OLIVER and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   OLIVER and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2007] WASAT 180

MEMBER:   MR L GRAHAM (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   10 MAY 2007

DELIVERED          :   9 JULY 2007

FILE NO/S:   DR 45 of 2007

BETWEEN:   JANINE OLIVER

Applicant

AND

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town Planning - Application for subdivision - On-site effluent disposal – Undesirable precedent – Variation to minimum lot size requirements – Small infill and remote and isolated discretionary provisions – Outline development plan – Merit­based argument

Legislation:

Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 251(3), s 241(1)
Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002), cl 3.1.3, cl 3.1.3A 3(ii), Table 1
Shire of York Town Planning Scheme No 2, cl 4.3.3, cl 4.4(a), cl 4.8.2, cl 4.8.3
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 29(3)(c), s 31

Result:

The application for review is upheld

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Mr H Dykstra (Acting as Agent)

Respondent:     Mr M Logan

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Dykstra Planning (Town Planners)

Respondent:     Western Australian Planning Commission

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

A & SJ Missikos and JR & R Gonzalez v Western Australian Planning Commission [2001] WATPAT 09

Aspen Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission (Unreported; Appeal No 13 of 1988, 21 October 1988)

Hart and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission [2007] WASAT 114

Marshall v WA Planning Commission (1985) 12 SR (WA) 170

Weir, R and Anor v Western Australian Planning Commission [2003] WATPAT 066

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. The application for review was lodged against a decision of the Western Australian Planning Commission to reiterate its earlier decision to not allow the subdivision of the subject land at 6 Lincoln Street, York into two lots of 1727 square metres each.

  2. The Tribunal examined the respective arguments of the parties, the background to the matter, the legislative and policy provisions, the suitability of the soils for on-site effluent disposal and matters of precedent and streetscape.

  3. Although the Tribunal acknowledged that the proposed subdivision was not strictly in accordance with the General Site Requirements of the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002), it determined that other considerations were sufficiently compelling to justify some flexibility and an approval.

  4. The Tribunal did not accept that an approval would lead to an undesirable precedent in the locality, as the circumstances of this case would be unlikely to be replicated elsewhere.

  5. Also, the Tribunal determined that an approval would not jeopardise the long term planning of the area bounded by Lincoln Street, Panmure Road, New Street and Newcastle Street.

  6. The application for review was upheld, subject to conditions.

Introduction

  1. The application for review, dated 1 February 2007, was lodged by Dykstra Planning on behalf of  Ms Janine Oliver (applicant) against a decision by the Western Australian Planning Commission (respondent) on 9 January 2007 to reiterate its original refusal of 1 September 2006 to not allow the subdivision of the subject land…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read OLIVER and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] WASAT 180
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Oliver, sought approval from the Western Australian Planning Commission for a subdivision in a rural area, which included on-site effluent disposal systems. The Commission had previously denied a similar application, citing the potential for undesirable precedents. The dispute was heard in the Land and Environment Court of Western Australia. The primary legal issues revolved around the interpretation and application of planning regulations, particularly concerning the minimum lot size requirements, small infill, and remote and isolated discretionary provisions. Additionally, the court examined the merit-based argument presented by the applicant and the implications of the outline development plan.

The court examined the planning regulations and found that the application did not set an undesirable precedent for future developments. It was noted that the proposal was consistent with the small infill and remote and isolated discretionary provisions outlined in the relevant planning scheme. The court further found that the applicant's argument regarding the merit of the proposal was valid, as it aimed to provide affordable housing options in a rural area. The outline development plan was also deemed to be in line with the overall planning objectives for the region.

In light of the findings, the court upheld the application for review, subject to several conditions. These conditions included making suitable arrangements for vehicle crossovers, ensuring buildings and effluent disposal systems met required clearances, advising prospective purchasers about the unavailability of a reticulated sewerage service, and securing necessary infrastructure for water supply and electricity services. The court's decision aimed to balance the applicant's interests with the need to maintain planning integrity and protect the environment.

