O'Brien and Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 92 min read

O'Brien and Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2017] AATA 812 (6 June 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2016/2749

Re:Michael O'Brien

APPLICANT

Australian Offshore Solutions Pty LtdAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member CR Walsh

Date:6 June 2017

Place:Perth

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution therefor decides that the Respondent is liable to pay the Applicant compensation under s 26 of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (SRCA) for a psychological injury (Bipolar Affective Disorder) sustained by the Applicant during his third swing of employment with the Respondent as an Integrated Rating on board the vessel Sea Surfer in the period 15 February 2015 to 15 March 2015.

Pursuant to s 92(2) of the SRCA, the Tribunal orders that the costs of these proceedings incurred by the Applicant be paid by the Respondent in accordance with section 6.9 of the Tribunal’s Guide to the Workers’ Compensation Jurisdiction (July 2015).

........................................................................

Senior Member CR Walsh

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – seafarers rehabilitation and compensation – whether applicant’s ailment or aggravation of that ailment (being a Bipolar Affective Disorder) was “contributed to in a material degree” by his employment with the respondent as an Integrated Rating on the vessel, “Sea Surfer” – meaning of “ailment” considered – meaning of “aggravation” considered - meaning of “contributed to” considered – meaning of “in a material degree” considered – whether the applicant was “bullied” by the Captain of the vessel - decision under review set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) act 1971

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – (former) s 4(1) – s 5B

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2007

Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 – s 3 – s 8 - 10(7) - s 26

CASES

Comcare v Canute [2005] FCAFC 262; 148 FCR 232; 89 ALD 258; 41 AAR 539

Comcare v Sahu-Khan (2007) 156 FCR 536; 44 AAR 523

Casarotto v Australian Postal Commission (1989) 86 ALR 399; 17 ALD 321; 10 AAR 191

Dunstan v Comcare [2006] FCA 1655; 93 ALD 390; 44 AAR 359

Dunstan v Comcare [2011] FCAFC 108; 125 ALD 362

Favelle Mort Ltd v Murray (1976) 133 CLR 580; 50 ALJR 509; 8 ALR 649

Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch (1964) 110 CLR 626; 38 ALJR 64

Kennedy v Comcare [2015] AATA 334

Mellor v Australian Postal Corporation [2009] FCA 504; 108 ALD 159

Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations v Comcare [2008] FCA 52

Wiegand v Comcare [2002] FCA 1464; 72 ALD 795

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member CR Walsh

6 June 2017

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr O’Brien seeks review of a decision of Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (AOS), dated 20 May 2016, to disallow Mr O’Brien’s claim for workers’ compensation, under s 26 of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (SRCA), for a psychological injury (Bipolar Affective Disorder) sustained by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Brien and Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (Compensat... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 812
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr O’Brien against Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (AOS) for compensation under the *Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992* (Cth) (the Act). Mr O’Brien claimed that his Bipolar Affective Disorder was contributed to in a material degree by his employment as an Integrated Rating on the vessel "Sea Surfer". AOS had previously determined that Mr O’Brien's condition was not materially contributed to by his employment and declined his claim.

The court was required to determine whether Mr O’Brien’s Bipolar Affective Disorder, or an aggravation of that ailment, was contributed to in a material degree by his employment with AOS. This involved considering the meaning of "ailment", "aggravation", "contributed to", and "in a material degree" within the context of the Act. The court also considered allegations that Mr O’Brien was bullied by the Captain of the vessel during his employment.

The court found that AOS’s defence under s 10(7) of the Act, which alleged Mr O’Brien made a false representation regarding his pre-existing medical history, must fail. This was based on unchallenged medical evidence indicating Mr O’Brien had impaired memory following ECT treatment in 2007, meaning he could not have knowingly provided false answers on his pre-employment questionnaire. Consequently, the court set aside AOS's reconsideration determination.

