Ozcan v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MERIT REVIEWER
CITATION: Ozcan v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited [2023] NSWPICMR 54
CLAIMANT: Tolgahan Ozcan
INSURER: QBE
MERIT REVIEWER: Katherine Ruschen
DATE OF DECISION: 18 October 2023
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; dispute about weekly payment of statutory benefits under division 3.3; dispute about pre-accident weekly earnings; when first began to earn continuously; schedule 1, clause 4(2)(a); meaning of earning continuously clause 4(4); whether earnings likely to be received on same or similar basis for at least 6 months; section 6.24; evidence in support of contention; validity of claim; Held – remitted to insurer for redetermination.

DETERMINATIONS MADE: 

CERTIFICATE

Issued under s 7.13(4) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017

DETERMINATION
The reviewable decision is about the amount of weekly payments of statutory benefits that are payable under Division 3.3 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act) and is therefore a merit review matter under Schedule 2(1)(a) of the MAI Act.

1.      The determination is as follows:

(a)     the claimant’s gross earnings from Uber in the 12 month pre-accident period are $6,497.34;

(b)     the claimant is to provide the insurer with information and documents about any other earnings received in the 12 month period before the accident within a reasonable period of time;

(c)     the matter is remitted to the insurer for redetermination of the claimant’s pre-accident weekly earnings (PAWE) under cl 4(1) once the claimant has been provided with a reasonable opportunity to provide further information and documents about other earnings received in the period 19 April 2022 to 18 April 2023, and

(d) there is no jurisdiction to determine costs on the basis of exceptional circumstances under s 8.10 of the MAI Act.


STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. There is a dispute between Tolgahan Ozcan (the claimant) and the insurer about the amount of weekly payments of statutory benefits payable under Division 3.3 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act).

  2. The claimant was involved in a motor accident on 19 April 2023.

  3. The claimant made an application for personal injury benefits under the MAI Act.

  4. On 27 June 2023 the insurer determined that the claimant’s pre-accident weekly earnings (PAWE) amount was $462.66.

  5. The claimant requested an internal review of the insurer’s PAWE decision of 27 June 2023.

  6. On 13 July 2023 the insurer issued their internal review decision in which the insurer varied their PAWE decision to $664.52.

  1. The claimant has requested a merit review of the insurer’s internal review decision dated 13 July 2023.

SUBMISSIONS

  1. The claimant was a self-employed Uber delivery driver at the time of the motor accident. The claimant submits:

    (a)    the insurer failed to include all income received in the relevant pre-accident period;

    (b)    the insurer made an excessive allowance for business expenses compared to actual business expenses;

    (c)    Goods and Services Tax (GST) paid for services provided by the claimant represents earnings received by the claimant because he was not registered for GST, and

    (d) his PAWE falls…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ozcan v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPICMR 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Ozcan v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, the claimant sought a merit review of the insurer's internal review decision regarding the determination of the Pre-Accident Weekly Earnings (PAWE) for the purposes of receiving statutory benefits under the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017. The claimant, who was a self-employed Uber delivery driver at the time of the accident, disputed the insurer’s calculation of his PAWE, arguing that the insurer had failed to include all income received, made an excessive allowance for business expenses, and incorrectly treated Goods and Services Tax (GST) as earnings. The insurer defended its decision by relying on a report from Procare Forensic Services and argued that the claimant was not registered for GST and therefore, GST should not be considered as earnings. The central issues before the court were whether the claimant's business expenses were accurately accounted for, if GST should be considered as earnings, and whether the claimant began earning continuously at a specific point in time.

The court focused on the interpretation of the statutory provisions concerning PAWE and earnings. It determined that earnings received after the accident, even if for work performed before the accident, should not be included in the PAWE calculation. The court also examined the nature of GST and concluded that since the claimant was not registered for GST, it should not be included as earnings. Additionally, the court found that the claimant had not provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that he had earned continuously in the 12 months prior to the accident, thus the insurer's decision to apply Schedule 1, clause 4(1) rather than clause 4(2)(a) was upheld. The court noted that the claimant’s failure to provide English translations of Uber records, particularly those in Turkish, hindered a complete assessment of the claim.

The court concluded that the claimant's arguments regarding the inclusion of all income and the treatment of GST were not substantiated by the evidence presented. The court found that the insurer’s calculation of business expenses and the exclusion of post-accident earnings were consistent with the statutory requirements. Consequently, the court upheld the insurer’s determination that the claimant’s PAWE was $857.10 and remitted the matter back to the insurer for redetermination in light of the findings regarding the claimant’s continuous earnings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 13 July 2023 the insurer issued their internal review decision in which the insurer varied their PAWE decision to $664.52. The claimant has requested a merit review of the insurer’s internal review decision dated 13 July 2023. The claimant was a self-employed Uber delivery driver at the time of the motor accident. The claimant submits:(a) the insurer failed to include all income received in the relevant pre-accident period;(b) the insurer made an excessive allowance for business expenses compared to actual business expenses; (c) Goods and Services Tax (GST) paid for services provided by the claimant represents earnings received by the claimant because he was not registered for GST, and (d) his PAWE falls under Schedule 1, cl 4(2)(a) of the MAI Act on the basis he contends he was not earning continuously in the 12 month period before the motor accident, until 8 March 2023. The insurer relies on a report of Procare Forensic Services dated 20 June 2023 and submits:(a) pursuant to the Federal Court decision in Uber B.V. v Commissioner of Taxation [2017] FCA 110 GST the claimant is required to be registered for GST and GST therefore does not represent earnings received by the claimant, and(b) PAWE is $857.10, should cl 4(2)(a) apply, however, Schedule 1, cl 4(1) applies as the claimant was not earning continuously for the purpose of cl 4(2)(a) within the meaning of earning continuously in cl 4(4) of the MAI Act. The following issues arise:(a) the amount of the claimant’s business expenses in connection with his work as an Uber delivery driver;(b) whether GST represents earnings received as an earner for the purpose of PAWE, and(c) whether the claimant first began to earn continuously when he commenced earning as an Uber delivery driver in March 2023 such that cl 4(2)(a) applies to calculation of his PAWE or alternatively, whether cl 4(1) applies. Bank statements show a total of $7,233.11 received by the claimant from Uber in the period 8 March 2023 to 18 April 2023. The claimant appears to have included the sum of $424.84 in pre-accident Uber earnings. However, that sum was received by the claimant on 26 April 2023, which is after the accident. Clause 4 is clearly only concerned with earnings actually “received” by the claimant before the accident and not the date on which the work was carried out. Accordingly, earnings received after the accident, even if for work carried out before the accident, are excluded from PAWE. Service fees are payable to Uber but have been deducted by Uber before payment is made to the claimant. Accordingly, the amount deposited into the claimant’s account is inclusive of GST but net of the service fee. If toll fees are incurred, Uber would generally include reimbursement of same in payments made to the claimant’s bank account. Accordingly, these would need to be deducted as a business expense from the amounts received into the claimant’s bank account. It is unhelpful that the claimant has not provided the English translation for all Uber records, many of which are in Turkish. The statements likely could have been printed in English by first changing the language setting on the claimant’s Uber driver account. In any event, as best as can be discerned from the Turkish documents the claimant does not appear to have incurred toll fees.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established