NT Power Generation Pty Ltd v Power and Water Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NT Power Generation Pty Ltd v Power & Water Authority [1999] FCA 1184

NT POWER GENERATION PTY LIMITED (ACN 061 314 921) v POWER AND WATER AUTHORITY and GASCO PTY LIMITED (ACN 009 627 801)

D5 OF 1999

MANSFIELD J

BRISBANE (Heard in Darwin)
27 AUGUST 1999


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NORTHERN TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

D 5 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

NT POWER GENERATION PTY LTD
(ACN 061 314 921)
Applicant

AND:

POWER AND WATER AUTHORITY
First Respondent

GASCO PTY LTD
(ACN 009 627 801)
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD J

DATE:

27 AUGUST 1999

PLACE:

BRISBANE (Heard in Darwin)

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The respondents have sought leave to amend their amended defence filed in this matter on 8 July 1999 (“the defence”).  I will refer to the proposed amended defence as “the proposed defence”.  The hearing of this matter commenced on 3 August 1999, but has now been adjourned to resume (subject to hearing one further witness in the meantime) on 11 October 1999.  In significant respects, the application to amend the defence is opposed, largely because it is said that the respondents seek to withdraw admissions.

  2. In ruling upon the application, I propose to apply the principles as expressed by the Full Court in Celestino v Celestino (Spender, Miles and von Doussa JJ, unreported, 16 August 1990).  In summary, they are

    (1)in deciding upon such an application, the Court should endeavour to decide the rights of the parties upon the real issues in the case, provided the amendment to the pleading can be done without injustice (Cropper v Smith (1884) 26 Ch D 700 per Bowen LJ at 710-711).

    (2)The application of that principle assumes that some error on behalf of the party seeking the amendment has been made or demonstrated, and generally speaking, the withdrawal of an admission in pleadings will require an explanation for the making of the admission, if necessary based upon “evidence of a solid and substantial character”.

    (3)In such circumstances, the withdrawal of the admission will nevertheless not be allowed unless no injustice will be occasioned to the other party which cannot be met by an appropriate order for costs.

  3. Celestino involved a dramatic attempt to withdraw an admission.  It was a claim for damages for personal injuries sustained in a vehicular accident.  The defendant, having been professionally advised, admitted liability.  At the commencement of the trial to assess the damages, the defendant sought to withdraw that admission.  The proposed further amended defence, in respect of which leave to amend in presently sought, does not present any such stark circumstance.

  4. The High Court in The State of Queensland v J L Holdings Pty Ltd (1996) 189 CLR 146 has reaffirmed the applicability of the principle in Cropper, per Dawson, Gaudron and McHugh JJ at 154 and per Kirby J at 167-172. The proposition that the ultimate aim of a court is the attainment of justice, and that that aim should inform decisions as to whether amendments to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NT Power Generation Pty Ltd v Power and Water Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] FCA 1184
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of NT Power Generation Pty Ltd v Power and Water Authority, the Federal Court of Australia was asked to determine whether the respondents, Power and Water Authority and GASCO Pty Limited, should be granted leave to amend their defence. The application to amend was largely opposed by the applicant, NT Power Generation, due to the respondents' attempts to withdraw certain admissions. The court needed to decide whether the proposed amendments would allow the respondents to withdraw admissions and if doing so would cause injustice to the applicant.

The court applied the principles set out in Celestino v Celestino, which state that amendments to pleadings should be allowed if they can be done without injustice. The court considered whether the amendments sought by the respondents would prejudice the applicant and whether any prejudice could be mitigated by an appropriate order for costs. The court found that some amendments could be allowed as they did not involve the withdrawal of admissions or cause injustice to the applicant. For instance, the court allowed the amendment to the assertion about the effect of the Competition Principles Agreement, as it related to the proper construction of the agreement. However, the court denied some amendments, such as those concerning the applicant's intention, as they did not significantly harm the respondents' position.

The court allowed the respondents to file and deliver an amended defence, with certain proposed amendments not being allowed. The court also granted leave to add a new paragraph to the defence, stating that the respondents did not admit to being aware of the matters alleged in paragraph 8 of the statement of claim. Overall, the court aimed to achieve justice by allowing amendments that would not cause prejudice to the applicant.

