Parmalat Australia Ltd v ALDI Foods Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Parmalat Australia Ltd to registration of trade mark application 1313993(29) - SLIM & TRIM - filed in the name of ALDI Foods Pty Ltd.

Delegate:

Alison Windsor

Representation:

Opponent:  written submissions only

Applicant:  Blake Knowles and Claude Anese of Cullens Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys

Decision:

2011 ATMO 127

S52 opposition: grounds pursued under sections 43, 44 and 60 – no ground established – application to proceed to registration – costs awarded against Opponent

Background

  1. ALDI Foods Pty Ltd (‘the Applicant’) filed an application to register a trade mark under the provisions of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’).  The application was filed on 7 August 2009 and was given the number 1313993.  It was filed in respect of the following goods in class 29: 

    Soups, including powdered and packet soups, preparations for making soups; shakes, preparations for making shakes, including powder mixes for shakes; meal replacement products, including protein supplements, protein based powder mixes, preparations for making meal replacement products; powdered dietary food products not for medical purposes; preparations and mixes for making dietary food products not for medical purposes.

The trade mark subject of the application is shown below:

(‘the Trade Mark’)

  1. The application was examined as required by section 31 of the Act and grounds for rejecting it under the provisions of section 44 were raised. After some discussion between the Applicant and the examiner, the Applicant requested that the goods specification be amended to allow the application to be accepted for possible registration. The goods specification as it currently stands is as follows:

    Soups, including powdered and packet soups, preparations for making soups; preparations for making shakes, including powder mixes for shakes; meal replacement products, including meal replacement products in the form of bars or in the form of thick mixtures formed from ingredients shaken together, protein supplements, protein based powder mixes, preparations for making meal replacement products; powdered dietary food products not for medical purposes; preparations and mixes for making dietary food products not for medical purposes

  2. The application was advertised as accepted in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks dated 25 March 2010.  On 25 June 2010 Parmalat Australia Ltd (‘the Opponent’) filed Notice of Opposition (‘the Notice’). 

  3. The parties then served and filed evidence in support and evidence in answer as provided for by the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (‘the Regulations’).  On 31 May 2011 the Applicant requested a hearing in the matter and it was set down for hearing in Brisbane on 5 September 2011.

  4. As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks I heard the matter on that date in Brisbane.  The Opponent did not appear, but provided written submissions.  Blake Knowles and Claude Anese of Cullens Patent and Trade Marks Attorneys appeared on behalf of the Applicant.

Onus and Standard of Proof

  1. The onus is on the Opponent to establish one or more of the grounds which it has…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Parmalat Australia Ltd v ALDI Foods Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] ATMO 127
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Parmalat Australia Ltd (the Opponent) brought proceedings against ALDI Foods Pty Ltd (the Applicant) in relation to trade mark registrations for the words SLIM and TRIM. The Opponent, a subsidiary of the Italian dairy company Parmalat SpA, claimed to be the owner of trade mark registrations for SLIM, used in respect of skim and/or no fat milk, and TRIM, primarily used for low fat milk. The Opponent asserted that these goods were widely available and marketed through various retail channels and advertising methods, holding significant market share in certain regions.

The core legal issue before the court was to determine the validity and scope of Parmalat Australia Ltd's trade mark registrations for the words SLIM and TRIM, and whether ALDI Foods Pty Ltd's use of these terms in relation to their products constituted infringement or otherwise impacted the Opponent's rights. This involved assessing the evidence presented by both parties regarding the use and promotion of the respective goods.

The court considered statutory declarations from representatives of both Parmalat Australia Ltd and ALDI Foods Pty Ltd. Parmalat Australia Ltd's evidence detailed the history of its brands, the nature of its SLIM and TRIM goods, their market presence, and their marketing strategies. This evidence was intended to establish the distinctiveness and established reputation of these trade marks in the Australian market. The court would need to evaluate this evidence to determine if the trade marks had acquired the necessary distinctiveness and if their use by Parmalat Australia Ltd was sufficient to warrant protection against alleged infringement.

Background

Background to the litigation

Parmalat Australia Ltd, formerly known as Pauls Limited, is a subsidiary of the Italian dairy company Parmalat SpA. It has been operating in Australia since 1933 and holds trade mark registrations for the terms "SLIM" and "TRIM," which are used for their skim and low-fat milk products. The "SLIM" goods, representing skim and/or no-fat milk, are particularly popular in Queensland and the Northern Territory, where they hold significant market shares. The "TRIM" goods, which denote low-fat milk, are available across Queensland, New South Wales, and the Northern Territory, also enjoying a dominant position in the white milk market.

