O'Donnell t/as Ronin Built v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND

ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CITATION:

O’Donnell t/as Ronin Built v Queensland Building and Construction Commission  [2020] QCAT 293

PARTIES: MORGAN JAMES O’DONNELL T/AS RONIN BUILT

(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR286-19

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

22 July 2020

HEARING DATE:

15 July 2020

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Kanowski

ORDERS:

1.   The decision made by Queensland Building and Construction Commission on internal review on 8 July 2019 to issue directions to rectify in respect of complaint items 9 and 17 is set aside.

2.   A decision is substituted not to issue directions to rectify in respect of those items.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – BUILDERS – STATUTORY POWER TO REQUIRE RECTIFICATION OF DEFECTIVE OR INCOMPLETE BUILDING WORK – where defective work but outstanding claim for payment against homeowners – whether unfair to issue direction to rectify

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 72

Birrell v Queensland Building Services Authority [2013] QCAT 56

Feodoroff v Queensland Building Services Authority [2005] QCCTB 146

Paul Wayne Townsend v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2019] QCAT 239

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented

Respondent:

HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. This is a review of a decision made by Queensland Building and Construction Commission (‘QBCC’) to issue directions to rectify to Mr O'Donnell, who is a licensed builder. Mr O'Donnell contends that directions to rectify should not have been issued. QBCC argues that the directions to rectify were appropriate.

  2. The Tribunal’s role is to conduct a fresh hearing on the merits, in order to reach the correct and preferable decision.[1] The Tribunal may confirm, amend or set aside QBCC’s decision.[2]

    [2]Ibid, s 24(1).

  3. Background

  4. Mr O'Donnell built a studio extension to a house in late 2018. It is a free-standing structure in the back yard of the property, next to a swimming pool. The contract price for the work was $74,697.65.

  5. Mr O'Donnell built the studio and considered that it had reached practical completion in December 2018, subject to any minor defects and omissions to be attended to during the defects liability period under the contract. The homeowners had obtained a pre-handover report from a building inspector, and they took a different view. A dispute ensued over payment of the amount still owing under the contract.

  6. In January 2019 Mr O'Donnell started a proceeding in the Tribunal against the homeowners, seeking payment of $19,286.51. In April 2019, the homeowners paid Mr O'Donnell $11,231.75. The homeowners paid the remainder of the disputed sum, $8,054.76, into the Master Builders Queensland holding account. This was pursuant to a term in the contract which permitted disputed sums to be paid into that account pending resolution. In June 2019 the homeowners agreed to the release of $5,371.26 from the holding account to Mr O'Donnell. This left $2,683.50 in dispute.

  7. On 12 September 2019 the Tribunal proceeding ended in a final decision under which the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Donnell t/as Ronin Built v Queensland Building and Constru... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QCAT 293
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of O'Donnell trading as Ronin Built versus the Queensland Building and Construction Commission involves a dispute over the rectification of defective building work. Mr O'Donnell, who built a studio extension for homeowners, was in a dispute over the final payment due to him. The homeowners complained to the Commission that the work was defective. The Commission initially decided not to issue rectification directions due to the outstanding payment dispute. However, after the homeowners released a portion of the disputed funds to Mr O'Donnell, the Commission's internal reviewer decided to issue rectification directions for certain defects. Mr O'Donnell challenged this decision in court.

The key legal issue before the court was whether the Queensland Building and Construction Commission was correct in its decision to issue rectification directions to Mr O'Donnell. The court had to determine if the outstanding payment dispute justified not issuing the directions. The court considered the circumstances of the case, including the amount still in dispute and whether Mr O'Donnell had taken steps to rectify the defects.

The court found that the Commission's decision to issue the rectification directions was not justified. The outstanding payment dispute was still significant enough to make it unfair to issue the directions. The court also noted that Mr O'Donnell had not taken any steps to rectify the defects since the payment release. Therefore, the court set aside the Commission's internal reviewer's decision and substituted a decision not to issue the rectification directions.

The court's final orders were to set aside the decision made by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission on internal review on 8 July 2019 to issue directions to rectify in respect of complaint items 9 and 17, and to substitute a decision not to issue those directions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision made by Queensland Building and Construction Commission on internal review on 8 July 2019 to issue directions to rectify in respect of complaint items 9 and 17 is set aside.

2. A decision is substituted not to issue directions to rectify in respect of those items.

Background

Background to the litigation

Background Mr O'Donnell built a studio extension to a house in late 2018. It is a free-standing structure in the back yard of the property, next to a swimming pool. The contract price for the work was $74,697.65. Mr O'Donnell built the studio and considered that it had reached practical completion in December 2018, subject to any minor defects and omissions to be attended to during the defects liability period under the contract. The homeowners had obtained a pre-handover report from a building inspector, and they took a different view. A dispute ensued over payment of the amount still owing under the contract. In January 2019 Mr O'Donnell started a proceeding in the Tribunal against the homeowners, seeking payment of $19,286.51. In April 2019, the homeowners paid Mr O'Donnell $11,231.75. The homeowners paid the remainder of the disputed sum, $8,054.76, into the Master Builders Queensland holding account. This was pursuant to a term in the contract which permitted disputed sums to be paid into that account pending resolution. In June 2019 the homeowners agreed to the release of $5,371.26 from the holding account to Mr O'Donnell. This left $2,683.50 in dispute. On 12 September 2019 the Tribunal proceeding ended in a final decision under which the $2,683.50 was to be released to the homeowners. I note that the Tribunal’s order indicates that it was made at a directions hearing, rather than after a substantive hearing on the merits. Accordingly, I accept Mr O'Donnell’s evidence that this decision resulted from a settlement agreement between the parties. Meanwhile, the homeowners had made two complaints to QBCC of defective work. The complaint which has led to the present proceeding is the earlier one, made in January 2019. It contained 23 complaint items. A QBCC inspector, Mr Brian Bates, conducted inspections in March and April 2019. He came to the view that some of the items were not defective; some had been rectified by Mr O'Donnell by the time of the second inspection at least; and some were defective but it would be unfair to issue a direction to rectify because of the amount outstanding in the ongoing dispute. This last category included complaint item 9 relating to the external shower, and complaint item 17 relating to external cladding. On the basis of that assessment, Mr Bates for QBCC decided on 22 May 2019 not to issue directions to rectify to Mr O'Donnell. On 3 June 2019, the homeowners authorised the release of the $5,371.26, which has been mentioned above, from the Master Builders Queensland holding account. On 10 June 2019 the homeowners applied to QBCC for an internal review of its decision of 22 May 2019, in relation to four complaint items. These included items 9 and 17. On 8 July 2019 a QBCC internal reviewer, Mr Leigh Blackman, set aside Mr Bates’ decision in relation to complaint items 9 and 17. Mr Blackman noted that since Mr Bates’ decision, a large portion of the previously-disputed amount had been authorised for release to Mr O'Donnell from the Master Builders Queensland holding account, although Mr O'Donnell had not yet taken the next step of having the money transferred to him. Mr Blackman considered that the remaining disputed sum, $2,683.50, was insufficient to render it unfair to issue directions to rectify. Mr Blackman also observed that Mr O'Donnell had not taken steps since the authorisation of the release of the money to rectify the defective work.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established