O'MEARA v FWV Stanke Holdings Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

O'MEARA v FWV STANKE HOLDINGS PTY LTD (No 3)

[2007] SASC 305

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Vanstone

17 August 2007

CORPORATIONS - MEMBERSHIP, RIGHTS AND REMEDIES - MEMBERS' REMEDIES AND INTERNAL DISPUTES - PROCEEDINGS ON BEHALF OF COMPANY BY MEMBER - STATUTORY DERIVATIVE ACTION

Plaintiff applies under s 237 Corporations Act to intervene in proceedings to take over defence of a company and to file a contribution notice - whether plaintiff acting in good faith - whether in best interests of company - whether serious question to be tried. Held: criteria in s 237(2) satisfied, application granted.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 237, referred to.
Carpenter v Pioneer Park Pty Ltd (in liq) (2004) 211 ALR 457; Swansson v R A Pratt Properties Pty Ltd (2002) 42 ACSR 313; Chahwan v Euphoric Pty ltd [2006] NSWSC 1002; Williams v Spautz (1992) 174 CLR 509, applied.
Belmont Finance Corporation Ltd v Williams Furniture Ltd [1979] Ch 250; Shelton v National Roads and Motorists Association Ltd (2004) 51 ACSR 278; Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298, considered.

O'MEARA v FWV STANKE HOLDINGS PTY LTD (No 3)
[2007] SASC 305

Civil

VANSTONE J:

Introduction

  1. By originating process filed 3 July 2007 the plaintiff, Mrs Leonie O’Meara, seeks permission under s 237 Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to intervene in action number 1565 of 2005 for the purpose of taking responsibility on behalf of the defendant (the third defendant in that matter) for its defence of the proceedings. Then, permission is sought to file an amended defence and a contribution notice.

  2. The application is supported by an affidavit of the plaintiff, the annexures to which include the current and the proposed pleadings in action number 1565. 

  3. The plaintiff has standing to bring this application as she is the holder of one of the four shares in the defendant company.  I note that she is also a beneficiary of the wills of her late parents, each of whom also held one share in the defendant.  Her brother, Frederick John Von Stanke, holds the other share and is a director of the defendant, as are also his two children.

  4. The defendant company resists the application.  In an earlier hearing I allowed two applications for permission to intervene to put submissions in opposition to the plaintiff’s application.  The intervenors are Mr Von Stanke in his capacity as executor for the estates of each of his parents (represented by Ms E F Nelson QC with Mr S D Ower) and Mr Von Stanke in his capacity as a shareholder of the defendant (represented by Mr P N Vickery QC with Mr T P Duggan).  The company itself, which, as I mentioned, counts Mr Von Stanke as a director, was represented by Mr T F Bathurst QC and Mr M A Frayne.  Mr Von Stanke was, then, to say the least, adequately represented on this application.  He filed affidavits in each of his capacities but, ultimately…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'MEARA v FWV Stanke Holdings Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 305
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of O'Meara v FWV Stanke Holdings Pty Ltd (No 3) involved a plaintiff seeking to intervene in proceedings to take over the defence of FWV Stanke Holdings Pty Ltd, a family company involved in a larger corporate dispute. The plaintiff aimed to file a contribution notice, seeking that FWV support the plaintiff's claims in an underlying oppression action. The court had to decide whether the plaintiff was acting in good faith, whether the intervention was in the best interests of the company, and whether there was a serious question to be tried. The case was heard and determined by the court, which found that the statutory criteria set out in section 237(2) of the Corporations Act were satisfied, thereby granting the plaintiff's application.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff met the statutory criteria for intervening in the proceedings and taking over the defence of FWV. The court had to examine the evidence and submissions from both sides to determine whether the plaintiff's actions were in good faith, aligned with the best interests of the company, and if there was a serious question to be tried. The court also needed to consider whether the plaintiff had an adequate basis for believing that the defence of FWV would support her claims in the underlying action.