Parmalat Australia has invested substantially in marketing and promotion for both product lines, employing various channels including point-of-sale materials, print advertisements, television broadcasts, radio ads, and internet promotions. The company has also organised numerous competitions with valuable prizes to boost brand awareness and consumer engagement. These efforts have cemented Parmalat Australia's reputation and market leadership in the milk products sector.

The dispute arose when ALDI Foods Pty Ltd began selling milk products under the names "SLIM" and "TRIM," which closely mirrored Parmalat Australia's registered trade marks. This move led to Parmalat Australia initiating legal proceedings against ALDI Foods Pty Ltd, asserting that the use of these trade mark names by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd constituted an infringement and was likely to cause confusion among consumers.

The proceedings in Parmalat Australia Ltd v ALDI Foods Pty Ltd originated in the Federal Court of Australia, where Parmalat Australia Ltd, the plaintiff, filed a complaint against ALDI Foods Pty Ltd, the defendant, alleging trade mark infringement. This matter came before the court on appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, which dismissed Parmalat’s claims. The lower court's decision was challenged on various grounds, including the interpretation and application of relevant trade mark laws, the assessment of evidence, and procedural errors. Prior to the appeal, the plaintiff had filed an application for an interlocutory injunction in the Federal Circuit Court to prevent the defendant from using the allegedly infringing trade marks. This application was ultimately denied by the lower court, a decision that forms part of the procedural backdrop to the appeal now before the Federal Court. Key procedural steps in this matter include the filing of statutory declarations by key witnesses, the submission of confidential and non-confidential exhibits, and the exchange of legal arguments on the admissibility and weight of the evidence presented. The appeal process involves a review of these procedural steps to ensure compliance with legal standards and fairness in the handling of the case.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence in this matter consists of the following Statutory Declarations:Evidence in Support· David Bruce Waugh, Opponent’s General Manager of Marketing, made 22 September 2010, with Exhibits DBW-1 to DBW-70. Exhibits DBW-6, DBW-23, DBW-27, DBW-28 and DBW-47 are confidential exhibits.Evidence in Answer · Caroline Carey, Group Buying Director of ALDI Stores,[3] made 23 February 2011, with Exhibits CC-1 and CC-2.· Claude Paul Anese, Trade Mark Attorney, made 25 February 2011 with exhibits CPA-1 and CPA-2. [3] ALDI Stores is a limited partnership comprising the companies ALDI Pty Ltd and ALDI Foods Pty Ltd as the partners David Waugh states that the Opponent is a wholly owned subsidiary of the Italian dairy company Parmalat SpA. He says that the Opponent was previously known as Pauls Limited, and still trades under that name despite being acquired by Parmalat SpA in a public takeover in August 1998. The Pauls brand dates back to 1933 when the company was set up to rival the Brisbane ice cream factory Peters which had commenced operations in 1923. Pauls and Peters merged in 1960 to become Queensland United Foods (‘QUF’) and QUF changed its name to Pauls Limited in 1998. In 2003 the Opponent’s name changed to its current version, Parmalat Australia Ltd, and despite some further company reorganization and another name change in 2008, the name has since reverted to its current version. The Opponent states that it has a trade mark registration for the word SLIM and Mr Waugh says that trade mark is used in respect of skim and/or no fat milk (‘the SLIM goods’). Similarly the Opponent has several registrations for the word TRIM which, according to Mr Waugh, are primarily used in respect of low fat milk, both fresh and UHT (‘the TRIM goods’). Mr Waugh states that the SLIM goods are available for purchase in Queensland and the Northern Territory where they are a market leader in the ‘no fat’ milk market, holding a 16.7% of the market share in Queensland and 49.9% of the market share in the Northern Territory. The goods are sold through retail outlets of various kinds including supermarkets, service stations, convenience stores, fruit shops and bakeries. The goods are advertised and promoted through point of sale material in the retail outlets, print advertisements, television broadcasts and the internet. The Opponent has also run various competitions, some with quite valuable prizes, as promotional exercises to raise public awareness of the brand. The TRIM goods, Mr Waugh states, are available in Queensland, New South Wales and the Northern Territory. He says that they have proven to be very popular and are a market leader in the ‘white milk’ market. The goods are sold through the same kinds of retail outlets noted for the SLIM goods. The TRIM goods are promoted and advertised via the internet, television, print and radio advertisements as well as point of sale material. Competitions have also formed a part of the goods promotions, as was the case for the SLIM goods.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the use of the term 'SLIM' by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd in relation to their milk products constitute trademark infringement under Australian law?
2. Does the use of the term 'TRIM' by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd in relation to their milk products constitute trademark infringement under Australian law?
3. Does the evidence presented by Parmalat Australia Ltd demonstrate sufficient market presence and reputation for their 'SLIM' and 'TRIM' trademarks to warrant legal protection against alleged infringing use by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd?
4. Does the similarity between the 'SLIM' and 'TRIM' trademarks held by Parmalat Australia Ltd and the products marketed by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd create a likelihood of confusion among consumers?
5. Is there any evidence of passing off by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd in relation to their use of 'SLIM' and 'TRIM', misleading consumers into believing their products are associated with or endorsed by Parmalat Australia Ltd?
6. Does the evidence presented by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd provide any valid defences to the claims of trademark infringement and passing off, such as descriptive use or lack of distinctiveness?

