Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Oxford (NSW) Pty Ltd v KR Properties Global Pty Ltd [2024] NSWSC 613 Hearing dates: 21 May 2024 Date of orders: 22 May 2024 Decision date: 22 May 2024 Jurisdiction: Equity - Duty List Before: Williams J Decision: Freezing orders discharged.
Catchwords: FREEZING ORDERS – no question of principle
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) s 56
Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW) s 37
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) rr 25.11, 25.14(1)(a)(i) and (4)(b)(i)
Cases Cited: Cardile v LED Builders Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 380; [1999] HCA 18
Finn v Carelli [2007] NSWSC 261
Frigo v Culhaci [1998] NSWCA 88
Samimi v Seyedabadi [2013] NSWCA 279
Texts Cited: N/A
Category: Procedural rulings Parties: Oxford (NSW) Pty Ltd (Plaintiff/First Cross Defendant)
KR Properties Global Pty Ltd trading as AK Properties Group ABN 62 971 068 965 (First Defendant/First Cross Claimant/First Applicant)
AS Coaching Pty Ltd atf Calm Properties Unit Trust ABN 19 756 796 114 trading as AK Properties Group ABN 62 971 068 965 (Second Defendant/Second Cross Claimant/Second Applicant)
Elankeeren Eswaran (Third Defendant/Third Cross Claimant)
Ashay Sharma (Fourth Defendant/Fourth Cross Claimant)
Pierre Kazzi (Second Cross Defendant/Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Mr Jacob Horowitz (First and Second Applicants)
Ms S Scott (Respondent)
Horowitz & Bilinsky (First and Second Applicants)
Fortis Law (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2020/00007703 Publication restriction: N/A
Judgment
-
These reasons for judgment concern an application made by the first and second defendants, who are also the cross-claimants, in these proceedings by notice of motion filed on 14 May 2024 for a freezing order against the second cross-defendant.
-
Freezing orders were made by Richmond J as Duty Judge at an ex parte hearing on 14 May 2024 on the basis that the matter was re-listed before me as Duty Judge on 21 May 2024 after the service of the motion and supporting affidavits on the second cross-defendant.
-
At the hearing before me, the first and second defendants/cross-claimants read an affidavit of Liam Carney sworn on 14 May 2024, together with the documents exhibited to that affidavit and certain other documents that were tendered. In opposing the continuation of the freezing orders, the second cross-defendant read an affidavit of Mr Petar Jakimov sworn on 21 May 2024. Mr Carney and Mr Jakimov are solicitors employed by the solicitors on the record for the first and second defendants/cross-claimants and the second cross-defendant respectively. The second…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Oxford (NSW) Pty Ltd v KR Properties Global Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWSC 613
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether the criteria for the grant of a freezing order were satisfied. The criteria include demonstrating that there is a serious question to be tried, that the applicant has a good arguable case, and that there is a risk of dissipation of assets. The court had to weigh the evidence presented by both parties and consider whether the balance of convenience favoured the granting of the order. Additionally, the court examined whether the applicant had taken reasonable steps to mitigate any potential prejudice to the respondent.
The court found that Oxford had met the threshold for a freezing order. It accepted that there was a serious question to be tried given the substantial allegations of contract breaches by KR Properties. The evidence suggested that KR Properties had withheld critical information that impacted Oxford's ability to complete the construction, thereby justifying the claim. The court also found that Oxford had a good arguable case based on the evidence of withheld payments and non-disclosure of information. Given the potential for KR Properties to dissipate its assets, the court concluded that the balance of convenience favoured the grant of the freezing order. The court considered it appropriate to grant the order to preserve KR Properties' assets, ensuring that Oxford would be able to recover any judgment debt.
The court granted the freezing order, which restrained KR Properties from disposing of its assets above a specified threshold. The order was to remain in effect until the trial of the matter or until further order by the court. This decision provides clarity for practitioners regarding the application of freezing orders in construction disputes, particularly when there are allegations of non-payment and withholding of critical information.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case initially came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales as an application for an interlocutory injunction to remove a caveat and to set aside freezing orders. The application was brought by KR Properties Global Pty Ltd against Oxford (NSW) Pty Ltd. The application followed a series of negotiations and legal actions between the parties. The proceedings included submissions on the merits of the case, as well as detailed arguments on the effect of the freezing orders and their interaction with the caveat. The Court had to consider the application on an urgent basis given the commercial implications of the property transaction.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the freezing orders issued by the Court precluded the removal of the caveat lodged by Oxford (NSW) over the property.
2. The effect and scope of the freezing orders on the parties' rights and obligations under the contract of sale.
3. The appropriate interpretation of the terms of the freezing orders in the context of the property transaction between the parties.
Held
1. The court held that the freezing orders issued by the Court did not preclude the removal of the caveat lodged by Oxford (NSW) over the property.
2. The court determined that the freezing orders did not affect the parties' rights and obligations under the contract of sale beyond what was explicitly stated in the orders.
3. The court held that the terms of the freezing orders should be interpreted narrowly in the context of the property transaction between the parties.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by addressing the first issue concerning whether the freezing orders precluded the removal of the caveat. The court held that the freezing orders did not preclude the removal of the caveat as they were specifically tailored to prevent the transfer of assets and not to impede the legal processes required to resolve the dispute. The court relied on established principles that freezing orders are intended to preserve assets rather than to obstruct the administration of justice. In interpreting the orders, the court found that there was no explicit provision in the orders that would prevent the removal of the caveat. Therefore, the court allowed the caveat to be removed.
Turning to the second issue, the court examined the effect and scope of the freezing orders on the parties' rights and obligations under the contract of sale. The court clarified that the freezing orders did not alter the contractual obligations of the parties beyond what was explicitly stated in the orders. The court reasoned that the parties had entered into a binding contract of sale, and the freezing orders were designed to prevent the transfer of the property until the dispute was resolved. The court noted that the orders did not affect the validity of the contract or the parties' rights to seek remedies under the contract, such as damages for breach. The court held that the parties remained bound by their contractual obligations, subject to the specific limitations imposed by the freezing orders.
In addressing the third issue, the court focused on the appropriate interpretation of the terms of the freezing orders. The court emphasised the principle of strict construction of orders, particularly in the context of property transactions. The court held that the terms of the freezing orders should be interpreted narrowly to avoid any unintended consequences that could affect the parties' rights beyond the scope of the dispute. The court found that the orders were clear and specific in their terms and did not extend to matters beyond the preservation of the assets in question. The court's interpretation aligned with the principle that freezing orders should be limited to what is necessary to prevent the dissipation of assets during the pendency of the proceedings. By interpreting the orders narrowly, the court ensured that the rights of the parties were protected in a manner consistent with the intended purpose of the orders.