Orient Overseas Container Line Ltd v ANL Singapore Pte Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Orient Overseas Container Line Ltd v ANL Singapore Pte Ltd [2020] FCA 921

File number: NSD 645 of 2020
Judge: STEWART J
Date of judgment: 11 June 2020
Date of publication of reasons 30 June 2020
Catchwords:

ADMIRALTY – marine casualty – where plaintiff seeks inspection of material parts of the vessel – whether defendants must assist with inspection by identifying particular machinery and equipment

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether inspection orders justified – whether defendants must assist with inspection

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – discovery of specified documents sought before statement of claim is filed – whether discovery justified

Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1979 (Cth) ss 37M, 37N

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) Pt 20, rr 1.40, 14.01, 14.10, 14.11

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) r 250

Cases cited:

Career Step, LLC v TalentMed Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 492

CGU Insurance Ltd v Malaysia International Shipping Corp Berhad [2001] FCA 1223; 187 ALR 279

CSL Australia Pty Limited v Formosa [2009] NSWCA 363; 235 FLR 273

Cummings v 2KY Broadcasters Pty Ltd (1981) 51 FLR 121; 1 NSWLR 246

Egg and Egg Pulp Marketing Board v K H Korp Tocumal Trading Co Pty Ltd(1963) VR 378

Evan Deakin Pty Ltd v Orekenetics Pty Ltd [2002] QSC 42; 2 Qd R 345

Johnson Tiles Pty Ltd v Esso Australia Ltd [1999] FCA 56; ATPR 41-679

Lyons v Kern Konstructions (Townsville) Pty Ltd (1983) 70 FLR 135; 47 ALR 114

Mount Isa Mines Ltd v The Ship “Thor Commander” [2018] FCA 1326; 263 FCR 181

Norm Engineering Pty Ltd v Digga Australia Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 1378

Smith v Peters (1875) LR 20 Eq 511

Date of hearing: 11 June 2020
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Admiralty and Maritime
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 44
Counsel for the Plaintiff: E G H Cox SC
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: HWL Ebsworth
Solicitor for the Defendants: M Hockaday of Thynne + Macartney

ORDERS

NSD 645 of 2020
BETWEEN:

ORIENT OVERSEAS CONTAINER LINE LTD

Plaintiff

AND:

ANL SINGAPORE PTE LTD

First Defendant

APL CO PTE LTD

Second Defendant

CMB OCEAN 13 LEASING CO PTE

Third Defendant

JUDGE:

STEWART J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 JUNE 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The second and third defendants permit the plaintiff, by its nominated expert, Mike Wilson of TMC Marine, to attend on board the vessel APL ENGLAND (Ship) at Brisbane, Queensland, at a time reasonably convenient to them and within 5 days, to:

(a)be permitted access to, and photograph, the on screen display for the Ship’s engine room alarm log; and

(b)to inspect, photograph, video record, measure any areas of the Ship connected with or relating to the Ship’s main engine and any repairs as the expert sees fit.

2.The second and third defendant identify an appropriately knowledgeable person to accompany Mr Wilson on the inspection referred to in Order 1 and identify at Mr Wilson’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Orient Overseas Container Line Ltd v ANL Singapore Pte Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 921
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Orient Overseas Container Line Ltd, brought an action against ANL Singapore Pte Ltd (the second defendant) and ANL Australia Pty Ltd (the third defendant) in the Federal Court of Australia. The plaintiff sought an inspection of the vessel APL ENGLAND, which had suffered an engine failure and subsequently ran aground off the coast of Queensland. The plaintiff sought orders to inspect various parts of the vessel, including the main engine, and to obtain certain documents from the defendants.

The legal issues before the Court included whether the plaintiff was entitled to inspect the vessel and whether the defendants were required to assist with the inspection by identifying particular machinery and equipment. Additionally, the plaintiff sought an order for discovery of specified documents before the statement of claim was filed. The defendants opposed the plaintiff’s application on various grounds, including that the inspection would cause undue hardship and delay and that the plaintiff had not provided sufficient evidence to justify the inspection.

The Court found that the plaintiff had established a prima facie case for the inspection and that the inspection would not cause undue hardship or delay. The Court also found that the defendants were required to assist with the inspection by identifying an appropriately knowledgeable person to accompany the plaintiff’s expert and to identify particular equipment or machinery. The Court further found that the plaintiff was entitled to discovery of the specified documents before the statement of claim was filed. The Court made orders for inspection and discovery as sought by the plaintiff, with certain conditions and timeframes. The costs of the interlocutory application were reserved for determination at a later date.

