced or provided on or after 4 November 2014: Schedule 7 to Counter Terrorism Legislation Amendment (Foreign Fighters) Act 2014 (No.116, 2014).107Notice of incorrect applications(1)If the Minister considers that the holder of a visa who has been immigration cleared (whether or not because of that visa) did not comply with section 101, 102, 103, 104 or 105 or with subsection (2) in a response to a notice under this section, the Minister may give the holder a notice:(a) giving particulars of the possible non‑compliance; and(b) stating that, within a period stated in the notice as mentioned in subsection (1A), the holder may give the Minister a written response to the notice that:(i)if the holder disputes that there was non‑compliance:(A)shows that there was compliance; and(B)in case the Minister decides under section 108 that, in spite of the statement under sub‑subparagraph (A), there was non‑compliance—shows cause why the visa should not be cancelled; or(ii)if the holder accepts that there was non‑compliance:(A)give reasons for the non‑compliance; and(B)shows cause why the visa should not be cancelled; and(c) stating that the Minister will consider cancelling the visa:(i)if the holder gives the Minister oral or written notice, within the period stated as mentioned in subsection (1A), that he or she will not give a written response—when that notice is given; or(ii)if the holder gives the Minister a written response within that period—when the response is given; or(iii)otherwise—at the end of that period; and(d) setting out the effect of sections 108, 109, 111 and 112; and(e) informing the holder that the holder’s obligations under section 104 or 105 are not affected by the notice under this section; and(f) requiring the holder:(i)to tell the Minister the address at which the holder is living; and(ii)if the holder changes that address before the Minister notifies the holder of the Minister’s decision on whether there was non‑compliance by the holder—to tell the Minister the changed address.(1A)The period to be stated in the notice under subsection (1) must be:(a) in respect of the holder of a temporary visa—the period prescribed by the regulations or, if no period is prescribed, a reasonable period; or(b) otherwise—14 days.(1B)Regulations prescribing a period for the purposes of paragraph (1A)(a) may prescribe different periods and state when a particular period is to apply, which, without limiting the generality of the power, may be to:(a) visas of a stated class; or(b) visa holders in stated circumstances; or(c) visa holders in a stated class of people (who may be visa holders in a particular place); or(d) visa holders in a stated class of people (who may be visa holders in a particular place) in stated circumstances.(2)If the visa holder responds to the notice, he or she must do so without making any incorrect statement.108Decision about non‑complianceThe Minister is to:(a)consider any response given by a visa holder in the way required by paragraph 107(1)(b); and(b)decide whether there was non‑compliance by the visa holder in the way described in the notice.109Cancellation of visa if information incorrect(1)The Minister, after:(a) deciding under section 108 that there was non‑compliance by the holder of a visa; and(b) considering any response to the notice about the non‑compliance given in a way required by paragraph 107(1)(b); and(c) having regard to any prescribed circumstances;may cancel the visa.(2)If the Minister may cancel a visa under subsection (1), the Minister must do so if there exist circumstances declared by the regulations to be circumstances in which a visa must be cancelled.