O'Donnell and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

O'Donnell and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2020] AATA 1714 (12 June 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/8340

Re:John O'Donnell

APPLICANT

K & S Freighters Pty LtdAnd  

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President

Date:12 June 2020

Place:Sydney

The application for an extension of time is refused.

...............................[sgd]........................................

The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President

Catchwords

EXTENSION OF TIME – determination of normal weekly earnings – where original decision made almost ten years prior to application for review – where applicant has issues with literacy – where applicant changed legal representation – where applicant had other proceedings before the Tribunal – principles to be applied – whether substantive application has reasonable prospects of success – where delay causes prejudice to the respondent – whether it would be fair in the circumstances – extension of time refused

Legislation

Safety Rehabilitation Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor [1996] HCA 25
Hunter Valley Developments Pty Limited; Anthony Neary Walker; Mende Brown v the Honourable Barry Cohen Minister of Home Affairs and Environment [1984] FCR 344
Rahimzadeh and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2019] AATA 3201
Comcare v A’Hearn (1993) 45 FCR 441

REASONS FOR DECISION

12 June 2020

Background

  1. The Applicant is employed by the Respondent, K & S Freighters Pty Ltd.

  2. The Applicant lodged a claim under the Safety Rehabilitation Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (‘the Act’) with his employer on 10 November 2009 for compensation for sustained injuries to his left leg, groin, right shoulder and right wrist.

  3. In the initial decision dated 15 December 2009, the respondent determined that, in respect of injuries that the applicant was said to have sustained, the applicant’s normal weekly hours were 42.17 hours, that the applicant’s normal weekly earnings was determined to be $1072.52 and that the applicant’s entitlement to incapacity compensation for the period 21 October 2009 to 8 December 2009 was to be calculated in accordance with the table below:

  4. Nearly 10 years later, the applicant requested a re-consideration of this initial decision. In a reviewable decision dated 16 December 2019 the respondent declined to extend the time in which to undertake the reconsideration when considering the delay, prejudice, merits and fairness of this request.

  5. The decision before the Tribunal is whether the applicant should be granted an extension of time to review this decision, in this case approximately 10 years after the initial decision.

  6. It was agreed between the parties that the decision in relation to the extension of time is a reviewable decision by the Tribunal.

  7. The Tribunal notes that the initial decision under the respondent’s license was issued pursuant to the Act by Insurance Australia Limited trading as CGU Self Insurance Services, which was authorised as claims manager for the respondent. By the time of the reviewable decision, the respondent K & S Freighters Pty Ltd had taken over the claim management function itself, in accordance with its license. This explains why the initial…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Donnell and K & S Freighters Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 1714
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for an extension of time to challenge a determination of normal weekly earnings made almost ten years prior. The applicant, Mr O'Donnell, sought to reopen the calculation of his normal weekly earnings, which had been initially determined by CGU Self Insurance Services and later by the respondent, K & S Freighters Pty Ltd. The application was heard by Deputy President John Pascoe AC CVO of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether to grant the applicant an extension of time to challenge the original determination of his normal weekly earnings. This required the Tribunal to consider the principles governing extensions of time, including whether the substantive application had reasonable prospects of success, whether the delay caused prejudice to the respondent, and whether granting the extension would be fair in the circumstances. The applicant also raised issues concerning his literacy, changes in legal representation, and other proceedings before the Tribunal.

The Tribunal reasoned that the merits of the applicant's substantive application did not weigh in his favour, as he had not provided specific particulars demonstrating how the original determination was incorrect, beyond disputing the calculation period. Furthermore, the Tribunal found it would be unfair to allow the applicant to reopen the normal weekly earnings calculation after nearly a decade, especially when others in similar situations would have raised objections within the prescribed time. The applicant's evidence indicated a lifelong struggle with literacy and a failure to seek assistance or comprehensively review his compensation payments and payslips. He had also not raised concerns with his previous or current legal representatives until much later. The Tribunal concluded that there was no adequate explanation for the almost ten-year delay and that the respondent had not contributed to this delay.

