Ortolan and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

Ortolan and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2020] AATA 3642 (18 September 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:2018/2057          

Re:Lisa Ortolan  

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member D Mitchell

Date:18 September 2020

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

...................[SGD]..............................................

Member D Mitchell

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – what is correct diagnosis of condition – Scheuermann’s disease – whether condition is an injury (other than a disease) or disease – whether the Applicant’s employment contributed, to a significant degree, to the onset or aggravation of the Applicant’s condition – where Respondent determined no liability for compensation pursuant to section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

CASES

Commonwealth v Beattie (1981) 35 ALR 369

Tippett v Australian Postal Corporation [1998] FCA 335

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member D Mitchell

18 September 2020

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Lisa Ortolan (the Applicant) is seeking review of a decision of the Respondent dated      8 January 2018.[1]

    [1]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T48, page 133, Reviewable Decision.

  2. The reviewable decision affirmed a determination dated 11 September 2017[2] that liability was denied under section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (SRC Act) for ‘compression factures in the spine, partially collapsed left lung’ (the claimed injury).[3]

    [2]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T36, pages 107-109, Determination Decision.

    [3]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T48, page 133, Reviewable Decision.

    BACKGROUND AND CLAIMS HISTORY

  3. The Applicant commenced her current employment with the Respondent in August 2011.[4]

    [4]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T6, pages 35-44, Pre-Employment Medical.

  4. After having been offered a full time position as a postal delivery officer (PDO)[5] she underwent a pre-employment medical examination[6] on 19 April 2016. On examination, the only active condition identified was left wrist pain. The Applicant’s lungs, neck/cervical spine and thoraco-lumbar spine were noted to be normal.[7]

    [5]     Exhibit 6, Various medical information and compensation forms filed by the Applicant on 17 April 2020,    Applicant’s submission.

    [6]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T6, pages 35-44, Pre-Employment Medical.

    [7]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T6, pages 42-43, Pre-Employment Medical.

  5. In completing the pre-employment medical examination form,[8] the Applicant disclosed the following medical history:[9]

    (a)Workers’ compensation claim for bone bruising and soft tissues injuries in March 2012 in the course of her employment with APC after being reversed into by a ute;

    (b)Right middle finger crush injury and amputation;

    (c)Motorcycle injury in 1994 resulting in left knee injury and patellectomy;

    (d)Motorcycle injury in 2011 resulting in left forearm, wrist and shoulder injury;

    (e)6 operations on left knee between 1995 and 2002;

    (f)6 operations on right middle finger between 2005 and 2010; and

    (g)Occasional migraines relieved by anti-migraine medication.

    [8]     Exhibit 1, T Documents, T6, pages 35-44, Pre-Employment Medical.

    [9]     As summarised in Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Statement of Issues, Facts and Contentions, pages 1-2,        paragraph 3.2.

  6. The Applicant’s last day at work was 20 March 2017. She provided medical certificates and reports certifying her as unfit to continue…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ortolan and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 3642
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal reviewed a decision by the Australian Postal Corporation to deny compensation to the applicant, Ms. Ortolan, under section 14 of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth). The applicant claimed injury due to compression fractures in her spine and a partially collapsed left lung, which she attributed to her employment as a postal delivery officer. The Corporation's initial determination, affirmed by a reviewable decision, found no liability for compensation.

The Tribunal was required to determine the correct diagnosis of the applicant's condition and whether it constituted an "injury" or a "disease" for the purposes of the SRC Act. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether the applicant's employment contributed to a significant degree to the onset or aggravation of her condition. The applicant had a history of various injuries and medical conditions, including spinal issues, which were disclosed during her pre-employment medical examination.

The Tribunal considered the medical evidence presented, including reports from Dr. Ferguson and Dr. Albietz, and the evidence of Dr. Steadman. While acknowledging the applicant's submission that she was unaware of having Scheuermann's disease prior to her claim, the Tribunal accepted Dr. Steadman's diagnosis that the applicant suffered from Scheuermann's disease of the thoracic spine. This diagnosis was consistent with imaging reports and Dr. Albietz's opinion, although Dr. Steadman could not account for the lung condition. The Tribunal found that Scheuermann's disease, as diagnosed, was not a "disease" for the purposes of sections 5A or 5B of the SRC Act.

Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that the applicant did not suffer a section 5A injury in relation to the claimed condition. Accordingly, the decision under review, which denied compensation, was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The reviewable decision affirmed a determination dated 11 September 2017[2] that liability was denied under section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (SRC Act) for ‘compression factures in the spine, partially collapsed left lung’ (the claimed injury).[3][2] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T36, pages 107-109, Determination Decision.[3] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T48, page 133, Reviewable Decision.BACKGROUND AND CLAIMS HISTORY The Applicant commenced her current employment with the Respondent in August 2011.[4] [4] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T6, pages 35-44, Pre-Employment Medical. After having been offered a full time position as a postal delivery officer (PDO)[5] she underwent a pre-employment medical examination[6] on 19 April 2016. On examination, the only active condition identified was left wrist pain. The Applicant’s lungs, neck/cervical spine and thoraco-lumbar spine were noted to be normal.[7] [5] Exhibit 6, Various medical information and compensation forms filed by the Applicant on 17 April 2020, Applicant’s submission.[6] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T6, pages 35-44, Pre-Employment Medical.[7] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T6, pages 42-43, Pre-Employment Medical. In completing the pre-employment medical examination form,[8] the Applicant disclosed the following medical history:[9] (a)Workers’ compensation claim for bone bruising and soft tissues injuries in March 2012 in the course of her employment with APC after being reversed into by a ute;(b)Right middle finger crush injury and amputation;(c)Motorcycle injury in 1994 resulting in left knee injury and patellectomy;(d)Motorcycle injury in 2011 resulting in left forearm, wrist and shoulder injury;(e)6 operations on left knee between 1995 and 2002;(f)6 operations on right middle finger between 2005 and 2010; and(g)Occasional migraines relieved by anti-migraine medication.[8] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T6, pages 35-44, Pre-Employment Medical.[9] As summarised in Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Statement of Issues, Facts and Contentions, pages 1-2, paragraph 3.2. The Applicant’s last day at work was 20 March 2017. She provided medical certificates and reports certifying her as unfit to continue her usual occupation.[10] [10] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T7, T8, T9, T10, T11, T12, T13, T14, T15, T16, T17, T18, T20, T21, T25, T27, T33, T40, Medical Certificates. In a letter dated 9 April 2017, Dr Chek Chan, General Practitioner provided:[11][The Applicant] has wedge fractures of T6 and 7 reported on xray. She has been having chest wall pain.It is possible that the wedge factures may be causing her pain in the context of her work as a bikie which does tend to keep jarring the spine to a greater or lesser degree.[11] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T15, page 53, Medical Report of Dr Chek Chan. On 28 April 2017, a Health and Safety Incident form was completed by the Applicant’s supervisor Ms Lea Brock.[12] Ms Brock recorded that an incident had occurred on 7 December 2016 at 11.00 am while the Applicant was delivering mail.[13] In response to the question what happened during the incident it was recorded that “PDO says she remembers hitting a large hole in the footpath.”[14] In response to the question provide details of injury/illness sustained it was recorded that “PDO says her injury fractures to back and compressed disks may have been due to hitting a large pot hole she did not feel any pain this was due to the pain relief she had been taking. PDO has not provided any time or date.”[15] [12] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T19, pages 60-64, Health and Safety Incident Form.[13] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T19, page 60, Health and Safety Incident Form.[14] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T19, pages 60-61, Health and Safety Incident Form.[15] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T19, page 61, Health and Safety Incident Form.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 4 of the SRC Act defines ailment as any physical or mental ailment, disorder, effect or morbid condition (whether of sudden onset or gradual development).EVIDENCEApplicant’s Evidence On 17 April 2020, the Applicant submitted to the Tribunal a statement setting out a timeline of events.[33] At Hearing it was decided that the information provided after the timeline entry dated 26 June 2015 would be admitted as evidence for consideration by the Tribunal. The Tribunal notes that it is clear from the Applicant’s timeline, other submissions that form part of the T-Documents[34] and her oral evidence at Hearing, that her employment with the Respondent had been quite difficult, she had experienced an earlier workplace accident and conflict with her supervisors. The Tribunal acknowledged these difficulties and while not discounting that they occurred or how they impacted upon the Applicant, explained that it does not have jurisdiction to consider any matters outside of the reviewable decision which relates to the claimed injury.[33] Exhibit 6, Various medical information and compensation forms filed by the Applicant on 17 April 2020, Applicant’s submissions.[34] Exhibit 1, T Documents. In the Applicant’s statement, she outlined that from June 2015 onwards she had reported back pain to her supervisors and to the doctor when she underwent her pre-employment medical examination. She said that once she started using the new postal bike her back hurt more and became progressively worse until she was no longer able to perform her duties. Her last day of work was in March 2017.