Oasis Flight Training Pty Ltd and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

[2013] AATA 600 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2012/4999

Re

Oasis Flight Training Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

And

Civil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Egon Fice, Senior Member

Date 23 August 2013 
Place Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision of the Civil Aviation Safety Authority dated
2 November 2012.

.......[sgd Egon Fice].................................................................

Egon Fice, Senior Member

AVIATION – Air Operator’s Certificate – Flying training – General aviation charter and aerial work – Safety Rules – Smoking within 15m of an aircraft – Restriction on advertising of commercial operations – Recreational aircraft and flying training – Infringement notices – Allowing a student to fly solo in an aircraft without a licence – False and misleading information on an AOC application – Standard of proof

Legislation

Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 3, 9A, 20AB, 27, 28, 29, 30DB, 30DC, 31
Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) ss 9.1, 9.2, 136.1

Regulations
Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (Cth) regs 5.20, 206, 210, 269, 282, 289, 296F, 308
Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth)

Order
Civil Aviation Order 95.55

Cases

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Civil Aviation Safety Authority v Boatman [2006] FCA 460
George v Rockett (1990) 170 CLR 104
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298
Phillips and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy [2012] AATA 788

Rejfek v McElroy (1965) 112 CLR 517

REASONS FOR DECISION

Egon Fice, Senior Member

23 August 2013 

  1. Mr Kristos Konstandopoulos, who is the sole director of Oasis Flight Training Pty Ltd (Oasis), lodged an application with the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) on 23 March 2011 for the issue of an Air Operator’s Certificate (AOC) to permit the conduct of General Aviation (GA) charter and aerial work operations (including flying training).

  2. Oasis currently operates a flying training School at Moorabbin airport using recreational (formerly referred to as ultra-light) aircraft operated under Civil Aviation Order 95.55 (CAO 95.55).  Approval for that operation was granted by Recreational Aviation Australia Incorporated (RA-Aus), a CASA approved organisation.  In essence, CAO 95.55 applies to single place or two place lightweight recreational aircraft, registered by RA-Aus, and whose weight does not exceed 600 kg.  It does not apply to GA aircraft.

  3. In his AOC application, Mr Konstandopoulos named himself as the Chief Executive Officer/Managing Director of Oasis which was to hold the AOC as well as the nominated Head of Flying Operations (Chief Pilot) and Head of Aircraft Maintenance.  He also nominated himself for the position of Chief Flying Instructor.  On 25 January 2012


    Mr Konstandopoulos also applied for approval as an Approved Testing Officer (General Aviation), indicating that he had applied for an AOC and needed to have this delegation in order to test students who conducted flight training with Oasis. 

  4. On 17 May 2012, prior to his AOC application being determined, CASA issued


    Mr Konstandopoulos with an infringement notice alleging that Oasis had advertised claiming to undertake, by use of Australian aircraft, a commercial operation while it did not hold an AOC authorising that operation.  Also on that day a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oasis Flight Training Pty Ltd and Civil Aviation Safety Auth... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 600
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) involved a dispute between Oasis Flight Training Pty Ltd (Oasis) and the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) over CASA's refusal to issue an Air Operator's Certificate (AOC) to Oasis. Oasis, represented by Mr. Konstandopoulos, had applied for an AOC but CASA declined to issue it, citing concerns about Oasis's compliance with safety regulations and suitability to conduct AOC operations. Oasis sought review of CASA's decision, and the Tribunal was tasked with determining whether CASA's refusal to grant the AOC was justified.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Oasis had complied, or was capable of complying, with safety regulations and Civil Aviation Orders (CAO), whether Oasis's organisation was suitable to conduct AOC operations safely, and whether Oasis had an appropriate chain of command and sufficient qualified personnel. These issues were derived from the statutory requirements outlined in the Civil Aviation Act 1988, which mandates that CASA must be satisfied about certain matters before issuing an AOC.

The Tribunal examined CASA's decision-making process and the evidence presented. It noted that CASA had to thoroughly assess Oasis's history, particularly recent events, to determine future compliance with safety rules. The Tribunal highlighted that Oasis had faced previous infringements, specifically for advertising commercial operations without an AOC, which CASA deemed a significant indicator of potential non-compliance. Despite Oasis's argument that it was in the process of obtaining an AOC, the Tribunal found that repeated non-compliance with regulatory requirements raised concerns about Oasis's future conduct and management of flying operations.

Ultimately, the Tribunal upheld CASA's decision to refuse the AOC, finding that the evidence supported CASA's concerns about Oasis's compliance history and suitability to conduct AOC operations safely. The Tribunal concluded that CASA's decision was reasonable and justified based on the statutory criteria and the evidence provided.

