Coles Supermarkets Pty Ltd v Westley Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Coles Supermarkets Pty Ltd v Westley Nominees Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 839

TAXATION – GST – transitional provisions – lease entered before 8 July 1999 and spanning 1 July 2000 – whether lease provides for a “review opportunity” – whether a taxable supply – consideration for the supply – whether supply – whether the respondents able to invoke the provisions of Div 2 of Pt 3 of A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax Transition) Act 1999 (Cth) – construction of lease.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether relief should be refused because the Commissioner of Taxation was not a party – where Commissioner aware of proceedings and gave private ruling that the applicant’s argument supported – dispute involved proper construction of the lease and the consideration for the lease – relief might be granted in the absence of the Commissioner.

WORDS AND PHRASES – “consideration”, “general review”, “in connection with”

A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax Transition) Act 1999 (Cth), ss 4, 5, 6, 7, 12, 13, 15A, 15C, 15K, 15L, 15M
A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (Cth) ss 1-2, 7-1, 7-5, 7-10, 7-15, 9-5, 9-10, 9-15, 9-40, 9-70, 9-75, 11-5, 11-10, 11-20, 11-25, 23-5, 29-70, 156-22, 195-1
Taxation Administration Act1953 (Cth), s 37
Tax Laws Amendment (Long‑term Non‑reviewable Contracts) Act 2005 (Cth)

Property Law Act 1974 (Qld), 55, 117, 118;

CSR Ltd v Hornsby Shire Council 2004 ATC 4966; [2004] NSWSC 946,distinguished
ACP Publishing Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2005] FCAFC 57, referred to
Case M58 (1990) 12 NZTC 2333, referred to
Orti‑Tullo v Sadek 2001 ATC 4688; [2001] NSWSC 855, referred to
DB Rreef Funds Management Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2005] FCA 509, considered
Commissioner of State Revenue v Price Brent Services Pty Ltd [1995] 2 VR 582, considered
Murray Goulburn Co‑operative Co Ltd v Cobram Laundry Service Pty Ltd [2001] VSCA 57, followed
The Council of the Upper Hunter County District v Australian Chilling and Freezing Co Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 429, cited
Pebruk Nominees Pty Ltd v Woolworths (Victoria) Pty Ltd [2003] TASSC 94, cited
O’Grady v The Northern Queensland Company Limited (1990) 169 CLR 356, referred to
PMT Partners Pty Ltd v Australian National Parks and Wildlife Service (1995) 184 CLR 301, referred to
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Scully (2000) 201 CLR 148, referred to
The Workers’ Compensation Board of Queensland v Technical Products Pty Ltd (1988) 165 CLR 642, referred to

G Knowles & Associates Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation 2000 96 FCR 402, referred to
Harris v Commissioner of Taxation [2002] FCAFC 226, referred to
Smith v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1987) 164, referred to
News Limited v Australian Rugby Football LeagueLtd (1996) 64 FCR 410, referred to

Explanatory Memorandum to the A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax Transition) Bill 1999 (Cth)
Macquarie Dictionary (Macquarie Library…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coles Supermarkets Pty Ltd v Westley Nominees Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 839
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Coles Supermarkets Pty Ltd, as the applicant, sought a declaration from the court that clause C in a lease agreement between it and Westley Nominees Pty Ltd, the respondent, provided an opportunity for a review of the rent payable under the lease. The dispute arose out of the application of the GST Transition Act to the lease agreement, which was made prior to the introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST). The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where Justice Gilmour was the presiding judge.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether clause C in the lease agreement provided a 'review opportunity' for the supplier to adjust the rent to account for the GST, as required by the GST Transition Act. The respondents argued that clause C did not permit a general review of the rent, due to several reasons, including the restriction on the review under clause C(b), the exclusion of certain outgoings and expenses, and the evidence of the valuer that the fair market rental value could not constitute the base rent under the lease. The applicant, on the other hand, contended that clause C did provide a review opportunity.

The court found that there was no 'review opportunity' under clause C of the lease agreement. Justice Gilmour held that the restriction on the review under clause C(b) and the exclusion of certain outgoings and expenses meant that the supplier could not adjust the rent to account for the GST. Furthermore, the evidence of the valuer supported the respondents' argument that the fair market rental value could not constitute the base rent under the lease. Consequently, the court ruled that the GST Transition Act did not apply to the lease agreement, and the applicant was not entitled to the declaration it sought.