[35] [35] Exhibit 6, Various medical information and compensation forms filed by the Applicant on 17 April 2020, Applicant’s submissions. Throughout the Tribunal process, the Applicant provided further medical evidence from Dr Ferguson and Dr John Albietz. In a report dated 6 November 2017, Dr Ferguson provided that:[36] The above patient has crush fractures in a number of vertebrae in her back. This may well have resulted from riding long hours on a small motorbike on uneven terrain.[36] Exhibit 6, Various medical information and compensation forms filed by the Applicant on 17 April 2020, Report of Dr Scott Ferguson dated 6 November 2017. The Applicant provided a report of Dr Albietz, Adult and Paediatric Spinal Surgeon dated 28 November 2017 addressed to Dr Ferguson.[37] Dr Albietz provided:[38]Between December 2016 and March 2017 [the Applicant] developed progressively worsening mid thoracic back pain through repeated jolting through her spine riding over speed bumps whilst delivering mail. This culminated in the development of severe thoracic pain in March 2017. [The Applicant] continues to experience mid thoracic pain, lower back pain, and left sciatica. She hasn’t been able to return to any work activity since that time. [The Applicant] place a claim through the Worker’s Compensation for the symptoms/injury which was denied and unfortunately not received any treatment other than analgesic medication. ………..Imaging of [the Applicant’s] spine includes a CT Scan, bone scan and recent MRI scan. The changes in her thoracic spine have been reported as fractures though in my opinion are consistent with thoracic Scheuermann’s disease with wedged vertebrae, discogenic deterioration, corrugated endplates and Schmorl’s nodes from T5 to T10. There is also discogenic deterioration at the L4/5 and L5/S1 levels. There is no neural compression to explained referred leg symptoms.Through work activity [the Applicant] has suffered repetitive strain to her thoracic spine aggravating thoracic Scheuermann’s disease/spondylosis. She was harshly dealt with to have her Workcover claim rejected. The report of thoracic fractures has and will continue to create significant psychological and potentially medicolegal problems. Early formalised therapy potentially may have provided significant benefit. [The Applicant] now has chronic pain, considerable dysfunction and an uncertain future. She requires input from a chronic pain physician and treatment through a formalised rehabilitation program including hydrotherapy. [The Applicant] is uninsured though I understand is engaging a lawyer which will hopefully allow her to obtaining appropriate medical treatment. ……[37] Exhibit 6, Various medical information and compensation forms filed by the Applicant on 17 April 2020, Report of Dr John Albietz dated 28 November 2017.[38] Exhibit 6, Various medical information and compensation forms filed by the Applicant on 17 April 2020, Report of Dr John Albietz dated 28 November 2017.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Consequently, the Applicant’s ailment, being Scheuermann’s disease is not a disease for the purpose of sections 5A or 5B of the SRC Act. CONCLUSION For the purpose of section 14 of the SRC Act, the Tribunal finds that the Applicant did not suffer a section 5A injury in relation to the claimed injury. Accordingly, the decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant said that the progress notes referred to by the Respondent and mentioned back pain were after a 2012 work place accident. She said that in 2000 she was not suffering with back pain and if her condition was as bad as has been stated how was she able to work. The Applicant contended that Dr Steadman said that activities and trauma can make the progression of Scheuermann’s disease more obvious and that in her opinion you cannot say that vertical compression on the bike did not do that, or at least contribute to it happening much faster than if she had not been doing the job.CONSIDERATION It should be noted from the outset that there is no dispute that the Applicant experiences back pain which has impacted on her ability to undertake daily living and work activities. This matter turns on the medical evidence in relation to diagnosis of the Applicant’s condition and the underlying pathology of that condition. Having considered the documentary medical evidence before the Tribunal and the evidence provided at Hearing by Dr Steadman the Tribunal considers that the opinion of Dr Steadman is the authoritative view, noting that on the face of the report provided by Dr Albietz the medical views put forward by the two specialists are not in conflict. The Applicant has provided medical certificates and reports from her general practitioner, Dr Ferguson and a report from Dr Albietz, however they were not called by the Applicant to give evidence at the Hearing and as such their opinions were not explained beyond that provided in writing, nor was the Respondent able to cross examine them. Consequently, the Tribunal accepts the contentions made by the Respondent in relation to the medical evidence before the Tribunal. In considering what is the correct diagnosis of the Applicant’s condition, the Tribunal accepts the Applicant’s submission that she was not aware prior to her present compensation claim what Scheuermann’s disease was or that she in fact suffers from it herself. The Tribunal accepts the diagnosis of Dr Steadman that the Applicant is suffering from Scheuermann’s disease of the thoracic spine as being the correct diagnosis of the Applicant’s claimed injury, noting that Dr Steadman provides that he could not account for the lung condition. This diagnosis is consistent with the imaging report dated 2 April 2010,[63] the 2017 suite of imagining[64] and the opinion provided by Dr Albietz.[65][63] Exhibit 7, Extract of summonsed documents from Royal Brisbane and Women’s Hospital pages 12(A) and 12(B).[64] Exhibit 1, T Documents, T4, page 23, X-Ray report dated 3 April 2017 and page 31, CT Scan report dated 18 April 2017; Exhibit 7, Extract of summonsed documents from Queensland Diagnostic Imaging, page 4, Bone Scan dated 11 May 2017 an Extract of summonsed document from Dr John Albietz, pages 2-3, MRI Scan report dated 17 November 2017.[65] Exhibit 6, Various medical information and compensation forms filed by the Applicant on 17 April 2020, Report of Dr John Albietz dated 28 November 2017.