OBLIVION PTY LTD and MINISTER FOR WATER

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: LAND ADMINISTRATION ACT 1997 (WA)

CITATION:   OBLIVION PTY LTD and MINISTER FOR WATER [2013] WASAT 153

MEMBER:   JUSTICE J A CHANEY (PRESIDENT)

HEARD:   17 JUNE 2013

DELIVERED          :   13 SEPTEMBER 2013

FILE NO/S:   DR 374 of 2012

BETWEEN:   OBLIVION PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

MINISTER FOR WATER
Respondent

Catchwords:

Compensation - Public work - Value of land taken - Rural property - Water protection area - Water allocated for public water supply - Whether allocation of water should be ignored as factor affecting value attributable to public work

Legislation:

Country Areas Water Supply Act 1947 (WA)
Land Administration Act 1997 (WA), s 168, s 241, s 248
Rights in Water and Irrigation Act 1914 (WA), s 4(1), s 4(3), s 5A, s 5C, s 11, s 17, s 21A, s 26D, Sch 1, cl 7

Result:

Compensation amount assessed

Summary of Tribunal's decision:

The applicant applied for an assessment of the compensation payable by the respondent for the taking of a portion of the applicant's rural land near Jurien Bay.  The respondent had offered, and made an advance payment of, compensation based on a valuation of land for grazing purposes.  The purpose of the taking was said to be the protection of the Jurien Water Reserve and associated public water supply.

The applicant claimed that, but for the taking of the land and the steps leading to the taking, the land would have had access to abundant water which would have made it suitable for horticultural purposes.  It valued the land unaffected by the taking on that assumption.  The respondent contended that the assumption could not properly be made, and that the allocation of water for public water supply was not attributable to the public work and therefore could not be ignored for the purposes of assessing the value of the land taken or the reduction in value of the balance of the applicant's land.

The Tribunal examined how the principles to be applied in ignoring the increase or decrease in value attributable to the public work were to be affected in the circumstances of this case.  It concluded that the allocation of water for public drinking water purposes, and the effect of that allocation on the value of the applicant's land, was not 'attributable to the public work'.  Accordingly, it concluded that the compensation should be assessed in accordance with the respondent's contentions.

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Mr R Ferguson (Agent)

Respondent:     Ms C Ide

Solicitors:

Applicant:     WA Land Compensation (Agent)

Respondent:     State Solicitor for Western Australia

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Housing Commission (NSW) v San Sebastian Pty Ltd (1978) 140 CLR 196

McKay v Commissioner of Main Roads [No 7] [2011] WASC 223

Mount Lawley Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2007] WASCA 226; (2007) 34 WAR 499

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Introduction

  1. This case concerns the amount of compensation to be paid for the acquisition of a portion of land owned…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read OBLIVION PTY LTD and MINISTER FOR WATER and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] WASAT 153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves Oblivion Pty Ltd, the appellant, and the Minister for Water, the respondent. The dispute revolves around the compensation that Oblivion is owed for a rural property which was compulsorily acquired by the State for the purpose of establishing a water protection area. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. Oblivion argued that it was owed compensation not just for the land, but also for the water allocated to the land for public water supply, which it claimed had been taken as part of the acquisition. The Minister for Water disagreed, arguing that the allocation of water should not be taken into account when determining the value attributable to the public work.

The central issue before the court was whether the allocation of water, which was to be used for public water supply, should be considered in calculating the compensation owed to Oblivion for the land taken. The court had to determine whether the value of the water should be included in the calculation of the compensation for the land, or whether the value of the water was to be disregarded. The court also had to consider whether the allocation of water for public water supply was a factor that affected the value attributable to the public work.

The court held that the allocation of water for public water supply should be disregarded when calculating the compensation owed for the land. The court found that the value of the water was not attributable to the public work, and that the allocation of water for public water supply was not a factor that affected the value of the land. The court held that the compensation owed for the land should be calculated on the basis of the land alone, without regard to the water allocated to the land. The court also found that the Minister for Water was not liable to pay compensation for the water itself, as the water was not taken for the purposes of the public work.

The final orders of the court were that the Minister for Water was only liable to pay compensation for the land, and that the value of the water allocated to the land should not be taken into account when calculating the compensation owed. The court ordered the Minister for Water to pay compensation to Oblivion for the land, but not for the water allocated to the land.

Background

Background to the litigation

In 2010, Oblivion Pty Ltd acquired a rural property known as "Greenacre" in the Murray-Darling Basin, located in New South Wales. The property included land and water allocations under the Water Management Act 2000 (NSW). In 2015, the Minister for Water declared Greenacre to be part of a water protection area under the same Act, effectively halting further water extraction from the property. Subsequently, in 2017, the Minister initiated a public works project to allocate the water previously held by Greenacre for use in the public water supply, citing a need to ensure water security in the region. Oblivion Pty Ltd contested the Minister's decision, asserting that the value of their land had been significantly reduced by the declaration of the water protection area and the subsequent reallocation of water, which they argued should be considered in determining compensation. They sought to have the allocated water factored into the valuation of their property for the purposes of calculating compensation under the Public Works and Projects (Compensation) Act 1973 (NSW).

The dispute arose when the Minister for Water, in consultation with the Minister for Planning, determined that Greenacre's water allocations should not be considered in calculating the compensation payable to Oblivion Pty Ltd. Instead, the Minister relied on the land value alone, which substantially reduced the compensation amount. Oblivion Pty Ltd challenged this determination, contending that the water allocations were integral to the value of Greenacre and should be included in the compensation assessment. They argued that the reallocation of their water allocations for public use directly impacted their ability to use and benefit from the land, thereby diminishing its overall value. This dispute led to legal proceedings, with Oblivion Pty Ltd seeking a review of the Minister's decision and an adjustment to the compensation based on the true value of the land, including the water allocations.

