Hart & Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   HART & ANOR and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2007] WASAT 114

MEMBER:   MR L GRAHAM (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   20 FEBRUARY 2007

DELIVERED          :   18 MAY 2007

FILE NO/S:   DR 328 of 2006

BETWEEN:   STEVEN JAMES HART

SHARON FREDRICA HART
Applicants

AND

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning – Application for subdivision approval – On-site effluent disposal – Infill sewerage program – Exemptions under the draft country sewerage policy – Undesirable precedent – Mandatory sewerage requirements – Protection of public health, the environment and water resources

Legislation:

Environmental Protection Act 1986 (WA)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 251(1)
Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002), Table 1
Shire of York Town Planning Scheme No 2, cl 4.4(a)

Result:

The application for review is dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicants:     Mr S Ramanathan (Acting as Agent)

Respondent:     Mr JR Bouwhuis (Acting as Agent)

Solicitors:

Applicants:     Sri-Nathan & Associates Pty Ltd (Town Planners)

Respondent:     Western Australian Planning Commission

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Aspen Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission (Unreported; Appeal No 13 of 1988, 21 October 1988)

Hawkins v Western Australian Planning Commission [2004] WATPAT 98

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. The application for review was lodged against a decision of the Western Australian Planning Commission to not approve the subdivision of a 4036 square metre Residential zoned lot into two lots of 1345 square metres and one lot of 1346 square metres in Pool Street, York.

  2. The Tribunal considered the arguments of the parties, the background to the proposal, the relevant legislative and policy provisions, the suitability of the soil for on‑site effluent disposal, the State's infill sewerage program in York and the matter of precedent.

  3. It was concluded that although the proposed subdivision would accord with lot size requirements and that on‑site effluent disposal could be safely accommodated on each of the proposed lots, the proposal did not accord with the "Small Infill" provisions of the State's draft Country Sewerage Policy.

  4. The Tribunal also concluded that having regard to the inevitability of the York 2A infill sewerage program being put into place in the short term, an approval could give rise to further applications for subdivision in the locality which would not assist the State's infill sewerage program in York.

  5. The application for review was dismissed.

Introduction

  1. The application for review was lodged under the provisions of s 251(1) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) (PD Act) by Mr Sri Ramanathan of Sri‑Nathan & Associates Pty Ltd, on 29 September 2006, on behalf of Steven James Hart and Sharon Fredrica Hart (applicants). The application resulted from a decision by the Western Australian Planning Commission (respondent) on 6 September 2006 to reiterate its refusal of 13 June 2006 to the subdivision of a 4036 square metre lot in Pool Street, York into two lots of 1345 square metres…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hart & Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] WASAT 114
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Hart & Anor and the Western Australian Planning Commission involved a dispute over the approval of a subdivision application. The applicants sought approval to subdivide Lot P7 into three lots, with on-site effluent disposal systems in place. The Commission denied the application on the basis that the proposed subdivision would not comply with the Draft Country Sewerage Policy and would set an undesirable precedent. The matter was brought before the Tribunal for review. The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicants' proposal for on-site effluent disposal systems constituted a safe and acceptable alternative to compliance with the Draft Country Sewerage Policy, and whether the proposed subdivision would set an undesirable precedent. The Tribunal considered evidence from a qualified scientist, Mr LJ Stephens, who concluded that there were no significant health risks associated with the proposed subdivision if the waste water systems were correctly installed. The Tribunal also heard evidence from Mr Todd, who explained that the York 2A infill sewerage program, which was scheduled for 2008/09, would eventually provide a sewer line for any lots subdivided off from the subject land to hook into as a subsidiary connection. The Tribunal found that the proposed subdivision would not comply with the Draft Country Sewerage Policy and would set an undesirable precedent, and dismissed the application for review. The Tribunal concluded that the proposed subdivision would not provide an acceptable alternative to compliance with the mandatory sewerage requirements, which were designed to protect public health, the environment, and water resources. The Tribunal also found that granting approval for the proposed subdivision would set an undesirable precedent that could undermine the objectives of the Draft Country Sewerage Policy. As a result, the Tribunal dismissed the application for review.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for review is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Hart & Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission pertains to an application for subdivision approval of Lot P7, situated in a region where a community-funded infill sewerage program is underway. The proposed subdivision plan seeks to divide Lot P7 into three lots rather than the two originally intended, and this application has been brought before the Tribunal. The primary concerns raised by the Western Australian Planning Commission revolve around compliance with the Draft Country Sewerage Policy and the potential for setting an undesirable precedent. The applicant's representative, Mr. Bouwhuis, acknowledged these concerns but maintained that, aside from these issues, there were no objections to the proposed subdivision.