The Court’s orders included permission for the plaintiff’s expert to inspect and photograph certain parts of the vessel, including the main engine, and to be accompanied by an appropriately knowledgeable person nominated by the defendants. The Court also ordered the defendants to identify and preserve certain documents and equipment related to the engine failure and voyage of the vessel. The parties were required to confer regarding the discovery of documents and to exchange information about the inspection and preservation of evidence. The interlocutory application was adjourned to a later date, and the costs of the application were reserved for determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The second and third defendants permit the plaintiff, by its nominated expert, Mike Wilson of TMC Marine, to attend on board the vessel APL ENGLAND (Ship) at Brisbane, Queensland, at a time reasonably convenient to them and within 5 days, to:

(a) be permitted access to, and photograph, the on screen display for the Ship’s engine room alarm log; and

(b) to inspect, photograph, video record, measure any areas of the Ship connected with or relating to the Ship’s main engine and any repairs as the expert sees fit.

2. The second and third defendant identify an appropriately knowledgeable person to accompany Mr Wilson on the inspection referred to in Order 1 and identify at Mr Wilson’s request particular equipment or machinery.

3. On or before 5:00 pm on 16 June 2020, the parties confer regarding the defendants giving discovery of documents as are on the ship or within the jurisdiction and within their possession, custody and power, set out in the attached Annexure.

4. The second and third defendants preserve and keep within this jurisdiction (i) any damaged components of the main engine removed from the Ship during repairs or damage assessment; and (ii) documents from the Ship relevant to the voyage, the cause of the engine stoppage, maintenance of the engine and the cargo securing for the voyage, in accordance with the attached Annexure.

5. The interlocutory application filed on 10 June 2020 is otherwise adjourned to a date to be arranged.

6. Costs reserved.

Annexure

1. Any Master’s Statement of Facts or note of protest.

2. The Ship’s Telegraph data logger or similar electronic recordings from 23 May 2020 to berthing.

3. The Ship’s Course recorder print out or similar electronic recordings from 23 May 2020 to berthing.

4. The Ship’s Tank sounding Log from 23 May 2020 to berthing.

5. The Ship’s Engine room alarm log print out or similar electronic recordings from 23 May 2020 to berthing.

6. General arrangement plan for the Ship.

7. Tank Capacity Plan for the Ship.

8. Weather forecasts received on board the Ship from 20 May 2020 to berthing.

9. The Ships’s Cargo securing manual, SMS or procedures relating to the securing of cargo and containers.

10. Any communications from the Ship’s Master and Chief Engineer reporting to owners from 23 May 2020 to berthing.

11. Any reports and notices provided to AMSA from 23 May 2020.

12. Maintenance records for cargo securing equipment for the Ship from 1 March 2019.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Orient Overseas Container Line Ltd (the plaintiff) sought to inspect material parts of the vessel APL ENGLAND (the Ship) owned by ANL Singapore Pte Ltd (the second defendant) and managed by APL Ship Management Pte Ltd (the third defendant). The plaintiff claimed that the Ship suffered an engine failure, resulting in damage to the vessel and its cargo. The plaintiff sought to inspect and photograph the on-screen display for the Ship’s engine room alarm log and inspect any areas of the Ship connected with or relating to the Ship’s main engine and any repairs. The plaintiff also sought discovery of specified documents before filing a statement of claim. The defendants opposed the plaintiff's request for inspection and discovery of documents.

This case involves an interlocutory application filed by the plaintiff seeking inspection of the Ship and discovery of specified documents. The application was heard by the Federal Court of Australia, which granted the application and made orders for inspection and preservation of documents. The case did not involve any prior decisions, tribunals, or courts. The key procedural steps included the filing of the interlocutory application, the hearing of the application, and the making of orders by the Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the defendants must assist with the inspection by identifying particular machinery and equipment.
2. Whether inspection orders are justified.
3. Whether discovery of specified documents sought before statement of claim is filed is justified.

Held
1. The court held that the defendants must assist with the inspection by identifying particular machinery and equipment. The second and third defendants must identify an appropriately knowledgeable person to accompany the plaintiff's nominated expert, Mike Wilson, during the inspection.
2. The court held that inspection orders are justified. The plaintiff is permitted to inspect the Ship's engine room alarm log and photograph the on-screen display, as well as inspect, photograph, video record, and measure any areas of the Ship connected with or relating to the Ship's main engine and any repairs.
3. The court held that the discovery of specified documents sought before the statement of claim is filed is justified. The defendants are required to provide the listed documents and preserve certain damaged components and documents within this jurisdiction.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the necessity for the plaintiff to inspect the vessel and its machinery to properly investigate the marine casualty. It acknowledged the importance of the inspection for the plaintiff's ability to establish its case and the defendants' obligation to assist in this process. The court applied the principles of fairness and necessity in ordering the inspection, ensuring that the inspection is conducted in a manner that is reasonable and does not unduly prejudice the defendants. The court also recognised the importance of timely access to relevant documents to facilitate the investigation, emphasising the principle that discovery of documents is justified when necessary for the just determination of the case. The court ordered the defendants to identify knowledgeable personnel to assist in the inspection, preserve and keep certain documents and equipment within the jurisdiction, and provide specific documents to the plaintiff. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that in marine casualty cases, the court may order inspections and discovery of documents to ensure a fair and just determination of the case, provided such orders are necessary and reasonable.