Pace v Westpac Banking Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:                Pace & Ors v Westpac Banking Corporation [2001] QSC

415

PARTIES:                     RENO PACE

(Plaintiff)

&

MARIO ANTHONY PACE

(Second Plaintiff)

and

PAUL MICHAEL PACE

(Third Plaintiff)

and

JOSEPHINE PACE

(Fourth Plaintiff)

v

WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION

(Defendant)

FILE NO:  S135/2000

DIVISION:                   Trial Division

DELIVERED ON:       29 October 2001

DELIVERED AT:        Mackay

HEARING DATE:          4th, 5th, 6th and 8th June, 25th and 26th July 2001.

JUDGE:   Dutney J

ORDERS:It is ordered that the defendant be permanently restrained from seeking to recover any part of the debt owed by the plaintiffs on account 20-1333 pursuant to any personal covenant the bank may have in relation thereto.  It is  further ordered that the mortgages in favour of the defendant over the land being lot 12 on Registered Plan 908019 and Lot 11 on registered Plan 908019 be released by the defendant at its expense.  The defendant is to pay damages to the plaintiffs assessed at

$173616.51 together with interest at 10% from 30

June 1999 in the sum of $40504.73.  On the counterclaim it is declared that the amount owing to the bank on account 20-1333 as at 26 July 2001 was $415,018.44.

2

CATCHWORDS:           CONTRACT – Whether buying englobo land in reliance on a statement by bank manager that the bank would finance a proposed subdivision gives rise to an enforceable contract.

TRADE PRACTICES - MISLEADING AND DECEPTIVE CONDUCT – whether statements misleading or deceptive – At what stage does the claim arise – At what time should damages be assessed – whether claim statute barred.

NEGLIGENCE – MIS-STATEMENT – Whether reliance on statements of bank’s employee was reasonable – Whether damage was a foreseeable outcome of reliance.

ESTOPPEL – Whether elements of estoppel present. DAMAGES – NEGLIGENCE – TRADE PRACTICES ACT - MITITIGATION - Time at which damages should be assessed – returning plaintiff to original position – Whether reasonable steps taken – Whether 12 months a reasonable period to attempt to sell property

Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Peat Marwick Hungerford (1996-1997) 188 CLR 241 – applied. Hawkins v Clayton (1988) 164 CLR 539 – applied. Kenny & Good Pty Ltd v MGICA (1992) Ltd (1999)

199 CLR 413 – referred to.

San Sebastion Pty Ltd v The Minister (1986) 162 CLR

340 – applied.

Waltons Stores (Interstate) Pty Ltd v Maher (1987-

1988) 164 CLR 387 – applied.

Wardley Australia Ltd v Western Australia (1992) 175

CLR 514 – referred to.

Water Board v Moustakis (1988) 180 CLR 491 –

applied.

Trade Practices Act (Cth) 1974 ss80, 82 and 87.

COUNSEL:   P Land for the Plaintiffs

D Savage for the Defendant

SOLICITORS:              S R Wallace and Wallace for the Plaintiffs

Corrs Chambers Westgarth for the Defendant

3

  1. Dutney J:  The first and third plaintiffs are brothers. Both were born in Malta. The  first  plaintiff  speaks  English  reasonably  well.    The  third  plaintiff  has enough English to cope with everyday life in Australia but plainly found the demands  of  giving  evidence  and  being  cross-examined  difficult.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pace v Westpac Banking Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QSC 415
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Pace v Westpac Banking Corporation was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The plaintiffs, Reno Pace, Mario Pace, Paul Michael Pace, and Josephine Pace, brought a claim against Westpac Banking Corporation for misrepresentation and misleading conduct in relation to a promise by a bank officer that the bank would finance a proposed subdivision. The plaintiffs sought damages for losses incurred in reliance on the promise. The bank counterclaimed for monies owing on an account. The court found in favour of the plaintiffs and ordered Westpac to be permanently restrained from seeking to recover any part of the debt owed by the plaintiffs. The court also ordered the bank to release mortgages over two properties and to pay damages to the plaintiffs. The court found that the bank officer had no authority to make the promise but that the plaintiffs were entitled to rely on his assurance. The representations were found to be misleading or deceptive and a breach of the Trade Practices Act. The plaintiffs were awarded damages of $213,634.95 plus interest. The court also granted relief under section 87 of the Trade Practices Act to put the plaintiffs in the position they would have been in had the offending conduct not occurred.