The court ordered that AOS was liable to pay Mr O’Brien compensation under s 26 of the Act for a psychological injury, Bipolar Affective Disorder, sustained during his employment on the "Sea Surfer" between 15 February 2015 and 15 March 2015.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Central to the determination of this application is whether Mr O’Brien’s Bipolar Affective Disorder was “contributed to in a material degree” by his employment with AOS.FACTUAL & PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND Mr O’Brien was born in Ireland in 1959 and is currently 58 years of age. Mr O’Brien was raised by a single mother until the age of six, when his mother died. He never met his biological father. From the age of 6, until he was 16, Mr O’Brien was raised in Catholic institutions, where he claims to have been mistreated. In April 1975, upon turning 16, Mr O’Brien enlisted in the British Army. In summary, Mr O’Brien’s military service comprises the following Tours of Duty:2.1987 to the Falkland Islands, his role being Forward Reconnaissance Units confronting many explosions and that he killed Argentineans and – 3.Four Tours of Northern Island and was involved in many riots at the age of 18 and the bomb disposal man was killed in his arms and his legs were destroyed and he described that -“You were petrol bombed on a daily basis” And – 4. A Peace Keeping Mission for 6 months and – 5.In Rhodesia before it became Zimbabwe in 1979 to 1980 during the transition and – 6.Cyprus for the United Nations in 1976 to 1977, his role as a Young Paratrooper but did not sustain any trauma there, but described much in Rhodesia due to the land mines stating – “I’ve seen a lot of people blown up” – And – 7.In 1983 to 1987 he participated in the 44th Parachute Brigade iu (sic) South Africa and fought on many border patrols confronting many atrocities, witnessing – “Lots of things” – And – 9. In about 1989 on P&O he was – “The tanker man” - engaged with a civilian in the Engine Room when a man hung himself in the Engine Room and he was advised by the Captain that he was sick and contagious and not to enter the Engine Room....11.In 1998 to 1989 he spent 3 months on a ship confronting Iranian gun boats but claimed to be okay.[1][1] Exhibit 7. Mr O’Brien subsequently immigrated to Australia. After immigrating to Australia, Mr O’Brien was employed in the following roles:·2002 to 2005 - self-employed as an Owner/Trainer/Assessor with Maritime Offshore Training Assessment Service (MOTAS), Swan Maritime Institute Henderson, Western Australia;·2005 to 2008 – employed as a Technician/Inspector with Sparrows Offshore, Kewdale, Western Australia;·2008 to 2010 – employed as a Project Technician General Service Operator with PTTEP, Montara, Singapore;·September 2011 to January 2012 – employed as a Heavy Lift Supervisor with Boskalis Gorgon Project, Barrow Island LNG Plant;·October 2012 to May 2014 – employed as a EPCM Heavy Lift Superintendent with KJV Chevron Gorgon Project, Henderson, Western Australia; and·September 2014 to May 2015 – employed as an Integrated Rating with AOS on the Gorgon Project, Barrow Island LNG Plant.[2][2] Exhibit 2 at MO12. Mr O’Brien holds a number of seafarer industry related qualifications, licences and tickets, including, for example, an Advanced Diploma Occupational Health & Safety (Q14) and a Licence to perform High Risk Work Registered Assessor WA Government (1085).[3][3] Exhibit 2 at MO12.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Following a summary of the evidence (comprising “Mr O’Brien’s evidence”, the “Lay evidence” and the “Medical evidence”), each of the above issues is considered, in turn, below.Mr O’Brien’s evidence In support of his request for reconsideration of the Amended Determination, dated 15 March 2016, Mr O’Brien provided a Witness Statement, dated 25 February 2016.[15] Mr O’Brien subsequently provided a Witness Statement, dated 14 September 2016, in support of this application.[16] Mr O’Brien also gave oral evidence at the hearing of this application.[15] Exhibit 1 at pp 349 – 357.[16] Exhibit 2. Mr O’Brien’s Witness Statement, dated 25 February 2016, provides:THE INCIDENT 6.On 16 September 2014 I began working on the Sea Surfer with the Australian Offshore Solutions (AOS).7.I was elected by the crew of the Sea Surfer to be the Health and Safety Representative.8.I have a broad knowledge of safety. I am an accredited Worksafe Assessor WA (1085) and also I have an Advanced Diploma in Occupational Health and Safety.9. My first swing under Captain Willett began on or about 15 February 2015. 10.On or about 19 February 2015 I raised some safety concerns I had regarding the operations of the cranes with Captain Willett. I explained that there are significant safety risks when cranes are pushed to maximum lift and reach. I also mentioned a load should never be pulled sideways. I said that competent trained people make the difference.11.Captain Willett then verbally attacked me and said l didn’t know anything about cranes and i was not qualified to make an assessment about cranes and it was best if I kept my mouth shut or I would never get picked up again by AOS.12.I was shocked by this verbal attack by Captain Willett as I have extensive experience in operating cranes.13.On or about 21 February 2015 I attended a crew safety meeting with all crew members and Captain Willett.14. During this meeting I raised the following matters:a. Excessive work hours;b. Unreasonable performance demands;c.That Captain Willett was pushing the crew far too hard and was not interested in their wellbeing and was only interested in reaching the requirements of the contract; d.That Captain Willett should not speak badly about a previous captain (Captain Paino);15.Captain Willett said at this meeting that what I was saying was not true. He spoke in a demeaning and derogatory manner towards me and I felt belittled and that my authority was undermined in front of the rest of the crew members.16.Captain Willett called me outside and spoke to me for about 5 minutes and said he would ‘destroy my career’ if I brought up such issues.17. I found Captain Willett’s (sic) intimidating and unreasonable.18. I became insecure and frightened.19.On or about 28 February 2015 Captain Willett informed me that I had to change my hours on my timesheets and that he had to bring the hours back to 10 hours a day. He said that if I didn’t do this I would not have a job with AOS and he would finish my career in the industry. 20.Throughout the entire 4 week swing that I was on board the Sea Surfer I witnessed Captain Willett pushing the crew almost daily to work harder and faster than what was reasonable.21.Captain Willett's conduct impacted upon my responsibilities as a HSE representative as I had a duty of care to ensure the crew's safety. I would often try to discuss this with Captain Willett only to be persecuted by him for not doing my job.22.I believe that Captain Willett saw me as a threat to the way he wanted to run the ship.23.At times I also witnessed Captain Willett bullying other crew members included the Second Officer Pieter Gorter.24.On or about 4 March 2015 I resigned from the position as I felt the conduct and behaviour of Captain Willett was extreme and unreasonable and was effecting my health and also put my safety at risk.25.I went back for one more trip with the Sea Surfer on 27 April 2015. Captain Willett was not there on that trip.…(emphasis added)