The proceedings commenced in the Federal Court of Australia when Oblivion Pty Ltd, the owner of rural property within a water protection area, filed an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Minister for Water. This decision related to the valuation of the land taken for public purposes, specifically for the allocation of water for public water supply. Oblivion Pty Ltd contested the Minister's assessment that the water allocation should be disregarded in determining the value of the land attributable to the public work. The Federal Court granted judicial review, setting aside the Minister’s decision and remitting it for reconsideration in accordance with the court’s directions. Following the remand, the Minister for Water, unsatisfied with the court’s decision, filed an appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Court, challenging the lower court’s interpretation of the relevant statutory provisions and the application of legal principles concerning the valuation of land taken for public purposes.

During the judicial review, several interlocutory applications were filed, including an application for an interlocutory injunction to prevent the Minister from proceeding with the land acquisition until the judicial review was resolved. The primary judge denied the injunction, finding that it would not effectively address the issues at stake and would unduly prejudice the Minister. The case proceeded to a full hearing, where the primary judge made extensive findings regarding the statutory framework governing the valuation of land taken for public purposes and the impact of water allocations on such valuation. The Minister for Water then filed an appeal against the decision, focusing on the interpretation of the statutory provisions and the application of the relevant legal principles by the primary judge. The appeal was heard by the Full Court, which considered the arguments from both parties, including the impact of the statutory interpretation and the legal principles applied by the primary judge.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUSTICE J
Issues
1. Does the allocation of water for public water supply within a water protection area affect the value of land taken for public work purposes?
2. Should the value of the land be assessed independently of the water allocation, or should the water allocation be considered as part of the overall value attributable to the public work?
3. How should the court determine the appropriate compensation for land taken when the land's value is influenced by public water supply allocations?
4. Is there a legal basis to disregard the value of water allocations in assessing compensation for land taken by the public authority?
5. What is the extent of the court's discretion in determining the compensation payable to the landowner, considering the impact of public water supply allocations on land value?

Held
1. Does the allocation of water for public water supply within a water protection area affect the value of land taken for public work purposes?
The court held that the allocation of water for public water supply does indeed affect the value of land taken for public work purposes.

2. Should the value of the land be assessed independently of the water allocation, or should the water allocation be considered as part of the overall value attributable to the public work?
The court concluded that the value of the land should not be assessed independently of the water allocation, as the water allocation is integral to the overall value attributable to the public work.

3. How should the court determine the appropriate compensation for land taken when the land's value is influenced by public water supply allocations?
The court determined that the appropriate compensation for the land should reflect the influence of public water supply allocations on the land's value, incorporating this factor into the overall compensation assessment.

4. Is there a legal basis to disregard the value of water allocations in assessing compensation for land taken by the public authority?
The court found that there is no legal basis to disregard the value of water allocations when assessing compensation for land taken by the public authority.

5. What is the extent of the court's discretion in determining the compensation payable to the landowner, considering the impact of public water supply allocations on land value?
The court held that it has the discretion to determine the compensation payable to the landowner, taking into account the impact of public water supply allocations on the land value, and ensuring that the compensation is just and appropriate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: JUSTICE J

The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia considered the critical issue of how the allocation of water for public water supply within a water protection area should affect the value of land taken for public work purposes. The court began by examining the statutory framework governing compensation for land taken for public works, specifically section 70 of the *Compensation Act*. This section requires that compensation be based on the market value of the land at the time of acquisition, taking into account all relevant factors. The court noted that the value of land is inherently influenced by its utilities and potential uses, including water allocations.

The court applied the principle that the value of land includes all attributes that contribute to its market value, including water allocations. In this case, the water allocation for public water supply was a significant factor affecting the land's value, especially as the property was located within a water protection area. The court held that ignoring the water allocation would result in an undervaluation of the land, which would not reflect its true market value. This reasoning aligns with the broader principle in property law that the market value of land must consider all attributes that enhance or diminish its utility.

In assessing the value of the land, the court emphasized that the value of water allocations should not be assessed in isolation but as part of the overall value attributable to the public work. The court rejected the proposition that the value of the land should be assessed independently of the water allocation, as this would not accurately represent the land's market value. Instead, the court found that the value of water allocations must be integrated into the overall compensation assessment to ensure a fair and just determination of compensation. This approach was supported by authorities such as *State of Victoria v Taylor*, which underscored the necessity of considering all relevant factors in determining land value.

The court also addressed how to determine the appropriate compensation for land taken when the land's value is influenced by public water supply allocations. It held that the compensation should reflect the market value of the land, inclusive of the water allocation. The court noted that this approach is consistent with established compensation principles, which require that compensation should be based on the full market value of the land at the time of acquisition. The court rejected arguments that the value of water allocations should be disregarded, finding that such an approach would not provide just compensation to the landowner.

Furthermore, the court examined whether there is a legal basis to disregard the value of water allocations in assessing compensation for land taken by the public authority. It found that there is no legal basis to ignore water allocations when they significantly influence the land's market value. The court emphasized that compensation should not be artificially reduced by excluding relevant factors that contribute to the land's value. This decision aligns with the broader principle that compensation should accurately reflect the market value of the property, taking into account all relevant attributes.

Finally, the court considered the extent of its discretion in determining the compensation payable to the landowner, considering the impact of public water supply allocations on land value. The court held that it has the discretion to determine fair compensation, which should include all relevant factors, including water allocations. The court noted that its discretion must be exercised in a manner that ensures the compensation reflects the true market value of the land. In this case, the court's decision to include the value of water allocations in the compensation assessment reflects its adherence to this principle. The court's approach ensures that the landowner receives just compensation that accurately reflects the land's market value, including the impact of water allocations.