Background

Background to the litigation

In 1991, Reno and Paul Pace, along with their brother Emmanuel, purchased a 100-acre block of land at Olletts Road, Habana, with savings. They sought a loan from Westpac to subdivide the land for resale. The bank agreed to lend them $100,000 secured over the Olletts Road land and later $150,000 to purchase another block at Habana known as Medina Heights. The subdivision on the Olletts Road land was completed in 1992, and the brothers repaid the loans from the proceeds. In 1995, the brothers decided to subdivide about half of the Medina Heights land into ten 5-acre blocks for resale. They approached Westpac's local business manager, Mr. Terry Seay, for finance to complete the subdivision. Initially, an overdraft of $25,000 was approved, but a subsequent request for $497,000 was declined pending further information. Despite the initial refusal, Mr. Seay eventually assured the brothers that the bank would lend the required amount. The Medina Heights subdivision was completed in about February 1997, and three of the ten blocks were presold. In January 1997, Reno Pace discussed purchasing another block of land at 3 Olletts Road with Mr. Seay. He signed a contract to purchase the land "subject to finance" and sought financing for the purchase and subdivision. Mr. Seay assured Reno that the bank would provide the necessary finance. In March 1997, all the plaintiffs attended a meeting where Mr. Seay confirmed that the bank would lend the required amount. The plaintiffs proceeded with the subdivision proposal until June 1999 when the bank refused to lend further funds.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of Queensland as a first-instance hearing. The case was heard over several days in June and July 2001. The primary judge, Dutney J, delivered the judgment on 29 October 2001.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether buying en bloc land in reliance on a statement by the bank manager that the bank would finance a proposed subdivision gives rise to an enforceable contract.
2. Whether the bank's statements were misleading or deceptive under the Trade Practices Act.
3. Whether the bank's statements constituted negligence.
4. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to relief based on estoppel.

Held
1. Buying en bloc land in reliance on a statement by the bank manager that the bank would finance a proposed subdivision does not give rise to an enforceable contract.
2. The bank's statements were misleading or deceptive under the Trade Practices Act.
3. The bank's statements constituted negligence.
4. The plaintiffs are not entitled to relief based on estoppel.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court found that while the bank manager's statements did not create an enforceable contract, the plaintiffs were reasonable in relying on them given their limited business experience and lack of access to capital. The Court held that the bank manager's statements were misleading or deceptive as they gave an unwarranted impression of the bank's preparedness to lend for the subdivision. The Court also found that the bank's conduct constituted negligence as the bank manager knew or ought to have known that the plaintiffs would rely on his statements, and it was reasonable for them to do so. The Court distinguished this case from mere non-fulfilment of a promise, finding that the bank manager's statements implied that the proposed subdivision met the bank's lending criteria. However, the Court held that the bank should not be estopped from denying its right to decline the plaintiffs' finance application because there was no binding promise made. The Court ordered that the bank be permanently restrained from seeking to recover any part of the debt owed by the plaintiffs on account 20-1333 pursuant to any personal covenant the bank may have in relation thereto, and the mortgages in favour of the defendant over the land being lot 12 on Registered Plan 908019 and Lot 11 on registered Plan 908019 be released by the defendant at its expense. The Court also ordered the defendant to pay damages to the plaintiffs assessed at $173,616.51 together with interest at 10% from 30 June 1999 in the sum of $40,504.73.