Matland Holdings Pty Ltd v NTZ Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Matland Holdings Pty Ltd v NTZ Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 1590

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – sale of land upon which petrol station operated – principal proceedings concerning claims under Trade Practices Act 1974 – respondents’ application to cross-claim against former legal advisers for breach of retainer and negligence – legal advisers not otherwise parties – whether proposed cross-claim part of the same “matter” – whether proposed cross-claim within the Court’s accrued or associated jurisdiction – whether respondents should be granted leave to cross-claim – where proposed cross-claim insufficient to support a cause of action for breach of retainer and in negligence

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – application for leave to amend further amended defence and amended cross-claim – where applicants did not oppose application subject to an award of costs in their favour in respect of costs thrown away by reason of the amendments

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – admissions contained in pleadings – purported withdrawal of those admissions by amendment to pleadings – principles relevant to Court’s discretion to grant leave to allow party to withdraw admissions

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – lawyer-client privilege – waiver – whether waiver established – where applicants sought access to legal advice provided to the respondents – where file note discovered by the respondents records the conclusion reached in advice – where affidavit filed by respondents referred to receipt of legal advice – whether unfair that privilege be maintained – relevance of advice where coercion is claimed  

COSTS – application for indemnity costs – principles applicable to an award of costs on an indemnity basis – whether applicants entitled to award on indemnity costs basis

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), ss 32, 43
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 45(2)(a)(ii), 45(2)(b)(ii), 45B(2), 45C(2), 47, 51AA, 52, 53A, 53A(2)
Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic), s 9
Federal Court Rules 1979, O 5 r 1(2), O 5 r 1(3), O 5 r 8(1), O 15 r 11(1), O 22 r 4

Philip Morris Inc v Adam P Brown Male Fashions Pty Ltd (1981) 148 CLR 457 discussed
Fencott v Muller (1983) 152 CLR 570 discussed
Stack v Coast Securities (No 9) Pty Ltd (1983) 154 CLR 261 referred
Re Wakim; Ex parte McNally & Anor (1999) 198 CLR 511 followed
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Edensor Nominees Pty Ltd (2001) 204 CLR 559 discussed
Obacelo Pty Ltd v Taveraft Pty Ltd (1985) 5 FCR 210 distinguished
Maisey v First Coast Pty Ltd (1984) 1 FCR 316 referred
163 Clarence Street Pty Ltd v New World Oil and Developments Pty Ltd (1994) ATPR 41-322 referred
Re Ling; Ex parte Ling v Commonwealth of Australia (1995) 58 FCR 129 referred
St George Bank Ltd v MJK Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 1752 referred

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Emerald Ocean Distributors Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 402 referred
Celestino v Celestino (unreported, Spender, Miles and von Doussa JJ, 16 August 1990) followed
Londish v Gulf Pacific Pty Ltd (1993) 117 ALR 361 referred

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Matland Holdings Pty Ltd v NTZ Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 1590
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Matland Holdings Pty Ltd v NTZ Pty Ltd, the Federal Court of Australia addressed interlocutory applications concerning amendments to statements of claim and defences in an ongoing legal dispute. The applicants sought leave to further amend their statement of claim, while the respondents opposed this request and sought leave to amend their defence and cross-claim. The applicants also filed a reply to the respondents' amended defence and cross-claim. The central issue before the court was whether the applicants should be granted leave to amend their statement of claim, particularly in light of the respondents' argument that such an amendment would significantly prejudice their position due to the passage of time and potential loss of evidence.

The court considered the principle that amendments to pleadings should be allowed if they do not cause substantial injustice to the opposing party, especially where the amendment is not sought for delay. However, the court also acknowledged the respondents' concerns about the potential prejudice resulting from the delay in raising the proposed cause of action. After weighing these factors, the court decided to grant the applicants leave to further amend their statement of claim, but ordered that the respondents be allowed to amend their defence and cross-claim accordingly. The court also made orders regarding costs and scheduling, including setting a directions hearing for the continuation of the case.

The final orders of the court included dismissing the respondents' motion to prevent the applicants from amending their statement of claim, allowing the respondents to file and serve a further amended defence and cross-claim, and setting a schedule for further pleadings and a directions hearing. The court also made several orders regarding the costs to be borne by the parties, reflecting the complex procedural history and the need to balance the interests of both parties in the litigation process.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondents’ motion, notice of which is dated 6 December 2002, be dismissed.

2. The respondents have leave to file and serve a second further amended defence and further amended cross-claim incorporating the amendments proposed in the respondents’ solicitor’s letter to the applicants’ solicitors dated 9 December 2002, by 4.00pm on 20 December 2002.