The court found that the plaintiff had sufficiently demonstrated that her actions were in good faith and in the best interests of the company. The plaintiff's evidence was uncontradicted and accepted by the court. The court was satisfied that there was a serious question to be tried, as the plaintiff's claims aligned with the "conventional understanding" that had been put forward by the defendants in the underlying action. The court considered the evidence provided by the plaintiff and did not need to draw any adverse inferences against the defendants for their failure to provide evidence. Based on these findings, the court concluded that the statutory criteria under section 237(2) were met, and therefore, the plaintiff's application was granted.

In conclusion, the court granted the plaintiff's application to intervene in the proceedings and take over the defence of FWV Stanke Holdings Pty Ltd. The court found that the plaintiff had satisfied the criteria set out in section 237(2) of the Corporations Act, including acting in good faith and in the best interests of the company, and that there was a serious question to be tried. The court will hear further submissions from the parties regarding the form of the orders to be made in light of the granted application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

I have had the benefit of extensive submissions, both written and oral, made on behalf of the defendant and for Mr Von Stanke in each of his capacities. Senior Counsel have referred me to the leading authorities on all aspects of the matter. The application was listed before me at short notice because the trial in action number 1565 is scheduled to commence on 15 November next. In view of that timetable I have determined to deliver my decision speedily, possibly at some cost to the extent of detail in these reasons.Background I set out something of the background to this application. The defendant, FWV Stanke Holdings Pty Ltd (“FWV”) is one of three companies which I shall call “the family companies”. The other two family companies are RCV Stanke Estates Pty Ltd (“RCV”) and JHV Stanke Properties Pty Ltd (“JHV”). These companies are aligned with three branches of the Von Stanke family, a family whose members, over more than 50 years, have pursued vocations as fishers, based in a location called Carpenter Rocks, not far from Mount Gambier. Each of the family companies owns one share in each of two further companies which I shall call “the fishing companies”. These run the fishing and fish processing businesses conducted at Carpenter Rocks. One or other of the fishing companies is the registered proprietor of large holdings of land in that area and further owns numbers of very valuable fishing licences which are used by various members of the Von Stanke family. The underlying action, number 1565, is an oppression claim brought by JHV against the fishing companies, certain directors of the fishing companies, including Mr Von Stanke, and the other two family companies, FWV and RCV. JHV alleges that the affairs of the fishing companies have been conducted in a manner which is oppressive to JHV by reason of decisions taken in the course of the business they run, the use of the companies’ assets, their failure to pay dividends and other matters. JHV seeks relief including an order for an account and enquiry of profits and that its shares in the fishing companies be bought by the other family companies. For the most part the fishing companies and the directors of the fishing companies admit the allegations. However they justify the way in which the business of the fishing companies has been conducted by reason of what is referred to as a “conventional understanding”. FWV has filed a defence in which it does not plead to a majority of the allegations. If the plaintiff were to take over the conduct of FWV’s defence it would be with a view to FWV supporting JHV’s claim and seeking similar relief on its own behalf by means of a contribution notice. She has offered an undertaking to the effect (broadly) that if FWV is unsuccessful in her hands she will meet any costs incurred by FWV from the point of her intervention.The s 237(2) criteria Section 237(2) Corporations Act sets out five criteria, satisfaction of which will result in the court granting the application.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to all these matters and to the findings I have made in relation to the issues of good faith and best interests of the company, I consider the plaintiff has sufficiently answered this criterion.Conclusion I mentioned that although Mr Von Stanke filed affidavits in support of the position he takes in each capacity they were not tendered. I have not read them. Counsel for the plaintiff suggested that I should draw adverse inferences against Mr Von Stanke by reason of his failure to give evidence on various issues raised by s 237 and by Mrs O’Meara’s evidence. He suggested that those inferences could be drawn by reference to Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298. In the event I have not needed to consider that issue. I have reached my conclusions on the basis of the evidence before me which is uncontradicted and which I have accepted, and without reference to any inference that Mr Von Stanke’s evidence would not have helped him. The plaintiff has met the requirements imposed by s 237(2). I must therefore grant the application. I shall hear the parties as to the form of the orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established