The court ordered that the applicant file and serve a minute of proposed orders by a specified date, and that the matter be fixed for mention to allow the parties to make submissions concerning the proposed orders. The costs of and incidental to the proceeding were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On or before 9.30 am 23 June 2005, the applicant file and serve a minute of proposed orders in accordance with the reasons for judgment delivered today.

2. The matter be fixed for mention at 2.15 pm on 24 June 2005 in order that the parties may make such submissions as they see fit concerning the applicant’s proposed minute of orders.

3. The costs of and incidental to the proceeding be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

KENNY J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KENNY J

Besides the fact that clause C operated of its own accord and a significant part of the consideration, on the respondents’ analysis, fell outside the scope of clause C(b), there were, so the respondents said, a number of other reasons why clause C(b) did not permit the supplier to conduct a general review. These further reasons were: (1) There is a restriction on the review under clause C(b) in that fair market rental is to be determined on a “sitting tenant” basis. (2) Clause C(b) expressly excludes from consideration “the outgoings and other expenses likely to be incurred by the Lessor in respect of the land and the Centre during the balance of the term and which are not recoverable by the Lessor from the Lessee …”.(3) The evidence of the valuer in this case was that fair market rental is exclusive of GST.(4)The evidence of the valuer was that the lease provides no opportunity for a general review because:(i)his assessed fair market rent valuation of $575,922 per annum as the base rent under the lease could not constitute the base rent as it is less than the agreed sum calculated under clause C(a), namely, $952,318.72; and (ii)if the figure of $525,922 were treated as base rent, then the threshold for the turnover rent would reduce and turnover rent would increase. As senior counsel for the respondent put it, “the snake would always swallow its tail”. This led the valuer to say, in his report, that he was “unsure how to advise the Court of the treatment of this matter”, in his assessment of the fair market rental value of the premises. In written submissions, the respondents contended that the valuer “comes to this state of uncertainty because he has proceeded on a hypothesis which is not permitted by the lease. Under the terms of this Lease there is simply no opportunity to adopt fair market rent if the amount in para (a) is greater”. In oral submissions, the respondents’ counsel submitted that clause C(b) was, practically speaking, unworkable, principally because of the provision in the lease for annual percentage rental and for the calculation of turnover rent.considerationWas there a ‘review opportunity’? The rationale for s 13 of the GST Transition Act is the need to balance the competing interests of suppliers and those to whom they supply, as well as the revenue, in relation to contracts entered into before the introduction of the GST and involving supplies after the imposition of the tax. A supplier would suffer an economic disadvantage if the supplier became liable to pay the GST upon a supply, the consideration for which was fixed before the tax was introduced. Equally, a recipient of a supply would suffer an economic disadvantage if the consideration payable for the supply was reflective of the GST but the recipient was unable to obtain the benefit of any input tax credit. The revenue would also be at risk from non‑taxable supplies under pre‑GST contracts, unless there was some mechanism to bring these supplies within the GST regime. The GST Transition Act takes account of these various interests by quarantining supplies made under pre‑GST contracts from the GST regime until 1 July 2005, unless there is a review opportunity, whether or not taken up, for a change in the consideration to take account of the GST. If there is such a review opportunity, then the GST becomes payable on supplies, although under pre‑GST contracts: see e.g., ACP Publishing at [44] per Hill J. The opportunities chosen by the legislature to attract the GST regime reflect the legislature’s resolution of these difficulties. Broadly speaking, a supply will become taxable when the supplier has the contractual ability to alter the consideration after the imposition of the GST on 1 July 2000: see GST Transition Act, s 7(1). In this way, the revenue is not at risk from parties who elect not to alter the consideration. Moreover, a recipient who is entitled to any GST credit may be able to enjoy that credit, notwithstanding that the supplier has elected unilaterally not to alter the consideration. Since the 2005 amendments, where the pre‑GST contract affords no relevant opportunity to change the consideration, the supplier can invoke the mechanism in Div 2 of Pt 3 to effect such a change.