Reported Decision:
[2001] NSWSC 855
[2001] ACL Rep 245 NSW 35
(2002) NSW ConvR 56-007
New South Wales
Supreme Court
CITATION: ORTI-TULLO & ANOR v. SADEK & ANOR [2001] NSWSC 855 CURRENT JURISDICTION: EQUITY FILE NUMBER(S): SC 1730/2001 HEARING DATE(S): 24/09/2001 JUDGMENT DATE:
28 September 2001PARTIES :
Salvatore Orti-Tullo & Antonia Orti-Tullo - Plaintiffs
Daniel Sadek & Liman Sadek - Defendants
JUDGMENT OF: Bryson J at 1
COUNSEL : M. Scheib - Plaintiffs
G.A. Sirtes - DefendantsSOLICITORS: Nicholas Pappas & Co - Plaintiffs
Leslie Caplan & Grunstein - DefendantsCATCHWORDS: LESSOR and LESSEE - rent review - Valuer's determination - Lessor sought to set aside valuer's determination - rental determination explained by valuer saying "our rental determination dated 1 August 2000 ... did not include GST" - consideration of grounds of review by Court of valuer's determination - on the facts, it had not been shown that the valuer made a mistake - judgment for lessee. - VALUATION OF LAND - valuer's determination on rent review under lease - no mistake shown. LEGISLATION CITED: A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999
A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax Transition) Act 1999CASES CITED: Arenson v. Arenson [1973] Ch 346
Campbell v. Edwards [1976] 1 WLR 4
Dean v. Prince [1953] Ch 590
Horwitz Grahame Books Pty Ltd v. Mid-City Centre Pty Ltd (1990) NSW ConvR 55
Strang Patrick Stevedoring Pty Ltd v. James Patrick & Co. Pty Ltd (1993) 32 NSWLR 538
Ricciardello v. Caltex Oil (Aust.) Pty Ltd [1991] ANZ ConvR 445.
Legal & General Life of Australia Ltd v. A. Hudson Pty Ltd (1985) 1 NSWLR 314
Holt & Anor v. Cox (1997) 23 ACSR 590
WMC Resources Ltd v. Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd (1999) 20 WAR 489
Commonwealth of Australia v. Wawbe Pty Ltd (1999) ANZ ConvR 597
Kanivah Holdings Pty Ltd v. Holdsworth Properties Pty Ltd & Ors [2001] NSWSC 405
Spencer v. Commonwealth (1907) 5 CLR 418DECISION: Judgment for lessee: see para [38]
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION1730/2001
FRIDAY 28 SEPTEMBER 2001BRYSON J.
SALVATORE ORTI-TULLO & ANTONINA ORTI-TULLO v. DANIEL SADEK & LIMAN SADEK
Judgment
: The plaintiffs challenge a determination by a valuer of the current market rental value of commercial premises on the exercise of an option to renew a lease. The challenge is based on the treatment of Goods and Services Tax (GST). The defendants conduct a Vartex branded Service Station on the leased land at 127-129 Marion Street, Leichhardt at the corner of Edith Street. The plaintiffs as lessors granted to the defendants as lessees a lease of the land for a term of five years from 1 August 1995 to 31 July 2000 with an option to renew for five years. In the schedule to the lease Item 3 showed the yearly rent as $50,868.72. There was no provision for annual market reviews. It is not disputed that the option to renew the lease was duly…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Orti-Tullo v Sadek and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] NSWSC 855
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue the court had to address was whether the valuer had indeed made a mistake in their determination and, if so, whether this mistake was sufficient to warrant setting aside the determination. The court had to consider the grounds of review and assess whether the valuer's oversight in omitting the GST from the determination constituted a material error.
The court concluded that, based on the evidence presented, there was no material mistake made by the valuer. The valuer's explanation that the omission of GST was an oversight did not amount to a mistake that could invalidate the determination. Therefore, the court upheld the valuer's determination and dismissed the lessor's application to set it aside. The court found in favour of the lessee, Sadek, and the valuer's determination stood as it was.
No further orders were made by the court beyond the dismissal of the lessor's application to set aside the valuer's determination.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court following an application by the lessor to set aside the valuer's determination on the grounds that it did not include the GST. The court was required to consider the grounds of review and determine whether the valuer had indeed made a mistake in the determination. The court heard arguments from both the lessor and the lessee and reviewed the valuer's determination to assess whether there was any basis for setting it aside. The case was heard as an application to review the valuer's determination, and no appeal or prior decisions were noted in the case details.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the valuer made a mistake in the determination by not including the GST.
2. Whether the lessor's application to set aside the valuer's determination should be dismissed.
Held
1. The court concluded that the valuer did not make a mistake in the determination by not including the GST. As a result, the lessor's application to set aside the valuer's determination was dismissed.
2. The court dismissed the lessor's application to set aside the valuer's determination.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court considered the grounds of review presented by the lessor against the valuer's determination. The lessor argued that the valuer had made an error by not including the GST in the rental determination. However, the Court found that the valuer's explanation, which explicitly stated that the rental determination did not include GST, was clear and straightforward. The Court held that it had not been demonstrated that the valuer made a mistake in the determination. Consequently, the Court dismissed the lessor's application to set aside the valuer's determination. The Court found that the valuer's explanation was sufficient to show that the absence of GST was intentional and not a result of an oversight or error. The Court also noted that the lessor had not provided any evidence to suggest that the valuer had made a mistake in the determination. As such, the Court held that the valuer's determination was valid and should not be set aside. The Court's decision in this case reinforces the principle that a valuer's determination on a rent review under a lease is binding unless there is clear evidence of a mistake or error in the determination. The Court held that the lessor had not provided such evidence in this case, and as such, the valuer's determination should stand. The Court's decision also highlights the importance of clear and explicit explanations in valuer's determinations to avoid potential disputes and applications to set aside the determination.