Background

Background to the litigation

NT Power Generation Pty Ltd, the applicant, initiated legal proceedings against the Power and Water Authority and GASCO Pty Ltd, the respondents, over matters related to the electricity supply market in the Northern Territory. The applicant alleged that the first respondent, the Power and Water Authority, had a substantial degree of market power in the Electricity Supply Market. This power was attributed to various factors including statutory regulatory functions, ownership of infrastructure, and barriers to entry and exit. The applicant claimed that the respondents' conduct, particularly in denying access to the infrastructure and information regarding access, constituted an exercise or taking advantage of market power in contravention of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The respondents denied these allegations and sought to amend their defence to adjust their admissions and denials concerning various aspects of the applicant's claims.

This case came before the Federal Court of Australia as an application by the respondents to amend their defence. The original statement of claim was filed on 12 March 1998, and was subsequently amended on 18 August 1999. The respondents' initial defence was filed on an unspecified date, followed by an amended defence on 8 July 1999. The respondents then sought leave to further amend their defence. The hearing on the application to amend the defence commenced on 3 August 1999 but was adjourned to resume on 11 October 1999, subject to hearing one further witness. The matter was heard in Darwin but the decision was delivered in Brisbane on 27 August 1999.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Should the respondents be allowed to amend their defence to change their assertion about the effect of the Competition Principles Agreement?
2. Should the respondents be allowed to amend their defence concerning the acknowledgment of facts giving rise to the first respondent's market power?
3. Should the respondents be allowed to amend their defence to change qualified admissions into general non-admissions concerning the applicant's intention?
4. Should the respondents be allowed to amend their defence by substituting the word "communicated" for "identified" in paragraph 23(b)?
5. Should the respondents be allowed to renumber paragraph 23(c) in their proposed defence?
6. Should the respondents be allowed to remove references to paragraphs 12, 13, and 23 from paragraphs 24 and 25 of their defence?
7. Should the respondents be allowed to amend their defence to withdraw the admission of awareness of certain facts alleged in the statement of claim?

Held
1. The court allowed the respondents to amend their defence to change their assertion about the effect of the Competition Principles Agreement.
2. The court allowed the respondents to amend their defence concerning the acknowledgment of facts giving rise to the first respondent's market power.
3. The court did not allow the respondents to amend their defence to change qualified admissions into general non-admissions concerning the applicant's intention.
4. The court allowed the respondents to amend their defence by substituting the word "communicated" for "identified" in paragraph 23(b).
5. The court allowed the respondents to renumber paragraph 23(c) in their proposed defence.
6. The court allowed the respondents to remove references to paragraphs 12, 13, and 23 from paragraphs 24 and 25 of their defence.
7. The court did not allow the respondents to amend their defence to withdraw the admission of awareness of certain facts alleged in the statement of claim.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Court, in considering the application for leave to amend the defence, applied principles established in Celestino v Celestino and reaffirmed in The State of Queensland v J L Holdings Pty Ltd. The court recognised that amendments to pleadings should be allowed where it would achieve justice without causing injustice to the opposing party. The court analysed each proposed amendment in turn. In relation to the effect of the Competition Principles Agreement, the court allowed the amendment as it related to the proper construction of the agreement, and no prejudice to the respondent was shown. Regarding the acknowledgment of facts giving rise to market power, the court allowed the amendment, noting that the statutory regulatory functions were matters for argument once the background facts were established. The court also allowed the substitution of the word "communicated" for "identified" in paragraph 23(b) and the renumbering of paragraph 23(c) in the proposed defence, finding that it did not cause injustice to the applicant. Additionally, the court allowed the removal of references to paragraphs 12, 13, and 23 from paragraphs 24 and 25 of the defence, reasoning that those references did not materially assist the applicant's claim. However, the court did not allow the respondents to alter qualified admissions into general non-admissions concerning the applicant's intention and to withdraw the admission of awareness of certain facts alleged in the statement of claim, as it found no real issue as to the applicant's intention and no evidence to explain the withdrawal of the admission.

The court's decisions in allowing or denying the amendments reflect its commitment to achieving justice and fairness in the proceedings while ensuring that the opposing party is not unduly prejudiced. The binding legal principle established is that amendments to pleadings should be allowed where they would achieve justice without causing injustice, and where there is an error in the pleadings that can be explained or where no prejudice to the opposing party will result. The court distinguished from prior authority where the withdrawal of an admission without explanation or where it would cause significant prejudice to the opposing party.