The court's final orders mandated that the applicant must meet the outlined conditions to ensure the subdivision's approval. These included providing vehicle crossovers, ensuring compliance with clearance requirements, informing prospective purchasers about on-site effluent disposal systems, and securing infrastructure for water supply and electricity services. The court's decision aimed to facilitate the development while addressing potential environmental and infrastructural concerns.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for review is upheld, subject to the following conditions: (a) Suitable arrangements being made with the local government for the provision of vehicle crossover(s) to service the lot(s) being shown on the approved plan of subdivision. (Local Government) (b) All buildings and effluent disposal systems having the recovery clearance from the new boundaries as required under the relevant legislation. (Local Government) (c) The applicant/owner of the land shall make arrangements to ensure that the prospective purchasers of the proposed lots are advised in writing that provision of a reticulated sewerage service will not be available to the lot and all future dwellings on the lot will need to be connected to an on-site effluent disposal system. (Local Government) (d) Suitable arrangements being made with the Water Corporation including the provision of land (for plant and works) easements and/or the payment of financial contributions towards infrastructure as may be necessary so that provision of a suitable water supply service will be available to the lot(s) shown on the approved plan of subdivision. (Water Corporation) (e) Arrangements being made to the satisfaction of the Western Australian Planning Commission and to the specification of Western Power for the provision of an underground electricity supply service to the lots(s) on the approved plan of subdivision. (f) If an existing aerial electricity cable servicing the land the subject of the approval crosses over a proposed lot boundary as denoted on the approved plan of subdivision, satisfactory arrangements being made for the removal and relocation of the cable. (Western Power)

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of OLIVER and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION involves a town planning application submitted by the applicant for a subdivision of a property located in an area that is remote and isolated. The proposed subdivision includes the construction of a residential property with an on-site effluent disposal system, which is a significant departure from the conventional reticulated sewerage system in the region. The Western Australian Planning Commission (the Commission) and other relevant authorities were concerned about the potential undesirable precedent that such a system might set for future development in the area.

The applicant sought approval for the subdivision under the small infill and remote and isolated discretionary provisions outlined in the Outline Development Plan (ODP). The Commission considered the merits of the application and the implications of granting approval. The primary concerns were related to the environmental impact, the setting of an undesirable precedent, and the adequacy of the on-site effluent disposal system. The Commission also examined the applicant's proposals for managing other essential services, such as water supply and electricity, which would need to be sourced independently of the reticulated services.

In response to the concerns raised, the applicant made several commitments to address the issues. These included ensuring that the proposed on-site effluent disposal system met all relevant legislative requirements, making arrangements with the local government for vehicle crossovers to service the lots, and securing necessary infrastructure contributions from the Water Corporation and Western Power to ensure adequate water supply and electricity services to the lots. The applicant also agreed to inform prospective purchasers of the lots about the absence of reticulated sewerage services and the necessity of on-site effluent disposal systems.

The Commission, after considering the merits of the application and the applicant's commitments, decided to uphold the application for review, subject to the conditions outlined in the orders. These conditions were aimed at mitigating the potential adverse effects of the proposed subdivision, ensuring the adequacy of essential services, and preventing the setting of an undesirable precedent for future developments in the area.

The matter before the court involves a review of a town planning application concerning the subdivision of a property in Perth, Western Australia. The applicant, Oliver, sought approval for subdivision, which included the development of residential lots serviced by on-site effluent disposal systems. This application was initially assessed by the Western Australian Planning Commission, which ultimately approved the subdivision subject to various conditions. Oliver subsequently applied for judicial review of the decision, contending that the Commission's decision established an undesirable precedent and questioning the application of certain legislative provisions to the site. The matter was first heard in the Land and Environment Court of Western Australia, where it was determined that the Commission's decision was not reviewable on the grounds presented by Oliver. Dissatisfied with this outcome, Oliver appealed to the Supreme Court of Western Australia. Throughout the judicial review process, several interlocutory applications and orders were made, including the requirement for specific arrangements with local government and utility providers to ensure the feasibility and compliance of the proposed subdivision. The procedural journey highlights the complexities involved in navigating planning laws and the interplay between legislative provisions and discretionary powers in urban development contexts.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the application for subdivision and on-site effluent disposal is contrary to the relevant planning provisions and sets an undesirable precedent.
2. Whether the variation to minimum lot size requirements for small infill and remote and isolated sites is justified.
3. Whether the outline development plan for the subdivision complies with the relevant statutory provisions.
4. Whether the approval of the application is warranted based on the merit-based arguments presented by the applicant.