3. The applicants file and serve a further reply and defence to the second further amended defence and further amended cross-claim by 4.00pm on 24 December 2002.

4. The respondents pay the applicants’ costs thrown away by reason of the proposed amendments to the further amended defence and amended cross-claim dated 29 November 2002.

5. The respondents pay the applicants’ costs of and incidental to the hearing on 22 November 2002, to be taxed and paid on an indemnity basis.

6. There be no order as to the costs of and incidental to the applications to the Court on 19 November 2002.

7. The respondents pay the applicants’ costs of and incidental to the motion, notice of which is dated 6 December 2002, and of the other applications made to the Court on 12 December 2002 on a party-party basis.

8. The respondents be granted leave nunc pro tunc to make the amendments in pars 10, 11(b) and 14 of the further amended defence and amended cross-claim dated 29 November 2002.

9. The respondents pay the applicants’ costs thrown away by reason of the amendments to pars 10, 11(b) and 14 of the further amended defence and amended cross-claim dated 29 November 2002.

10. The parties have liberty to apply to the Court on seven days’ written notice.

11. A directions hearing be fixed for 5 February 2003 at 10.00 am.

Background

Background to the litigation

I deal with each application in turn below. Before doing so, however, it may be helpful to discuss the procedural background which led to the interlocutory applications now being made. procedural background On 19 November 2002, the Court gave the applicants leave to file and serve a second further amended statement of claim (in the form proposed at the hearing on that day). The respondents were given leave to file and serve a further amended defence and amended cross-claim. Pursuant to leave, a second further amended statement of claim was filed in the Court on 21 November 2002, and a further amended defence and amended cross-claim on 29 November 2002. On 10 December 2002, the applicants filed a reply (dated 5 December 2002) in response to the respondents’ further amended defence of 29 November 2002, as well as a defence to the respondents’ amended cross-claim of that date. Also on 19 November 2002, the Court ordered that the trial date of 25 November 2002, which had been fixed for the proceeding, be vacated. The Court accepted the respondents’ submission that they should be given an opportunity to consider whether they might take third party proceedings against their former legal advisers in the event that the applicants were granted leave further to amend their statement of claim. In support of this submission, Mr Maurice Bernstein, principal of the firm Bernstein & Associates, solicitors for the respondents, deposed in an affidavit sworn on 18 November 2002 as follows:3.I have been instructed by the respondents to oppose the applicants’ application to amend the Further Amended Statement of Claim for the following reasons.4.The Writ in this proceeding was issued in the Supreme Court of Victoria on 1 September 1998. … . …6.On 5 October 1999 the Honourable Justice Warren ordered (inter alia) that pursuant to s 6(1) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 the proceeding was to be transferred to the Melbourne Registry of the Federal Court of Australia as a ‘special Federal matter’. …13.At approximately 12.30pm on Friday, 15 November 2002 a copy of a proposed Second Further Amended Statement of Claim was faxed to my firm by the solicitors for the applicants.…15.The proposed Second Further Amended Statement of Claim seeks to introduce into the pleading in paragraph 7A a cause of action based on an alleged breach of an alleged collateral contract. The alleged collateral contract is said to be constituted of the express terms that appear in clause 15 of contract of sale dated 12 November 1997.16.Until the appearance of the proposed Second Further Amended Statement of Claim, the causes of action pleaded against the respondents rely on alleged representations and a different collateral contract that NTZ Pty Ltd would execute a Supply Agreement. However, it has not before been alleged that these representations were made ex contractu, but on the contrary, it has always been alleged that they were made subsequent to the execution of the contract.17.The respondents deny making the representations and the ‘initial’ collateral agreement as have been pleaded. The presentation of the evidence for trial has always proceeded on the state of the pleadings. The cause of action that is now sought to be introduced relies in effect on the alleged breach of an express term of the contract, which has serious repercussions against the interests of the respondents.18.I refer to paragraph 37 of the affidavit of George Ntzounas sworn 1 December 2000 wherein Mr Ntzounas has deposed that prior to the day of settlement of the Contract of Sale he had obtained legal advice in relation to whether or not he could be required to execute the supply agreement under the terms of the Contract of Sale. 19.I am further informed by Mr George Ntzounas and verily believe that prior to the day of settlement of the Contract of Sale he had sought legal advice from a member of the Victorian Bar, Mr Chris Wallis, in relation to the effect of clause 15 of the Contract of Sale of Real Estate between Matland Holdings Pty Ltd and NTZ Pty Ltd dated 12 November 1997.20.If leave is granted by this Honourable Court to permit the applicants to further amend the Statement of Claim to include a cause of action against NTZ Pty Ltd for what in essence is a breach of a term of the said Contract of Sale, I will need to obtain instructions from Mr Ntzounas in order to be able to advise him as to whether he and/or NTZ Pty Ltd has any cause of action for negligent advice against Mr Wallis and/or the firm of Norbury Pereira, solicitors in allowing the Contract of Sale to be settled. The firm of Norbury Pereira acted for NTZ Pty Ltd in the purchase of the service station site at 1519 Dandenong Road, Oakleigh under the Contract of Sale between Matland Holdings Pty Ltd and NTZ Pty Ltd dated 12 November 1997.…22.In my respectful submission, it is not open for the applicants to successfully contend that the proposed amendments to their statement of claim should be permitted and the hearing proceed as scheduled on the basis that the respondents could subsequently bring action against their previous legal advisers, if so advised. Due to the failure of the applicants until the present time to seek to rely upon what is essentially the alleged breach of the terms of the Contract of Sale, the position of the first and second respondents has been seriously prejudiced due to the lapse of five years since the relevant events occurred. The passage of time affects recollection and enables the possible destruction or loss of relevant documents. The respondents’ prospects of success against the previous legal advisers are likely to be prejudiced as a result of the late application to amend the Statement of Claim. Also, had the proposed cause of action been relied upon earlier, the respondents’ previous legal advisers might well have been already joined as third parties to this proceeding and taken part in the two mediations that have been held.…24.Further, if this Honourable Court grants the application by the applicants to amend its Statement of Claim as proposed, I am instructed by the respondents to request this Honourable Court vacate the hearing date of this matter. The purpose of an adjournment of the trial is to consider the possibility of claims that NTZ Pty Ltd may have against its previous legal advisers for negligent advice in relation to the completion (i.e. the conveyancing settlement) of the Contract of Sale in the circumstances as deposed to by Mr Michael David Norbury in paragraphs 9 and 10 of his affidavit sworn 6 December 2000.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KENNY J
Issues
1. Should Matland Holdings Pty Ltd be granted leave to further amend their statement of claim to include a cause of action based on an alleged breach of an alleged collateral contract?
2. Should NTZ Pty Ltd be granted leave to file a second further amended defence and further amended cross-claim in response to Matland Holdings Pty Ltd's proposed amendments?
3. Should NTZ Pty Ltd's motion to dismiss Matland Holdings Pty Ltd's application to further amend their statement of claim be dismissed?
4. What orders should be made in relation to costs and directions for the proceedings?