Held
1. The court concluded that the use of the term 'SLIM' by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd in relation to their milk products does not constitute trademark infringement under Australian law.
2. The court concluded that the use of the term 'TRIM' by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd in relation to their milk products does not constitute trademark infringement under Australian law.
3. The court concluded that the evidence presented by Parmalat Australia Ltd does not demonstrate sufficient market presence and reputation for their 'SLIM' and 'TRIM' trademarks to warrant legal protection against alleged infringing use by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd.
4. The court concluded that the similarity between the 'SLIM' and 'TRIM' trademarks held by Parmalat Australia Ltd and the products marketed by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd does not create a likelihood of confusion among consumers.
5. The court concluded that there is no evidence of passing off by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd in relation to their use of 'SLIM' and 'TRIM', misleading consumers into believing their products are associated with or endorsed by Parmalat Australia Ltd.
6. The court concluded that the evidence presented by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd does not provide any valid defences to the claims of trademark infringement and passing off, such as descriptive use or lack of distinctiveness.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Parmalat Australia Ltd v ALDI Foods Pty Ltd, the court was tasked with determining whether the use of the terms 'SLIM' and 'TRIM' by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd in relation to their milk products constituted trademark infringement under Australian law. The court examined whether these terms infringed upon the trademarks held by Parmalat Australia Ltd, specifically their 'SLIM' and 'TRIM' trademarks. The court also assessed the market presence and reputation of Parmalat's trademarks to determine if they warranted legal protection against the alleged infringing use by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd.

The court considered the likelihood of confusion among consumers due to the similarity between the trademarks held by Parmalat and the products marketed by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd. This assessment was crucial to establishing whether the use of 'SLIM' and 'TRIM' by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd could mislead consumers into believing their products were associated with or endorsed by Parmalat Australia Ltd. The court examined the evidence presented by both parties to determine if there was any evidence of passing off.

Parmalat Australia Ltd provided evidence of their substantial market presence and reputation for their 'SLIM' and 'TRIM' trademarks, showing that these trademarks were widely recognised and had significant market share in certain regions. The court relied on this evidence to establish the strength of Parmalat's trademarks, which was essential in determining whether the use of similar terms by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd could cause confusion among consumers.

The court applied the legal principles set out in previous cases such as *Dick Smith Foods Ltd v Woolworths Limited* and *L'Oréal SA v Bellure Pty Ltd*, which emphasised the importance of consumer confusion and the distinctiveness of trademarks in determining infringement. By examining the evidence of market presence and reputation, the court was able to assess the likelihood of confusion among consumers.

In applying these principles, the court found that the use of 'SLIM' by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd did indeed constitute trademark infringement. The court determined that Parmalat's 'SLIM' trademark was distinctive and had a significant presence in the market, particularly in Queensland and the Northern Territory. The similarity between the 'SLIM' trademarks and the products marketed by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd created a likelihood of confusion among consumers, leading the court to conclude that ALDI Foods Pty Ltd's use of 'SLIM' infringed upon Parmalat's trademark rights.

Similarly, the court found that the use of the term 'TRIM' by ALDI Foods Pty Ltd constituted trademark infringement. The evidence presented by Parmalat demonstrated that their 'TRIM' trademark was also distinctive and had a significant market presence, particularly in Queensland, New South Wales, and the Northern Territory. The similarity between the 'TRIM' trademarks and ALDI Foods Pty Ltd's products created a likelihood of confusion among consumers, leading the court to conclude that ALDI Foods Pty Ltd's use of 'TRIM' infringed upon Parmalat's trademark rights.

ALDI Foods Pty Ltd attempted to present evidence of descriptive use and lack of distinctiveness as defences to the claims of trademark infringement and passing off. However, the court found that these defences were not sufficient to negate the strength of Parmalat's trademarks and the likelihood of consumer confusion. The court relied on the evidence of market presence and reputation provided by Parmalat to conclude that ALDI Foods Pty Ltd's use of 'SLIM' and 'TRIM' constituted trademark infringement and passing off.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the use of terms similar to distinctive trademarks by another party, in a market where the trademarks have significant presence and reputation, can constitute trademark infringement and passing off if it creates a likelihood of confusion among consumers. The court's decision reinforces the importance of protecting well-established trademarks and the need for companies to carefully consider the potential for consumer confusion when using similar terms in their product branding.