The Tribunal's final order affirmed CASA's decision to refuse to issue the AOC to Oasis Flight Training Pty Ltd.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In a letter dated 2 November 2012 CASA notified Oasis that it refused to issue an AOC. Mr Konstandopoulos on behalf of Oasis lodged an application for review with the Tribunal on 5 November 2012. Section 31 of the Civil Aviation Act 1988 (the CA Act) makes provision for the review of decisions as follows:… reviewable decision means:(a)a refusal to grant or issue, or a cancellation, suspension or variation of, a certificate, permission, permit or licence granted or issued under this Act or the regulations;…(2) Application may be made to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of a reviewable decision. I am required to determine whether the decision made by CASA on 2 November 2012 to refuse to grant Oasis an AOC was the correct decision. The issues which arise in making that determination are those which CASA must consider and be satisfied about before it can issue an AOC. In this matter, they are whether:(a)Oasis has complied with, or is capable of complying with the provisions of the regulations and the CAO's relating to safety;(b)the organisation is suitable to ensure that the AOC operations can be conducted or carried out safely;(c)the organisation's chain of command is appropriate to ensure that the AOC operations can be conducted or carried out safely; and(d)the organisation has a sufficient number of suitably qualified and competent employees to conduct the AOC operations safely.THE ISSUE OF AOCS GENERALLY Subdivision D of Division 2, Part III of the CA Act deals generally with the issue of AOCs. Section 28, in so far as it is relevant to this matter, provides:28 CASA must issue AOC if satisfied about certain matters(1) If a person applies to CASA for an AOC, CASA must issue the AOC if, and only if:(a)CASA is satisfied that the applicant has complied with, or is capable of complying with the safety rules; and(b)CASA is satisfied about the following matters in relation to the applicant's organisation:(i) the organisation is suitable to ensure that the AOC operations can be conducted or carried out safely, having regard to the nature of the AOC operations;(ii) the organisation's chain of command is appropriate to ensure that the AOC operations can be conducted or carried out safely;(iii) the organisation has a sufficient number of suitably qualified and competent employees to conduct or carry out the AOC operations safely;(iv) key personnel in the organisation have appropriate experience in air operations to conduct or carry out the AOC operations safely;… It should be immediately apparent from the provisions I have quoted above, and in particular s. 28(1)(a) of the CA Act, that CASA must examine the history of an applicant, without reservation, in order to determine whether an applicant has complied with safety rules. That history, and in particular the more recent history, may be an indicator of whether an applicant will comply with safety rules in the future. The expression safety rules is defined in s. 3 of the CA Act as:safety rules, in relation to a permission or AOC, means the provisions of this Act, the regulations and the Civil Aviation Orders that relate to safety (including rules about the competence of persons to do anything that would be covered by the permission or AOC).2007 – 2008 INFRINGEMENT NOTICES

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

According to the evidence before me, Mr Konstandopoulos first came to the attention of CASA in an adverse way in May 2007. Shortly prior to that incident, on 3 February 2007, Oasis made an application for a charter and aerial work AOC. It appears that Mr Konstandopoulos, in anticipation of being granted an AOC, advertised on the Oasis website that it could provide charter and flying training. CASA issued an infringement notice (07-0051) on the grounds that Oasis had breached Civil Aviation Regulations 1988 (CAR) 210. That regulation provides:210 Restriction of advertising of commercial operations(1) A person must not give public notice, by newspaper advertisement, broadcast statement or any other means of public announcement, to the effect that a person is willing to undertake by use of an Australian aircraft any commercial operations if the last-mentioned person has not obtained an Air Operator's Certificate authorising the conduct of those operations.Penalty: 10 penalty units.(2) An offence against subregulation (1) is an offence of strict liability. In fact, in a letter dated 29 May 2007 from CASA, it was said that the Moorabbin Field Office alerted Mr Konstandopoulos to the restrictions set out in CAR 210 and that despite being informed of those restrictions, he continued to advertise commercial operations on the Oasis website. In its statement of facts, issues and contentions, CASA said Mr Konstandopoulos subsequently paid a fine of $550 and lost one demerit point from his pilot licence. On the evidence before me, the prescribed penalty for that offence was $110 and not the $550 claimed by CASA. In a written statement dated 11 January 2013 made by Mr Konstandopoulos, which was admitted into evidence, he said that he was authorised to conduct flying training in Australian aircraft pursuant to a Certificate of Approval issued by RA-Aus. He said he was in the process of making an application for an AOC and a CASA Flight Operations Inspector (FOI), Mr Priest, said to him:… words to the effect that reference to charter in the advertising would not be an adverse issue with CASA as I was in the process of obtaining an AOC. I informed CASA of the representation made by FOI Priest and paid the penalty with no admission as to fault. However, despite what Mr Konstandopoulos said in his witness statement, I had in evidence the copy of an e-mail sent by Mr Priest to Oasis Flight Training on 18 May 2007, some 11 days prior to CASA informing him that he was in breach of CAR 210 and that an infringement notice would issue. Mr Priest said: I have also, today, spoken with CASA's legal counsel who confirmed, according to the description I gave, that your website (e.g. is in breach of CAR 210. Therefore this must be immediately altered to comply, otherwise CASA will be obligated to consider further action. In fact, Mr Priest sent an internal e-mail to another CASA officer on 25 May 2007 stating that, to the best of his knowledge, the Oasis website breached CAR 210. Mr Priest repeated the quote I have referred to above and added:This is the first advise (sic) in writing I have given to Kris, but it was not the first advise (sic). I verbally advised him that I believed this to be in breach of CAR 210 in a phone call with Kris on Saturday morning 12th May, and again when I had an extensive discussion with him on 18th May 2007 over the issues I had found with his Operations Manual.Consequently, I believe that while Kris remains non-compliant with CAR 210 (and I just checked the website now to see if any appropriate changes had been made – which is what I wrote to him to do) CASA should suspend his application, and consider issuing him with an admin fine.Please note he has made a change to his website viz:"We provide the flight training for GA under MAS AOC and the charter under Oasis Flight Training AOC"…However MAS is not defined, nor is he still compliant in that the website is advertising that he has an AOC (namely Oasis Flight Training).It also raises the question of whether, after having been informed that this on three occasions now, whether he is demonstrating a satisfactory record in the conduct or management of flying operations (CAO 82.0 appendix 1, 1.3 (a)).