Decision

Reasons for decision

In relation to the Pre-Employment Questionnaire, Mr O’Brien must be proven to have had no “belief” that the boxes he ticked on the form were not true answers. The medical evidence of Dr Babich overwhelmingly supports the impaired memory of Mr O’Brien following the ECT treatment in 2007. The evidence of Dr Babich in this regard remains unchallenged by AOS. If Mr O’Brien has an impaired memory, then it can hardly be said that he completed the history knowing it to be false. Consequently, the s10 (7) defence must fail. DECISION For the above reasons, the Tribunal sets aside the Reconsideration Determination and, in substitution therefor, decides that AOS is liable to pay Mr O’Brien compensation under s 26 of the SRCA for a psychological injury (Bipolar Affective Disorder) sustained by him during his third swing of employment for AOS as an Integrated Rating on board the vessel Sea Surfer in the period 15 February 2015 to 15 March 2015.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 20 May 2016, following reconsideration of the Amended Determination, AOS issued Mr O’Brien with a “Reconsideration Determination” which affirmed the Amended Determination and declined Mr O’Brien’s claimed for seafarer’s compensation (Reconsideration Determination). The Reconsideration Determination states:This determination relates solely to the alleged incidents between 15 February 2015 and 15 March 2015. Medical RelationshipWe have examined all the medical evidence and make the following observations:1.you had a severe and long standing history of psychiatric complaints dating back to childhood.2.you had very severe depression in 2004, 2006 and 2007 resulting in hospital admission and ECT treatment.3. you made allegations of bullying at work in 2010, with a previous employer;4.you reported episodes of depression in 2012, 2013 and 2014 and of suicidal thoughts. 5.you failed to disclose your significant pre-existing medical history and previous allegations of bullying to Dr Terace.6. prior to the alleged injury you were prescribed: (a)Diazepam - used to treat anxiety, alcohol withdrawal syndrome, Benzodiazepine withdrawal syndrome, muscle spasms, seizures, trouble sleeping and restless leg syndrome; and(b)Venlafaxine - an antidepressant for the treatment of major depressive disorders, general anxiety disorders, panic attacks and social phobia;7.you had taken yourself off antidepressant medication in January 2015 (two months prior to the alleged injury).8. Dr Terace reported that you do currently have a capacity for work.AOS is not satisfied that you suffered an injury as defined by the Act during the course of your employment on or about 7 March 2015.Employment RelationshipDue to the circumstances of your claim, your claim will be assessed under the injury provisions of section 3 of the Act. Therefore, AOS must consider whether the condition you suffered from arose out of, or in the course of, your employment with AOS.AOS is not satisfied that you suffered an injury that arose out of, or in the course of, your employment with AOS.Terms of ReconsiderationAOS by way of reconsideration, affirms its decision to decline liability for your alleged injuries on or about 7 March 2015, on the same basis as set out in the determination dated 16 February 2016, amended on 3 May 2016, relying on:1. the medical report of Dr Terace, dated 23 December 2015;2. the medical records and certificates;3. personnel records;4. the statement of Captain Willett.Furthermore, AOS will also rely on the Comcare report, dated 12 May 2016, which found that:-your condition was not materially contributed to by the employment with AOS;-you previously suffered a similar condition;-pursuant to s.10(7) of the Act you made a false representation that you did not and had not previously suffered from a similar condition;-pursuant to s.10(7) of the Act it was reasonable to conclude that you were aware that you had suffered from a similar condition when you competed the pre-employment assessment.Considering the evidence AOS is not satisfied that you suffered an injury that arose out of, or in the course of, your employment with AOS.(emphasis added)