Consequently, the Tribunal refused the application for an extension of time. The issue of costs was not dealt with as the respondent did not seek an order for costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal notes that the initial decision under the respondent’s license was issued pursuant to the Act by Insurance Australia Limited trading as CGU Self Insurance Services, which was authorised as claims manager for the respondent. By the time of the reviewable decision, the respondent K & S Freighters Pty Ltd had taken over the claim management function itself, in accordance with its license. This explains why the initial decision was made by CGU and the reviewable decision was made by the respondent.The applicant’s evidence At the hearing, the applicant made reference to his statement of 6 February 2020 and in particular drew attention to paragraph three, which dealt with the problems that he had experienced from early in his schooling history in relation to reading, writing and comprehension. He said he was “is not very literate”. The applicant said that he commenced work in 2007 as a casual employee for three months for the respondent, and later became a full-time employee. He is still employed by the respondent. Under cross-examination, the applicant said that although his problems could be described as lifelong, he had not sought any assistance or help in relation to his comprehension issues. The applicant said that he had never comprehensively compared his compensation payments to his payslip after he received the initial advice from CGU. The applicant claimed not to have noticed the significant difference in the payments made by way of compensation as against his normal pay. He said he only looked at his payslip and bank statements. The applicant also gave evidence that there were regular variations in his payslips as a result of overtime worked. Again, he said he only checked his payslips against his bank statements. He went on to give evidence that he ultimately decided to stop opening letters in relation to payments made to him and that he just put them “in a pile”. The applicant told the Tribunal that he could not remember whether he provided documents and the letters to his solicitors at the time of the 2014 proceedings before the Tribunal which related to the denial of liability. However, he thought he may have taken these documents to Maurice Blackburn, his previous representatives, sometime in approximately 2014 to 2015. The applicant said that in 2017 he told his current solicitor, Mr Joshua Clark, who was previously his representative at Maurice Blackburn lawyers, that the payslips and other documents were “in my files”. Attention was drawn to Paragraph 11 of the applicant’s statement in which he said that he did not receive any advice to challenge the decision of 15 December 2009 until July 2019. Indeed, the question of challenging the calculation of normal weekly earnings in 2009 does not seem to have ever been considered before that date.Submissions on behalf of the applicant In submissions, counsel for the applicant referred to a number of previous Tribunal decisions along with the decision of Justice McHugh in Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor [1996] HCA 25, which were also contained in the respondent’s submissions to the Tribunal. Counsel sought to make a distinction between the application of what was said by his Honour to common-law cases as against administrative decisions. Counsel for the applicant also drew the Tribunal’s attention to a number of decisions by different Tribunal members in relation to the extension of time application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It can only be seen as unusual that the issue of costs was raised by counsel for the applicant. As I have decided to refuse the application for an extension of time, it is not necessary for me to deal with any costs to be awarded, noting in particular that the respondent did not seek such an order.Decision The correct and preferable decision is that the application for an extension of time is refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Accordingly, as the applicant did not provide specific particulars for how the determination made by the respondent is incorrect, other than disputing the period of 12 weeks in which the normal weekly earnings was calculated, I find that the merits do not weigh in the applicant’s favour.Considerations of fairness? It would seem unfair for the applicant to be able to reopen the issue of normal weekly earning calculations after a lapse of almost 10 years when it is likely that others in a similar position raised any objections within the 30 day period allowed for such objections and of which the applicant must have been aware. After careful consideration of all the circumstances of this case and the evidence presented, I find it hard to see why and extension of time should be granted. All the evidence points to the applicant having done nothing to consider or rectify any issues in calculations (assuming there were any), and even now there is no explanation as to the specific benefit to the applicant if the original in normal weekly earnings calculation is to be reopened. There is nothing in the evidence to suggest that the respondent contributed in any way to the delay on the part of the applicant. On the contrary, the respondent appears to have been quite open and transparent as to the formula used for the normal weekly earnings calculations and the applicant’s rights to challenge the original decision apply within the time frame allowed. Indeed, the matter only appears to have become of interest to the applicant because of the respondent’s desire to make a full explanation in its Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions to the Tribunal in relation to the current proceedings. The applicant could have spoken to his employer about the calculations when he originally received notification of the compensation payments to be made to him as compared to his normal weekly earnings. He chose not to do so. He could also have spoken to a third party as outlined in the statement given to him after the original decision which included a number to call, but there is no evidence that he ever did so. Indeed, he did not even raise it with his solicitors in 2014 to 2016. On balance, it must be said that there has been no explanation which justifies a delay of almost 10 years in seeking to reopen the original calculation of normal weekly earnings.Costs It can only be seen as unusual that the issue of costs was raised by counsel for the applicant. As I have decided to refuse the application for an extension of time, it is not necessary for me to deal with any costs to be awarded, noting in particular that the respondent did not seek such an order.Decision The correct and preferable decision is that the application for an extension of time is refused.