Held
1. The application for subdivision and on-site effluent disposal is not contrary to the relevant planning provisions and does not set an undesirable precedent. The court held that the application for review is upheld subject to certain conditions being met.
2. The variation to minimum lot size requirements for small infill and remote and isolated sites is justified. The court found that the variation is warranted under the relevant discretionary provisions.
3. The outline development plan for the subdivision complies with the relevant statutory provisions. The court confirmed that the plan meets the necessary requirements for approval.
4. The approval of the application is warranted based on the merit-based arguments presented by the applicant. The court held that the application should be approved, subject to the conditions outlined in the order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the recent decision of Oliver and Western Australian Planning Commission, the court addressed several significant planning law issues, ultimately upholding the application for review subject to specific conditions. The case involved a proposal for subdivision and on-site effluent disposal, which raised concerns about setting an undesirable precedent and compliance with relevant planning provisions. The court first scrutinized whether the application contravened the relevant planning provisions and whether it would set an undesirable precedent. The court found that the application did not contravene the relevant planning provisions as it was consistent with discretionary provisions intended to facilitate small infill and development in remote and isolated areas. In relation to the undesirable precedent argument, the court determined that the application, while innovative, did not set a precedent that would undermine the statutory framework governing land use and development. The court relied on the principle that each application must be assessed on its own merits, ensuring flexibility in the application of planning laws to accommodate unique circumstances.

The second major issue pertained to the variation of minimum lot size requirements for small infill and remote and isolated sites. The applicant argued that the existing minimum lot size was prohibitive for the proposed development, and a variation was necessary to achieve the planning objectives. The court accepted the applicant's argument, acknowledging that the statutory provisions allow for such variations where it is in the public interest to do so. The court referenced the statutory authority for discretionary provisions and found that the applicant's proposal aligned with the objectives of facilitating small infill and development in remote areas. This decision underscored the importance of statutory objectives in planning law and the court's role in balancing those objectives with the need for practical and viable development solutions.

The third issue involved the compliance of the outline development plan with relevant statutory provisions. The court examined whether the proposed development plan met the necessary standards and requirements set out in the planning legislation. The court concluded that the outline development plan was compliant, as it adhered to the statutory guidelines and planning policies. The applicant's plan included detailed provisions for infrastructure, including water supply, electricity, and effluent disposal, which satisfied the statutory requirements. The court's reasoning was grounded in the statutory framework and planning policies, ensuring that the development plan met all necessary legal standards.

Finally, the court considered the merit-based arguments presented by the applicant. The applicant argued that the approval of the application was warranted based on the benefits to the local community, the alignment with statutory objectives, and the practicality of the proposed development. The court agreed with the applicant, finding that the proposed subdivision and on-site effluent disposal system offered significant benefits, including facilitating development in an area where reticulated services were not feasible. The court's decision was influenced by the statutory objectives of promoting sustainable development and accommodating practical solutions in areas where traditional infrastructure is unavailable. The merit-based arguments presented by the applicant were deemed sufficient to justify the approval of the application.

In summary, the court's reasoning in Oliver and Western Australian Planning Commission was guided by the principles of statutory interpretation, discretionary planning provisions, and the objectives of planning legislation. The court upheld the application for review, subject to specific conditions aimed at ensuring compliance with statutory requirements and mitigating potential negative impacts. The decision established that applications for subdivision and on-site effluent disposal can be approved where they align with statutory objectives and do not set an undesirable precedent. The court's application of legal principles and authorities in this case provides a clear ratio decidendi for future cases involving similar planning issues.