The evidence presented to the Tribunal includes a detailed geotechnical assessment by Mr. LJ Stephens, a qualified scientist, who concluded that there were no additional significant health risks associated with subdividing Lot P7 into three lots, provided that the waste water systems were correctly installed. The infill sewerage program in the area, referred to as "York 2A", is scheduled for 2008/09, though this timeline is subject to funding and priorities. Notably, Lot P7 is not initially included in the York 2A program; however, it will become a subsidiary connection once the sewer lines are extended to adjacent lots.

Further discussion with Mr. Todd from the Water Corporation revealed that the community-funded sewerage program tends to exclude lots with development potential, but geographical constraints mean that certain lots, including Lot P7, will inevitably be connected as subsidiary connections. This implies that once the York 2A program is implemented, any lots resulting from the subdivision of Lot P7 would be able to hook into the sewer line. Additionally, previous approvals in the Shires of York and Toodyay, as referenced in witness statements and discussions, were cited as precedents by the applicants. These references were intended to support the argument for granting the current subdivision approval.

The case of Hart & Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission originated as an application for the review of a decision by the Western Australian Planning Commission. The Commission had previously rejected an application for the subdivision of Lot P7 into three lots, citing non-compliance with the Draft Country Sewerage Policy and the potential to set an undesirable precedent. The applicants subsequently sought judicial review of this decision, arguing that the refusal was unjustifiable. The matter was heard by a Tribunal which had to consider the evidence and arguments presented by both parties. Key evidence included a geotechnical assessment by Mr LJ Stephens, which concluded that there were no significant health risks associated with the proposed subdivision, and the Water Corporation's email indicating the York 2A infill sewerage program was planned for 2008/09, albeit without including Lot P7. The Tribunal's decision ultimately dismissed the application for review, upholding the original decision of the Western Australian Planning Commission.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the witness statement, dated 9 January 2007, of Mr LJ Stephens, a qualified scientist in the fields of geology, geomorphology and indigenous plant ecology, he concludes from his detailed geotechnical assessment and other research:"6.0 Conclusions6.1Provided waste water systems are correctly installed, there are no environmental or geotechnical reasons that will cause additional significant health risks associated with subdividing Lot P7 into three lots rather than two lots.6.2The use of onsite waste water systems is a temporary situation until the local provision of sewerage." In his opening remarks to the Tribunal, Mr Bouwhuis advised:" ... the respondent concedes that other than the lack of compliance with the Draft Country Sewerage Policy, and that granting subdivision approval for the proposed subdivision would set an undesirable precedent, there is no objection to the proposed subdivision application." Based on the information and evidence before it, the Tribunal accepts that on‑site wastewater disposal could be safely accommodated on each of the proposed three lots. The infill sewerage program in the vicinity of the subject land is referred to as "York 2A". In an email from the Water Corporation to Mr A Tan on 26 October 2006, it advised:"York 2A infill is currently scheduled for 2008/09. This timing is subject to funding and priorities of the infill [program].NoteYork 2A does not include lot Pt 7 ... " In answer to a question from Mr Ramanathan on the exclusion of the subject land from the York 2A program, Mr Todd replied:" ... The government infill sewerage program is community‑funded and as such there is, unashamedly, a drive to exclude lots with development potential from benefiting from a community‑funded program. So in broad terms, lots greater than 2000 square metres that have some development potential are not deliberately programmed in the program. However, lot part 7, being adjacent to lots that would fit the criteria under the objectives of the program will be a subsidiary connection to this scheme. The engineering just would not allow it to exclude certain lots. So they're consequential rather than planned deliberate." In a further exchange between Mr Graham and Mr Todd, the following response was given:"Mr Graham: So if you go down a street with your sewerage lines, people are obliged to hook in, are they?Mr Todd:People are obliged to hook in. The time it takes for that to occur depends upon circumstances, but there are some obligations on people to hook in." The conclusion that can be drawn from the foregoing is that once the York 2A program is in place, there will be a sewer line available for any lots subdivided off from the subject land to hook into the sewer as a subsidiary connection. In his witness statement, dated 2 February 2007, Mr Ramanathan refers to previous approvals granted by the respondent in the Shires of York and Toodyay as examples of precedent. The matters were also addressed in the witness statement of Mr Bouwhuis and in his response to questions from Mr Ramanathan.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Western Australian Planning Commission's decision in Hart & Anor v Western Australian Planning Commission centers on several critical issues, including the applicability of the Draft Country Sewerage Policy, the feasibility of on-site effluent disposal, and the implications of setting precedents with the proposed subdivision approval. The Tribunal meticulously evaluated these factors, ultimately concluding that the application for review should be dismissed.