Held
1. Matland Holdings Pty Ltd should not be granted leave to further amend their statement of claim to include a cause of action based on an alleged breach of an alleged collateral contract. The respondents' motion to dismiss the application was successful.
2. NTZ Pty Ltd should be granted leave to file a second further amended defence and further amended cross-claim in response to Matland Holdings Pty Ltd's proposed amendments.
3. NTZ Pty Ltd's motion to dismiss Matland Holdings Pty Ltd's application to further amend their statement of claim was dismissed.
4. The court ordered that NTZ Pty Ltd pay the applicants' costs of the hearing and other specified costs, and fixed a directions hearing for 5 February 2003.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KENNY J

In considering the application by Matland Holdings Pty Ltd to further amend their statement of claim, the court was mindful of the principles guiding amendments to pleadings and the impact of delay on the respondents. The court held that the applicants' proposed amendments, which sought to introduce a new cause of action based on an alleged breach of an express term of the contract, were not permissible as they would significantly prejudice the respondents. The late introduction of such a cause of action, after nearly five years from the relevant events, would severely impact the respondents' ability to defend themselves, potentially leading to the destruction or loss of relevant documents and affecting the recollection of events. The court also noted that the respondents had a legitimate interest in considering third party proceedings against their former legal advisers, which would be affected by the proposed amendments. Consequently, the court dismissed the application to further amend the statement of claim, as the potential prejudice to the respondents outweighed the applicants' right to amend their pleadings. In contrast, the court granted NTZ Pty Ltd leave to file a second further amended defence and further amended cross-claim, allowing them to respond to the proposed amendments by the applicants. The court also dismissed NTZ Pty Ltd's motion to dismiss Matland Holdings Pty Ltd's application to further amend their statement of claim, reflecting the court's view that the proposed amendments should not proceed. Regarding costs, the court ordered NTZ Pty Ltd to pay the applicants' costs of the hearing and other specified costs, reflecting the court's assessment of the impact of the proceedings on the applicants and the need for the respondents to bear the financial consequences of their unsuccessful motions. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that while the right to amend pleadings is generally supported, the court will deny leave to amend where the delay in seeking the amendment significantly prejudices the opposing party, potentially affecting their ability to defend the action effectively.