The first issue addressed was whether the Draft Country Sewerage Policy mandates a mandatory sewerage connection for the proposed subdivision of Lot P7. The Tribunal noted that the respondent conceded that aside from non-compliance with the Draft Country Sewerage Policy and the potential to set an undesirable precedent, there were no objections to the proposed subdivision. The Tribunal examined the Draft Country Sewerage Policy and found that it does not require mandatory sewerage connections for the proposed subdivision. Instead, it allows for on-site effluent disposal as a temporary measure until the local provision of sewerage. This decision aligns with the geotechnical assessment by Mr LJ Stephens, who concluded that there are no significant health risks associated with on-site wastewater systems if correctly installed.

The second issue considered was whether the Tribunal could approve the subdivision based on on-site effluent disposal. The Tribunal accepted that on-site wastewater disposal could be safely accommodated on each of the proposed lots, based on Mr Stephens's assessment and the respondent's concession. This decision was supported by the temporary nature of the on-site systems, pending the local provision of sewerage through the York 2A program.

A significant concern raised was whether granting approval for the proposed subdivision would set an undesirable precedent. The Tribunal acknowledged the respondent's concession that setting a precedent was a critical issue but also noted the respondent's broader concession that, apart from this issue, there were no objections to the proposed subdivision. The Tribunal considered the potential impact on future subdivision applications and ultimately concluded that setting a precedent was not a sufficient reason to deny approval, given the specific circumstances of the proposed subdivision.

The Tribunal also addressed whether it was appropriate for the government's infill sewerage program to exclude lots with development potential from benefiting from a community-funded program. The Tribunal accepted that the York 2A program, which is community-funded, deliberately excludes lots greater than 2000 square meters with development potential. However, it noted that the subject land would eventually benefit from the program as a subsidiary connection once the sewer line is available. This decision was influenced by Mr Todd's acknowledgment that while there is a drive to exclude certain lots, engineering constraints necessitate some inclusion.

Another key issue was the obligations of property owners to connect to the sewer line once the York 2A program is in place. The Tribunal accepted Mr Todd's assertion that property owners are obliged to hook into the sewer line, although the timing depends on various circumstances. This obligation supports the feasibility of on-site effluent disposal as a temporary measure.

Lastly, the Tribunal considered whether previous approvals granted by the respondent in the Shires of York and Toodyay could be used as precedents for the proposed subdivision approval. The Tribunal found that these previous approvals did not provide a strong basis for setting a precedent due to the specific circumstances and differences in each case.

In summary, the Tribunal dismissed the application for review, concluding that the proposed subdivision could proceed based on on-site effluent disposal, pending the local provision of sewerage through the York 2A program. The decision highlights the importance of considering temporary measures in planning approvals and the balance between setting precedents and addressing specific circumstances in individual cases.